Blindingly bright black holes could help cosmologists see deeper into the universe's past

Astronomers keen to solve some of the universe’s most fundamental mysteries have their eyes on a new target: quasars, tempests of matter that swirl violently around colossal black holes and pierce the cosmos with their brilliant light. 

© NASA, ESA and J. Olmsted (STScI) An illustration of a quasar, the chaotic bodies that swirl around black holes.

These poorly understood galactic cores outshine just about every other object in the universe. Visible across unthinkable distances, they could turn out to be just what researchers need to understand certain traits of the entire cosmos, including its expansion. Early attempts to harness the mighty spotlights have been plagued with uncertainties, but a new analysis finds that the objects just might shine consistently enough for researchers to use them to fill a yawning hole in cosmic history. 

“There is a very huge gap,” says Susanna Bisogni, an astrophysicist at the National Institute for Astrophysics in Milan, Italy. “Quasars have the potential to span this range.”

In recent decades, the gold standard for measuring vast distances has been one variety of stellar explosion: the type 1a supernova. These supernovae typically detonate with the same brightness, so astronomers know that more brilliant ones must be closer while dimmer ones must be farther away. These so-called “standard candles” have revealed that the universe is expanding faster and faster, implying that a mysterious “dark energy” is driving galaxies apart. 

But individual stars, even exploding ones, eventually peter out as astronomers peer deeper into the darkness. With current telescopes, researchers can’t see type 1a supernovae beyond nine to ten billion years ago (because light takes billions of years to reach earth, looking out into space also means looking back in time.) Without any visible supernovae, cosmologists—researchers who specifically study the evolution of the cosmos as a whole—are left largely in the dark as to what went on during the universe’s first four billion years. 

That’s where quasars come in. A supermassive black hole drags gas toward itself with such intensity that the matter gets white hot, outshining the entire galactic system that surrounds it. 

Since astronomers can pick out the blaze of quasars during the universe’s first billion years, could these objects serve as brighter, more penetrating standard candles? 

Some astronomers believe that they can, thanks to one crucial property. Quasars pump out ultraviolet light, and some of these ultraviolet rays smash into a surrounding cloud of hot electrons, unleashing higher energy X-rays. Because the ultraviolet light makes X-rays in a predictable way, a quasar’s X-ray brightness is tied to its ultraviolet brightness in a fixed manner, no matter how far away the galaxy is.  By comparing the ultraviolet and X-ray emissions with how bright or dim a quasar appears overall, astronomers can use it as a cosmic mile marker. 

[Related: One of Einstein’s predictions on black holes has finally been confirmed]

Or at least that’s the theory. It has appeared to hold up for many relatively nearby quasars, but the many details of how the objects emit ultraviolet light and X-rays remain unknown. Some researchers have questioned whether quasars in the early universe behaved in the same way they do now. 

To find out, a team of Italian astronomers combed through legacy observations and looked further back in time. They used data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey to find quasars shining in the ultraviolet, and data from the Chandra X-ray Observatory to find quasars shining in X-rays and compared the two groups. They found that the relationship between the two emissions held all the way back to about 1.3 billion years after the Big Bang. In other words, the quasars burned steadily throughout the universe’s history, as good standard candles should. 

“This was a necessary check for us to be able to use this method for measuring distances, and to be sure that we were not using a tool that’s changing in time,” Bisogni says. 

The group published a preprint of their research, which has been accepted by the journal Astronomy & Astrophysics, on September 7. 

The astronomers suspect that their ancient quasars are already hinting that theorists’ account of the cosmos might need major edits. When they calculated the distances to the oldest quasars in 2019, their results clashed with the leading “Standard Model” of cosmology, with one potentially groundbreaking interpretation being that dark energy has changed over time. “We think it’s real,” says Francesca Civano, an astrophysicist with the quasar team who works at the Center for Astrophysics, which is jointly run by Harvard University and the Smithsonian. “The difference is quite significant.”

Bold claims require rock solid evidence, however, and cosmologists need more convincing. Dan Scolnic, a cosmologist at Duke University who uses type 1a supernovae to make precise measurements of the universe’s expansion and was not involved with the quasar research, praised the group as “one of the top teams for understanding the physics of quasars,” and said they’re “doing the right steps” to test quasars’ potential as standard candles. 

[Related: Astronomers may have found the surprisingly elusive medium-sized black hole]

Yet he doesn’t believe current quasar observations are mature enough to dethrone supernovae, the locations of which astronomers can pinpoint five times more accurately than they can quasars. The Italian astronomers’ latest work overcomes this drawback by analyzing a mountain of quasars big enough to easily pass statistical tests. But Scolnic worries, for instance, that different varieties of quasars could be hiding in the comparatively noisy data. 

“What makes me a bit nervous is that, when you have individual measurements that are not terribly precise,” he says, “you have to wonder what systematic uncertainties are lurking in that data.”

The situation will become clearer in the coming years. A recently launched X-ray space telescope known as eROSITA is expected to turn up millions of nearby quasars, which could validate their usefulness as standard candles in the better-understood local universe, while additional surveys will likely discover more of the objects in the shrouded, ancient universe.  

“Cosmologists, they need to take quasars seriously for cosmological measurements,” Civano says. “They’re a very good resource.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


The best free-to-play Steam games 2021

The best free games on Steam should not be discounted. While they may come without the high-end graphics or big production of more expensive games, you can still enjoy them ... Read more »

How to change Alexa's name and end one of the worst things about an Echo

The voice assistants built into smart devices can prove extremely useful, setting timers, providing the weather report, and even controlling your smart home devices. They’re often heavily discounted on Black ... Read more »

MacBook Pro 14-inch (2021) vs MacBook Pro 13-inch (2020)

With the recent release of the MacBook Pro 14-inch (2021), you might have some questions regarding just how that stacks up against the MacBook Pro 13-inch (2020). Whether you already ... Read more »

Man United vs Liverpool live stream: how to watch Premier League online from anywhere

After all the edge-of-the-seat drama delivered by both these sides in the Champions League in midweek, this clash between these two old foes has a lot to live up to. ... Read more »

Best Horror VR Games you can play on Oculus Quest 2, PSVR and Valve Index

Halloween is fast approaching and we have the perfect trick to get you into the spooky season spirit: play one of these frightening horror VR games. If you find that ... Read more »

Get a free Google Pixel 6 with Verizon's deals this weekend

In case you hadn’t heard already – Google Pixel 6 deals have officially landed and this weekend’s brought some fantastic pre-order bonuses to consider. The frontrunner for value is Verizon ... Read more »

Forget Black Friday: epic deals on AirPods, iPads, Apple Watch, and the iPhone now

Black Friday deals are arriving earlier than ever, which means you can shop record-low prices right now on some of Apple’s best-selling devices, including AirPods, iPads, the Apple Watch, the ... Read more »

Adapting Dune: Denis Villeneuve on bringing Frank Herbert's sci-fi epic to life

How do you go about adapting Dune? It’s a question that numerous studios and filmmakers have struggled to answer, including legendary director David Lynch. And with good reason. On the ... Read more »

Strictly star Anton du Beke opens up about secret wedding

Anton Du Beke is wowing in his new role as a full-time judge on Strictly Come Dancing – and has revealed that he sprung the idea of marriage on his ... Read more »

Kitten Tiny Tim ‘doing amazingly' after being found alone in garden at week old

A kitten nicknamed Tiny Tim is “doing amazingly” after being found in a garden away from his mother. The cat is believed to have been around a week old when ... Read more »

Everton vs Watford live stream: how to watch Premier League online from anywhere

After a promising start to the season, new Everton boss Rafael Benitez now has a battle on his hands to navigate his way through an injury crisis that’s in danger ... Read more »

How a new Dune video game could succeed where others have failed

It’s been a long time coming but Warner Bros. and Legendary’s gigantic Dune adaptation finally hit cinemas and HBO Max this week, sparking a revival of interest in Frank Herbert’s ... Read more »

Foundation episode 6 recap: deadly decisions and suspicious minds

Huge spoilers follow for Foundation episodes 1 to 6. Watch them all before reading on. Foundation hasn’t been shy about examining the subject of death. Through the murder of key ... Read more »

Best cheap graphics cards 2021: the top graphics cards on a budget

If you’re in the market for the best budget graphics cards 2021 has to offer, you have quite a few to choose from. Flagship graphics cards might be getting the ... Read more »

Michael Bay's next movie looks like an absurdly wild ride

The first trailer for Michael Bay’s next movie has landed online – and it looks as ridiculously over the top as you’d expect. Ambulance, which is based on a 2005 ... Read more »

Don't be tricked by an electric toothbrush on Black Friday

This year’s Black Friday deals are fast approaching, with the big day scheduled for November 26, but some of the most impressive offers aren’t necessarily what they seem – particularly ... Read more »

Herring vs Stevenson live stream: how to watch boxing online from anywhere

It’s an all-American title showdown, as Jamel Herring (23-2) puts his WBO Super Featherweight belt on the line for the fourth time, with undefeated superstar in the making Shakur Stevenson ... Read more »

How to watch India vs Pakistan live stream for free and anywhere in T20 World Cup 2021

India vs Pakistan, a rivalry that goes way beyond sport. Thankfully, this battle’s only being fought on the pitch, and what a game it promises to be as Virat Kohli’s ... Read more »

Leeds vs Wolves live stream: how to watch Premier League online from anywhere

With just one victory since the start of the 2021/22 season, Marcelo Bielsa will be looking for a win at home today against a Wolves side that appears to have ... Read more »

GTA 3(D): how Rockstar Games took Liberty City into the open world

Rockstar Games hasn’t always been untouchable. To identify the exact moment perhaps the world’s most celebrated video game company became ice cool, check out the trailer for Grand Theft Auto ... Read more »

RPA: Why you need to care about this totally unsexy technology

Robotic process automation, or RPA, is a technology with an identity problem. The name is both dry enough to make the eyes glaze over and confusing enough to obscure precisely ... Read more »

The older Chinese consumers turning silver into e-commerce gold

Zhu Genghui is new to online shopping but she has taken to it like someone a third of her age. In between taking care of her grandchildren and square dancing ... Read more »

Tencent, Huawei, other major Shenzhen firms to bolster user data safeguards ahead of roll-out of new personal information law

More than 20 major Shenzhen-based companies, including video gaming and social media giant Tencent Holdings and telecommunications equipment maker Huawei Technologies Co, on Friday vowed to bolster user data safeguards ... Read more »

US approval of export permits to Huawei, SMIC suppliers shows challenges in decoupling from China

The US government’s decision to issue US$100 billion worth of export permits to suppliers of Huawei Technologies Co and China’s top chip maker Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC) – both ... Read more »

ByteDance gaming studio lays off dozens of employees amid Beijing's gaming crackdown, sending a chill down industry

TikTok-owner ByteDance, which had been expanding into video gaming aggressively, is laying off dozens of employees at one of its gaming studios as Beijing’s crackdown on the industry clouds the ... Read more »

China's EV battery manufacturers race to develop new technologies that are less reliant on pricey metals

This second instalment of a three-part series on China’s electric car batteries looks at the technology behind the alternative power source. On the evening of January 9, William Li, chief ... Read more »

Milan Design Week showcased 2022's most fashionable furniture, with Supersalone featuring homeware from Bulgari, Dior, Fendi, Gucci and Hermès

When Milan Design Week got underway in early September, it was a scaled-down affair after a pandemic-induced 18-month delay. Included in the week’s festivities was Supersalone, a special edition of ... Read more »

Tencent fixes WeChat bug that exposed some social media content to Google, other external search engines

Chinese internet giant Tencent Holdings says it has fixed a bug it found on super app WeChat that exposed some social media content to external search engines, such as Bing ... Read more »

China puts cryptocurrency mining on industrial blacklist in final step to eliminate the activity

China’s top economic planner is seeking to eliminate cryptocurrency mining activity in the country, months after a government crackdown that turned dozens of companies from model energy consumers into pariahs ... Read more »

Kiss frontman Gene Simmons lists Las Vegas Valley mansion for sale for £10 million five months after buying it

(ES Composite) Less than five months after buying his striking Las Vegas Valley mansion, Kiss frontman Gene Simmons has listed it for sale – for £2.9 million more than he ... Read more »

Rachel Riley says she was groped by 'Countdown' fan

Rachel Riley stars as the maths guru on ‘Countdown‘. (Channel 4) Rachel Riley has told how she was once groped by a Countdown fan in front of his wife, before ... Read more »

Parents who are occasionally abrupt with their children may be guilty of 'mild neglect', says NSPCC

Mother scolding son in living room – takasuu Parents who are occasionally abrupt with their children and hold low-key celebrations may be guilty of ‘mild neglect’, according to NSPCC guidance. ... Read more »

Boris Johnson: Nothing to suggest lockdown is on the cards

Boris Johnson has said that despite a rise in the number of Covid-19 cases, a winter lockdown is unlikely at the moment. Read more »

'Strictly's' AJ and Kai rival Adam and Katya's 'almost kiss'

AJ Odudu and Kai Widdrington appeared to come close to kissing. (BBC) AJ Odudu and Kai Widdrington have become the latest Strictly couple to “almost kiss” at the end of ... Read more »

Android devs, rejoice! Google will take less of your cash — here are the details

Google made a significant announcement for developers last night by reducing fees for recurring subscriptions to 15% or less for all apps. There are still tons of caveats and conditions ... Read more »

Conservatives say Twitter suppresses their voices. Twitter says it amplifies them

It’s tough being a conservative on Twitter. Everywhere you look, those damn liberals are censoring right-wingers for dropping truth bombs based on facts, not feelings. At least, that’s what I’ve ... Read more »

While everyone obsessed over the iPod, I stanned the Zune

The iPod turns 20 this year. That device changed tech as we know it, starting Apple‘s resurgence and eventual dominance of the tech industry. But while everyone reminisces about grinding ... Read more »

9 time-saving tricks for your command line

How do you write great code? By being efficient. If you want to create something awesome, you’ll have to eliminate the time dumps that slow you down. With just a ... Read more »

Think you've got what it takes to build your own mechanical wristwatch? Rotate makes it possible

TLDR: With a Rotate DIY Watchmaking Kit, tinkerers can put their skills to the ultimate test, assembling their own dynamic mechanically-driven watch. Maybe jigsaw puzzles and Sudoku aren’t quite doing ... Read more »

It's iPod's 20th birthday and people have a lot of feelings

As a tech journo, I love it when people share their experiences of tech with me. It’s so much more interesting than a review someone is being paid to write ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic