Building laws ‘still open to abuse' 10 years after safety fiasco at Priory Hall

Asia's Tech News Daily

South Dublin County Council will not prosecute a property developer who bypassed planning and building regulations brought in after the Priory Hall debacle and filled an apartment complex with tenants without proper certification.

Now Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin has said local authorities should be more assertive when it comes to holding developers to account when they break the rules.

He cites the example of Larkfield House in Dublin’s Clondalkin as a scheme where a developer bypassed regulations and put tenants in an uncertified building but did not face sanctions, thus sending a message to developers that cutting corners won’t be punished.

Larkfield House is a former Ben Dunne gym that was bought by a company run by developer Vincent Cosgrave, who applied for planning permission in 2016 to convert it into a block of 27 apartments, which was granted.

He then tried to increase the number of apartments to 48 but failed, and appealed to An Bord Pleanála.

“While that appeal was being heard, the old gym was turned into 44 apartments,” Mr Ó Broin said.

“The original architect on the project was not registered with the Royal Institute of Architects register,” he said, adding that it is an offence not to be registered if you are an architect seeking certification in building and planning matters.

“Not only did the developers breach the planning permission, but they also at no stage lodged any valid certificates of compliance with the local authority.

“They then lost their appeal with the board, but by that stage they had the property fully tenanted.

“Building control compliance isn’t some minor affair.

“The act states very clearly that if you allow a building to be occupied without a completion certificate, under the new building regulations brought in after Priory Hall, you can be subject to criminal proceedings, and a hefty fine of up to €10,000 and up to six months in jail.”

In 2018, Mr Cosgrave applied to SDCC to retain 37 of the 44 apartments they had built, but the matter of finalising certification is still ongoing.

When contacted, Mr Cosgrave accepted that he did not have planning permission for the number of apartments he constructed at Larkfield House, he had no commencement notice or completion certificate, and the architect he first used was not registered, meaning any certification he submitted was not valid.

“I wasn’t building a new building. I was converting one that was already there, so I didn’t think we’d have any problems [with planning ­permission],” he said.

Read More

Asked about using an unregistered architect, Mr Cosgrave said he had been using the man for years and didn’t know he was not registered.

“Building is bogged down with paperwork these days,” he said. “I don’t think he was up to speed on it all. He’s retired now and I’m using another architect.

“I accept things were done wrong but I didn’t set out to break any rules. Whatever is needed is getting done and sorted now. It was an oversight and we got slapped on the hand for that.”

However Mr Ó Broin says the worry is that “if this one developer, in a very public way, can breach not only planning law, but every single aspect of the building control amendment regulations, that sends out a signal to builders and developers that says, ‘do you know what, these reforms that were put in place in 2014 aren’t worth a damn’”.

In response to questions from the Irish Independent, SDCC said additional works requested by Dublin Fire Brigade (DFB) had been carried out at Larkfield House by the developer, and the fire consultant was awaiting a final sign-off by the ancillary certifiers.

SDCC confirmed no commencement notice was submitted to it in relation to the change of use of the premises from gym to apartments prior to the work starting.

“It was not obvious from the street that any works were being undertaken as they were being carried out within the shell of an existing building,” a council spokesman said.

“SDCC carried out a site inspection as soon as it became aware of the works ­following an anonymous phone call.

“SDCC issued a letter to the developer on May 11, 2017, instructing him to cease all works forthwith because a commencement notice had not been submitted.”

The SDCC spokesman said the developer continued with the works and proceeded to occupy the building, and that Dublin Fire Brigade inspected the building in February 2018 and reported the premises was found to be broadly compliant and no enforcement action was deemed to be necessary under that legislation.

“No enforcement proceedings were brought under building control legislation,” the SDCC spokesman confirmed.

Read More

Get ahead of the day with the morning headlines at 7.30am and Fionnán Sheahan’s exclusive take on the day’s news every afternoon, with our free daily newsletter.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


NCP leader Nawab Malik now has Rs 1000 crore defamation suit to reply to in 6 weeks

Bombay HC grants Nawab Malik 6 weeks to reply to Rs 1000 cr defamation suit The Bombay High Court on Monday granted six weeks’ time to Maharashtra cabinet minister and ... Read more »

Weather Updates: Cyclonic storm likely to hit Andhra Pradesh, Odisha on Dec 3; check forecast for your city

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: The India Meteorological Department (IMD) on Monday (November 29) predicted heavy rainfall in Odisha and Andhra Pradesh from November 30 ... Read more »

Ferrari appoints ORECA to build next-gen GT3 car

© SRO #52 AF Corse Ferrari 488 GT3: Louis Machiels, Andrea Bertolini ORECA has won the tender to assemble the new contender under development on an as-yet-to-be disclosed car from ... Read more »

Cyber Monday: Five Excellent Products For Tesla Owners

© InsideEVs from left: Tesla Model S, Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model X and Tesla Model Y at a Tesla Supercharging station When it comes to shopping, it’s the most ... Read more »

Sir Frank Williams: The motor-racing mastermind who took his team to Formula 1's summit

Frank Williams has died at the age of ?? (David Davies/PA). (PA Archive) Sir Frank Williams was one of the most remarkable figures in British sport. Williams took his motor ... Read more »

Why I'm thrilled Steven Spielberg is remaking West Side Story: It soundtracked my own coming of age

The sound of a whistle, that’s all it took to put a stupid smile on my face. © ES Composite WestSideStory1961v4.jpg “Nothing’s even happened yet,” my baffled friend said as ... Read more »

Beer Association promotes moderate alcohol consumption as fourth wave looms

©… © viteethumb/ CAPE TOWN – Fearing a crackdown on alcohol sales when COVID-19 hospitalisations rise, the Beer Association of South Africa (Basa) on Monday said it was advocating ... Read more »

Bitcoin: Tech company buys $400 million in crypto as price dramatically recovers

Tech company MicroStrategy has bought more than $400 million of bitcoin as it continues to invest in the cryptocurrency. © Independent Breaking News MicroStrategy is a software company that sells ... Read more »

Max Malins: ‘If you're in an England shirt, you can't be too disappointed'

As the unflappable Max Malins has been demonstrating all year, rugby can still be a game for languid piano players as well as piano shifters. Of course it matters who ... Read more »

PMGC 2021 Finals invited slot will be given to Indian team

© Provided by Dot Esports A team from India will receive a direct invite to the PUBG Mobile Global Championship (PMGC) 2021 Finals, Tencent confirmed today. When the format for ... Read more »

Pension warning: Britons may face retirement income shortfall as investment returns fall

Consumers approaching retirement may be disappointed to find that their prospects could be worsening, as the average annuity income fell during the third quarter (Q3) of 2021. has warned ... Read more »

Omicron: Urgent hunt for COVID cases linked to KFC restaurant and school in Essex

A primary school and a KFC restaurant in Brentwood, Essex, are linked to a case of the Omicron variant of coronavirus. (Reach) Health officials are hunting for anyone linked to ... Read more »

Moderna can take months to ship Omicron-specific vaccine, CEO says on CNBC

FILE PHOTO: Test tubes are seen in front of a displayed Moderna logo in this illustration (Reuters) – Moderna Inc could take months to begin shipping a COVID-19 vaccine that ... Read more »

Yussuf Mustapha: 14-year-old who killed schoolboy Keon Lincoln is jailed for life

Yussuf Mustapha, the 14-year-old who shot dead schoolboy Keon Lincoln during a gun and knife attack in Birmingham, has been sentenced to life in prison, with a minimum term of ... Read more »

Truss warns Vienna talks are ‘last opportunity' for Iran to revive nuclear deal

International negotiations in Vienna mark the “last opportunity” for Iran to revive its original nuclear deal, the Foreign Secretary has warned. Liz Truss told a joint press briefing, held alongside ... Read more »

Joey Barton ‘only person I saw' after tunnel incident, rival manager tells court

A football manager has told a jury how the only person he saw after he was shoved into a metal post in the tunnel after a League One match, injuring ... Read more »

5-year-old Minnesota boy fatally shot on Thanksgiving by teen making social media video

A 5-year-old Minnesota boy was fatally shot on Thanksgiving by a 13-year-old handling a gun while making a social media video, police said. Officers with the Brooklyn Park Police Department ... Read more »

Amir Khan and Kell Brook butt heads and are pulled apart by security as a furious row breaks out at opening press conference

Amir Khan vs Kell Brook, live on Sky Sports Box Office, on February 19 - "He has run away! It has got to a part of his career where there is nowhere else for him to run!" Read more »

50 Best Winter Whiskeys to Try This Season

© Courtesy Image Tenjaku Blended Japanese Whisky—the perfect bottle for your sipping and gifting needs this season. This article was produced in partnership with Tenjaku Whisky We’re in the golden ... Read more »

China's Xi pledges another 1 billion COVID-19 vaccine doses for Africa

© Reuters/CARLOS GARCIA RAWLINS FILE PHOTO: Chinese President Xi Jinping BEIJING (Reuters) -President Xi Jinping on Monday said China would offer another 1 billion doses of COVID-19 vaccines to African ... Read more »

Rangnick sah pengendali sementara United

© Provided by Sinar Harian RALF Rangnick secara rasmi diumumkan sebagai pengendali sementara Manchester United sehingga penghujung musim selepas pemecatan Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. Rangnick akan meninggalkan tugasnya sebagai pengarah sukan ... Read more »

Inside Ghislaine Maxwell's friendship with Prince Andrew as she introduced him to Epstein & ‘sex slave' Virginia Roberts

PRINCE Andrew says he first met Ghislaine Maxwell when he was at university – but it became a friendship that plunged into scandal for the Duke. Ghislaine today faces court ... Read more »

Jon Jones explains in detail why Khabib cannot be considered the GOAT of UFC

Twenty-nine fights. 29 wins. As far as legacies go, Khabib Nurmagomedov has cemented his. © GiveMeSport p1fllsu6ugd0f1061fv916n31od9f.jpg Often touted as the greatest UFC fighter in the history of the promotion, ... Read more »

Orbit Energy on brink of administration - another UK firm goes under due to crisis

The UK energy firm is closing its doors after a spike in global gas prices and is now poised to go into administration. A judge in a specialist court on ... Read more »

Wales resurrect disbanded team as new coach named

Rugby World Cup Sevens winner Richie Pugh has been named as the Welsh Rugby Union’s head of sevens ahead of Wales returning to the World Series in the new year. ... Read more »

A bounce back made of girders: Irn-Bru-maker AG Barr weathers supply crunch and Covid to boost profit forecasts

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Soft drink manufacturer AG Barr shares are up 6 per cent this morning after the Irn-Bru-maker revealed it expects profits to come ... Read more »

Japanese knotweed saves £11.8billion off property values

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Japanese knotweed is responsible for shaving £11.8billion off the value of Britain’s property market, new research by a removal specialist claims. As ... Read more »

Government launches 'unique' face recognition tech for pensioners

Minister of State for Personnel Jitendra Singh on Monday launched a “unique” face recognition technology that would act as a proof of ‘life certificate’ for pensioners and ensure ease of ... Read more »

No Entry Permission slips for goods vehicles now valid till Dec 31: Delhi Police

New Delhi, The Delhi Police on Monday said the validity period of No Entry Permission (NEP) stickers for commercial goods vehicles for plying during restricted hours has been extended up ... Read more »

33% wells registered decline in ground water levels in the range of 0 to 2 meters: Ministry of Jal Shakti

About 33% of wells registered decline in ground water levels in the range of 0 to 2 metres, the Ministry of Jal Shakti said on Monday, noting that decline of ... Read more »

At least 1 person killed as storm pounds Istanbul

ISTANBUL (AP) — A powerful storm pounded Istanbul and other parts of Turkey on Monday, killing at least one person and causing havoc in the city of around 15 million ... Read more »

Biden to meet with CEOs on supply chain amid new COVID threat

U.S. President Joe Biden delivers remarks on the economy at the White House in Washington WASHINGTON (Reuters) – President Joe Biden planned to meet with chief executives of a variety ... Read more »

Pictured: Brutus the great white shark bares his teeth for the camera

Brutus, the 1,500-pound great white shark, baring his ferocious teeth at the camera. – Euan Rannachan/ Not everyone is lucky enough to be born with a Hollywood smile. But Brutus, ... Read more »

PNP chief Carlos favors streamlining gun ownership requirements

© Senate PRIB PNP chief Police General Dionardo Carlos attends a hearing of the Committee on Public Order and Dangerous Drugs on Wednesday, November 24, 2021. Senate PRIB Philippine National ... Read more »

Winteruniversiade abgesagt: Janine Geigele: «Das ist ein Schock»

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Foto: Sven Thomann, 21.9.2019, Genf: Laver-Cup Genf 2019. Janine Geigele moderiert fuer TV24. Corona macht vor der Schweiz nicht halt. Auch diesmal nicht. Nachdem die Eishockey-WM ... Read more »

Franco Nuschese on bringing Cafe Milano to Expo 2020 Dubai

© Provided by The National Homemade pasta served with red, and white wine at Cafe Milano, Dubai Expo. Khushnum Bhandari/ The National You know you’re somewhere special the moment you ... Read more »

Discover Habitas AlUla, an immersive luxury resort in the desert canyons

© Motivate Publishing Habitas AlUla Habitas AlUla is the brand’s first property in the Middle East… © Motivate Publishing The magical landscape of AlUla, with its dramatic sandstone cliffs and ... Read more »

Travis Barker joins Kourtney Kardashian & Penelope Disick as they spin around for an EPIC TikTok video

© Provided by Pinkvilla Kourtney Kardashian, Travis Barker and Penelope Disick have shared a brand new TikTok video where the three of them are spinning around wildly to Bosnian singer ... Read more »

Check Out Pranati Rai Prakash's Hot Belly Dancing Moves!

© Provided by Lehren Check Out Pranati Rai Prakash’s Hot Belly Dancing Moves! Belly Dances are among the most difficult dance moves to perform, but when we witness someone executing ... Read more »

Higher government spending on healthcare lowered per capita out-of-pocket expenses

© Shubhangi Mishra Higher government spending on healthcare lowered per capita out-of-pocket expenses There’s some happy news on government spending on healthcare. The share of government expenditure on healthcare climbed ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic