Big gap between Pfizer, Moderna vaccines seen for preventing COVID hospitalizations

© Provided by The LA Times A dose of Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine is readied at a mobile vaccine clinic in Los Angeles. (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times)

Amid persistent concerns that the protection offered by COVID-19 vaccines may be waning, a report released Friday by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention finds that America’s workhorse shot is significantly less effective at preventing severe cases of disease over the long term than many experts had realized.

Data collected from 18 states between March and August suggest the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine reduces the risk of being hospitalized with COVID-19 by 91% in the first four months after receiving the second dose. Beyond 120 days, however, that vaccine efficacy drops to 77%.

Meanwhile, Moderna’s vaccine was 93% effective at reducing the short-term risk of COVID-19 hospitalization and remained 92% effective after 120 days.

Overall, 54% of fully vaccinated Americans have been immunized with the Pfizer shot.

The surprising findings came as a Food and Drug Administration advisory panel recommended against offering booster doses of the Pfizer vaccine to all Americans ages 16 and older. In a striking rebuke, 16 of 18 experts told the agency it had not mustered enough data to make a third shot the norm.

In lengthy briefings to the panel, representatives from Pfizer pointed to clinical trial results involving 306 mostly healthy participants to argue that a booster “restores” the 95% vaccine effectiveness rate seen earlier in the pandemic.

Company officials also touted evidence from Israel, which rolled out boosters after seeing a rise in hospitalizations among people who were fully vaccinated. Those hospitalizations dropped dramatically after third doses were given, Israeli scientists have said.

But panel members made clear that the despite Pfizer’s aggressive stance, it had not gathered enough evidence that a third shot was safe for young people and for those at lesser risk of becoming severely ill with COVID-19.

“We need age-specific data” on the safety and protective benefits of a further booster, said Dr. Ofer Levy, a panel member who directs the Precision Vaccines program at Boston Children’s Hospital.

FDA clearance for booster shots for everyone 16 and older would be seen as something “close to a mandate,” said Dr. Eric Rubin, a panel member and infectious-disease expert at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. Rubin worried that such a move could redefine what it takes to be considered fully vaccinated against COVID-19.

“None of us are there yet,” he said.

But others apparently are. Dr. Anthony Fauci, President Biden’s top advisor on vaccines, has come out strongly in favor of booster shots, saying before Friday’s vote that a failure to endorse the shots “would be a mistake.”

And in mid-August, Biden himself said his administration would begin making booster shots available the week of Sept. 20 to those vaccinated for at least eight months.

Biden cautioned at the time that his plan was contingent on FDA approval. But his announcement stoked concerns of political meddling in a matter that required the unhindered evaluation of scientists.

“This should demonstrate to the public that the members of this committee are independent of the FDA,” Dr. Archana Chatterjee, dean of the Chicago Medical School, said after the vote. “In fact, we do bring our voices to the table when we are asked to serve on this committee.”

The panel unanimously agreed that a third shot of the vaccine now sold under the brand name Comirnaty should be offered to select groups: individuals 65 and older, people at risk of developing severe disease, and those, including healthcare workers, whose occupations put them at high risk of infection.

Dr. Peter Marks, who leads the FDA’s evaluation of drugs and vaccines, told panel members that the agency could give its blessing to booster shots with an emergency use authorization — a regulatory step that falls short of the full approval Pfizer had sought.

The company issued no statement Friday in response to the panel’s vote.

Researchers in the United States have been warning for months that the immunity afforded by COVID-19 vaccines might be waning. The CDC reported that in late July, close to three-quarters of the 469 people swept up in a Massachusetts outbreak were fully vaccinated. And the agency has launched several studies aimed at detecting changes in vaccine effectiveness in healthcare workers and others who were vaccinated early.

But virtually all of those infections appeared to be mild. And health officials eager to induce vaccine skeptics to step up for their shot — including Fauci and Dr. Rochelle Walensky, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — have repeatedly praised the vaccines for keeping most fully vaccinated people out of hospitals.

The new report on waning vaccine efficacy challenges that expectation.

© (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times) Vials of Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 sit on a tray at a mass vaccination clinic in Ontario, Calif. (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times)

Researchers from around the country found striking differences between two mRNA vaccines long thought to be interchangeable.

When the Moderna vaccine received emergency use authorization in December, the company reported that 30 people in its clinical trial developed severe cases of COVID-19, including nine who required hospitalization. All 30 patients were in the placebo group, resulting in a vaccine efficacy against severe disease of 100%.

Ten people in Pfizer’s initial clinical trial developed severe cases of COVID-19. Nine of them were in the placebo group, including seven who were hospitalized, resulting in a vaccine efficacy against severe disease of 88.9%.

Once the two vaccines were rolled out to the public, their records of preventing COVID-19 hospitalizations in the first four months were neck and neck — 91% and 93% effective, respectively. But the degree of protection diverged after that.

Focusing only on the period 120 days beyond the second dose, the study authors found that the Moderna vaccine remained 92% effective at preventing COVID-19 hospitalizations. But the equivalent figure for the Pfizer vaccine was 77%.

The results were published in the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.

Both the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines are based on mRNA technology, which delivers temporary instructions to the body’s muscle cells that help it learn to recognize the spike protein, a key part of the coronavirus’ structure. But “they’re actually not necessarily interchangeable,” said Dr. Timothy Brewer, a professor of medicine and epidemiology at UCLA.

Each vaccine is formulated and administered differently, Brewer said, and those differences could affect the strength and duration of the two vaccines’ protection.

Moderna’s shot contains 100 micrograms of vaccine, more than three times the 30 micrograms in the Pfizer shot. And Pfizer’s two doses are given three weeks apart, while Moderna’s two-shot regimen is administered with a four-week gap.

Brewer also pointed to evidence that the Moderna vaccine seemed to elicit higher levels of a key antibody compared to the Pfizer vaccine.

“We know from other studies the neutralizing antibody levels will decay over time, so starting at a higher level will mean that you have farther to go before you decay to a point where efficacy drops off,” he said.

Dr. Robert Murphy, who directs Northwestern University’s Institute for Global Health, said the Pfizer vaccine’s reduced protection against severe disease may bolster the case for boosters for all who got the vaccine, not just the specific groups identified by the FDA advisory panel.

“Based on the data I have seen, persons who received the Pfizer vaccine would benefit from a booster dose at this time,” he said. “I don’t see why we have to wait until the younger people get sick and become hospitalized.”

But Dr. Arnold Monto, who chairs the FDA advisory panel, applauded the agency’s willingness to withhold a full-throated call for boosters until a stronger case can be made. And he suggested that as more evidence accumulates, boosters for all might still get the nod.

“That’s the beauty of the emergency use authorization,” said Monto, an epidemiologist at University of Michigan. “It can be changed based on changing data.”

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Covid-19: New Delta variant strain detected in US after spreading across UK

Covid-19: New Delta variant strain detected in US after spreading across UK A new strain of the Delta variant of Covid-19 that has been spreading across the UK has now ... Read more »

FDA authorizes booster doses of Moderna and Johnson & Johnson vaccines, says mix and match OK

The US Food and Drug Administration authorized booster doses of both Covid-19 vaccines made by Moderna and Johnson & Johnson Wednesday and also said any of the three authorized vaccines ... Read more »

Dopesick Episode 4 Recap: The Doctor (Tragically) Becomes the Patient

© Courtesy of Hulu There is nothing predictable about Hulu’s limited series Dopesick. The minute you think the drama is going to swerve right, it goes left and vice versa. ... Read more »

8 TikTok accounts to follow if you're tired of COVID misinformation

Paging Dr. Internet, we need a diagnosis. In this series, Mashable examines the online world’s influence on our health and prescribes new ways forward. © Provided by Mashable 8 TikTok ... Read more »

Climate change is 'first and foremost' a health crisis, new report finds

Working construction under the merciless Arizona sun, Eleazar Castellanos knew the signs that heat exhaustion was settling in. On the days when the temperature would top 100 degrees, he and ... Read more »

You Season 3 Star Shalita Grant Opens Up About Why She Left NCIS: New Orleans: 'I Was Protecting Myself'

Before Shalita Grant played mom-blogging influencer Sherry Conrad in the Netflix thriller You, she starred as special agent Sonja Percy on NCIS: New Orleans. During an appearance on the Monday’s episode ... Read more »

Yankees: 3 shortstops Brian Cashman can target above all the rest

© Provided by Fansided New York Yankees general manager Brian Cashman further stressed the need for shortstop in New York. Here are three elite options to fill the void. With ... Read more »

4 Reasons You Might Be Dealing with Menstrual Cup Leaks, According to an Ob-Gyn

© Pexels / Cliff Booth 4 Reasons You Might Be Dealing with Menstrual Cup Leaks, According to an Ob-Gyn Menstrual cups can be super reliable and convenient tools for managing ... Read more »

Photos: See Cody Bellinger turn around the series in NLCS Game 3

Cody Bellinger’s home run for the Dodgers came with runners on second and first. Bellinger’s hit came on a pitch well above the strike zone: A fastball armpit high that ... Read more »

After 4 homeless men shot near Ballona Wetlands, suspect is charged with attempted murder

A June 11 photo shows RVs parked along West Jefferson Boulevard near the Ballona Wetlands, where four homeless men were shot in August. A suspect has been charged. (Al Seib ... Read more »

Former Baldwin Park police officer charged with assaulting teenager

Los Angeles County Dist. Atty. George Gascón outside the downtown L.A. Hall of Justice in June. (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times) A Baldwin Park police officer was charged with ... Read more »

What is salmonella and what are the symptoms?

SALMONELLA has key signs for detection once it enters the human body. The Centers for Disease Control announced on October 20, 2021, that people across 37 states had a salmonella ... Read more »

Phase 2 Trial On Ayahuasca's Active Ingredient Puts Small Pharma On Track To Winning The Psychedelics Race

© Provided by Benzinga Small Pharma Inc. (OTCQB: DMTTF) (TSXV: DMT), a biotech company focused on psychedelic therapies, has begun its phase 2a clinical trial on SPL026. SPL026 is a ... Read more »

The FDA just authorized booster shots of Moderna's and Johnson & Johnson's COVID-19 vaccines and is letting users mix and match shots

© Provided by Business Insider An employee of Japan’s Suntory Holdings receives the Moderna coronavirus vaccine for Covid-19. KAZUHIRO NOGI/AFP via Getty Images The FDA authorized booster shots of the ... Read more »

‘Untethered' judge causes pain for pharmacies that filled legal painkiller prescriptions

No matter how often plaintiffs’ attorneys and leftist activists pretend otherwise, it is insanely unfair to blame the opioid epidemic on pharmacists filling otherwise valid prescriptions from licensed physicians. © ... Read more »

GPs refuse to dish out booster jabs ‘as they're too busy with other jobs'

DOCTORS are refusing to dish out booster jabs — claiming they are too busy with other jobs. Family doctors say they can’t deal with routine appointments and top-up vaccines as ... Read more »

Parents in Michigan, Virginia sue DOJ over response to school board threats

A lawsuit accuses Attorney General Merrick Garland of trying to criminalize free speech by ordering a review of threats made against school personnel. Read more »

Vulnerable OAP, 92, finally gets her booster thanks to Give Britain A Booster campaign

SOME Sun readers have struggled to get boosters despite being eligible. The NHS booking service will not allow appointments without an invitation. Vulnerable Irene Turi, 92, could not secure her ... Read more »

FDA OKs Moderna, J&J boosters, along with 'mix and match' approach

The move will greatly expand access to booster shots. Read more »

Sajid Javid begs Brits to get their Covid booster jabs or face return to resitrctions

SAJID Javid begged Brits last night to get their booster vaccinations or face a return to Covid restrictions. The Health Secretary, backing The Sun’s Give Britain a Booster campaign, warned ... Read more »

Heart health key to Type 2 diabetes prevention: researchers

Heart health is a key component to the prevention of Type 2 diabetes, according to researchers.  In a September study published in the European Journal of Preventive Cardiology, Netherlands scientists ... Read more »

Can My Dog Eat Spicy Food?

Some spicy foods are so good that it’s tempting to sneak your dog a bite. But can dogs eat spicy food? And do they even like it? Not all spicy ... Read more »

Slow Sales of Alzheimer's Drug Costing $50K a Year Partially Blamed on Supply Chain Issues

Biogen’s new Alzheimer’s drug, Aduhelm, brought in an unexpectedly low $300,000 in sales during its first full quarter on the market. The company blamed the tepid debut on coverage questions ... Read more »

Democrats weigh vouchers for Medicare dental benefits amid funding squeeze

Congressional Democrats looking to cut at least a trillion dollars from their social spending package are considering converting one of the most expensive health care pieces — dental benefits for ... Read more »

This New Nasal Swab Test Can Predict Whether COVID Patients Will Be Hospitalized

For nearly two years, public health systems have been playing a game of Russian roulette when it comes to severe COVID-19. Some people get extremely sick or die. Others escape ... Read more »

Blunt praised for medical research funding during dedication of University of Missouri facility

Administrators, scientists and politicians praised U.S. Sen. Roy Blunt on Tuesday for years of securing medical research funding while dedicating the NextGen Precision Health facility in his name on the ... Read more »

Nation's vaccine experts debate goal of booster campaign

Are boosters meant to prevent infections? Or to keep people out of the hospital? Read more »

Fact check: Are smokers at less risk for contracting the coronavirus?

The claim: Nicotine substitutes could have a positive effect in fighting COVID-19 Amid coronavirus news, claims have surfaced that nicotine could contribute to preventing people from contracting COVID-19. This followed ... Read more »

Vaccine breakthrough! Needle-free flu jab could suppress winter crisis

British biotech firm Enesi Pharma announced it will begin clinical trials to help contain the outbreak of a ‘super cold’. Enesi Pharma joined forces with National Institutes of Health (NIH) ... Read more »

Feeling anxious? Here are our top picks for apps to help calm your inner panic

March 2020 marked the beginning of change – and not in a good way. No longer could we distract our minds by throwing ourselves into socialising or work. The gym ... Read more »

St James Quarter's Bonnie & Wild hosts Champagne tasting event, running alongside Seafood Week treats

Partner oysters with a couple of different fizz brands © Bonnie & Wild They say real pain for your enemies, Champagne for your friends. Thus, make a date to celebrate ... Read more »

Alandas opens gelato shop in historic Edinburgh building that was once Greyfriars Bobby's lunch spot

© Alandas gelato “One of the most noticeable and arguably most challenging differences between ice-cream and gelato is the way it is served”, says Carla Black, head of marketing and ... Read more »

Cavity-Prone? A Dentist Explains Why You Should Be Careful About Mouthwash

© Photo: Stocksy/ Milles Studio Side view of black female in sleepwear using toothbrush to clean teeth while looking at mirror in modern bathroom in morning. The rules of good ... Read more »

Don't Write Off Vaxart, As Its Oral Vaccine Still Has a Chance

© Source: Ascannio / Shutterstock.com VXRT stock First off, it makes sense why many may be skeptical about Vaxart (NASDAQ:VXRT). One of the lesser-known Covid-19 vaccine companies, VXRT stock has seen ... Read more »

Meghan Markle is urging Democratic leaders in Congress to support for paid family and medical leave

© WPA Pool/Getty Images WPA Pool/Getty Images Meghan Markle urged Democratic leaders in a letter Wednesday to support paid family and medical leave. The letter comes as Biden’s paid leave ... Read more »

COVID vaccine rollout for kids under 12: What to know

Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine is expected to be authorized and recommended for kids ages 5-11 in early November, and the Biden administration “will be ready to begin getting shots in arms ... Read more »

Scientists search for cause of mysterious Covid-related inflammation in children

More than 5,200 of the 6.2 million U.S. children diagnosed with Covid have developed MIS-C, or multisystem inflammatory syndrome. Read more »

Is It Safe to Trick-or-Treat This Year? Expert Advice for Celebrating Halloween During COVID

© Provided by Health Getty Images In fall 2020, when masks were already mainstream but vaccines were just a pipe dream, the scariest part about Halloween was the prospect of ... Read more »

How to Stay Connected to Your Loved One in a Nursing Home

We all need to feel connected to the outside world. For people living in nursing homes, staying in touch has always been more of a challenge, particularly with family members ... Read more »

Ending the opioid crisis starts with proper distribution of settlement payouts

The opioid crisis is an ever-present and increasingly deadly epidemic impacting the lives of families in every community across America. The BAD news is that 2020 saw a devastating increase ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic