Biden’s hunger hubbub ignores the federal obesity fiasco

opinion, food stamps, hunger, joe biden, obesity, richard nixon, biden’s hunger hubbub ignores the federal obesity fiasco

President Joe Biden once used obesity to justify the biggest boost in food-stamp benefits in history. AP/Evan Vucci

President Joe Biden hosts a White House Conference on Hunger, Nutrition and Health next Thursday. He promises to “take bold steps to end hunger,” and his summit will likely unleash a torrent of demands for new federal handouts. But neither Biden nor the attendees will admit the vast collateral damage from a 50-year-plus surge of federal food aid.

In 1969, President Richard Nixon held a summit on hunger and received glowing press coverage for proclaiming, “The moment is at hand to put an end to hunger in America itself for all time.” That year, 3 million Americans received food stamps, a burgeoning federal program that cost $228 million. Last year, 41 million people received food stamps, and the program cost $114 billion. Thanks to an array of other subsidies, the federal government is now feeding more than 100 million people.

Yet hunger supposedly remains a grave problem. Rep. Jim McGovern (D-Mass.), chairman of the House Rules Committee, declared Sept. 15: “Almost 40 million Americans don’t know where their next meal is coming from.”

Yet the federal government doesn’t even attempt to collect data on how many Americans actually go hungry. In 2006, the National Academy of Sciences urged the US Department of Agriculture to create a hunger gauge, but the agency’s done nothing on that score. Instead, USDA conducts annual surveys measuring a vaporous notion of “food security” — which can simply mean uncertainty about being able to afford groceries in the future or not being able to afford the organic food one prefers.

That survey is designed to spur perpetual false alarms and demagoguery. The latest survey, released this month, declared that 10% of American households are “food insecure.” Politicians and much of the media take such statistics as proxies for mass hunger despite USDA’s explicit warnings on the limits of the data.

Thanks to federal programs, millions of low-income Americans are undernourished but overfed. Walter Willett, chair of Harvard University’s Department of Nutrition, observed in 2015, “We’ve analyzed what [food-stamp] participants are eating and it’s horrible food. It’s a diet designed to produce obesity and diabetes.”

A 2017 study published in BMC Public Health found food-stamp recipients twice as likely to be obese as eligible non-recipients. The recipients consume twice as many of their daily calories from sugar-sweetened beverages as do higher-income groups (12% vs. 6%), per a 2015 study in Preventive Medicine.

Food stamps have been one of the most tragic bait-and-switches in modern political history. More than 40 years ago, the Congressional Budget Office warned that “it still remains unclear if increased food purchases . . . means improved nutritional status.”

In recent decades, an array of governors and mayors (including New York City’s Mike Bloomberg) sought to amend the food-stamp program to cease paying for junk food. But Washington has always blocked those reforms.

Young children in low-income families are more than 50% more likely to be obese than those in other families, a 2016 report found. While politicians portray hunger as the gravest peril for the poor, “seven times as many [low-income] children are obese as are underweight,” the Journal of the American Medical Association noted in 2012.

The American Journal of Public Health reported in 2017 that food-stamp recipients had double the likelihood of cardio-related mortality and three times the rate of diabetes-related mortality as the general population and sharply higher risks than food-stamp eligible non-recipients.

opinion, food stamps, hunger, joe biden, obesity, richard nixon, biden’s hunger hubbub ignores the federal obesity fiasco

Last year, 41 million people received food stamps.

Christopher Sadowski

Expect no candor on food handouts’ collateral damage at the White House summit. In August 2021, the Biden administration tacitly invoked obesity to justify the biggest boost in food-stamp benefits in history. USDA revised its Thrifty Food Plan, which determines Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (i.e, food-stamp) benefit levels, to “reflect current realities providing sufficient energy to support current weight status.”

The American Enterprise Institute’s Angela Rachidi noted, “Giving SNAP participants more money without restrictions will more than likely increase the consumption of unhealthy items, worsening the problems of obesity and disease caused by poor diet.” Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack justified the higher benefits to prevent beefy mobs from attacking USDA headquarters: “We may have a Constitution and a Declaration of Independence, but if we had 42 million Americans who were going hungry, really hungry, they wouldn’t be happy and there would be political instability.”

The summit will also likely ignore the role of food stamps and other benefit programs in shrinking the workforce. A 2012 Journal of Public Economics study concluded that receiving food stamps sharply reduces single mothers’ work hours. The 2018 Council of Economic Advisers report warned that increased food-stamp enrollment was causing healthy adults to “become increasingly reliant on welfare” and producing “stalled employment growth, in part because of the disincentives welfare programs impose on increasing one’s own income.”

Those disincentives have worsened because the Biden administration last year canceled the requirement for able-bodied adults without children to seek work instead of perpetually relying on food stamps. Secretary Vilsack declared, “Groups with typically higher unemployment, including rural Americans, Black, Indigenous, Hispanic and People of Color, and those with less than a high-school education would have been disproportionally harmed by this cruel policy.”

At a time employers were begging people to accept jobs, Team Biden portrayed the necessity of working as a human-rights violation — at least for those categories Vilsack recited.

Media coverage has perennially equated a rising demand for free food with proof of mass hunger. But fighting hunger is profitable for politicians and ritzy nonprofits. Continually encouraging people to seek aid spurs miles-long lines of cars (including fancy late models) at food banks. In reality, the demand for free items (including food stamps) only proves that people like freebies.

If federal spending could abolish hunger, the problem would’ve vanished long ago. Carpet bombing food-stamp recipients with more calories is not even “close enough for government work” if the goal is to improve American nutrition. As long as Biden and other Washington politicians refuse to end the federal junk-food entitlement, all their talk of reform is hogwash.

James Bovard is the author of 10 books and a member of the USA Today Board of Contributors.

News Related


Iran blocks internet, social media as Mahsa Amini protests grow

The Iranian government has blocked mobil internet and social media apps following the protests against Mahsa Amini's death Read more »

Tigers' Javy Báez Embraces Villain Role Against White Sox

Javy Báez embraces villain role against White Sox originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago White Sox fans have made sure Javy Báez hears how they feel about him this weekend ... Read more »

Mexico Beats Peru 1-0 in International Friendly Inside Rose Bowl

Hirving Lozano scored the winner in the 85th minute Read more »

Post Malone Hospitalized With ‘Stabbing Pain’ Cancels Show A Week After Stage Fall

Wagner Meier/Getty Images Post Malone is experiencing a “stabbing pain” which has forced him to cancel his show in Boston. The artist shared a message on social media apologizing to ... Read more »

Hochul’s insane green power scheme may raise New Yorkers’ power costs

Blackstone’s investment in “clean hydropower” will bring allegedly spotless electricity to New York City residents. Getty Images The green-energy movement has been very good for Wall Street, and not so ... Read more »

Fatal Hit-And-Run in Dallas, Man Struck by Two Vehicle

NBC News A man is dead following a hit-and-run in Dallas early Saturday morning just after 1:00 a.m., authorities say. According to Dallas Police, an unknown make or model suspect ... Read more »

Storm Fiona washes houses into sea and knocks out electricity in two Canadian provinces

Fiona transformed from a hurricane into a post-tropical storm late Friday, but it still brought with it hurricane-strength winds, drenching rains, and huge waves. Read more »

Julius Randle’s ability to play off ball the biggest Knicks question

The Knicks believe they have answered their point-guard conundrum with the addition of Jalen Brunson. Team president Leon Rose locked up long-term building block RJ Barrett. The front office found ... Read more »

14-Year-Old Shot, Wounded Inside Vehicle in Dallas

NBC 5 News A 14-year-old boy was shot and wounded early Saturday morning in Dallas, authorities say. Officers responded to a shooting call in the 9600 block of CF Hawn ... Read more »

Cuba to hold referendum on same-sex marriage, surrogate pregnancies, in possible shift away from machismo culture

Cubans on Sunday will vote in a landmark referendum on whether to legalise same-sex marriage and adoption, allow surrogate pregnancies and give greater rights to non-biological parents. The new family ... Read more »

Jets looking to turn heat up on Bengals and Joe Burrow

So far, the Jets have not been in much of a rush this season. Their pass rush, which was expected to be a strength of the team, has been mostly ... Read more »

How Much It Would Really Cost To Attend Harry Potter's Hogwarts

Warner Bros. Pictures/YouTube Ever since the first “Harry Potter” book became a phenomenon that changed the publishing industry forever (via Vox), readers and watchers of the franchise have been waiting for ... Read more »

Hurricane Fiona sweeps away houses, knocks out power in eastern Canada

Fiona washed houses into the sea, tore the roofs off others and knocked out power to the vast majority of two Canadian province. AP TORONTO — Fiona washed houses into ... Read more »

SpaceX launches 52 Starlink satellites, lighting up night sky as far up coast as Long Island

SpaceX launched another 52 Starlink satellites from Florida Saturday — and their rockets were seen as far as Long Island on their way into space. A Falcon 9 rocket equipped ... Read more »

Reid Detmers and Angels’ defense have a tough night in loss at Minnesota

MINNEAPOLIS —  Gary Sanchez drove in four runs, including a three-run homer in the fifth inning, and the Minnesota Twins ended a five-game losing streak with an 8-4 win over the ... Read more »

Father Speaks Out After Son and Daughter Killed in Oak Forest Domestic Disturbance

Jorge Rodriguez said his daughter, Briana, had a big smile, while Emilio was protective of his older sister. Read more »

New prime minister and chancellor forced to defend controversial tax cuts

Using more than £70 billion of increased borrowing, Kwasi Kwarteng announced the biggest programme of tax cuts in 50 years, including abolishing the top rate of income tax for the highest earners. Read more »

Yankees’ playoff hopes hinge on answering bullpen question

An Aaron and a No. 99 homered Friday night. Neither was hit by Aaron Judge (it was Hicks and Boston’s Alex Verdugo). The Yankees and Red Sox combined for five ... Read more »

US spy satellite launched into orbit from California

US spy satellite launched into orbit from California A classified satellite for the U.S. National Reconnaissance Office has launched into orbit aboard a United Launch Alliance Delta 4 Heavy rocket ... Read more »

Ohio Republican candidate denies misrepresenting military service

Ohio Republican candidate denies misrepresenting military service Military records reviewed by ABC News show J.R. Majewski was based in Qatar. An Ohio Republican House candidate who critics say misrepresented his ... Read more »

New DART Software Helps Spot Potential Safety Issues

NBC 5 News DART has launched a pilot program using high-tech equipment that aims to enhance rider safety, transit officials say. The “Real-Time Transit Infrastructure & Rolling Stock Condition Assessment” ... Read more »

470,000 without power after Fiona causes 'shocking' damage in Canada

Hundreds of thousands of Canadians were without power Saturday after former hurricane Fiona slammed into the country’s Atlantic provinces, causing what officials called a shocking and devastating amount of damage. ... Read more »

Middle Tennessee Stuns No. 25 Miami, 45-31, With Big Plays

Chase Cunningham completed 16 of 25 passes for Middle Tennessee State, including a 69-yard scoring throw to Elijah Metcalf Read more »

Manoah, Merrifield lead Blue Jays to 3-1 win over Rays

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. (AP) — Alek Manoah pitched seven shutout innings, Whit Merrifield hit a three-run homer and the Toronto Blue Jays regained the top AL wild-card spot with a ... Read more »

Death toll from Hurricane Fiona rises to 16 in Puerto Rico

Hurricane Fiona has killed at least 16 people in Puerto Rico, authorities said late Saturday. The island is still digging out from the massive storm, which crashed ashore Sept. 18 ... Read more »

Media midterm games at border

A bus carrying Venezuelan migrants from Marthas Vineyard arrives off of a freight ferry in Woods Hole on Sept. 16. John Tlumacki/The Boston Globe via Getty Images If you’re trying ... Read more »

Jimmy Garoppolo has chance to be 49ers’ savior this season

Jimmy Garoppolo has spent the better part of his five-plus seasons with San Francisco somewhat scorned by 49ers fans, many of whom always seem to have been left wanting for ... Read more »

Rangers’ Artemi Panarin wants to play more unpredictably again

Artemi Panarin, dissatisfied not only with his work in the playoffs but also during the entire the 2021-22 regular season, said he intends to revert to the more unpredictable style ... Read more »

Zach Charbonnet helps UCLA cruise past winless Colorado to improve to 4-0

BOULDER, Colo. —  Nearly a month into the season, UCLA’s toughest opponent continues to be the UC regents. Colorado showed some early spunk Saturday before quickly folding, the winless Buffaloes unlike ... Read more »

A pocos les preocupa el medio ambiente en la Amazonía

Operación ilegal de búsqueda de oro en la ribera del río Ireng, en la reserva indígena de Raposa Serra do Sol en el estado de Roraima, en Brasil, el 7 ... Read more »

Family Celebrates Birthday of Missing Postal Worker Kierra Coles as 4 Years Since Disappearance Nears

Coles was three months pregnant when she disappeared on Oct. 18, 2018. Read more »

'Woke' Labour republicans say Britain faces a 'future with a white privileged male' as head of state for the next century at fringe conference event after the Queen's death

Around 60 people, including MP Richard Burgon, listened to the fringe event It discussed the case for a British republic just weeks after the Queen's death Hosts argued power by 'accident of birth' is 'incompatible' with the Labour Party Labour stressed it is not responsible for the content of the fringe events The Queen's funeral: All the latest Royal Family news and coverage Read more »

'No excuse': No. 25 Miami Hurricanes stunned at home by Middle Tennessee Blue Raiders

'No excuse': No. 25 Miami Hurricanes stunned at home by Middle Tennessee Blue Raiders MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. — Miami quarterback Tyler Van Dyke — the ACC's rookie of the year ... Read more »

What Happened To Sara Ramirez After Leaving Grey's Anatomy?

ABC The ABC medical drama “Grey’s Anatomy” is full of over-the-top moments but has been on the air for nearly two decades, having racked up a slew of seasons in ... Read more »

Revealed: 'Child' boat migrant who sailed across the Channel to the UK is actually a 25-year-old Iranian trying to date over-30s who was caught out by his GREY beard

A migrant who claimed to be a child to stay in the UK is actually in his mid-20s Aria Ibrahimi, who is now believed to be 25, was taken into care by Kent CouncilIbrahimi, who is from Iran, arrived by boat in May 2020 and claimed to be 16A social worker said they thought he was in his late 20s and had a few grey hairs Read more »

'Mum's gone, but she's standing right there': Neil Kinnock's children describe heartbreaking toll of Alzheimer's after their mother Glenys, 78, was diagnosed

Rachel, 51 and Stephen Kinnock, 52, have described 'slow grief' of the disease Baroness Kinnock was left 'mortified' as her memory gradually slipped awayLord Kinnock, 80,  has previously said he deals with the challenge 'out of love' Read more »

Fantasy baseball: Use closers to clinch your league championship

The final push toward a fantasy baseball championship is always the toughest. If you are playing in a head-to-head championship, you need to adjust your roster more toward how your ... Read more »

12-year-old Texas girl shoots dad in alleged plot with friend to kill their families

A 12-year-old girl shot her father then turned the gun on herself in Texas. Getty Images A 12-year-old girl shot her father then turned the gun on herself after making ... Read more »

Locals’ undefeated weekend even rarer than you think

If last Sunday felt a little different … well, it should have felt different. Between 4 o’clock and 5 o’clock, the following things happened: The Giants outlasted the Panthers at ... Read more »

'I got in a bit of a muddle!' Strictly's Shirley Ballas suffers a hilarious blunder as she accidentally gives Tyler West and Dianne Buswell the 'wrong score' following their debut dance

Get all the glitz, glamour and gossip from the first Strictly Come Dancing live show HERE Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network