Bungie sues Bungie impersonator for millions over Destiny 2 DMCAs

Destiny 2 developer Bungie has filed a $7.6 million lawsuit against one Nicholas Minor, alleging they sent DMCA takedown notices pretending to be from Bungie

Bungie sues Bungie impersonator for millions over Destiny 2 DMCAs

Bungie has filed a lawsuit against one Nicholas Minor, claiming that, after receiving a copyright takedown notice on their Destiny 2 YouTube videos, they retaliated by creating a series of fake Bungie email addresses, and sending DMCA notices to other YouTubers, pretending to be from the company.

Minor was the owner of a YouTube account named Lord Nazo. According to Bungie’s filing, in December 2021, CSC Global – which acts as the developer’s brand protector – sent a takedown notice to Minor after they had uploaded to YouTube the soundtrack for the Destiny expansion The Taken King. Minor allegedly refused to remove their videos, and left them online until they were removed by YouTube in January. Minor then registered a new Gmail address, designed to mimic the email addresses of CSC Global employees.

In February, another Destiny soundtrack was uploaded to the Lord Nazo channel, this time from the Destiny 2 Witch Queen expansion, and again, Bungie issued an official takedown notice. Minor allegedly then registered a second CSC-style email address, and – according to Bungie’s filing – “began to send out a wave of fraudulent takedown notices.”

Bungie learned of Minor’s actions when it was sent data by Google, outlining the recent takedown notices that had been issued by the supposed “CSC”, as well as the IP address from which they had originated. The former Halo developer claims that Minor orchestrated the campaign in order to damage its reputation among players and the Destiny community, as retaliation for the copyright takedowns Minor had received – the studio claims that, as well as sending out fake takedown notices, Minor used his Lord Nazo online accounts to spread “disinformation” about Bungie, and the wave of false DMCA takedowns that Minor themself had engineered.

“Ninety-six times,” explains the studio’s legal filing, “Minor sent DMCA takedown notices purportedly on behalf of Bungie, identifying himself as Bungie’s ‘brand protection’ vendor in order to have YouTube instruct innocent creators to delete their Destiny 2 videos or face copyright strikes, disrupting Bungie’s community of players, streamers, and fans. And all the while, ‘Lord Nazo’ was taking part in the community discussion of “Bungie’s” takedowns, spreading disinformation.

“This caused Bungie significant reputational and economic damage, for obvious reasons. As discussed below, the Destiny community was bewildered and upset, believing that Bungie had reneged on a promise to allow players to build their own streaming communities and YouTube channels on Destiny 2 content. Destiny community members were also misled to believe that Bungie’s brand protection agent was also fraudulent, causing confusion among users as to the authenticity of legitimate DMCA notices. Bungie had to devote significant internal resources to addressing it and helping its players restore their videos and channels.”

Bungie is now seeking total damages of $7.6m dollars – $150,000 “for each of the works implicated in the Fraudulent Takedown Notice”. We will continue to keep you updated on this story as it develops.

News Related


OnePlus Might Launch New TWS & Wearables in Q3 2022

OnePlus Buds (2021) A reliable tipster suggested that OnePlus has two new wireless buds to launch this year. Besides, the OnePlus launch lineup also includes OnePlus Watch 2 and the ... Read more »

Lyrics 2+3=5

After the song Toskaa, TRI continued to release the song 2+3=5. Belonging to the genre of young music, gentle melodies, simple lyrics, right from the first days of its release, ... Read more »

PS Plus Essential July 2022 Lineup Has Leaked

PS Plus Essential July 2022 games lineup has leaked. We’re confident about this one because it comes from the same Dealabs user, billbil kun, who has been accurately leaking the ... Read more »

The Callisto Protocol Will Feature 10-11 Enemy Types

Studio head and game director Glen Schofield also confirms that The Callisto Protocol will not feature any space combat. Read more »

Take a trip with us in the Tesla Model Y and the Audi e-tron GT

Check out the first two instalments of our new Quick Look series, EV Hour. Read more »

The FFXIV report system is still awful, say players

Nearly ten years after MMORPG Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn launched, players say the FFXIV report system is still hard to find in-game and terrible to use Read more »

Forza Motorsport is Looking Like a Technical Xbox Series X Powerhouse

Forza Motorsport's recent gameplay showing has promised a visual showcase the Xbox Series X/S next year. Read more »

Your Mistake lyrics

With passionate lyrics, the song “My mistake” was composed by young singer Dinh Dung and performed by a large number of young audiences. The content of the song tells about ... Read more »

Final Fantasy 16 Won’t Have American Accents Because of Its Medieval Europe Setting

Good news! Final Fantasy 16 setting and accents will match, ensuring that players don’t complain about immersion, or lack thereof, when they hear American accents while running around in fantasy ... Read more »

Final Fantasy 16 is Still No. 3 in Famitsu’s Most Wanted Charts

The upcoming PS5 RPG is beaten to the charts' top spot by upcoming Switch exclusive duo Splatoon 3 and Xenoblade Chronicles 3. Read more »

Final Fantasy 16’s English Audio Features Only British Accents for Authenticity’s Sake, Developer Says

Producer Naoki Yoshida says the decision was made to authentically portray a medieval European fantasy setting. Read more »

PS5 Was Outsold by Xbox Series X/S in Japan Again Last Week Thanks to Persisting Stock Shortages

The Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S both individually managed to outsell the PS5's two models combined in the region last week. Read more »

Xenoblade Chronicles 3 Seemingly Has Lip Sync for Both Japanese and English Audio

Fans seem to have noticed a long-requested improvement in recent Xenoblade Chronicles 3 gameplay footage. Read more »

Hideo Kojima wanted a game “similar” to The Boys with Mads Mikkelsen

According to Metal Gear Solid and Death Stranding creator Hideo Kojima, he considered a superhero game similar to The Boys starring Mads Mikkelsen Read more »

Skull and Bones Rated by the ESRB Ahead of Rumoured Imminent Reveal

The ESRB rating seems to confirm that the game has dropped last-gen versions in favour of native current-gen releases, in addition to PC and Stadia versions. Read more »

Fall Guys Attracted 20 Million Players Within 48 Hours of Free-to-Play Launch

Mediatonic's battle royale title went free-to-play recently, and reaped the benefits with over 20 million players in its first two days. Read more »

Upcoming Nintendo Direct Will be Focused on Third Party Games – Rumour

A journalist has claimed that the rumoured upcoming Nintendo Direct will be focused on third party titles, including announcements for Persona, Mario + Rabbids, and more. Read more »

Warzone: How to Win More Gunfights

Warzone can be a hard game for even the most experienced Call of Duty players. Its high punishments for death and player base of knowledgeable players can sometimes make gunfights ... Read more »

15 Best Apple Watch Games With or Without iPhone

Apple Watch games are the perfect way to pass the time when you’re bored or waiting for something. They’re also a great way to stay entertained while you’re on the ... Read more »

Sony Computer Entertainment America’s Founding Member Bernie Stolar Has Passed Away

Image: VentureBeat Former PlayStation executive and Sony Computer Entertainment America’s founding member Bernie Stolar has passed away aged 75. News of Stolar’s demise was first reported by VentureBeat and confirmed ... Read more »

12 Best Pirate Games for An Ultimate Adventure

Ahoy me, fellow captains! Arrr, ye ready to embark on a voyage, sail into treacherous waves, and dock your ship in the lands full of treasures? Listen to the tale ... Read more »

11 Best Mystery Games of All Time

There’s always something peculiar about mystery games that attract the attention of witty players. The sense of discovering a point to pull off the string and let the thread go ... Read more »

Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart Might Join PS Plus

Players in some countries have spotted a promotional image suggesting that Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart PS Plus entry is on its way. The screenshot that’s being circulated on Reddit ... Read more »

10 Best Batman Games of All Time

When it comes to gaming, superhero games are in a league of their own. That feeling you get when you defeat bad guys after hours of grinding and save the ... Read more »

Take a look at this Red Dead Revolver Fan Remake in Unreal Engine 5

TeaserPlay has shared a new video, showcasing what a remake of Rockstar’s Red Dead Revolver could have looked like in Unreal Engine 5. For this video, TeaserPlay used Lumen, Nanite, ... Read more »

How to List All Windows Services using PowerShell or Command Line

The running applications you see on your screen are a fraction of what is happening in Windows. From managing device drivers to ensuring security, a bunch of background processes maintain ... Read more »

Action RPG Valkyrie Elysium Rated for Release on PS5, PS4

Looks like Square Enix’s action RPG Valkyrie Elysium is on schedule for its 2022 release, as it’s been rated by a number of classifications boards around the world – including ... Read more »

Lego Star Wars Summer Vacation is coming to Disney+ this August

The animated special features the voices of Star Wars alumni and even includes a new, original song from "Weird Al" Yankovic. Read more »

Half-Life Alyx No VR Mod looks better than ever, new gameplay video

It’s been a while since our last look at the No VR Mod for Half-Life Alyx. And last month, SoMNst released a brand new gameplay video for it, showcasing its ... Read more »

Far Cry: Rework is another cool mod for Crytek’s classic shooter

Modder ‘-SX-‘ is currently working on a brand new mod for Crytek’s classic shooter, Far Cry. This is the third major mod that is in development for the first Far ... Read more »

MSI Stealth GS66 (12UGS) Review- Like A Sleek, Elegant Sports Car

Nowadays, portability is almost as important as the actual function of a laptop, yet the two always seem inversely proportionate: the more portable a computer, the less likely you’d be ... Read more »

3D Scanning Trouble? This Guide Has You Covered

When it comes to 3D scanning, a perfect surface looks a lot like the image above: thousands of distinct and random features, high contrast, no blurry areas, and no shiny ... Read more »

How to complete Continued Cleanup in the Genshin Impact A Muddy Bizarre Adventure event

Screenshot by Pro Game Guides Genshin Impact’s A Muddy Bizarre Adventure event reunites players with Sumeru Researcher Hosseini in The Chasm Underground Mines. You’ll be working together to find a ... Read more »

Lost Ark announces Witcher 3 collaboration and new class

Smilegate announces a Lost Ark Witcher 3 collaboration and previews the upcoming Aeromancer class, coming to the free-to-play ARPG's Korean server in early July Read more »

Forget Fallout 5, epic Fallout 4 mod Fallout London is out 2023

Fallout 5 and Elder Scrolls 6 are years away, but epic Fallout 4 mod Fallout: London falls-out in 2023 - the same year as Starfield. Here's the epic new trailer Read more »

Top acne removal apps for smartphone believers

When it comes to facial beauty things such as: slimming chin, whitening skin, removing scars, removing acne… often users will immediately think of photo editing software. Photoshop On a computer, ... Read more »

Fallout 4’s DLC-sized Mod, Fallout London, gets a new in-engine trailer

The modding team behind the DLC-sized mod for Fallout 4, Fallout London, has released a brand new in-engine trailer. According to the team, this video and announcement were put together ... Read more »

Apple AirPods Pro 2 Leaks Suggest H1 Chip, Heart Rate Detection & More

Image: 52Audio Apple has been working on AirPods Pro’s next-generation for a long time, and till now, we have got a lot of rumors about it, but the latest report ... Read more »

How to Block Extension Installation in Microsoft Edge

Just like Google Chrome, Edge browser also lets you install several extensions to improve or expand the web browser’s functionality. While there are no restrictions on the number of extensions ... Read more »

Talking Point: What PS Plus Games for PS5, PS4 Do You Want This Month? (July 2022)

What are the PS Plus games for PS5 and PS4 in July 2022? When will All PS Plus Games for July 2022 be announced? We’re in a brave new era ... Read more »