Biden's bewildering decision to expand a Trump-era immigration policy

Asia's Tech News Daily

Biden’s bewildering decision to expand a Trump-era immigration policy
© Mario Tama/Getty Images Asylum-seeking migrants, at right, pray for a group of migrants, left, who have already received asylum petition appointments during a worship service at a migrant shelter in Tijuana, Mexico, in July.

President Joe Biden says he wants to end the “Remain in Mexico” policy, a Trump-era program that has forced tens of thousands of migrants to await decisions on their immigration cases in Mexico for months.

In a seemingly contradictory move, Biden is first reinstating and expanding it. The program’s return was ordered by the courts. The policy’s expansion, however, was a choice made by the Biden administration.

On Thursday, the US reached an agreement with the Mexican government to revive the Migration Protection Protocols (MPP), also known as the “Remain in Mexico” policy. Under Trump, the policy allowed 70,000 migrants seeking entry into the US to be sent to Mexican border towns where many lived in squalid encampments or in overcrowded shelters and were targeted by criminal gangs.

Biden halted MPP shortly after taking office, fulfilling a campaign promise. But his administration has argued that it has no choice but to reinstate the program starting on Monday. A federal court in Texas ordered the administration to continue forcing migrants to wait in Mexico until it expands its capacity to detain migrants in the US. The ruling came as part of a lawsuit brought by Texas and Missouri; the Supreme Court has refused to block that lower court ruling.

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas nevertheless has maintained that the administration is committed to ending the program eventually.

“MPP had endemic flaws, imposed unjustifiable human costs, pulled resources and personnel away from other priority efforts, and did not address the root causes of irregular migration,” he wrote in an October memo. “MPP not only undercuts the Administration’s ability to implement critically needed and foundational changes to the immigration system, it fails to provide the fair process and humanitarian protections that individuals deserve under the law.”

But by reimplementing the program in the meantime with relatively few changes, the Biden administration has disappointed some Democrats, migrant advocates and even asylum officers tasked with screening people subject to the program. They have argued that the program is itself illegal and shirks the US’s obligation under federal and international law not to return migrants to danger.

Immigration advocates are also angered by the fact that Biden isn’t just reinstating MPP; he’s broadening its scale. Now, all other citizens of countries in the Western Hemisphere can be sent back under the program, which previously only covered Spanish speakers.

The administration isn’t doing so because the court ordered it to — that wasn’t part of the court’s instructions — and it hasn’t explained why it’s expanding the program, and did not respond to a request for comment on Friday. That leaves room for doubt about its commitment to ensuring the safety of migrants who will suffer from keeping MPP in place.

“We categorically reject the Biden administration’s claims that it can administer the Remain in Mexico program in a more humane manner,” Jorge Loweree, policy director at the American Immigration Council, said in a statement. “The longer the administration delays terminating this unlawful and cruel policy, the more people will suffer.”

Biden’s changes to the program aren’t enough

The dangers associated with sending migrants back to Mexico are well documented. As of February 2021, a report by Human Rights First identified more than 1,500 murders, kidnappings, rapes, torture and other attacks on migrants returned to Mexico under MPP. And a survey of 20,000 asylum seekers trapped at the US-Mexico border conducted by the legal aid group Al Otro Lado found that 83 percent had been subject to threats or physical violence, including 89 percent of LGBTQ asylum seekers.

Despite that, and despite having permission from the lower court to do things differently, Biden isn’t changing much about the way MPP has been run. And his administration’s policy still leaves determinations about exemptions to the discretion of individual border agents.

The administration says it will complete all cases in the program within six months of a migrant’s return to Mexico. The Trump administration promised to clear cases in the same time frame, but largely failed to meet it in practice due to a lack of prioritization and backlogs in the immigration courts, limitations the Biden administration still faces.

Biden has also outlined exemptions to the program similar to those the Trump administration used, including for people with disabilities and the elderly. Given that border agents will be tasked with identifying those people, some may fall through the cracks.

The US has said it will also work with the Mexican government to provide “safe and secure” shelters for those enrolled in the program. However, shelter directors along the border say they’re already overwhelmed, and local officials in Mexico have yet to be approached by the Biden administration about funding to expand capacity. The two countries have also promised to provide safe transport to and from US ports of entry, and work permits, health care, and other services in Mexico.

Perhaps most importantly, border agents will now proactively interview migrants to determine whether they have a “reasonable possibility” of facing danger in Mexico before returning them under the program. It will be up to those agents to refer migrants who express any fear of harm if returned to Mexico to an asylum officer for further screening.

Migrants will be able to consult a lawyer before those interviews, though few will benefit from that part of the deal. Previously, only about 18 percent of people subject to MPP who showed up for their hearings were able to pay for a lawyer or had access to free legal counsel, according to the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse at Syracuse University, which collects and analyzes data on US immigration courts.

But even with those changes, the administration’s own asylum officers say there is no way to ensure migrants’ safety under the “irredeemably flawed” program.

“While the administration has taken measures intended to mitigate some of the most egregious elements of MPP’s prior iteration, a program that requires asylum seekers to remain in one of the most dangerous parts of the world while their cases are pending in US immigration courts cannot guarantee their protection from persecution and torture, as required by US law,” the union for asylum officers tasked with screening people subject to MPP wrote in a letter on Thursday.

Biden wasn’t forced to expand MPP

The Biden administration argued that its hands are tied by the courts when it comes to MPP. Immigrant advocates, however, say that the administration should have acted more quickly to build its case against the program, and that it is under no legal obligation to expand it.

The Biden administration first issued a memo terminating MPP in June. The Texas court found that memo didn’t provide sufficient justification for the decision on August 13. Still, it wasn’t until October 29 that Mayorkas finally issued another memo elaborating on the administration’s reasoning in a manner that might have boosted its case had it been released in July.

Karen Tumlin, an immigration litigator and director and founder of the Justice Action Center, said the Biden administration bears responsibility for dragging their feet on issuing the second memo — what she says is the “thing that was most likely to ultimately end the court order.”

“That delay is what caused the situation we are in today,” she said.

There is also nothing in the court’s order that suggests the Biden administration had to expand MPP. With the exception of Brazilians, non-Spanish speakers were not previously subject to the program, in part because they would have difficulty finding work in Mexico and would have no realistic means of sustaining themselves while pursuing their asylum claims in the US.

Now, all citizens of Western Hemisphere countries are subject to MPP unless they qualify for an exemption. That includes Haitians, who have faced racial discrimination and been targets of violent crimes in Mexico — and not just at the hands of gangs. According to the Al Otro Lado survey, 20 percent of Haitian asylum seekers had been subject to physical violence or extortion by Mexican law enforcement.

The Biden administration noted in its plan for reimplementation that the Mexican government may narrow the categories of migrants subject to MPP, or limit the number of non-Spanish speakers in the program going forward. As it stands, however, the program could cover more migrants than it did under Trump.

“The Biden administration was not ordered by the court to expand Remain in Mexico to new populations,” Ursela Ojeda, senior policy adviser for migrant rights and justice at the Women’s Refugee Commission, said in a press call. “They are going well above and beyond good faith compliance that’s required of them [by the court] to make this policy more cruel and more deadly.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Khoisan group in court battle to halt construction of Amazon Africa headquarters

‘Our heritage is not for sale,’ say Khoisan members as they legally oppose the development of what will house Amazon’s Africa operations headquarters. © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All ... Read more »

Unilever investors call AGM vote to push for healthy food targets

© Reuters/DADO RUVIC Illustration of Unilever logo By Simon Jessop and Siddharth Cavale LONDON (Reuters) – A group of investors in Unilever said on Thursday they had filed a fresh ... Read more »

Top 10 Chinese Women list taken down due to objections from netizens over the inclusion of Lee Jinglei and Du Meizhu

© The Independent Singapore © The Independent Singapore Mandopop singer Wang Leehom’s ex-wife Lee Jinglei may have won a lot of support from many as the messy split between the ... Read more »

Lack of sellers spurs rapid house price growth in UK - RICS

© Reuters/PHIL NOBLE An estate agent’s board is displayed outside a house on a terraced street in Blackburn LONDON (Reuters) – British house prices rose rapidly again last month as ... Read more »

Stormont ministers to consider relaxations to Covid restrictions

Stormont ministers are set to consider relaxations to Covid-19 restrictions. They will be informed by the latest Department of Health data which indicates Northern Ireland is likely at the peak ... Read more »

Workers face first commute since Plan B axed as masks in classrooms end

Commuters across the country are set to travel in to work for the first time since Plan B measures to curb the spread of Omicron were axed on Wednesday. The ... Read more »

Covid driving record numbers in England to become nurses

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Richard Saker/The Observer The Covid pandemic has inspired record numbers of people to become nurses, with more than 56,000 signing up to nursing courses ... Read more »

Eric Adams considers exempting NYPD from city agency budget cuts

Mayor Eric Adams said Wednesday he may exempt the New York Police Department from the 3 percent across-the-board budget cut he ordered this month — while lambasting the agency’s habit ... Read more »

Khalid Samad dibenar poligami, serah banglo, penthouse kepada isteri

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mahkamah Tinggi Syariah membenarkan Khalid Samad berpoligami selepas beliau bersetuju menunaikan hak-hak isterinya, Zaiton Abu Bakar. PETALING JAYA: Mahkamah Tinggi Syariah di Shah Alam ... Read more »

Boris and Carrie Johnson's baby daughter Romy had Covid and was ‘hit quite badly' by the virus

BORIS Johnson's baby daughter was badly-hit by Covid when she was just five weeks old, it's reported. The Prime Minister vanished from the public eye last Thursday after a member ... Read more »

Boris Johnson covid announcement: PM rips up restrictions as work from home, face mask & vaccine passport rules to END

BORIS Johnson yesterday announced he's scrapping almost all of England's Covid restrictions in a huge boost to millions of Brits. The PM said he's binning all of the Plan B measures which ... Read more »

Trudeau says government not planning new law to curb protests targeting politicians

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says his government has no plans to expand a law protecting health care workers and patients from aggressive protests to cover politicians. As the pandemic nears ... Read more »

Australia news live update: 25 Covid deaths in NSW; 15 in Victoria; TGA approves Novavax vaccine and two oral treatments; national cabinet meets

LIVE – Updated at 00:16 Follow all the day’s news. TGA grants provisional approval to Novavax vaccine 00:16 Finally! It looks like there may be light at the end of ... Read more »

Elitist fashion industry chewed up André Leon Talley as it does everyone

The fashion world was Andre Leon Talley’s everything, so once it was gone his life was never the same. Shutterstock With André Leon Talley’s passing comes the death, too, of ... Read more »

Colleyville rabbi who escaped synagogue hostage situation: ‘It's safe to go to shul'

© (photo credit: JTA) Rabbi Charlie Cytron-Walker. Rabbi Charlie Cytron-Walker, the man at the center of the Colleyville, Texas, synagogue hostage crisis last weekend, says that he is looking for ... Read more »

The politics of disruption: ANC councillors' destructive path is likely to hurt the party in 2024 elections

The past few days have provided evidence that those predicting chaos in local government after last year’s elections may have been correct. © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights ... Read more »

GOP lawmaker leaves race for Arkansas secretary of state

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – In this Feb. 1, 2021, file photo, Rep. Mark Lowery speaks to reporters at the Arkansas state Capitol in Little Rock, Ark. Lowery ... Read more »

U.S. Congress subpoenas two far-right leaders in Capitol attack probe

© Reuters/SHANNON STAPLETON Supporters of U.S. President Donald Trump gather in Washington WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The congressional committee probing the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol issued subpoenas ... Read more »

Good fortune helped Rangers weather latest COVID storm

In the third NHL season impacted by COVID-19, the Rangers have been luckier than many other teams. Not only was their recent outbreak mild and slow-moving through the locker room, ... Read more »

AP FACT CHECK: Biden puffs up claims of virus, job gains

The Associated PressPresident Joe Biden leaves after a news conference in the East Room of the White House in Washington, Wednesday, Jan. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh) WASHINGTON — In ... Read more »

Jared Leto and Anne Hathaway Live WeWork's Rise and Fall in WeCrashed Trailer: 'You're Not God'

“WeWork isn’t just a company. It’s a movement.”  The first trailer for Apple TV+’s WeCrashed takes a dramatized look inside the successes and failures of shared workspace startup WeWork, and the founders ... Read more »

Borussia Mönchengladbach scheitert im Cup, Union weiter

© KEYSTONE/AP/Swen Pfartner Borussia Mönchengladbach verliert in Hannover 0:3 und ist schon wieder im Krisenmodus angekommen. Union Berlin gewinnt derweil bei Stadtrivale Hertha. Zweieinhalb Monate ist es her, da konnte ... Read more »

Arsenal's Dusan Vlahovic swoop moves forward as Mikel Arteta's plan becomes clear

Arsenal boss Mikel Arteta’s plan to land top January transfer window target Dusan Vlahovic may have moved a step closer following the latest development in determining Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang’s future at ... Read more »

Demi Lovato and Sir Elton John among GLAAD Media Award nominees

© Bang Showbiz Demi up for GLAAD Award Demi Lovato and Sir Elton John are amongst the nominees for the 2022 GLAAD Awards. The 29-year-old popstar – who made the ... Read more »

More venues eyed for vax campaign expansion

© The STAR/Geremy Pintolo More venues eyed for vax campaign expansion MANILA, Philippines — After drugstores, the National Vaccination Operations Center (NVOC) is exploring all other possible “avenues” to scale up ... Read more »

DoJ to summon 'Poblacion Girl'

THE Department of Justice (DoJ) will summon Gwyneth Anne Chua, also known as “Poblacion Girl” in social media, along with her parents and several staff from the hotel she was ... Read more »

Omicron now dominant Covid-19 variant in PH

THE Philippines on Wednesday reported an additional 492 new cases of the Omicron variant of the coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) and the first two deaths due to the highly infectious ... Read more »

Britney Spears said her father exploited her conservatorship to pitch his own cooking show called 'Cookin' Cruzin' and Chaos with Jamie Spears,' court documents show

© Nick Ut/AP/Steve Granitz/WireImage Nick Ut/AP/Steve Granitz/WireImage Jamie Spears tried to launch his own cooking show using Britney Spears’s music supervisor, court docs say. Britney Spears accused her father of ... Read more »

Cardi B says she will cover the funeral costs for the 17 victims of the Bronx fire: 'I knew I needed to do something to help'

© Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/Getty Images Axelle/Bauer-Griffin/Getty Images On January 9, an apartment fire in the Bronx killed 17 people and injured dozens of others. Rapper Cardi B told Insider that she would ... Read more »

Tory MP suspended for a day after undermining apology for bullying staff

A Tory MP has been suspended from the House of Commons for one day after undermining an apology he gave for bullying staff. © PA Daniel Kawczynski apologises in the ... Read more »

Voices: At Biden's first press conference of 2022, we learned a lot about his relationship with Putin and Mitch McConnell

© Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. Biden – Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. One day, there will be an Oscar-baiting biopic called Mitch and ... Read more »

Supreme Court allows release of Trump White House docs to January 6 committee

© EPA-EFE Supporters of Donald Trump storm the US Capitol on 6 January 2021 – EPA-EFE Donald Trump can’t block the release of White House documents about the 6 January ... Read more »

Trump falsely claims Biden was ‘reading' answers at his news conference

© Getty Images GettyImages-1365695525.jpg Donald Trump has falsely claimed that Joe Biden was “reading” his answers to “softball” questions during his White House press conference. Mr Biden spoke for almost ... Read more »

For Just $45 You Can Buy an Amazon Fire HD 8 Tablet for Everyone in Your Family

The new year is offically here and there are so many amazing 2022 deals, it’s hard to keep up. There are huge savings on iPads, 4K Smart TVs, homewares, tax ... Read more »

Strictly's Nadiya Bychkova reveals glam hair transformation after split from fiancé

STRICTLY star Nadiya Bychkova revealed her glamourous hair transformation after split from her footballer fiancé. The 32-year-old, who has reportedly split from Matija Škarabot, showed off her wavy new hairstyle ahead ... Read more »

I'm sick of people telling me I'll regret not having kids – I'm 32 and I much prefer dogs, children are just annoying

A WOMAN who doesn't have children has urged people to stop telling her she'll regret not starting a family. The 32-year-old, who posts under the Cheffychefcheff account on TikTok, took ... Read more »

When will Final Fantasy XIV Patch 6.1 be released?

© Provided by Dot Esports The Endwalker expansion was released over a month ago and the developer is already working on more content to keep Final Fantasy XIV fresh. The ... Read more »

Biden says he would keep Kamala Harris as running mate if he seeks reelection

President Biden on Wednesday pledged to keep Vice President Kamala Harris as his running mate if he seeks a second term in 2024. Harris recently claimed she and the 79-year-old ... Read more »

Antibiotic-resistant superbugs killed 1.2MILLION people in 2019

Antibiotic-resistant infections directly killed 1.2million people in 2019, according to the largest study of its kind that lays bare the growing threat of superbugs.  This would make superbugs a bigger ... Read more »

Valerie Bertinelli is mourning the loss of her co-star Betty White

Valerie Bertinelli still thinks about her friend Betty White all the time.  The actress, 61, shared her thoughts during an Extra interview about her relationship with her Hot In Cleveland co-star, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic