Bush-era Libby indictment could be 'informative precedent' for any Trump charges

Former Vice President Dick Cheney’s chief of staff Scooter Libby was pardoned in 2018 by then-President Donald Trump, more than a decade after federal prosecutors brought perjury and obstruction of justice charges against Libby.

Now, some legal experts wonder if the Bush-era case serves as a template for how prosecutors could decide to go after Trump with federal charges, should they choose to, for any classified information crimes or something more benign, such as illegal retention of standard government records.

Following the FBI raid on Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate last week, a released search warrant revealed that the Department of Justice is looking into possible offenses by the former president, including removing or destroying government records, obstructing justice, and violating the Espionage Act.

Trump claimed in a statement last week that the documents seized were “all declassified,” though no further details were offered. Still, Trump’s office maintained the former president issued “a standing order” that the records brought to his residence were “deemed to be declassified.”


bush-era libby indictment could be 'informative precedent' for any trump charges

Scooter Libby (Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP)

The public remains in the dark as to what materials were outlined in the search affidavit, prompting some experts to ponder whether the actual documents obtained in the search may amount to a negligent mishandling of records or a serious blow to national security.

National security lawyer Bradley P. Moss told the Washington Examiner that Libby’s case marks an “interesting informative precedent, but it’s nothing that prohibits a prosecution here,” highlighting the key differences between Trump and the former Bush official.

“The Scooter Libby case was about information. There wasn’t anything with markings. This was information they disclosed from what had been a classified document or set of documents. But it was a verbal dissemination,” Moss said, adding, “It’s nothing that anybody could cite to in a court filing.”

While Libby was once Cheney’s right-hand man, he was convicted in March 2007 of lying and obstructing an investigation into the leak of the identity of undercover CIA operative Valerie Plame to journalists. In 2003, special counsel Patrick J. Fitzgerald was tasked by then-Deputy Attorney General James Comey to head up the investigation.

In 2006, Libby claimed his “superiors” authorized him to leak highly sensitive intelligence information to the press, including to a New York Times reporter he allegedly tipped off with the name of the undercover CIA operative, according to federal prosecutors.

“If Mr. Fitzgerald had actually sought prosecution of Scooter Libby for violations of either the Espionage Act or for Section 1924, which is unauthorized removal of classified records, we don’t know how it would have played out. He declined to do so. We don’t know what his internal deliberations were on the front of the classification. That was the choice he made,” Moss said.

FBI agents found 11 sets of classified documents during their search at Trump’s Florida estate last week, some of which contained top secret/sensitive compartmented information, or TS/SCI.

“Here with former President Trump, these are hard copy documents that still have the classification markings on them,” Moss added.

Steven Aftergood, a leading authority on classified information policy, said the “Libby case might have been the first time in memory that the question of unilateral presidential declassifications arose,” according to a Politico interview Monday.

“It was giving one-time permission to a particular individual to disclose information to another particular individual. … It highlights the fact that the president purports to, or does, stand outside of the classification system,” Aftergood added.


For Moss, the only way the DOJ would not move forward on charges for Trump related to mishandled documents is if the department is persuaded by sufficient evidence that Trump’s intent was to have declassified all the records he possessed at Mar-a-Lago, emphasizing that there needs to be “somewhere it’s written down.”

“But if that’s not in play, I don’t see how they can ignore the mountain of evidence that we’ve already learned about, either through the court filings or through media recording, because what it shows is he took 20-something boxes’ worth of records that were never supposed to be in possession anyways. They were all supposed to be turned over to the National Archives,” Moss said.


Washington Examiner Videos

Tags: Donald Trump, George W. Bush, FBI, Mar-a-Lago, Justice Department

Original Author: Kaelan Deese

Original Location: Bush-era Libby indictment could be ‘informative precedent’ for any Trump charges

News Related


Wednesday Is Your Last Chance To Buy Morgan Stanley Emerg Mkts Before The Dividend Payout

Wednesday Is Your Last Chance To Buy Morgan Stanley Emerg Mkts Before The Dividend Payout Wednesday marks the last chance for investors to receive the next dividend payout from Morgan ... Read more »

The White Castle Location Where No One Can Eat

A White Castle meal Imagine going into a new restaurant that just opened up in town. As soon as you walk in, the man behind the counter tells you that ... Read more »

Man Tries Enormous 'British Burrito' in London and the Video Is Going Viral

It’s like a Sunday roast all wrapped in a burrito. If you’re hungry and you only have a salad on the menu today, you might want to skip this video. ... Read more »

Why QuantumScape Shares Jumped Today

Why QuantumScape Shares Jumped Today What happened Shares of QuantumScape (NYSE: QS) jumped as much as 6% Monday morning on some news from a partner in its quest to commercialize ... Read more »

Joe Benigno shreds Robert Saleh, Jets coaching staff: 'Freaking disaster'

Joe Benigno shreds Robert Saleh, Jets coaching staff: ‘Freaking disaster’ The New York Jets are a more talented team this year than last, so it’s hard not to point to ... Read more »

Biden's new minimum tax could hit Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway the hardest, study show

Democrats' book minimum tax could bring in $31.8B, study shows Read more »

Insider Q&A: FDA official on vaping's "promise or peril"

Insider Q&A: FDA official on vaping's “promise or peril” The new chief at the Food and Drug Administration's tobacco center has inherited a raft of problems WASHINGTON — There’s been ... Read more »

Review: A Montana private detective faces two mysteries

Review: A Montana private detective faces two mysteries In “Treasure State,” C This cover image released by Minotaur shows “Treasure State” by C.J. Box. (Minotaur via AP) The Associated Press ... Read more »

TV hit ‘Peaky Blinders’ expands story through dance show

TV hit ‘Peaky Blinders’ expands story through dance show A new show is expanding the story of the popular “Peaky Blinders” television series This image released by Rambert Dance shows ... Read more »

Cargo traffic movement resumes between Colombia, Venezuela

Cargo traffic movement resumes between Colombia, Venezuela Trucks loaded with aluminum and medications have crossed a bridge linking Colombia and Venezuela for the first time in seven years Venezuelans wait ... Read more »

These Houston-area restaurants made Yelp’s list of the top 100 taco spots in the US

HOUSTON – Yelp this week identified the most-beloved and best-reviewed taco joints in the country. The crowd-sourced review website identified businesses in the restaurant category serving tacos, then ranked those ... Read more »

No, NASA’s plan to crash a satellite into an asteroid doesn’t put Earth at risk

NASA is crashing a satellite into an asteroid called Dimorphos. Dimorphos orbits a larger asteroid, so it's impossible for the satellite to send its target into us. Read more »

Andreas Athanasiou Calls Signing With Blackhawks ‘a No-Brainer'

Athanasiou calls signing with Hawks ‘a no-brainer’ originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago It’s no secret the Blackhawks are in the beginning stages of a full-blown rebuild. The moves they ... Read more »

‘Have fun’: Dr. Dre gives Rihanna some advice ahead of 2023 Super Bowl halftime show

Super Bowl LVI halftime show headliner and self-proclaimed Rihanna “super-fan” Dr. Dre “can’t wait to see” what the “Umbrella” artist has in store for next year’s event. During a radio ... Read more »

New rule will show ‘true cost’ of plane tickets, White House says

WASHINGTON —  President Biden will announce a new initiative Monday that would eventually allow consumers to see a more complete price on airline tickets — including baggage and change fees — ... Read more »

Gisele Bündchen Takes Tom Brady Split Rumors To New Level With Buccaneers Game Absence

Gisele Bündchen posing Tom Brady and Gisele Bündchen’s 13-year marriage has survived some major career changes and big moves. It has withstood Brady’s sudden un-retirement and a relocation from Boston to Tampa ... Read more »

Boeing 737 Cargo Plane Overshoots Runway, Recovered From Lake by Giant Cranes

Boeing 737 Cargo Plane Overshoots Runway, Recovered From Lake by Giant Cranes A Boeing 737 cargo jet has been recovered from a lake after overshooting the runway on landing in ... Read more »

Florida under watches and warnings as Cat 1 Hurricane Ian expected to rapidly intensify

This article tracking Hurricane Ian is available for free to all readers. A large swath of Florida’s Gulf Coast is under hurricane and storm surge watches Monday from Hurricane Ian, ... Read more »

Giant Kidney Stone Gets Stuck Leaving Man in Excruciating Pain for Months

u/Psytoxic’s kidney stone as pictured next to a banana candy. When it passed, it was around 0.2 inches across. A man has shared the picture of a kidney stone that ... Read more »

Dear TSLA Stock Fans, Mark Your Calendars for Sept. 30

There’s one thing about Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) that market experts know to be true; when the company kicks off a major event, it sends TSLA stock soaring. Elon Musk has proven ... Read more »

Canada to drop Covid measures at the border on Oct. 1

Workers wearing protective masks hang a Canadian flag. OTTAWA — Canada will end Covid measures at its border Oct. 1. Incoming travelers will no longer have to test, quarantine, declare ... Read more »

A new island is forming in the Pacific Ocean after a volcanic eruption

A volcano that erupted in the southwest Pacific Ocean has started to create a new island. On Sept. 10, a volcano erupted on Home Reef, an undersea mountain that is ... Read more »

Farmers threaten to quit NFU as leader backs scrapping of nature subsidies

Photograph: Fototek/PA Farmers are threatening to quit the National Farmers’ Union after its leader said she supported the government’s apparent move to scrap post-Brexit nature subsidies. This weekend, the Observer ... Read more »

Graham Potter has chance to correct Thomas Tuchel's £97m transfer mistake at Chelsea

Romelu Lukaku faces an uncertain future at Chelsea Graham Potter’s immediate Chelsea squad may well look very different in 12-months time. Although the foundations for a revamp have already been ... Read more »

NFL World Not Happy With Terry Bradshaw News

NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA – JANUARY 20: Commenter Terry Bradshaw looks on prior to the NFC Championship game between the Los Angeles Rams and the New Orleans Saints at the Mercedes-Benz ... Read more »

Sources: Los Angeles Chargers LT Rashawn Slater expected to miss rest of season with torn biceps

Sources: Los Angeles Chargers LT Rashawn Slater expected to miss rest of season with torn biceps COSTA MESA, Calif. — Los Angeles Chargers left tackle Rashawn Slater is expected to ... Read more »

Don't doubt Shanahan's front-office impact

Don't doubt Shanahan's front-office impact Larry Johnson. He goes in, talks about the games, leaves it at the office and goes home to his family. Might not have the adrenaline ... Read more »

Canada to drop vaccine mandate, mask requirements for professional athletes, visitors

Canada to drop vaccine mandate, mask requirements for professional athletes, visitors TORONTO — The Canadian government confirmed, on Monday, that non-citizens entering the country — including professional athletes — will ... Read more »

Cyprus seeks UN help to stem asylum-seeker 'avalanche'

Cyprus seeks UN help to stem asylum-seeker 'avalanche' The interior minister of Cyprus says he’s seeking help from the United Nations to stem an “avalanche” of migrants who make their ... Read more »

Rachel Zegler Reveals She Had a Breast Cancer Scare at 19

Charles Sykes/Invision/AP, File Rachel Zegler is getting real about her health. The “West Side Story” star took to social media to share her experience with a breast cancer scare she ... Read more »

Sad Stat Highlights How Bad NFL's London Matchups Have Been

Sad stat highlights how bad NFL’s London matchups have been originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston London has hosted almost two seasons worth of NFL games, but it has seen ... Read more »

Watch: ‘La Brea' Season 2 Trailer Teases New Adventures

NBCUniversal Media, LLC NBC’s sci-fi series “La Brea” is back for a second season. The first season of the David Applebaum-created series saw a massive sinkhole opening up in Los ... Read more »

San Francisco firefighter wearing ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ T-shirt violated uniform policy

A San Francisco firefighter seen wearing a T-shirt while on duty with the conservative catchphrase “Let’s Go Brandon” written on it violated department policy, a spokesman said. The city employee ... Read more »

Man charged with beating, carjacking of chef in Chinatown

chef CHICAGO (WBBM NEWSRADIO) — An 18-year-old man is charged with attempted murder and other felonies for the beating and carjacking over five months ago near Chinatown, officials announced Friday. ... Read more »

What did Argentina coach Lionel Scaloni say about Mexico’s national team?

LONDON, ENGLAND – MAY 31: Lionel Scaloni, Head Coach of Argentina speaks to the media during the Argentina Press Conference at Wembley Stadium on May 31, 2022 in London, England. ... Read more »

No, you don't need Amazon Prime to watch the Bengals vs Dolphins on Thursday night

When the Cincinnati Bengals (1-2) face the Miami Dolphins (3-0) on Thursday Night Football, the game will be broadcast locally. Channel 9 (WCPO-TV) will air the local broadcast of the ... Read more »

Peer who organised Queen's funeral banned from driving for using phone behind wheel

A senior peer who organised the Queen’s funeral has been handed a six-month driving ban for using his mobile phone behind the wheel. The Duke of Norfolk in his role ... Read more »

Hurricane Ian Could Gain Strength Rapidly. Here’s Why.

A firefighter in Bourg, La., during Hurricane Ida last year. Wind speeds in the storm rose to 150 miles per hour, from 85 m.p.h., in less than 24 hours. Early ... Read more »

Paul Finebaum Uses 1 Word To Describe How He Feels About 2 Prominent SEC Programs

@finebaum Last Saturday afternoon, the Auburn Tigers narrowly escaped a close game against the Tigers of Missouri. It was a pretty awful football game, and Paul Finebaum came away “depressed” ... Read more »

Cabell County Schools confirms drowning victim as student

WSAZ HUNTINGTON, W.Va. (WSAZ) — Cabell County Schools Director of Communications, Jedd Flowers, confirms Monday a young boy who drowned Saturday while swimming in the Ohio River was a student of ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network