Biden Cannot Declare Victory on Climate Without One of These Policies

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Ryan McGinnis / Getty

In the past few years, a historic shift has occurred in American public opinion: For the first time ever, and across a variety of polling outlets, a majority of Americans say that they want to see the government take serious action on climate change. This shift has accompanied an eruption of climate-related disasters. Wildfires now paralyze the West Coast. Heat waves  have killed elderly people in their homes. And record-breaking floods have destroyed farms, shut down cities, and drowned children in basements.

Since he entered the race for his current job, President Joe Biden has stressed the danger of climate change, naming it one of the “four historic crises” that the country faces now. He has promised to zero out carbon pollution from the electricity system by 2035, with 80 percent of U.S. electricity coming from zero-carbon sources by 2030.

These goals are the backbone of Biden’s climate agenda. He cannot meet his climate commitment without a realistic, trustworthy plan to hit these electricity goals. There are two different ways to achieve them: the Clean Electricity Program, which incentivizes utilities to increase the amount of zero-carbon power that they generate each year, or a carbon tax, which levies a fee on each ton of greenhouse-gas pollution released into the atmosphere.

If Congress can pass either of these policies, then Biden’s climate agenda will succeed, and the world will have a much better shot of avoiding the worst ravages of climate change by the middle of the century. If not, then Biden’s climate agenda will fall short.

The fate of these policies is being decided now. Last night, The New York Times reported that Senator Joe Manchin, a Democrat from West Virginia, opposes the Clean Electricity Program proposed in the reconciliation bill. But Manchin himself has not said so publicly, and House progressives, too, have some leverage left: If that bill does not address climate change to their satisfaction, then they can veto the bipartisan infrastructure bill.  

Today, remarkably, 60 percent of U.S. electricity is generated by fossil fuels. In order to meaningfully address climate change, that number must decline and rapidly reach zero. Building a zero-carbon electricity system isn’t some environmentalist fantasy; it is the first and most important step to actually managing climate change in the next two decades.

This is because of the basic restrictions of chemistry and technology. Right now, a huge portion of economic activity is powered by the controlled combustion of fossil fuels, which produce carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Humanity knows how to generate energy without causing carbon pollution—using wind turbines, solar panels, nuclear plants, and more—but only in the flexible yet specific form of electricity. Nearly every plan to limit climate change in the United States follows a two-step process: First, the country must scale up the power grid, generating nearly all of its electricity from zero-carbon sources. Second, it must bring almost every fossil-powered industrial process onto the electricity grid.

Between the Clean Electricity Program and a carbon tax, the Clean Electricity Program is Biden’s best option. It would directly incentivize utilities to clean up their grid by offering federal grants for those that boosted zero-carbon electricity production by 4 percent each year. Utilities that do not meet that standard can buy credits or pay a small penalty. The policy is designed to keep electricity rates low for consumers, has support from large utilities, and resembles clean-electricity programs that have been successfully implemented in 29 states. With this program in place, the U.S. electricity grid would generate 73 percent of its energy from zero-carbon sources within a decade, preventing at least 400 million tons of carbon pollution, according to the Rhodium Group, an energy-analysis firm. (Climate tax credits would bump zero-carbon energy’s share of the energy mix the rest of the way to Biden’s 80-percent goal.) Resources for the Future, a nonpartisan think tank, has found similar results.  

Biden’s other option is to support a carbon price. Such a policy has traditionally been a favorite of economists, and it would reduce carbon pollution. A carbon fee of $15 per ton, rising 5 percent each year and exempting gasoline (as any Biden plan reportedly would), promises to eliminate 45 percent of U.S. carbon pollution by 2030 compared with its all-time high, according to Resources for the Future. That makes it roughly comparable to the Clean Electricity Program, and it would make Biden’s goal of halving carbon pollution by 2030 feasible.

But there are good reasons to be skeptical of a carbon tax. A carbon tax is, by design, intended to raise fossil-fuel prices, which strikes me as politically unwise, amid a global spike in energy prices and an ongoing producers’ strike in the Texas oil patch. Taxing carbon also turns fossil fuels into an enduring source of government revenue, when the goal should instead be to eliminate them.

Yet for all these quibbles, a carbon tax would undoubtedly work. And the passage of either a carbon tax or the Clean Electricity Program would amount to a colossal political achievement, finally allowing the United States to sit among its peer countries that have passed significant climate policy.

Manchin is the greatest opponent of both these policies. He has reportedly told Biden that he cannot accept the Clean Electricity Program, even though he seemed to accept it in a secret agreement that he signed with Majority Leader Chuck Schumer this summer. Senate Democrats respect Manchin and understand his unusual political acumen—he has, after all, found a way to win elections as a Democrat in a state that Donald Trump won by 39 points last year. Although Manchin’s family owns a coal-brokerage company from which he might still draw an income, he may have broader goals as a politician. He seems determined to ensure that the roughly 31,000 fossil-fuel workers in his state can envision a future for themselves in a decarbonizing economy—much as climate activists are desperate to see a safe and prosperous future for themselves in the hot years ahead.

If the Times is wrong that Manchin has categorically rejected Clean Electricity Program, there is plenty about these policies that Manchin and Biden can and should negotiate about. They could slow the Clean Electricity Program’s pace of change (should utilities go zero-carbon at 3 percent a year, rather than 4?) or adjust the amount of carbon capture permitted  (should natural-gas plants that capture 80 percent of their pollution count?). They could exempt certain states from the program during its early years. The Clean Electricity Program would supercharge one of Manchin’s own provisions in the bill—a tax credit that would help companies build clean-energy technologies in America—by creating 15 to 30 percent more jobs than the policy would alone.

These details matter—they will decide how fast America’s significant share of global carbon pollution falls—but ultimately either the Clean Electricity Program or carbon tax would allow the U.S. to further drive down the cost of producing zero-carbon energy. That benefit would redound worldwide, shaping a far larger share of global climate pollution.

Is there a third option here? According to the Times, White House staff is now “trying to cobble together a mix of other policies that could also cut emissions,” and they could plausibly find some provisions that are acceptable to Manchin that would also encourage utilities to replace some of their fossil-fuel generation with renewables. But barring a miracle, the administration would be forced to fall back on using Environmental Protection Agency rules to reduce carbon pollution, a potentially costly and arduous process that would be vulnerable to challenges at the conservative Supreme Court or rollbacks from future presidents. And there is no guarantee that it would become settled law by the 2024 election.

These political concerns may seem quotidian, and they are—but how and whether any of these policies pass is a question of world-historical importance. Lawmakers, the press, and Americans of good character must understand that the U.S. has more at stake than the particular makeup of its electricity system. Over the past few years, some of the most famous institutions in the country—the biggest companies, universities, states, and cities—have pledged to act on climate change. Leading diplomats have flown around the world to proclaim the seriousness of America’s commitment.

But what have they concretely accomplished? For all its climate-destroying coal plants, China still installs more solar power than any other country, sells more electric vehicles than any other country, and operates a weak but expanding carbon market. Trans-Atlantic strategists worry that the European Union, which also maintains a carbon price, could eventually fuse its system to that of its largest trading partner, China. For the U.S. to fail to follow through after so much blabber would suggest, as China’s leaders reportedly believe, that our democracy is too sclerotic to meet the current crisis. That is a mortifying conclusion for the country, and a potentially dangerous one for the world order. If the U.S. cannot pass one of these policies, cannot bring itself to actually reduce carbon pollution, then it will strengthen the perception that American democracy is fundamentally sick, dying, unable to act on an issue on which its leaders’ credibility and its international stature rides. We will look like a decadent, soul-sick nation, too feeble to govern our basest instincts. And, well, aren’t we?

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

2022 Honda Civic Si First Drive: Straying From The Formula

© Motor1.com 2022 Honda Civic Si First Drive Despite offering less power, the latest Si remains a fun, affordable sedan with tons of charm. Since its introduction in 1984, the ... Read more »

ICICI Venture divests partial stake in Go Fashion

ICICI Venture, the alternative asset arm of ICICI Bank , on Tuesday said it has divested half of its 13.5 per cent stake in the recently concluded IPO of Go ... Read more »

UK universities hit by strike action over pay and pensions

Photograph: Adam Vaughan/REX/Shutterstock Latest round in bitter dispute will affect campuses across England, Scotland and Northern Ireland More than a million students will be hit by three days of strikes ... Read more »

Fort Worth shooting Monday night leaves one person injured, police say

A shooting in west Fort Worth left one person injured Monday night. The shooting occurred around 9:20 p.m. near the 2800 block of Broadmoor Drive, police said. They responded to ... Read more »

Pep Guardiola raises alarm over Man City squad 'emergency' ahead of December

Pep Guardiola says Manchester City have an emergency ahead of the toughest month of the calendar. The City manager is unlikely to be able to welcome back Phil Foden, Jack ... Read more »

Mandatory RT-PCR test for int'l travellers arriving in Karnataka amid growing concern over Omicron

Amid growing concerns over Omicron, the new variant of coronavirus, the Karnataka government on Tuesday said international travellers arriving in the state will have to mandatorily undergo RT-PCR test and ... Read more »

Body formally identified as missing teenager Bobbi-Anne McLeod

A body found close to a beach has been identified as missing teenager Bobbi-Anne McLeod, police said. The 18-year-old was last seen alive waiting at a bus stop on the ... Read more »

Not yet 'V-shaped' recovery, sectors of economy still 'crippled': P Chidambaram

With India’s GDP growth at 8.4 percent in the second quarter of 2021-22, senior Congress leader P Chidambaram on Tuesday said it was not yet a V-shaped recovery and there ... Read more »

Wall Street opens lower as Omicron fears grow after vaccine warning

U.S. stocks opened sharply lower on Tuesday after a warning from vaccine maker Moderna’s chief executive on the effectiveness of COVID-19 shots against the Omicron variant hammered travel, energy and ... Read more »

SAT quashes NSE's directive to Axis Bank in Karvy case

New Delhi, In a relief to Axis Bank, the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) has quashed a direction issued by NSE that funds lying in the bank account of Karvy Stock ... Read more »

Covaxin for 2-18 yrs: Centre examining Expert Committee recommendations, informs Health Ministry in Rajya Sabha

The Central government is examining the recommendation of the Subject Expert Committee (SEC) regarding the grant of market authorization of Covaxin for the age group of 2 to 18 years ... Read more »

Vicar Of Dibley writer reveals why he is ‘quite glad' he has Parkinson's

Scriptwriter Paul Mayhew-Archer has revealed he is “quite glad” he was diagnosed with Parkinson’s because using humour to deal with the experience sparked an unexpected career in stand-up comedy. After ... Read more »

More than 1,000 big cats, turtles and birds seized as part of worldwide trafficking investigation by Interpol

Codenamed Operation Thunder 2021, the month-long investigation involved police, financial intelligence units, and wildlife enforcement agencies in 118 countries - the largest number since the annual probe began in 2017. Read more »

Experts critique Prince William's ideas on Africa population

© Provided by Al Jazeera The British royal suggested that pressure on Africa’s wildlife and wild spaces was increasing because of ‘human population’ [File: John Stillwell/AFP/Pool] London, United Kingdom – ... Read more »

Final results show Cleric Sadr won Iraq vote, state media says

© Reuters/Ahmed Saad A poster of Iraqi Shi’ite cleric Moqtada al-Sadr in the Sadr City district of Baghdad CAIRO (Reuters) – Iraqi Populist Shi’ite cleric Moqtada al-Sadr’s movement secured the ... Read more »

UK energy watchdog promises tougher stress tests for suppliers

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Rosemary Roberts/Alamy The energy regulator has promised to put in place tougher stress tests for energy suppliers to prove they have the financial strength ... Read more »

Tristan Thompson has NBA fan booted over Khloe Kardashian comment

Tristan Thompson took a page out of pal LeBron James’ book when he had a heckling fan removed from the Kings-Grizzlies game on Sunday. During the fourth quarter at FedExForum, ... Read more »

Samsung ‘kills off Galaxy phone FOREVER' – is this the end for your model?

SAMSUNG has killed off one of its most beloved smartphone ranges, according to reports. Production of the South Korean tech titan's pricey Galaxy Note series has apparently ground to a ... Read more »

The Humans Star Richard Jenkins Reveals The One Director And Actor He Wants To Work With - Exclusive

Emma Mcintyre/Getty Images Ever since starting his film career in earnest in 1985 with the Western “Silverado,” actor Richard Jenkins — who currently stars in the indie drama “The Humans,” ... Read more »

Discount and specialty retailers like TJ Maxx and Sephora won Black Friday, leaving big box chains in the shade

© Provided by Business Insider TJ Maxx discount racks. Insider/Mary Hanbury Most stores saw foot traffic soar this Black Friday versus 2020 when customers shopped from home.  But only a few ... Read more »

Labour reshuffle: a focus on big beasts and savvy performers

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA “Reshuffle” seemed an understatement, given the radical scope of the shake-up Keir Starmer carried out among Labour’s top ranks on Monday, with ... Read more »

Royal insider reveals details of the Queen's daily drinking habits

© Provided by Extra.ie A royal insider has lifted the lid on the Queen’s daily drinking habits. The 95-year-old was recently went on a short public break from public duties ... Read more »

Call the Midwife's Helen George teases Christmas special's 'traumatic' storyline

It’s become a Christmas tradition to sit down on the sofa and tune into BBC One’s Call the Midwife every Christmas Day – and this year will be no exception. ... Read more »

Reader Q&A: What do you want to know about the Covid vaccine booster rollout?

© Shutterstock THE HSE’S COVID-19 vaccine booster rollout has been ongoing for several weeks – with boosters approved for all adults last week.  However, mRNA vaccine boosters are currently being ... Read more »

17-year-old Molloy named WNL Player of the Month after starring in the FAI Women's Cup final

© Laszlo Geczo INPHO Ellen Molloy during the FAI Women’s Cup final. WEXFORD YOUTHS TEENAGER Ellen Molloy has been named SSE Airtricity Women’s National League Player of the Month for ... Read more »

IPL Retention Live Updates: RCB to Release Yuzvendra Chahal; SRH Set to Retain 2 Uncapped Players

© Provided by News18 IPL Retention Live Updates: RCB to Release Yuzvendra Chahal; SRH Set to Retain 2 Uncapped Players IPL 2022 Retention DEADLINE Day: The Indian Premier League is ... Read more »

Kuujjuaq pilot Johnny May has flung candy out of his plane on Christmas for 55 years—until now

© Provided by Maclean’s Nunavummiut await the treats delivered to Kuujjuaq by May (Isabelle Dubois) Nunavummiut await the treats delivered to Kuujjuaq by May (Isabelle Dubois) In the far northeast ... Read more »

The last gasp of the anti-carbon taxers

© Provided by Maclean’s Ontario Premier Ford once got a lot of mileage out of attacking the carbon tax but now seems to be easing off the gas (Nathan Denette/CP) ... Read more »

Is Your Freezer Set to the Right Temperature?

To make sure that food stays safe and fresh, you’ll want to keep it properly chilled. What’s the right freezer temperature for optimal performance? Read on. © Photo: Shutterstock The ... Read more »

Insulate Britain protesters stage 24-hour fast outside Downing Street

Insulate Britain supporters are staging a 24-hour fast outside Downing Street in solidarity with jailed members who are on hunger strike to call for action on fuel poverty. © James ... Read more »

Mitverantwortlich für den Höhenflug: Dieses Trio verlängert bei den Lakers

© Bereitgestellt von Blick 09.10.2021; Zug; Eishockey National League – EV Zug – SC Rapperswil-Jona Lakers; Dominic Lammer (M, Rapperswil) wird nach seinem Tor zum 1:2 von den Spieler auf ... Read more »

«Absage würde für Verunsicherung sorgen» – St. Moritz kämpft um Weltcup

Die neue Mutation des Coronavirus sorgt auch bei den Veranstaltern der alpinen Ski-Rennen für Alarmstimmung. Wegen der Omikron-Variante drohen nun die Super-Gs der Frauen in St. Moritz auszufallen. Yanick Eschler ... Read more »

Unions-Länder fordern deutliche schärfe Maßnahmen für ganz Deutschland

© WELT Angela Merkel, der designierte Kanzler Olaf Scholz und die Ministerpräsidenten der Länder beraten über das weitere Corona-Vorgehen. Ob sie sich auf einen gemeinsamen Plan einigen können und welche ... Read more »

Urs Kryenbühl und Ralph Weber profitieren von den Wetterkapriolen in Lake Louise: Die ungeimpften Schweizer Ski-Cracks als heimliche Gewinner

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Die ungeimpften Schweizer Ski-Cracks als heimliche Gewinner Der letzte Sonntag hat Urs Kryenbühl grosse Sorgen bereitet. Grund: Der Schwyzer liegt in der Weltcup-Startliste im Super-G an ... Read more »

Neuinfektionen in Deutschland: Inzidenz in Deutschland erstmals seit Wochen leicht gesunken

Die bundesweite Sieben-Tage-Inzidenz bei den Corona-Neuinfektionen ist erstmals seit Wochen leicht gesunken. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Versorgung von Covid-19.Patienten im bayerischen Freising Nach Angaben des Robert Koch-Instituts (RKI) vom Dienstagmorgen ... Read more »

Stay away from the woods, forestry bosses urge after Storm Arwen damage

Visitors have been told to stay away from forests across much of northern England after Storm Arwen blew over tens of thousands of trees. Forestry England will conduct an aerial ... Read more »

The Tempest review – Michael Pennington's mighty magician lends spark

This production brings its enchantments but one enthralling moment on its first night comes after Michael Pennington’s Prospero takes his bows, with a tribute to Stephen Sondheim from the theatre’s ... Read more »

Duke of York avoiding 'confronting his own misconduct' by blaming his victim, accuser's lawyers claim

Prince Andrew – Steve Parsons/AP The Duke of York is trying to avoid “confronting his own misconduct” by blaming and shaming his victim, his accuser’s lawyers have claimed. New court ... Read more »

Caller asking sex offenders for cash to avoid penalty. It's a scam, NC sheriff warns.

A new scam is targeting people who appear on the sex-offender registry in North Carolina, Orange County officials say. An Orange County Sheriff’s Office investigator received two calls about the ... Read more »

Erie police search for suspect in robbery of Family Dollar store Monday morning

Erie police said a man who indicated that he had a weapon robbed a westside store of cash late Monday morning. The armed robbery was reported on Monday at about ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic