Bullies rely on power to protect them, not online anonymity

Asia's Tech News Daily

I’ve had more death threats than flat whites. But almost everyone who abused me did so using their real names

The prime minister would have you believe that social media is where people hide behind faceless avatars to cause harm. ​​​​​​

Those who “go anonymously on to social media”, he said, “need to be responsible for what they’re saying.” According to Scott Morrison, those online bullies lurk only in the shadows, spewing lies and wreaking havoc, cowardly exploiting the cover of darkness.

His comments came as he was announcing that a bill would be introduced to parliament this week which he said would help reveal the users behind anonymous “troll” accounts and make it easier to sue them for defamation.

Related: Should politicians like Peter Dutton suck up Twitter’s hot-gives and -takes or pursue vindication? | Paul Daley

But those who cause the most harm in our society do not need to hide. They vilify, harass and abuse in plain sight, and are often rewarded for their trouble. The worst bullies in Australia are not anonymous trolls but those in power who do not wish to be challenged, using every weapon in their arsenal to maintain the status quo.

Trust me, I know.

I’ve had more death threats than flat whites. I’ve spent years opening my inbox to emails from strangers detailing their graphic fantasies of my execution (after I have been raped and flogged, of course). I’ve listened to pundits casually chatting about murdering me on national radio, politicians suggest I support dictatorships, seen over 200,000 words written about me in the press, all amounting to a “full-scale assault on [my] existence”.

I know first hand what it’s like to be vilified and harassed, so naturally, I would welcome a genuine attempt to help.

But this, no matter how the prime minister and his government try to dress it up, will not. Because here’s the kicker: Almost every single person who took part in the unrelenting tsunami of abuse and harassment against me did so using their real identity.

The government’s proposed legislation, forcing social media companies to reveal the identities of anonymous accounts, is less about protecting the average citizen and more about the government’s singular obsession with control and power.

Anonymity is not what protects bullies. Power is.

Morrison has framed the bill as a the pathway for individuals to sue anyone online for defamation. Let us ask ourselves: who has enough money to sue anonymous users of the internet? Who has the financial resources, legal knowhow, the time? I certainly don’t, but defence minister Peter Dutton does.

When Dutton sued the activist Shane Bazzi for defamation, he told the court Bazzi’s since deleted tweet had “deeply offended” him, was “defamatory, hurtful and I took particular exception to it”.

We all take particular exception to things people say about us. The Lebanese community took exception to Dutton saying it was a mistake to resettle Lebanese-Muslims in Australia. The South Sudanese community took exception to Dutton’s hurtful and offensive comments about “African gang violence”. I personally took exception to Dutton gloating when I lost my job at the ABC.

But none of us were in a position to sue Dutton, for defamation or otherwise.

“The rules that exist in the real world must exist in the digital and online world,” the prime minister has said.

It is worth remembering our reality, where the rules in the offline world favour those in power. By attacking anonymity, this proposal entrenches inequalities further. As Digital Rights Watch reminds us, real-name policies leads to real-world harm.

Related: Muslim and fabulous: how the internet changed fashion for Aussie hijabistas | Yassmin Abdel-Magied

Anonymity online is one of the few things that ever so slightly levels the playing field, allowing us to explore and organise and play without fear. Whether it’s a woman creating a nameless account to help her leave an abusive relationship, a young teen exploring identity or our favourite political parody accounts, anonymity is foundational to the free and open internet.

If the government is genuinely interested in online safety, there are plenty of avenues worth considering: updating archaic data protection laws, resourcing existing regulators effectively and tackling big tech’s harmful business model.

Online safety is a vitally important issue but one that can only be dealt with by addressing the concentration of power in companies that are not accountable to their users. That is where the attention of any government seriously concerned with digital rights should be.

Anonymity is a red herring, cloaking the fragile egos of cowardly men.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Royal scandal: why Meghan and Harry feel vindicated about leaving the ‘toxic’ royals

She’s about to celebrate 70 years on the throne, and last week, the Queen proved she’s not a monarch to be messed with as she dramatically stripped son Prince Andrew ... Read more »

Quarantined Italian MPs gear up for drive-in vote for new president

Photograph: Giuseppe Lami/EPA Speaker of lower house seeks permission to give 35 ‘grand electors’ a chance to have their say Italian parliamentarians who have Covid-19 may be allowed to cast ... Read more »

A commit from four-star QB Jackson Arnold may get the Sooners rolling for their 2023 recruiting efforts

Oklahoma has finally gotten the much-needed stabilization they needed following the upheaval that occurred at the core of their program when Lincoln Riley left following their loss to their in-state ... Read more »

Arsenal make bid for American goalkeeper with Bernd Leno expected to move on

© Provided by Metro Matt Turner could be making his first move to a European club (Picture: Getty Images) Arsenal have made a bid for New England Revolution and United ... Read more »

Missouri hires LSU's former linebacker coach Blake Baker

© Provided by LSU Tigers Wire Former LSU linebackers coach Blake Baker will now coach Safeties at Missouri for the Tigers. Baker joined LSU’s coaching staff last year. Before that, ... Read more »

USC lands Pac-12 running back as Trojans continue to weaken their rivals

© Provided by Trojans Wire It’s been a busy few days in terms of roster turnover for the USC Trojans. They have added a few big players, but what is ... Read more »

The Omicron Variant Is Impacting Young People's Mental Health

© Getty Images Elias, 14, lost both his grandfathers to COVID on the same day in April of 2021. Even if the virus eventually passes and people can safely leave ... Read more »

Investing legend Jeremy Grantham says market speculation has already peaked —and warns the S&P 500 could plunge 44% despite the Fed's best efforts

© Boston Globe/Getty Images Jeremy Grantham, Boston Globe/Getty Images Jeremy Grantham says the speculative boom in meme stocks and crypto has already peaked. The GMO cofounder warned the S&P 500 ... Read more »

How ExpertFlyer saved my spring break trip from a drastic schedule change

MSN has partnered with The Points Guy for our coverage of credit card products. MSN and The Points Guy may receive a commission from card issuers. My wife and I ... Read more »

Quick Points: Earn American Loyalty Points when you stay at hotels and rent cars

MSN has partnered with The Points Guy for our coverage of credit card products. MSN and The Points Guy may receive a commission from card issuers. Hotel chains and car ... Read more »

How to watch Fairleigh Dickinson vs. St. Francis (N.Y.): TV channel, NCAAB live stream info, start time

© Provided by CBS Sports Mar 20, 2019; Salt Lake City, UT, USA; General overall view of a basketball approaching the rim and net before the first round of the ... Read more »

Detectives pull apart rundown caravan to bag evidence from where Kallista Mutten spent the night as her nine-year-old daughter was allegedly murdered 80km away at Justin Stein's luxury family estate

Police spent day pulling apart a rundown caravan where Kallista Mutten stayedMother of slain schoolgirl was at isolated park before Charlise Mutten diedRiviera Ski Park is 80km from luxury estate where Charlise disappearedOn Friday detectives combed caravan, a cabin and briefly detained two men  Read more »

Video: Greggs worker who filmed video of 'mountains' of food going to waste every day at the bakery chain was sacked when it became a massive TikTok hit

Read more »

Cardiff could progress in Champions Cup after Toulouse forfeit

Cardiff could find themselves in the knock-out stages of the Heineken European Champions Cup, as their final pool fixture this weekend has been cancelled. Holders Toulouse have suffered a Covid ... Read more »

People positive in COVID-19 self-test should report to authorities –DILG

A COVID-19 Lateral Flow (LFT) self-test kit, containing a SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Rapid Test, supplied by Britain’s National Health Service (NHS), is arranged for a photograph in Brenchley, southeast England, on ... Read more »

Ukraine-Russia crisis – latest: Putin raises invasion fears with troop build-up as Blinken holds Geneva talks

LIVE – Updated at 10:45 Russia has bolstered its military deployment on the border with Ukraine in recent weeks with Moscow’s military power now consisting of 106,000 troops, according to ... Read more »

Twitter suspends over 300 accounts of Marcos Jr. ‘supporters'

Twitter thumb Twitter thumbnail Social media platform Twitter disclosed Friday that over 300 accounts from the supporter base of former senator and presidential aspirant Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. have been ... Read more »

Is THIS the Oscar Best Picture Winner?

Already seen as a strong Oscars favourite, Sir Kenneth Branagh’s autobiographical film Belfast has been met with rave reviews as it opens in UK and Irish cinemas today.  The story ... Read more »

Ben Shephard recalls 'throwing' Meat Loaf out of studio after 'extraordinary' interview

© Bang Showbiz Ben Shephard and Kate Garraway have shared their memories of late singer Meat Loaf Ben Shephard has recalled Meat Loaf being “thrown” out of a studio because ... Read more »

Russia will be ‘punished’ if troops are sent into Ukraine – No 10

Russia will be “punished” if the country pushes ahead with any “destabilising action” in Ukraine, Downing Street has warned. US Secretary of State Antony Blinken is holding last-ditch talks with ... Read more »

Boris Johnson tells schools to ditch masks in class

© PA Wire Masks in school classrooms were scrapped on Thursday – PA Wire Downing Street has told schools to follow the Government’s new guidance on wearing face masks in ... Read more »

Cast members of Meat Loaf-inspired musical to pay tribute to rocker during show

The cast members of a musical based on Meat Loaf’s Bat Out Of Hell album have said performing the rocker’s songs will be “incredibly moving”. Bat Out of Hell: The ... Read more »

US warns any movement of Russian military forces across Ukraine's border will be met with 'severe response'

US secretary of state Antony Blinken has said that any movement of “Russian military forces across Ukraine’s border” will be met with a “swift, severe and united response”. © Sky ... Read more »

Biden approval has sunk most with young Americans, independents

While President Biden’s rating decline over the past year has been broad-based, spanning both political and demographic lines, it has been especially pronounced among younger people and independents. Both groups ... Read more »

How to buy a gaming laptop

Gaming laptops have evolved to keep up with the needs of even the most intense gamers, making them a serious alternative to desktop PCs for all but the highest-power setups. ... Read more »

Segera kuat kuasa pelan anti rasuah GIACC, DPMM beritahu kerajaan

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Barisan pimpinan DPMM bersama pemimpin NGO Melayu lain pada sidang media sempena majlis ramah mesra bersama media. KUALA LUMPUR: Dewan Perniagaan Melayu Malaysia (DPMM) ... Read more »

YouTube deactivates two Oath Keepers channels after seditious conspiracy charges

Two YouTube channels linked to the far-right extremist group Oath Keepers have been deactivated by the website, the Google subsidiary told Axios. It wasn’t exactly due to the content of ... Read more »

No Downing Street investigation into blackmail claims, despite minister’s call for probe

© PA Wire Business Secretary Kwasi Kwarteng (Victoria Jones/PA) – PA Wire Downing Street is not conducting an inquiry into allegations of intimidation and blackmail by government whips, despite a ... Read more »

Wallace & Gromit set for epic film return as BBC announces first new movie in 16 years

WALLACE & Gromit are returning to the screen once more – over a decade since their last special A Matter Of Loaf And Death aired. The comedy franchise is set ... Read more »

French cannibal who murdered and ate farmer ESCAPES and beats woman with a stick in random horror attack

A NOTORIOUS French cannibal who murdered and ate a farmer has escaped custody and beaten a woman with a stick in a random horror attack. Jeremey Rimbaud, 34, grabbed his ... Read more »

Sturgeon reported to statistics watchdog over claims she ‘twisted’ data

Nicola Sturgeon has been reported to the statistics watchdog amid claims she “seriously twisted” the use of coronavirus figures. During First Minister’s Questions on Thursday, Ms Sturgeon referenced Office for ... Read more »

Der noch sportlichere SL-Bruder kommt 2023 - Erlkönig Mercedes-AMG GT

Mercedes bringt auf der gleichen Plattform wie beim SL ein Sportcoupé. Der neue AMG GT wird für 2023 erwartet. Jetzt wurde erst erstmals als Erlkönig erwischt. © Stefan Baldauf Mit ... Read more »

[PICS] Residents urged to keep away after shipwreck washes up on Cape Town beach

The City of Cape Town has urged the public to stay clear of the shipwreck at Oudekraal beach The old shipwreck wash shifted from the ocean’s floor following massive waves ... Read more »

Meat Loaf, 'Bat Out of Hell' Singer and 'Rocky Horror Picture Show' Actor, Dead at 74

© Eddie Malluk/WireImage for Virgin Records – NY Meat Loaf has died. The legendary rocker and actor, whose real name was Marvin Lee Aday, was 74. Meat Loaf’s manager Michael ... Read more »

England to play Ivory Coast for the first time in friendly at Wembley

England will play their first ever senior fixture against the Ivory Coast in a friendly this March, which could see former Three Lions winger Wilfried Zaha line up for the ... Read more »

Rangers and Manchester City 'keeping track' of Motherwell talent as preferred transfer destination stated

Rangers and Manchester City are two teams reportedly looking at signing Motherwell prospect Bailey Rice. The 15-year-old is considered as one of the Steelmen’s brightest youngsters at the minute and ... Read more »

Mass: Ann Dowd explains why she is unable to watch her intense new film

Ann Dowd is quite certain she will never watch her new film. Dowd stars in Mass, a drama that premiered in Sundance Film Festival last January and has finally been ... Read more »

Newcastle boss Eddie Howe frustrated over attempts to sign Manchester United's Jesse Lingard

Newcastle boss Eddie Howe has aired his frustrations over attempts to make new signings this week amid interest in Manchester United’s Jesse Lingard. The Magpies have been one of the ... Read more »

Starting Daryl Dike, Kyle Bartley's fitness & Dara O'Shea's West Brom's plan

Kyle Bartley is set to return to West Brom’s starting XI for the visit of Peterborough on Saturday. Centre half Bartley was an absentee – one of five defenders to ... Read more »

Spider-Man Across the Spider-Verse 1 & 2: Everything you need to know

Spider-Man is bigger than ever, with No Way Home similarly breaking the box office to the tune of $1.6 billion. Right ahead of its success, Sony gave fans their first ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic