Bonhomme Richard: Navy report blames crew for devastating fire on US warship

Asia's Tech News Daily

Bonhomme Richard: Navy report blames crew for devastating fire on US warship
© Copyright 2020 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. Navy Ship Fire – Copyright 2020 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

A Navy report has concluded there were sweeping failures by commanders, crew members and others that fueled the July 2020 arson fire that destroyed the USS Bonhomme Richard, calling the massive five-day blaze in San Diego preventable and unacceptable.

While one sailor has been charged with setting the fire, the more than 400-page report, obtained by The Associated Press, lists three dozen officers and sailors whose failings either directly led to the ship’s loss or contributed to it. The findings detailed widespread lapses in training, coordination, communication, fire preparedness, equipment maintenance and overall command and control.

“Although the fire was started by an act of arson, the ship was lost due to an inability to extinguish the fire,” the report said, concluding that “repeated failures” by an “inadequately prepared crew” delivered “an ineffective fire response.”

It slammed commanders of the amphibious assault ship for poor oversight, and said the main firefighting foam system wasn’t used because it hadn’t been maintained properly and the crew didn’t know how to use it. The report is expected to be released Wednesday.

U.S. Navy officials on Tuesday said that while crews at sea consistently meet high firefighting standards, those skills drop off when ships move into maintenance periods. The Bonhomme Richard was undergoing maintenance at the time of the fire.

During maintenence there are more people and organizations involved with the ship, including contractors. And the repairs often involve equipment and chemicals that present different hazards and challenges.

The report describes a ship in disarray, with combustible materials scattered and stored improperly. It said maintenance reports were falsified, and that 87% of the fire stations on board had equipment problems or had not been inspected.

It also found that crew members didn’t ring the bells to alert sailors of a fire until 10 minutes after it was discovered. Those crucial minutes, the report said, caused delays in crews donning fire gear, assembling hose teams and responding to the fire.

Sailors also failed to push the button and activate the firefighting foam system, even though it was accessible and could have slowed the fire’s progress. “No member of the crew interviewed considered this action or had specific knowledge as to the location of the button or its function,” the report said.

The report spreads blame across a wide range of ranks and responsibilities, from the now retired three-star admiral who headed Naval Surface Force Pacific Fleet — Vice Adm. Richard Brown — to senior commanders, lower ranking sailors and civilian program managers. Seventeen were cited for failures that “directly” led to the loss of the ship, while 17 others “contributed” to the loss of the ship. Two other sailors were faulted for not effectively helping the fire response. Of the 36, nine are civilians.

Adm. William Lescher, the vice chief of naval operations, has designated the commander of U.S. Pacific Fleet to handle any disciplinary actions for military members. The Navy officials said the disciplinary process is just beginning. One official said the key challenge in making improvements will be addressing the “human factor,” including leadership skills and ensuring that everyone down to the lowest ranking sailors understands their responsibilities, and can recognize problems and correct them.

The officials spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss the report ahead of its public release.

Specifically, the report said failures of Vice Adm. Brown; Rear Adm. Scott Brown the fleet maintenance officer for the Pacific Fleet; Rear Adm. William Greene, the fleet maintenance officer for U.S. Fleet Forces Command; Rear. Adm. Eric Ver Hage, commander of the regional maintenance center; Rear Adm. Bette Bolivar, commander of Navy Region Southwest; Capt. Mark Nieswiadomy, commander of Naval Base San Diego; and Capt. Tony Rodriguez, commander of Amphibious Squadron 5, all “contributed to the loss of the ship.”

The report also directly faults the ship’s three top officers — Capt. Gregory Thoroman, the commanding officer; Capt. Michael Ray, the executive officer; and Command Master Chief Jose Hernandez — for not effectively ensuring the readiness and condition of the ship.

“The execution of his duties created an environment of poor training, maintenance and operational standards that directly led to the loss of the ship,” the report said of Thoroman. And it said Ray, Hernandez and Capt. David Hart, commander of the Southwest Regional Maintenance Center, also failed in their responsibilities, which directly led to the loss of the ship.

The report only provides names for senior naval officers. Others were described solely by their job or rank.

More broadly, the crew was slammed for “a pattern of failed drills, minimal crew participation, an absence of basic knowledge on firefighting” and an inability to coordinate with civilian firefighters.

“The loss of the USS Bonhomme Richard was a completely avoidable catastrophe,” said U.S. Rep. John Garamendi D-Calif., chairman of the House Armed Services readiness subcommittee. He said he read the report “with shock and anger,” and will look into the matter carefully to “determine the full extent of the negligence and complacency that occurred.”

The ship was undergoing a two-year, $250 million upgrade pierside in San Diego when the fire broke out. About 115 sailors were on board, and nearly 60 were treated for heat exhaustion, smoke inhalation and minor injuries. The failure to extinguish or contain the fire led to temperatures exceeding 1,200 degrees Fahrenheit in some areas, melting sections of the ship into molten metal that flowed into other parts of the ship.

Due to the damage, the Navy decommissioned the ship in April. In August, Seaman Apprentice Ryan Mays was charged with aggravated arson and the willful hazarding of a vessel. He has denied setting the fire.

The blaze began in the lower storage area, which Mays’ duty station had access to, according to a court document. Investigators found three of four fire stations on the ship had evidence of tampering, including disconnected firehoses, and highly flammable liquid was found near the ignition site.

Efforts to put out the fire were hampered because the ship’s crew and other outside fire response departments and organizations were not coordinated, couldn’t communicate effectively, hadn’t exercised together and weren’t well trained, the report said.

The report, written by Vice Adm. Scott Conn, included a number of recommended changes and improvements that have been endorsed by Lescher. The Navy set up a new fire safety assessment program that conducts random inspections, and has taken steps to increase training. Nearly 170 of those inspections have already been done, and officials said they are finding good results.

The Navy also conducted a historical study, looking closely at 15 shipyard fires over the last 12 years. It found recurring trends including failures to comply with fire prevention, detection and response policies.

As a result, Navy leaders are expanding the staffing and responsibilities of the Naval Safety Center to perform audits and unannounced assessments of Navy units. The final costs are still being calculated.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

3 festive cocktails to get you into the holiday spirit

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Are you planning on hosting a holiday dinner party and want to impress your guests? Look no further than these cocktails with whimsical Christmas-themed ... Read more »

Central Florida firefighter to participate in Pearl Harbor commemoration

We recognize a local firefighter as part of this week’s FOX 35 Care Force. Jose Ortiz was chosen to take part in this year’s commemoration of the attack on Pearl ... Read more »

StoreDot's New Battery Tech Repairs Cells, Increases Battery Life

© insideEvs.com Copyright StoreDot 4680 Cylindrical Cells The system identifies bad cells, isolates them, and fixes them without impacting the EV’s driving experience. Battery experts at startup StoreDot have just ... Read more »

Every MTG Arena nerf and buff with launch of Alchemy

© Provided by Dot Esports Nerfs and buffs are coming to MTG Arena via Alchemy, a new Standard digital-only format in Magic, hitting overpowered cards like Luminarch Aspirant and Alrund’s ... Read more »

Mandela 100: Global Citizen changed over 12 million lives in 2021

© Provided by Eyewitness News PICTURE: Kgomotso Neto, Global Citizen CAPE TOWN – On the third anniversary of the Mandela 100 festival, Global Citizen has announced that over 12 million ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett Trial: Man Says Actor Paid Him to 'Fake Beat Him Up'

© Rob Kim/Getty Images One of the two brothers who claim actor Jussie Smollett paid them to pull off a fake attack took the stand on Wednesday. Smollett, 39, faces ... Read more »

Special prosecutor rests case against Jussie Smollett at actor's trial for allegedly staging and reporting phony hate crime

CHICAGO — The team of special prosecutors handling the case against actor Jussie Smollett for allegedly orchestrating and reporting a phony hate crime against himself rested its case late Thursday ... Read more »

Florida man charged for allegedly shooting, killing wife and kids

Florida man charged for allegedly shooting, killing wife and kids A Florida man accused of fatally shooting his wife and two adult children Wednesday morning was arrested and charged with ... Read more »

Politicised security services hindered intelligence on unrest and looting, human rights commission told

‘If the July unrest were to be preempted, it would have required that the intelligence services focus their scrutiny on elements within or linked to the governing party,’ SAHRC inquiry ... Read more »

This 1:2-Scale BMW R 90 S Boxer Model Recreates Iconic Engine

© RideApart.com BMW R 90 S Model – Completed The perfect gift idea for the gearhead on your list. When BMW launched the R 90 S in 1973, the model ... Read more »

Outgoing German Chancellor Angela Merkel receives farewell military honors at 'Grand Tattoo'

© Provided by dw.com Angela Merkel will leave office as soon as the new government is sworn in next week At a ceremony held by torchlight, the Bundeswehr, Germany’s federal ... Read more »

Omicron hits New York City; South Africa registers 11,535 new cases

South Africa registered 11,535 new Covid-19 cases, bringing the cumulative total to 2,988,148. A further 44 Covid-19-related deaths were reported, taking total official deaths to 89,915. A total of 26,109,436 ... Read more »

Electrify America Installed ESS At 140 Stations: 30 MW Output

© InsideEVs Electrify America Installed Battery Energy Storage at 140 DC Fast Charging Stations Across the US The company initiates Virtual Power Plant (VPP) services. Electrify America, one of the ... Read more »

Cricket SA still expect India to tour, but await confirmation from BCCI

Read more »

Cape Flats foundation provides a safe space for children living with Down's syndrome to discover their talents

‘We, as parents, are so used to telling children with Down’s syndrome what they must do. My daughter has taught me that children with Down’s syndrome have a life and ... Read more »

Electoral amendment proposals raise concerns amid pressure to meet June 2022 ConCourt deadline

What’s tabled under the name of the Electoral Amendment Bill in Parliament is understood to have sparked a behind-the-scenes scramble as the document misses bill drafting standards. This complicates matters ... Read more »

Plett Rage Festival cancelled due to spiking COVID cases

© Instagram/@plettrageofficial. A view of Plettenberg Bay where Plett Rage was held this year. JOHANNESBURG – The Rage Festival in Plettenburg Bay has now been cancelled due to the alarming ... Read more »

Eddie Mekka, who starred as the 'Big Ragu' on 'Laverne & Shirley,' dies at 69

© Photo by Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images Penny Marshall, Eddie Mekka star in the 1978 “Laverne & Shirley” episode “Laverne and Shirley Move In.” Photo by Disney ... Read more »

Matthews didn't disclose conflict of interest, performance found wanting - Prasa

© Provided by 702 The Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa) board has terminated CEO Zolani Matthews’s contract of employment. It all seems to centre around the fact that ... Read more »

Britney Spears and the #FreeBritney Movement to Be Honored at LiveOne 2021 Breakout Awards

© VALERIE MACON/AFP via Getty Images Britney Spears and the #FreeBritney movement are being recognized. On Thursday, LiveOne announced that the singer and the successful movement to get her out ... Read more »

Halyna Hutchins' Husband Matthew Attends Event Honoring Her Legacy in Film

© Valerie Durant Halyna Hutchins’s husband, Matthew, attended an event honoring influential women in entertainment, media and technology, and the late cinematographer was among those listed as Changemakers of 2021. TheWrap‘s ... Read more »

Lily Collins Says 'Emily In Paris' Made Changes to Season 2 After Golden Globes Backlash

© Stephanie Branchu & Carole Bethuel/Netflix Lily Collins isn’t blind to the criticism surrounding Emily in Paris. The 32-year-old actress covers the December issue of Glamour, and, in the accompanying interview, opens up about ... Read more »

Could Future Honda Fireblades Get Variable Valve Timing Tech?

© RideApart.com 2021 CBR1000RR-R SP Fireblade – On Track Team Red is working on a new radiator as well. Prior to Honda’s unveiling of the 2020 CBR1000RR-R SP Fireblade at ... Read more »

Eminem's Daughter Hailie Jade Shares Her Top Spotify Artist -- And It Might Surprise You

© Albert L. Ortega/Getty Images Eminem has found one of his biggest fans in a sweet place. The 49-year-old rapper’s daughter, Hailie Jade, posted about her 2021 Spotify Wrapped year-end review ... Read more »

FIFA 22 December Promotion Calendar: What's Expected

December is set to be a big month in FIFA 22, with a variety of promos coming to the game. With a great Black Friday promo rounding out November, there’s ... Read more »

Zee, Sony close in on mega merger; Puneet Goenka travels to Los Angeles

Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd (ZEE) and Sony Pictures Entertainment (SPE) are set to sign a binding merger agreement before Christmas, within the pre-agreed 90-day exclusivity period, said people aware of ... Read more »

RBI moots easier rules for investing overseas

Mumbai: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is batting for easier overseas investment norms for Indian tech entrepreneurs and angel investors, said people with direct knowledge of the matter. As ... Read more »

Indices report biggest single-day gain in a month

Mumbai: India’s benchmark indices gained 1.4% on Thursday to post their biggest single-day rise in a month, led by oil and gas and technology stocks. Recent economic data has led ... Read more »

France slaps down Boris Johnson's plan to curb Channel crossings amid diplomatic spat

France has slapped down Boris Johnson’s plan to crack down on people making dangerous Channel crossings. The Prime Minister had called for British officers to carry out joint patrols on ... Read more »

I'm a Celebrity's Ant and Dec poke fun at Snoochie cheating claims

I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here! hosts Ant and Dec have called out claims Snoochie Shy had cheated in a dig on live TV. © ITV I’m a ... Read more »

Spacewalking astronauts avoid debris as they repair antenna

Spacewalking astronauts replaced a broken antenna outside the International Space Station after getting Nasa’s all-clear for orbiting debris. © Provided by PA Media Astronaut Tom Marshburn replaces a broken antenna ... Read more »

OPD investigating ‘large brawl,' shots fired near Carver Middle School

Orlando police are investigating a “large brawl” that happened off-campus near Carver Middle School Thursday afternoon, where gunshots were heard by school resource officers, according to a department spokesperson. Three ... Read more »

'The Princess Switch 3' includes a cameo from yet another 'Christmas Prince' character and it's further deepening a major plot hole

© Mark Mainz/Netflix Vanessa Hudgens as Princess Stacy, Vanessa Hudgens as Fiona, and Vanessa Hudgens as Queen Margaret in “The Princess Switch 3: Romancing the Star.” Mark Mainz/Netflix Warning: There ... Read more »

Bangor police warns residents of holiday package thefts

Dec. 2—The Bangor Police Department is urging residents to take caution with their holiday packages after a recent theft in an area neighborhood. A package was stolen from a porch ... Read more »

Man at center of Jussie Smollett case testifies he helped fake hate crime because he ‘felt indebted' to actor

One of the men at the center of the criminal case against former “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett took the witness stand on the third day of the trial Wednesday, testifying ... Read more »

State rests case at Smollett trial after star witnesses

CHICAGO (AP) — The state rested its case at Jussie Smollett’s trial Thursday after key testimony from two brothers who said the former “Empire” actor plotted a racist and anti-gay ... Read more »

Black and south Asian Covid death rates ‘higher than for white people' amid vaccine gap

© PA Archive Coronavirus A greater proportion of black and Asian people are dying with coronavirus than white people, despite case numbers in the latter group being higher, a study ... Read more »

How to get the Down with the Ship Commendation in Sea Thieves

© Provided by GamePur The Down with the Ship Commendation in Sea of Thieves requires you to sit in the Captain’s Chair of your Galleon as it sinks. If you’re ... Read more »

Na'Vi Junior received new NFT-based Runner-up Award at WePlay Academy League Season 2

© Provided by Dot Esports This article is proudly WePlay Esports held the finals of the WePlay Academy League Season Two on Nov. 14, which saw MOUZ NXT repeat as ... Read more »

Will Fortnite Go Offline for Chapter 3?

Will Fortnite go offline for Chapter 3? The climax of more than two years of Fortnite content and story building is all set to kick off this coming weekend, likely ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic