'Bias' review for Israel-Palestinian Facebook posts

© Getty Images Some felt that posts about the Gaza conflict earlier this year were not treated equally

Facebook’s Oversight board has recommended an independent review into alleged bias in moderating posts related to Israel and Palestinians.

It comes after the board said the tech giant failed to answer all its questions around alleged censorship of Palestinian activists.

The case centred around a user who shared an Arabic-language post from a news outlet about a militant group.

In response, Facebook said it would look at the recommendations.

It added it “welcomed” the Oversight board’s decision.

“After conducting a review of the recommendations provided by the board in addition to their decision, we will update this post,” it added.

In May 2021, a Facebook user in Egypt shared an Arabic-language post from what the board said was a “news page” of the Al Jazeera media network, about escalating violence in Israel and the occupied territories of Gaza and the West Bank.

The post also contained a photo showing two people in camouflage gear with their faces covered, wearing headbands with the insignia of the Izzedine al-Qassam Brigades, the armed wing of the Hamas militant group which controls Gaza.

The board said translated into English, it read: “The resistance leadership in the common room gives the occupation a respite until 1800 to withdraw its soldiers from the Al-Aqsa mosque and Sheikh Jarrah neighbourhood otherwise he who warns is excused. Abu Ubaida – Al-Qassam Brigades military spokesman.”

The user added a single-word caption reading “ooh” in Arabic.

The al-Qassam Brigades has been designated as dangerous under Facebook’s Dangerous Organisations and Individuals community standard.

Facebook initially removed the post but later restored it after the user appealed directly to the Oversight board.

It was unable to explain why two human reviewers had originally judged the content to violate its policy, noting that moderators are not required to record their reasons for content takedown decisions.

The board agreed with its decision to restore the post which it said was the “re-publication of a news item from a legitimate news outlet on a matter of urgent public concern”.

Israeli requests

As part of its investigation, the Oversight board asked Facebook if it had received official or unofficial requests from the Israeli government to remove content related to Israel-Palestinian violence in April and May, which escalated into a conflict between Israel and Gaza.

While Facebook said it had not received any official requests, it did not answer whether it had had any unofficial ones.

Public comments submitted about the case included allegations that Facebook disproportionately removed or demoted content from Palestinian users and content in Arabic during the conflict. There were also criticisms that it was not doing enough to remove content that incited violence against Israeli civilians.

A Palestinian digital rights group found at the time of the conflict that nearly 500 posts related to the Gaza conflict were removed between 6 and 19 May.

Facebook’s vice-president for global affairs Nick Clegg later apologised to Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh for wrongly labelling some posts as incitement to violence.

As a result of its investigation, the Oversight board is recommending Facebook do several things, including:

  • set up an independent entity not associated with either side of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to conduct a thorough examination to determine whether Facebook’s content moderation in Arabic and Hebrew, including its use of automation, have been applied without bias
  • make the report and conclusion on this public
  • develop a process outlining how it receives and responds to all government requests for content removal, and ensure that they are included in transparency reporting
  • the reporting should distinguish government requests that led to removals for violations of the Community Standards from requests that led to removal for violating local law, in addition to requests that led to no action.
News Related


Thousands of migrants camp under US-Mexico bridge

Thousands of migrants have set up a makeshift camp on the United States side of the southern border, under a bridge that connects Texas with Mexico. Late on Thursday, the ... Read more »

How to watch The Morning Show season 2 online from anywhere

© Provided by GamesRadar Jennifer Anniston and Reese Witherspoon in The Morning Show season 2 Apple TV Plus’ flagship show arrives for its second season, with a star-studded cast returning ... Read more »

Infineon opens Austrian power-chip plant ahead of schedule

© Reuters/Lisi Niesner FILE PHOTO: The logo of semiconductor manufacturer Infineon is seen at its Austrian headquarters in Villach VILLACH, Austria (Reuters) – Infineon Technologies opened a 1.6 billion euro ... Read more »

Suu Kyi didakwa junta atas salah laku rasuah

© Provided by Berita Harian Aung San Suu Kyi. – Foto AFP YANGON: Junta Myanmar bakal mendakwa pemimpin yang digulingkan, Aung San Suu Kyi atas tuduhan salah laku rasuah. Perkara ... Read more »

China's Shenzhou 12 Astronauts Land After 92 Days in Space

A capsule carrying the crew members of China’s Shenzhou 12 back to earth landed successfully in Inner Mongolia, China, on Friday, September 17. China Aerospace Science and Technology posted this ... Read more »

Coronation Street star's son rushed to intensive care

Coronation Street star Ryan Thomas and his partner Lucy Mecklenburgh have revealed that their young son Roman has spent time in intensive care over the past week. The news was ... Read more »

Pusat transit gelandangan sakit mental akan diwujudkan di KL

© Provided by Sinar Harian JELEBU – Kementerian Wilayah Persekutuan akan mewujudkan pusat transit khusus untuk gelandangan yang mempunyai masalah kesihatan mental di Kuala Lumpur. Timbalan Menterinya, Datuk Seri Jalaluddin ... Read more »

5 Best Places To Buy Fresh Seafood In Singapore

© Provided by The Asian Parent For seafood lovers, there is nothing better than fresh fish. Now that we have to spend time indoors, it is even better to enjoy ... Read more »

Ganda subsidi upah bagi pekerja sektor pelancongan, kata Guan Eng

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Industri pelancongan terlalu penting untuk diabaikan atau ditinggalkan tanpa sebarang bantuan kewangan bersepadu, kata Setiausaha Agung DAP Lim Guan Eng. GEORGE TOWN: Kerajaan perlu ... Read more »

Drink driver jailed after ploughing Range Rover into side of speeding train

© SWNS off-the-rails-t-731783.jpg A drunk driver who smashed his car into a speeding train near Doncaster has been jailed for 10 months. Michael Rochford, 27, admitted perverting the course of ... Read more »

Warga emas ditemukan meninggal dunia di tepi basikal

© Provided by Harian Metro Lokasi warga emas ditemui meninggal dunia di hadapan rumah kedai di Jalan Padang Temusu, Sungai Petani, hari ini. Foto Ihsan Pembaca am@hmetro.com.my Sungai Petani: Lelaki ... Read more »

Bung heads special panel on natural disasters

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Three people were killed in a landslide in Penampang after hours of non-stop rain on Wednesday. (Fire dept pic) KOTA KINABALU: Sabah deputy chief ... Read more »

Andrew Neil stepped down from GB News over 'differences with board'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Andrew Neil has broken his silence after stepping down from GB News and has revealed he had differences with the board and managers ... Read more »

Sultan Johor bidas KDN, kecewa syarat ketat MM2H

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar berkata, syarat ketat akan membawa implikasi negatif kerana MM2H sebelum ini membawa kesan positif kepada ekonomi negara, rakyat dan kerajaan. ... Read more »

Appointment of PM's brother as NAFAS head is above board, says Nazri

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Nazri Aziz said it was the NAFAS board that decided on the appointment of Zamri Yaakob and had nothing to do with the prime ... Read more »

#Showbiz: 'Some parents fear schools reopening, yet flock to tourist spots' - Michael Ang

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: Outspoken television drama director Michael Ang has slammed certain parents who worry about schools reopening, yet take their children to popular tourist ... Read more »

EWS quota is a bad law, it needs to go

© Provided by The Print The Economically Weaker Section or EWS quota will come in for judicial scrutiny soon. But it’s not only a matter for the judiciary, India’s Parliament should revisit the law too. ... Read more »

Single Sifar bersaing di Kanada

© Provided by Berita Harian Single Sifar adalah hasil kolaborasi komposer Asfan (gambar), Tripdisk dan Kmy Kmo. Foto IG Asfan Shah bhhip@bh.com.my KUALA LUMPUR: Lagu Sifar yang menjadi runut bunyi ... Read more »

NSFC fokus aksi terakhir

© Provided by Harian Metro ZAQUAN (kiri) tonggak Negeri Sembilan FC. firdaushashim@hmetro.com.my Kuala Lumpur: Pasukan-pasukan dari Liga Perdana enggan memikirkan tentang cabaran serta peluang untuk berentap di Piala Malaysia kerana ... Read more »

Ada 17,577 jangkitan baharu

© Provided by Berita Harian Pesakit COVID-19 berkurangan di Hospital Kuala Lumpur. – Foto NSTP/Aswadi Alias luqman.arif@bh.com.my KUALA LUMPUR: Kadar jangkitan COVID-19 merekodkan pengurangan, iaitu 17,577 kes positif baharu setakat ... Read more »

Aina Abdul gabung tiga lagu dalam single terbaharu

© Provided by Harian Metro AINA Abdul. najiy.jefri@hmetro.com.my Kuala Lumpur: Penyanyi Aina Abdul tampil dengan single baharu berjudul AINA ABDUL yang menggabungkan tiga lagu popular ciptaannya iaitu Sumpah, Semalam dan ... Read more »

Entrepreneurship to be made harder in britain as Rishi Sunak may target Capital Gains Tax

Rishi Sunak recently revealed the next Budget will take place on October 27 and given the state’s recent tax changes, Britons may be worried about what’s on the horizon. Despite ... Read more »

Polis tahan 3 lelaki, rampas 654 bungkus air ketum

© Provided by Sinar Harian BUTTERWORTH – Kegiatan tiga lelaki menjual air ketum membawa padah apabila mereka ditahan polis bersama 654 bungkusan air ketum dalam serbuan di kawasan Kampung Manggis, ... Read more »

5 Shampoo tricks you'll wish you knew sooner for dramatically GLOSSY and silky smooth hair

Have you been practising everything possible, from oiling to masking your hair and still can’t see results? We have some new expert-approved tips that might be the saving grace you ... Read more »

Malaika Arora's age defying look in a DARING violet outfit from Aje redefines luxe party sheen; Yay or Nay?

The 47-year-old actress, Malaika Arora is a no-brainer to fashion. Her impeccable styles have always made our jaws drop and hearts race. While bright and dope colours and edgy makeup ... Read more »

Warga Indonesia ditahan miliki 17 laras senjata tiruan

© Provided by Harian Metro PELBAGAI jenis senjata api yang dirampas daripada suspek. FOTO MELVIN JONI am@hmetro.com.my Mukah: Sebanyak 17 laras senjata tiruan pelbagai jenis yang diseludup masuk dari Indonesia ... Read more »

Sultan Johor akan bangkitkan isu MM2H kepada PM

© Provided by Sinar Harian JOHOR BAHRU – Sultan Johor, Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar menzahirkan rasa kecewa terhadap Kementerian Dalam Negeri (KDN) kerana enggan menyemak semula syarat ketat Program Malaysia ... Read more »

Best gaming laptops in Australia: the top gaming laptops we've reviewed in 2021

© Provided by TechRadar best gaming laptops image with an Asus gaming laptop displayed There are plenty of reasons for Aussies to seek out a gaming laptop – whether you’re ... Read more »

I tried the Smeg BCC02 coffee machine and it is small and so simple but mighty

If you’ve been wanting to make the step up from a pod coffee machine to a bean to cup but have been put off by their complexity and bulk, Smeg ... Read more »

Schools and Colleges Shut For Two Days in Uttar Pradesh Due to Heavy Rain

© Provided by News18 Schools and Colleges Shut For Two Days in Uttar Pradesh Due to Heavy Rain All schools, colleges and Universities in Uttar Pradesh will remain shut for ... Read more »

'Rakhi Sawant of Punjab': On Sidhu's Video Message, AAP's Raghav Chadha Makes Controversial Counter

© Provided by News18 ‘Rakhi Sawant of Punjab’: On Sidhu’s Video Message, AAP’s Raghav Chadha Makes Controversial Counter Aam Aadmi Party MLA, Raghav Chadha hit out at Punjab Pradesh Congress ... Read more »

OnePlus 9RT may come with 65W fast charging, 3C listing tips

Rumours are rife for the OnePlus 9RT, expected to mark its debut next month in select countries, likely including India. Though these rumours provide us with a hint of what ... Read more »

Maggi Milkshake Is The Newest Food Combo That's Making The Internet Weep

© Provided by iDiva Hot and steaming plates of Maggi have truly helped a lot of us get through this pandemic, if not life. Sitting at home has made chefs ... Read more »

One of Disney Plus' biggest problems is finally fixed

The Disney Plus app is now available on Panasonic TVs, finally amending one of the biggest issues with the massive streaming service in the UK – namely, that anyone with ... Read more »

I-T search at Sonu Sood continues for 3rd day; Sena says, 'Once BJP's favourite'

© Provided by Hindustan Times Shiv Sena said BJP leaders used to attend Sonu Sood’s events earlier.  (HT PHOTO) The income tax department search at the properties of Bollywood actor ... Read more »

Fashion began 1.2 lakh years ago, scientists find evidence in Morocco

Excavation When we hear the word fashion, the first thought that pops into our minds is Paris, the capital of innovation in clothes, style and branding. But that’s the modern ... Read more »

Samsung's Foldable Phone Exclusivity Unlock With WhatsApp, Google And Microsoft

© Provided by News18 Samsung’s Foldable Phone Exclusivity Unlock With WhatsApp, Google And Microsoft Samsung has such a big first mover advantage that the company is able to command the ... Read more »

Sky Sports pundit issues score prediction for Cardiff City v Bournemouth

© Provided by Football League World Cardiff City Stadium pre extension Cardiff City currently sit two points off the Championship play-offs in ninth place and will be hoping to strengthen ... Read more »

Airtel to conserve Rs 40,000 crore cash through moratorium

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: A day after the government announced a mega bailout package for the telecom industry, Bharti Airtel chief Sunil Mittal said the ... Read more »

El Salvador Court to investigate Bitcoin roll out

© Provided by City AM El Salvador’s Court of Accounts will investigate government Bitcoin purchases and crypto ATMs after receiving a complaint from a human rights watchdog. Earlier this month ... Read more »