Biden can't afford to repeat Obama's mistakes on climate policy

Asia's Tech News Daily

After a major setback on a historic package of climate legislation, President Joe Biden and Democrats in Congress are scrambling to find other ways to slash US emissions. As they race to create a Plan B for an escalating climate crisis, they stand to learn a lot from the Obama era — a history that’s littered with similar setbacks and climate policies that never saw the light of day.

Biden can’t afford to repeat Obama’s mistakes on climate policy
© Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images Demonstrators chant in front of the White House during a climate march on October 12.

One of the most impactful climate policies that Congress has ever considered, the clean electricity payment program (CEPP), is on the chopping block. Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) says he will not support a bill that penalizes coal and natural gas for the outsized role they play in US pollution. Democrats can’t pass their budget bill, the Build Back Better Act, without his support, and its size and scope has been shrinking.

Meanwhile, a key window for progress is closing: Top Democrats have promised to hammer out a domestic climate deal by the time Biden speaks at a pivotal United Nations climate conference in Glasgow, which begins October 31. If Congress fails to enshrine key climate policies as federal laws, Biden’s Plan B includes executive orders and major regulations from the Environmental Protection Agency, the New York Times reported.

The problem is that executive actions aren’t an ideal substitute for federal laws, and may last only as long as Biden’s presidency. EPA regulation also “tends to lag [behind] the technological realities,” meaning it may only modestly nudge the economy in a new direction, Jesse Jenkins, an environmental engineering professor at Princeton University, told Vox. It’s also vulnerable to intervention by the Supreme Court.

In some respects, Democrats have been here before. Under President Barack Obama, a similar political bind in Congress made his climate actions weaker and open to reversal. “I am not sure there are easy ways to avoid the pitfalls the Obama administration faced in taking regulatory action on climate change,” Matto Mildenberger, a University of California Santa Barbara political scientist who has written on the history of US climate policy, told Vox.

Democrats have options left. The $500 billion Democrats have promised for climate funding would represent historic Congressional investment, and roughly a third of the funding in the possible Build Back Better plan. But it still would not make up for the policies that have been cut. If the past any guide, their best chance is to throw the kitchen sink at the climate crisis, consistently and relentlessly, on every level of government.

To make sweeping and lasting progress, they’ll need to outdo the Democrats of the Obama era by pushing not only for executive and state action, but also funding for smaller climate policies that can fill what experts described as the “CEPP-sized hole” in the budget bill. If Democrats do that, Mildenberger still believes the US could manage to have a “world-leading” climate agenda.

Democrats run the risk of repeating mistakes they made in the Obama era

Obama’s strategy for tackling climate change counted on Congress passing a bipartisan bill, which would have capped climate pollution and created a market for trading credits. Success depended on the support of wary Democrats as well as some Republicans. By summer 2010, Obama appointees admitted they didn’t have the votes in the Senate. The bill quietly died that summer, and the path to passing a federal law closed when Tea Party-backed Republicans swept the midterm elections.

As the New Yorker reported at the time, “Obama said that he knew ‘the votes may not be there right now, but I intend to find them in the coming months.’ He never found them, and he didn’t appear to be looking very hard.”

Biden can’t afford to repeat Obama’s mistakes on climate policy
© Alex Wong/Getty Images President Barack Obama unveiled his climate change plan on June 25, 2013, at Georgetown University in Washington, DC. Key portions of his plan were undone by the Supreme Court and President Donald Trump.

The Obama administration didn’t charge ahead to find other ways to deliver pollution cuts, at least not right away. Climate activists spent the subsequent years accusing Obama of “climate silence,” according to the Washington Post. It wasn’t until his 2013 State of the Union that he made his lengthiest comments on climate change in years and promised: “If Congress won’t act soon … I will … with executive actions.”

By summer 2013, well into Obama’s second term, the administration was pushing forward with a new comprehensive strategy for tackling climate change, relying primarily on executive and regulatory action to clean up power and transportation emissions. For the first time, a president began to realign the executive branch, especially the EPA, to issue landmark standards for cleaner cars, power plants, and methane from gas operations.

But Obama was not able to replicate what Congress could have accomplished. As ambitious as his first-ever coal regulations seemed at the time, for example, they were halted by the Supreme Court before taking effect. Even without them, utilities ended up keeping pace with most targets on their own, showing how moderate the regulations were.

There are other reasons that a new wave of EPA action won’t be as powerful as federal climate legislation. Regulations still take time to draft and finalize and are frequently challenged in court. The Supreme Court swung to the right under President Donald Trump and seems even more skeptical of the EPA’s powers.

In hindsight, the Obama administration arguably miscalculated the odds that its climate policy would outlast his presidency. The office of Sen. Tina Smith (D-MN), who sponsored the clean electricity plan, told Vox that politicians can’t take for granted that all climate policies will last. Smith’s staff said that Biden’s Plan B must find other ways to cut emissions, even as Manchin insists on cuts and the bill’s price tag keeps shrinking.

Biden can’t afford to repeat Obama’s mistakes on climate policy
© Ting Shen/Bloomberg via Getty Images Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) speaks at the Economic Club of Washington in Washington, DC, on October 26. He has opposed major climate provisions in Democrats’ budget bill.

Obama-era Democrats left other climate policies in a precarious place: For example, key tax breaks for wind and solar repeatedly expired throughout the 2000s and were only renewed after the fact, slowing gains in the two renewable energy sectors. Even when Democrats controlled Congress in Obama’s terms, these credits received short-term extensions. And by waiting until Obama’s second term to roll out key climate regulations for the power sector and transportation, the administration took a risk that some wouldn’t be finalized before the next administration, making it that much easier for any Trump to halt.

Trump easily blocked methane rules for existing oil and gas facilities because they were still being drafted. “There are tiers of executive actions, each of which have different relative permanency,” CNN explained in 2016. And finalized rules take longer for an incoming president to reverse than rulemaking that’s still underway.

The Biden White House’s climate strategy in 2021 may end up not so different from the course of the Obama administration. Obama, facing the reality of a gridlocked Congress, relied on executive action to push the country forward on climate. And when Trump reversed course on climate policy, some states tried to continue their own shifts toward clean energy.

Still, Democrats can learn from this history and take action in three important ways: 1) pushing the executive branch to quickly finalize regulations of the biggest emitters, such as coal-fired power plants and oil and gas producers; 2) writing climate standards into their subsidies for other polluting sectors, like industry, transportation, and buildings; and 3) updating the Build Back Better budget bill so that it funds every possible incremental way to close the gap in emissions.

They also have to remember what has changed: The political movement urging climate action is far bigger than it was a decade ago. The problem is, the warnings in climate science of inaction are also more dire. The Biden administration will have to outdo the Obama administration in the pace and the scale of its ambitions.

Biden’s goals are bigger than Obama’s, but he has less margin for error

A decade of inaction by Congress has now cost the world precious time to avoid the most severe consequences of climate change. A global goal of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius, enshrined in the 2015 Paris agreement, could slip through our fingers in a matter of years, according to the World Meteorological Organization and Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Every fraction of a degree of warming can claim lives and livelihoods as it ripples through ecosystems, water supplies, agriculture, and more.

The US is making progress, but not quickly enough. Domestic climate pollution has fallen by under 22 percent between 2005 and 2020. After rejoining the Paris climate agreement this year, Biden announced a new target: cutting US climate pollution by at least 50 percent by 2030.

The best way of ensuring the US gets the rest of the way to this target, climate experts told Vox, would be ambitious congressional action. Federal laws could transition the electricity sector off fossil fuels and replace gas-guzzling cars with electric vehicles.

“Even with what some would view as moderate congressional action, there is still a pathway to meeting the target.”

Now that the Senate appears to have sunk its best single weapon against climate change, the clean electricity payment program, the White House is falling back on a “three-pronged approach” to meet its goal.

One prong still depends on Congress passing historic clean energy funding as part of the Build Back Better Act (albeit a smaller package than the White House wanted). The second relies on the White House preparing ambitious regulations of electricity, transportation, a natural gas production. And the third prong depends on states — especially the 25 that are already committed to climate action — ramping up energy efficiency, fuel standards, and clean energy to match the most ambitious regions in the nation.

This Plan B will be difficult to pull off, and is less ambitious than climate activists had hoped for. A clean electricity policy would have accounted for roughly 25 percent of the package’s pollution cuts, according to a Princeton Zero Lab analysis from Jenkins. Democrats may also scrap their second major climate proposal, a plan to fine oil and gas producers for methane pollution, from the Build Back Better Act. Methane is a potent greenhouse gas that, over the short term, warms the planet even more than carbon dioxide.

Other powerful levers in the fight against climate change, like a carbon tax or specific penalties on fossil fuels, are just as unlikely to make it into the final plan. So the final infrastructure package and budget bill likely won’t make as big of a dent in climate pollution as many Democrats once hoped.

But that doesn’t mean all hope is lost for US climate action. “Even with what some would view as moderate congressional action, there is still a pathway to meeting the target,” John Larsen, climate director of the energy research firm Rhodium Group, told Vox. “It’s just going to mean that there needs to be sustained effort by other parts of the federal system and state level to really follow through.”

How Democrats can still make lasting progress on climate policy

In a Monday speech in New Jersey, Biden projected optimism that his Build Back Better agenda is “going to address the root cause of ever-increasing extreme weather and destruction.”

Biden can’t afford to repeat Obama’s mistakes on climate policy
© Evan Vucci/AP President Joe Biden speaks on his Build Back Better infrastructure, climate, and social spending agenda at the New Jersey Transit Meadowlands Maintenance Complex in Kearny on October 25.

For him to follow through on this promise, he’ll have to avoid the pitfalls that Obama faced. The past decade highlights how critical it is for a Build Back Better plan that closes the gaping holes likely left without the clean electricity payment program and methane fees — and for Democrats to maintain a sense of urgency and chip away at the climate crisis at every level.

  • The first, most important lesson from the Obama era is that there is no time to waste. Regulations take years to draft and finalize, so the earlier in Biden’s term that his administration creates them, the better shot they’ll have at outlasting his presidency.

Biden has seemed to appreciate this lesson. His EPA has been busy preparing and finalizing upgrades for Obama-era climate regulations for the power sector, transportation, and oil and gas production. “If you don’t have the methane fee, then the methane regulations that EPA is cooking up are going to be that much more important,” Larsen pointed out.

  • It’s still possible to meet Biden’s goals even without the CEPP and methane fees, according to a Rhodium Group analysis that Larsen coauthored last week. Rhodium estimated the impact of extremely aggressive action, including almost a dozen core executive actions the Biden administration would need to take. Some of these would have to build on what Obama originally planned, but at a far more ambitious scale, like far-reaching new climate standards for the power sector. Larsen also suggested that Biden would have to test the Clean Air Act in new ways, for example by issuing the first-ever climate regulation for industrial pollution, and requiring that every new natural gas terminal and chemical plant is equipped with carbon capture.
  • Congress still needs to pass as many climate priorities as possible in the infrastructure deal and Build Back Better plan. Democrats still have a shot at funding clean energy tax breaks, improving electricity transmission to connect renewables to new areas of the country, and expanding access to electric vehicles.

“My view on climate policy is you just keep accelerating things as much as you can, wherever you can,” Jenkins said. Some Democratic senators hope to redirect the CEPP’s $150 billion price tag to other programs.

Notable — @brianschatz and @SenatorCarper told me they’re under the impression the $150 billion for the CEPP will be spread around to other programs, rather than getting cut altogether. Again, will have to see what Manchin says bc that $ is in his committee.

— Ella Nilsen (@ella_nilsen) October 25, 2021

“Carbon pollution is is all throughout the American economy,” making it possible to pull levers that “together create something that would fill the CEPP-sized hole,” said Mildenberger, the USC political scientist. Those cuts could come from energy efficiency in industrial manufacturing, building electrification, or preventing nuclear plants from retiring.

Democrats could tweak requirements for projects that receive funding from new infrastructure spending. For example, Congress can require that federally funded building projects meet higher energy efficiency standards.

What are the other climate policies could benefit from an infusion of cash? Sen. Smith’s office suggested funding for renewable energy and transmission — though Manchin, as chair of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, might still have influence over that.

The Atlantic’s Robinson Meyer also pointed to long-distance electricity transmission:

The U.S. must triple its transmission infrastructure in order to decarbonize by 2050, according to a landmark Princeton study. As Steve Cicala, an economics professor at Tufts University, recently told me, solar and wind are now the cheapest forms of electricity generation in some parts of the country. But those cost declines only matter if the largest power markets are connected—via new transmission!—to those areas.”

The group We ACT for Environmental Justice suggested the funding should be used to clean up highway pollution that disproportionately affects communities of color, for example by increasing funding for clean cars and zero-emissions heavy-duty trucks.

Meanwhile, Mildenberger suggested, funding for nuclear power would ensure that the US doesn’t lose the 20 percent of its carbon-free energy that currently comes from nuclear. Otherwise, that electricity could be replaced with gas and coal.

Biden will need to multitask to make his Plan B work, Larsen said. “If any one component were not to take place in the timeframe that we’re talking about, then something else is going to have to happen,” he said. “That could be additional regulations, it could be new states that are leading; it could be future congressional action. But you would need to see other actions somewhere else to make up the difference.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Früherer Corona-Hotspot Ischgl startet trotz Lockdown in die Skisaison

Diashow ein In der Silvretta-Arena laufen die Lifte wieder. So belebt wie hier im Februar 2020 ist das Skigebiet allerdings noch nicht. Ischgl hatte als Ansteckungs-Hotspot unrühmliche Geschichte geschrieben. Etliche ... Read more »

Marian Rivera confirmed to sit as Miss Universe 2021 selection committee member: "Magiging patas ako."

© Provided by Si Marian Rivera ang tinutukoy sa blind item na lumabas dito sa (Philippine Entertainment Portal) noong November 27, Sabado, tungkol sa isang sikat na Kapuso ... Read more »

Vitto Marquez, shookt nang mapanood ang sexy films noon ng inang si Alma Moreno

Vitto Marquez Ipinakita ni Vitto Marquez ang naging reaksiyon niya nang mapanood ang mga sexy movies noon ng kaniyang ina na si Alma Moreno. Sa “Tough-patan” segment ng “Mars Pa ... Read more »

Feast your eyes on the celebrity chefs in new cooking show 'My Festive Menu'

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) It’s that time of the year when you ditch the calorie-counting and feast. As such, “My Festive Menu”, which starts on SABC3 on Friday, ... Read more »

Cape Town weekend weather - a bit of rain is coming

© Provided by CapeTalk Capetonians can expect some rain this weekend, according to the South African Weather Service. On Saturday, it’s forecasting a maximum temperature of 23 degrees Celsius and ... Read more »

Road Traffic Inspectorate brings in tow trucks to disperse, remove illegal truck driver protest on N3 in KZN

Road Freight Association urges government and SAPS to proactively intervene in chaotic protests rather than simply ‘monitoring’ activities, arguing SA’s road transport credibility is in rapid decline. © Copyright (c) ... Read more »

'Gauteng's Covid-19 infections highest among over-60s followed by preschoolders'

© Provided by CapeTalk Gauteng health officials are investigating the reason for the high Covid-19 hospitalisation rate for children under the age of 5 Preschoolers are now the second most ... Read more »

Christie Brinkley dances in figure-hugging mini green dress – and fans make cheeky comment!

© Provided by Hello! christie-cheeky-comment Christie Brinkley is feeling festive ahead of Christmas and she let that show on Thursday night as she attended Nick Cannon’s show in a gorgeous ... Read more »

IGNITE 2021 CYBER: Fueling opportunities for startups

© Provided by BusinessWorld Having experienced the effects of the COVID-19 crisis, organizations may be looking for innovations that can support their rebound and growth. IGNITE PH, with a focus ... Read more »

How to dismiss companions in Final Fantasy XIV

© Provided by GamePur You’ll now have the chance for Scions to accompany you while walking around in Final Fantasy XIV. You’ll need to have specific companions with you if ... Read more »

Elon Musk unloads Tesla shares for over $10 billion

Elon Musk has sold more than $10 billion worth of Tesla stock over the past month. AP Elon Musk’s stock selling spree continues. The world’s wealthiest man sold 934,000 Tesla ... Read more »

Germany's Covid wave could reach ‘sad peak' at Christmas, outgoing minister says

Germany’s fourth wave of the pandemic could reach a “sad peak” in intensive care units around the country around Christmas, the outgoing health minister, Jens Spahn, has warned as he ... Read more »

Trump's White House doctor facing fresh scrutiny over Covid test timeline

Former President Donald Trump’s positive Covid test in September 2020, three days before the first presidential debate, is raising new questions about whether Trump’s physician at the time, Dr. Sean ... Read more »

2021 homicides worst in almost 30 years

2021 is shaping up to be one of the worst years for deadly violence in Chicago history. Over 1,000 homicides have already been recorded in Cook County in 2021 and ... Read more »

Liverpool handed double injury boost ahead of Wolves clash, Klopp will be delighted - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast klopp After convincingly seeing off their struggling Merseyside rivals in the recent 4-1 victory over Everton at Goodison Park in midweek, Liverpool’s next Premier League ... Read more »

Cardiff finally given green light to fly home from South Africa today

© Morgan Treacy INPHO CARDIFF ARE SET to arrive back in the UK tonight after finally leaving South Africa. The travelling party of 42 was given the green light to ... Read more »

Tourists left stunned by ‘game-changing' hotel key card trick

TOURISTS have praised a “game-changing” clever hotel card key trick which lets you leave the room without cutting off the electricity. Most hotel rooms require a key card to be ... Read more »

Exclusive: Sheffield Wednesday ace attracting interest from West Brom, Middlesbrough, Blackburn Rovers, Stoke City and Hull City

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Sheffield Wednesday v Nottingham Forest Sheffield Wednesday talisman Josh Windass has been scouted by a number of Championship clubs heading into the ... Read more »

Magnus Carlsen v Ian Nepomniachtchi: World Chess Championship Game 6 – live!

© Photograph: Giuseppe Cacace/AFP/Getty Images Ian Nepomniachtchi, left, faces Magnus Carlsen during Game 5 of their world championship encounter. LIVE – Updated at 12:07 Rolling report: Magnus Carlsen meets Ian ... Read more »

This Morning's Alison Hammond apologises after breaking Christmas decoration on set

Alison Hammond issued a huge apology on This Morning on Friday, after breaking part of the set within seconds of entering the studio. The telly favourite got a bit too ... Read more »

Michigan school shooting – latest: Sheriff criticises school for not reporting Ethan Crumbley before attack

© AP michigan shooting LIVE – Updated at 11:54 Teachers at the high school in Oxford, Michigan, where 15-year-old Ethan Crumbley was accused of fatally shooting four students dead on ... Read more »

Top scientist's warning: get Covid vaccine to protect yourself from tragedy

© AFP via Getty Images BRITAIN-ECONOMY-HEALTH Millions of unjabbed people in Britain have been warned they cannot “dodge” Covid forever so should get vaccinated to protect themselves from the risk ... Read more »

England Euro 2020 final win would have had ‘horrific' consequences

© PA England fans outside Wembley Stadium. AN ENGLAND WIN in the Euro 2020 final could have led to 6,000 ticketless individuals storming Wembley with “horrific” consequences, an independent review ... Read more »

Jack and the Beanstalk review – Clive Rowe is a giant among panto dames

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Tristram Kenton/the Guardian In its 120th anniversary year, Hackney Empire is returning to its roots with a highly traditional pantomime. That’s mostly good news ... Read more »

New Man United boss Ralf Rangnick explains why he rejected Chelsea interim role

© Provided by Ralf Rangnick has revealed why he rejected Chelsea but accepted an interim manager’s job at Manchester United. The German has taken over at Old Trafford following ... Read more »

Struggling firms will get decision soon on financial support, Varadkar says

Tanaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment Leo Varadkar (Brian Lawless/PA) (PA Wire) A decision on financial support for the hospitality sector and other businesses will be made in ... Read more »

Euro 2020 final violence must be a ‘turning point' as Baroness Casey backs 2030 World Cup bid

© AFP via Getty Images wembleyway1107a The author of today’s damning report into the disorder at the Euro 2020 final wants the “day of national shame” to be “a turning ... Read more »

26 new candidates start Garda diversity internship programme

© Provided by Mr Harris went on to say that far-right organisations in Ireland have transitioned from using open source means of communication such as social media, and now ... Read more »

Tommy Fury's sparring partner offers prediction ahead of Jake Paul fight

Tommy Fury’s sparring partner believes the Brit will have too much skill for Jake Paul when the pair square off later this month. The Love Island star is favourite with ... Read more »

Jason Oppenheim says Chrishell Stause wanted to hide their romance from Selling Sunset cast

© Provided by The Independent Selling Sunset star Jason Oppenheim has said that Chrishell Stause initially wanted to keep their relationship a secret while they were filming the show. Speaking ... Read more »

Burglary discovered at Joplin nail salon

Dec. 3—Someone broke into a Joplin nail salon around midnight Tuesday and stole an iPad belonging to the business. The burglary at the Glow Nail Lounge, 2402 E. 32nd St., ... Read more »

Edinburgh crime: Police investigation launched after Edinburgh crash puts man in hospital

© Edinburgh crime: Police investigation launched after Edinburgh crash puts man in hospital Emergency services were called to the scene on the Ravelston Dykes and Murrayfield Road junction around 1.25 ... Read more »

Weather snow forecast UK – Prepare for a BRUTALLY cold weekend, Brits told as temperatures plunge more snow on its way

MORE winter weather is set to hit the UK this weekend with a barrage of snow and freezing temperatures expected. It will be most piercing in West London and Hereford ... Read more »

Police: Girl admitted 'making up' threats against McKeesport Area, West Mifflin schools

Dec. 3—McKeesport police say a girl is facing charges after allegedly admitting she made “violent threats” against a local middle school. Police said they were notified on Tuesday about an ... Read more »

Man's death under investigation in Galena

Dec. 3—GALENA, Kan. — The Kansas Bureau of Investigation is assisting local police in the investigation of the death of a man whose body was discovered Wednesday night inside his ... Read more »

UK snow forecast: Heavy showers turn to hail then white stuff to hit in just DAYS with hopes of White Christmas

HEAVY showers will turn to hail and then snow will fall in just DAYS as hopes of a White Christmas is on. Temperatures will drop to -3C in some areas ... Read more »

Urgent warning from heart surgeons as quarter of a million Brits at risk

OVER a quarter of a million Brits could face a new heart-related illness due to the stress of the Covid pandemic, experts have warned. Poor diet, lack of physical activity ... Read more »

Rihanna ‘shuts down pregnancy rumours in DM with a follower' after fans convinced she's having baby with A$AP Rocky

RIHANNA has 'shut down pregnancy rumours in a DM with a follower' after fans were convinced she's having baby with A$AP Rocky. The superstar, 33, set tongues wagging she could ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin honors wife, ignores cinematographer in Instagram post after TV interview

Alec Baldwin penned an emotional Instagram message following his ABC News interview with George Stephanopoulos on Thursday night. ABC via Getty Images Alec Baldwin took to Instagram after his tearful ... Read more »

Corona-Lage: Jens Spahn sieht genug Impfdosen zum Boostern bereitgestellt

In Deutschland sollen bis Jahresende 30 Millionen Impfungen erfolgen. Die Impfdosen sind bereits da, sagt der scheidende Gesundheitsminister. © Kay Nietfeld/​dpa Jens Spahn das letzte Mal als Bundesgesundheitsminister zur Corona-Lage ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic