Biden's Supreme Court commission ends not with a bang but a whimper

Asia's Tech News Daily

Surprising no one, the presidential commission studying potential U.S. Supreme Court reform measures has issued a draft report that stopped short of any recommendation to turn the nation’s highest court into a partisan rubber stamp.

© New York Times/Pool Supreme Court Justices pose for group photo with newly sworn in Justice Amy Coney Barrett on April 23, 2021

How could it have been otherwise? The 36-member panel reached the same conclusion as did President Biden, current and former justices including Ruth Bader Ginsburg, and elected officials who declined to join the left-wing fringe. In short, the commission said court-packing would undermine the public’s trust in the court’s crucial role as protector of the Constitution and civil liberties and turn it into another partisan tool.

Expanding the Supreme Court from nine justices to 13 or more to clear the way for a political agenda “would reinforce the notion that judges are partisan actors” and would undermine the “perception” of judicial independence, the commission said in its report. What’s more, the commission pointed out that striving for an ideological balance on the court was a fool’s errand when no such balancing act exists in Congress or the White House. That’s a matter of election outcomes.

The commission’s warning echoed that of Justice Amy Coney Barrett who, in a speech last month in Louisville, told her audience that “my goal today is to convince you that this court is not [composed] of a bunch of partisan hacks.” She argued that justices are guided by their “judicial philosophies” and not by personal political views.

But political hackery is exactly what some on the left have been aiming for with dark money-funded media campaigns and legislative initiatives in Congress. Those backing these initiatives likely knew that the Biden Supreme Court commission would never back their proposals, as the draft report confirmed.

“This was not even close to being worth the wait,” said Brian Fallon, executive director of the Demand Justice court-packing project. “From the beginning, the purpose of this commission was not to meaningfully confront the partisan capture of the Supreme Court, but rather to buy time for the Biden administration while it fights other legislative battles.”

Many progressives want to pack the court with friendly jurists in a naked grab for political power. Their goal, in the words of Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), is to “change America.” The change they seek would destroy the system of checks and balances that the Founders endowed us with and destroy the independence of the judiciary. That could destroy the civil liberties of all Americans. Those who hold political power under such a regime would be the sole interpreters of the Constitution. Americans would face enormous pressure to conform to government edicts.

While some on the left claim that court-packing is needed to “save democracy,” most American voters aren’t buying it. In an April opinion piece, the Wall Street Journal reported on polling indicating that 68 percent of American voters oppose court-packing. The Washington Examiner, in a June opinion piece, reported that a supermajority (69 percent) of voters reject any proposed court reform measure requiring a constitutional amendment.

For now, the common sense of Americans stands in the way of the court-packers – just as public opinion turned against Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s failed court-packing scheme in 1937. Lacking political backing, from Biden or his Supreme Court commission, the current effort has stalled. But don’t expect the court-packers to give up their fight. A non-endorsement from the White House isn’t likely to deter them.

For those who cherish the constitutional protections of religious freedom and other civil liberties, the words of Irish statesman John Philpot Curran, a champion of liberties, still ring true: “The condition upon which God hath given liberty to man is eternal vigilance,” Curran said, “which condition if he break, servitude is at once the consequence of his crime and the punishment of his guilt.”

Jeremy Dys (@jeremydys) is special counsel for litigation and communications for First Liberty Institute, a nonprofit law firm that defends religious freedom for all Americans.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Bukayo Saka explains how David Luiz has 'done so much' for his Arsenal career

Arsenal academy sensation Bukayo Saka has pinpointed former Gunners central defender David Luiz as the player that has helped him the most in his career so far. It has felt ... Read more »

Our World in Pictures: Week 47 of 2021

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved © Provided by Daily Maverick In this handout image provided by Parks Australia, thousands of red crabs are seen walking over ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb fans question ITV show's Covid rules after Richard Madeley exit interview

Some I’m A Celebrity viewers queried the ITV show’s Covid rules, after the exit of Richard Madeley this week. Hosts Ant McPartlin and Dec Donnelly interviewed Richard in their studio ... Read more »

Tuchel backs 'tactically elite manager' Rangnick to revive United

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Thomas Tuchel admits he was and still is expecting more from Manchester United this season. Perhaps it will come once his former mentor Ralf ... Read more »

Villa starlet ‘will not sign new contract' amid City, Liverpool interest

© PA Images Carney Chukwuemeka during a match Aston Villa youngster Carney Chukwuemeka “will not sign a new contract” amidst interest from Man Utd, Man City and Liverpool, according to reports. ... Read more »

‘Stale' Tottenham star urged to make radical move and ‘start again'

© PA Images Dele Alli and Bryan Gil look towards the ball during Tottenham’s match against Vitesse Arnhem, October 2021 Darren Bent feels Dele Alli should leave Tottenham and consider ... Read more »

Storm Arwen - latest: People urged to stay indoors as winds hit 78mph and man killed by falling tree

© PA PRI179974004.jpg LIVE – Updated at 23:04 People have been urged to stay indoors and avoid driving as Storm Arwen sweeps into the country, with the Met Office issuing ... Read more »

Marjorie Taylor Greene hits out at Kevin McCarthy, says he ‘doesn't have full support' to be speaker

© Getty Images Marjorie Taylor-Greene – Getty Images Marjorie Taylor-Greene has hit out at Republican minority leader Kevin McCarthy and said he does not “have the full support” to become ... Read more »

McDonald's staff hid in fridge to avoid customer who started a fight after restaurant ran out of menu item

© WSB-TV 2 Atlanta Cell phone video caught the encounter between McDonald’s staff and a customer in Henry County, Georgia – WSB-TV 2 Atlanta Staff at a McDonald’s in Henry ... Read more »

Seth Rogen sends private messages to haters: 'I tell them to go f*** themselves'

© Bang Showbiz Seth Rogen at the premiere of The Lion King Seth Rogen likes to send private messages to his critics to tell them to “go f*** themselves”. The ... Read more »

Megawide says arrest warrants out vs GMCAC officials

© Provided by BusinessWorld Megawide Construction Corp. said the Lapu-Lapu City Regional Trial Court has issued arrest warrants against the officials of GMR Megawide Cebu Airport Corp. (GMCAC) over alleged violations of the ... Read more »

‘Critically flawed': Review of new Tesla sparks debate after writer claims problems with autopilot

© AP A Tesla Model Y Long Range is displayed on Feb. 24, 2021, at the Tesla Gallery in Troy, Mich. Consumer Reports says electric SUVs generally are among the ... Read more »

Sebastian Aho scores twice, Hurricanes beat Flyers 6-3

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Sebastian Aho scored twice, Jesperi Kotkaniemi had a goal and an assist and the Carolina Hurricanes beat the Philadelphia Flyers 6-3 on Friday. Jesper Fast, Steven Lorentz ... Read more »

Ole Miss dominates in 2nd half, beats MVSU 73-58

OXFORD, Miss. (AP) — Nysier Brooks scored 12 of his 15 points in the second half when Robert Allen scored all of his 11 and Ole Miss defeated Mississippi Valley ... Read more »

Black Friday 2021 Xbox Series X, Series S and Xbox One deals at Amazon, Walmart and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Microsoft first introduced the Xbox to the world 20 years ago ... Read more »

Stephen Sondheim, iconic Broadway composer and lyricist, dies at 91

Stephen Sondheim’s death comes after a highly decorated career as one of the most celebrated composers in the 21st century. Read more »

Kaprizov has goal, three assists as Wild rout Jets 7-1

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Kirill Kaprizov scored and tied a career high with three assists to help the Minnesota Wild rout the Winnipeg Jets 7-1 on Friday. Mats Zuccarello ... Read more »

David Moyes warns against ‘quick fix' cash injection from new West Ham investors

© PA Wire West Ham manager David Moyes believes hard work on the training pitch rather than just the transfer market is crucial to long-term success (Adam Davy/PA) – PA ... Read more »

Government's rail plans ‘disgraceful sell-out' and ‘betrayal of North' – Labour

© PA Wire Labour Party Conference 2021 Labour will accuse the Prime Minister of betraying the North and “robbing Ashton to protect Ashford” after scaling back plans for rail investment ... Read more »

West Brom fail to close on top two after stalemate

© PA West Brom failed to make up any significant ground on front-runners Fulham and Bournemouth as they drew 0-0 against Nottingham Forest at The Hawthorns. Valerien Ismael’s men undoubtedly ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel hails teachings of "pioneer" Ralf Rangnick with odd toilet analogy

Thomas Tuchel has claimed tactical guru Ralf Rangnick has shown “it’s not necessary to follow people to the toilet in football games”. And the Chelsea head coach insisted his German ... Read more »

Grigor Dimitrov slammed by Nick Kyrgios with Roger Federer remark - 'Get your own game'

Roger Federer has been recognised as a pioneer for tennis players around the world, creating a new outlook on tennis alongside superstars Rafael Nadal and Novak Djokovic that has never ... Read more »

Michigan's Covid-19 cases are soaring, so feds are sending doctors and nurses to help strained hospitals

With Michigan’s Covid-19 case and hospitalization numbers hovering near all-time highs, the federal government will send doctors, nurses and others to support certain hospitals, the state health department said Wednesday. ... Read more »

Stephen Sondheim: His life in musicals

Composer and lyricist Stephen Sondheim, pictured here in 2005, was one of the most inimitable musical theater artists of his generation. He died Nov. 26 at his home age age ... Read more »

Jackson scores 21 points, Clippers beat Pistons 107-96

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Reggie Jackson scored 21 points and the Los Angeles Clippers got back on track with a 107-96 victory over the lowly Detroit Pistons on Friday. After ... Read more »

John Lloyd Cruz and Bea Alonzo's top 5 highest-grossing films

© Provided by PEP.ph John Lloyd Cruz and Bea Alonzo have been a love team since 2002. The two were first paired on television, and their tandem eventually headlined box-office ... Read more »

This Farmer Is Also An Advertising Agency CEO

© Provided by Yummy PH The fast life can be exhausting and overwhelming. Especially if you work in an industry where you constantly need to be creative. “‘Yung farming kasi, ... Read more »

Lions reeling after chaotic finish leaves them at 0-10-1

DETROIT (AP) — The Detroit Lions, for all the mistakes they had made Thursday against the Chicago Bears, still had one chance to pick up their first win of the ... Read more »

HSN Has a Bunch of Nintendo Switch Deals for Black Friday & They're Selling Out Fast

© Image: Nintendo. Right before Black Friday, we discovered that QVC had out-of-this-world deals on Nintendo Switch bundles, which never happens. And on this Black Friday, we’ve been handed another early ... Read more »

Disney+, Hulu and more—the best Black Friday 2021 streaming deals you can get

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Some great deals are going up this year for Black Friday, ... Read more »

The best New Balance deals you can shop on Black Friday 2021

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. ‘Tis the season for holiday shopping and saving. With Black Friday ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian and North West Have Launched a Joint TikTok Account: Watch Their Videos!

© Arnold Jerocki/GC Images and Karwai Tang/Getty Images Kim Kardashian and North West have made their TikTok debut! The 41-year-old reality star launched the account @KimAndNorth with her oldest daughter on Thanksgiving Day, and it ... Read more »

HSN Has a Bunch of Nintendo Switch Discounts for Black Friday & They're Selling Out Fast

© Nintendo. Right before Black Friday, we discovered that QVC had out-of-this-world deals on Nintendo Switch bundles, which never happens. And on this Black Friday, we’ve been handed another early holiday ... Read more »

All the Can't-Miss Deals From Ulta Beauty's Black Friday Sale — Including the TikTok-Famous Neutrogena HydroBoost

© Image: Michael Buckner; Design: Ashley Britton/SheKnows. Black Friday is here, and we’ve already made space in our cabinets for all the new goodies we’ll be stocking up on. Among ... Read more »

This Top Reviewed Legging Brand Is Having a Huge Sale on Amazon For Black Friday

If you could take only one clothing item with you on a deserted island, what would you take? I would bring a pair of leggings. I mean seriously, they’re so ... Read more »

Four gaming PCs you might actually buy for an RTX 3080, 3070 Ti or 3060 Ti on Black Friday

Good gaming GPUs are still selling for ridiculous sums on eBay, because they’re practically impossible to find at retail — particularly for anything close to their MSRP. But if you’re ... Read more »

Victoria Beckham Loves These Low-Waste Makeup Pads & They're 30% Off Today for Black Friday

© Priscilla Grant/Everett Collection Makeup wipes are horrendous for the environment and sometimes a cleanser takes too long for when you’re sleepy before bed — and then you fall asleep ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic