Being paid in cash causes problems for two taxpayers who claimed COVID-19 benefits

being paid in cash causes problems for two taxpayers who claimed covid-19 benefits

If you’re getting paid in cash, make sure you have a record of it.

It’s perhaps no secret that nearly all casual babysitting services are paid in cash. After all, it’s fast, easy and convenient. But the main reason a sitter may request cash for their services is that there’s no record of them having received the income, making the amounts nearly impossible to trace should the Canada Revenue Agency question the sitter’s reported income under our self-assessment, “honour” tax system.

But the lack of appropriate records can prove problematic for some taxpayers. For example, a parent who incurs babysitting costs to enable them to earn income from employment, carry on a business or attend school may be able to claim those costs as tax-deductible child care . It would be wise for them to hang on to proof of payment should the CRA question the deductibility of those expenses.

The receipt of cash, even if reported on a return, can also be problematic for the sitter. Two recent cases dealt with babysitter claims for COVID-19-related benefits , each of which hinged on whether they could prove they earned at least $5,000 in income to qualify. Let’s take a brief look at each case.

The Alberta grandmother

The first case involved an Alberta taxpayer who immigrated to Canada from Bangladesh following the death of her husband in 2001. She lives with her son and his family, and provided babysitting services for her son’s children, for which she was paid in cash. In 2020, she applied for benefits under the Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB) program, and collected benefits for two periods in the fall of 2020.

Subsequently, the CRA conducted a validation review for CRB eligibility and asked the taxpayer to submit documents to support her claim that she met the criteria of having a minimum earned income of $5,000 in 2019, 2020 or in the 12 months preceding the date of her benefit application.

The taxpayer submitted a letter dated Nov. 27, 2020, enclosing babysitting receipts for 2019 and 2020, as well as a partnership income statement for the 2019 tax year relative to a business in Bangladesh. The CRA, after reviewing the documents, concluded she didn’t meet the criteria. The taxpayer asked for a second review, which was conducted in February 2021, but the CRA reached the same conclusion.

The taxpayer then appealed to Federal Court, asking it to determine whether the CRA’s decision to deny her the CRB was “reasonable.” As with prior decisions, the court must decide whether the decision under review “bears the hallmarks of reasonableness — justification, transparency and intelligibility — and whether it is justified in relation to the relevant factual and legal constraints that bear on that decision.”

The taxpayer claimed she was paid $3,500 in babysitting income in 2019, and $1,600 in 2020, which, when combined with her Bangladesh income, would exceed the $5,000 required threshold. But all payments were made in cash, and the evidence that was submitted — a combination of invoices and bank statements — “did not add up,” according to the CRA.

The CRA concluded there was insufficient documentary evidence to support the taxpayer’s claim of babysitting income. As a result, the judge found “no reviewable error” in the CRA’s decision, and thus no basis for judicial intervention.

The Quebec babysitter

The second case, which was decided last week, involved a babysitter who claimed the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) for the seven four-week periods from March 15, 2020, to Sept. 26, 2020, receiving a total of $14,000 in government benefits.

In October 2020, the taxpayer’s file was selected for a first review of CERB eligibility. In order to be eligible, a taxpayer had to meet two criteria: income of at least $5,000 from (self)employment in 2019 or in the 12 months preceding the first CERB application, and have stopped working due to COVID-19.

The taxpayer stated he worked in 2019 as a babysitter in a private home. That year, his employer lost his job and the sitter found himself unemployed. He looked for new work, but was unsuccessful.

The reviewing CRA officer requested proof of income for the amount of self-employment income claimed, noting that the taxpayer had “no documentation supporting the invoices submitted, and no bank statement, since he was paid in cash and did not deposit the amounts paid” in a bank account.

The CRA also had trouble with the second criterion. Although the taxpayer was working in 2019, he was terminated in 2019 after his employer lost his job. Since “there was no talk of COVID-19 in 2019,” the taxpayer cannot have lost his job due to COVID-19. The CRA agent, therefore, concluded the taxpayer was ineligible for the CERB based on the information submitted.

The taxpayer requested a second-level review, which was conducted by a different CRA officer in December 2020. That officer also concluded he was ineligible for the CERB.

In November 2021, the taxpayer asked the Federal Court to determine whether the CRA’s decision to deny him the CERB was reasonable. The judge, after reviewing all the evidence, concluded that “the reasons given by the (CRA) agent for rejecting the CERB application are intelligible and justified in light of the evidence and the CERB legislative regime.”

As the judge cautioned, “A taxpayer who wishes payment in cash must be all the more concerned to be able to prove the payment in order to obtain a benefit under the act. It was up to the officer to assess the sufficiency of the evidence and, in this case, she was not satisfied with the evidence filed by the (taxpayer).”

Jamie Golombek, CPA, CA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Estate Planning with CIBC Private Wealth in Toronto.


 If you like this story, sign up for the FP Investor Newsletter.


News Related


Right-Wing Figures Suddenly Drop Abortion Militancy After Walker Revelation

Herschel Walker Campaigns For Senator Of Georgia With Nikki Haley Abortion is murder…until there’s a Senate seat on the line, apparently. Earlier this week, the Daily Beast published a report ... Read more »

Ohio elections chief announces new public integrity unit

COLUMBUS, Ohio —  Ohio’s Republican elections chief on Wednesday announced a new public integrity unit in response to what he called Americans’ “crisis of confidence” in the electoral process, even while ... Read more »

Immersive King Tut Experience to Bring Ancient Egypt to Chicago

The exhibit will debut Oct. 14 at Lighthouse ArtSpace Chicago in the city's Old Town Read more »

I’m at the hot tub. I’m at the art installation. I’m at the combination hot tub-art installation

Shortly before the pandemic, I had a prophetic studio visit with a sculptor who was holding a sale out of his workspace. I left with a fog machine, a strobe ... Read more »

Mexico pledges to bring 2nd lawsuit against gun dealers

Mexico pledges to bring 2nd lawsuit against gun dealers The Mexican government plans to bring another lawsuit against U.S. companies it claims are responsible for the flow of illegal weapons ... Read more »

You can fly from San Jose to Tokyo for under $475 roundtrip

If a trip to Japan has been on your must-travel list, well, it’s finally time: After two years of isolation and closing off from tourists due to the pandemic, Japan ... Read more »

Zara McDermott looks typically chic in a turtle neck bodycon dress as she cosies up to boyfriend Sam Thompson at fashion range launch party

Latest news and updates on all of your favourite Love Island contestants Read more »

Chelsea FC vs AC Milan: Champions League kick off time, team news, prediction, TV, live stream, h2h - preview

GrahamPotter0510 Chelsea and AC Milan will meet at Stamford Bridge tonight in a Champions League glamour tie. Ahead of the first of two games between Group E’s biggest teams, the ... Read more »

It's Time to Take a Hard Look at Pat Narduzzi

Are the Pitt Panthers in the best possible hands? The Pitt Panthers entered the 2022 college football season in the best shape it’s been in for a lengthy period of ... Read more »

Pep Guardiola denies rumours of Real Madrid release clause for Erling Haaland

Guardiola said there was no truth to the reports. Read more »

Graham Potter lauds ‘top’ Serie A forward as Chelsea chiefs get to work on finalising big-money deal

Graham Potter managing in the Premier League, August 2022 Graham Potter has increased the speculation surrounding Rafael Leao and Chelsea by calling the forward ‘ a top player’. Leao will ... Read more »

Long Island nonprofit targeted in robbery overwhelmed with donations, sends supplies to hurricane-ravaged Florida

EAST PATCHOGUE, N.Y. — A local nonprofit that helps low-income families was targeted in a robbery last week, and since CBS2’s story aired, a Long Island community has rallied around ... Read more »

Are Elizabeth Line, Overground and Thameslink trains running today? How the rail strikes affect TfL services

Elizabeth Line services are not expected to be affected by the strike (Photo: Tfl/PA) Rail workers are striking again on Wednesday, after large parts of the country were cut off ... Read more »

Appeals Court Sends DACA Case Back to Lower Court, Temporarily Protecting Dreamers

The ruling allows the program to go forward, but only for current DACA recipients known as Dreamers, not new applicants Read more »

Fabio Capello says Chelsea star 'shows no personality' after AC Milan win

Fabio Capello says Kalidou Koulibaly is yet to reach his best form for Chelsea (Getty) Fabio Capello has accused Kalidou Koulibaly of playing with ‘no personality’ following his move to ... Read more »

Ohio State coach reportedly not interested in Notre Dame job

Brian Hartline We’re not halfway through the college football season, and the college coaching rumor carousel is already in motion. On some level, it would make sense for Ohio State ... Read more »

'I don't know right now': Kyle Walker's World Cup is in DOUBT as Pep Guardiola confirms the defender's injury and refuses to provide a timescale for his return... leaving Gareth Southgate with a major defensive HEADACHE for England

Pep Guardiola confirmed Kyle Walker has picked up an abdominal injuryWalker limped off against Man United and missed City's clash with Copenhagen Guardiola failed to put a timescale on his return, putting his World Cup in doubt His City and England teammates John Stones and Kalvin Phillips are also injured  Read more »

'Just ridiculous' - Man City fans go wild as Erling Haaland scores yet again in Champions League

Erling Haaland celebrates for Man City Manchester City fans could not hide their excitement as Erling Haaland scored yet again for the Blues during their Champions League match against FC ... Read more »

13 Oldest Pubs In The US Worth A Visit

People holding up beer You can call it a pub, tavern, bar, whatever, but no matter what you call the place locals to gather to eat, drink, and be merry, ... Read more »

NHS makes ‘urgent’ call for black blood donors

More donors are needed to treat patients with sickle cell disease. Read more »

'Joe Hart showcasing why Pep sold him': Celtic fans turn on former Man City and England keeper after his HOWLER gifted RB Leipzig the lead in Champions League clash, with fans calling his pass to Dominik Szoboszlai 'embarrassing and inexcusable'

Celtic goalkeeper Joe Hart has come under fire for an error against RB LeipzigThe former England man passed to a Leipzig player and gifted them a goal Celtic went on to lose 3-1, leaving their UCL campaign in the balanceFans lamented Hart's fatal error as 'embarrassing and inexcusable'  Read more »

Gov. DeSantis seeks to shield congressional redistricting documents

La demanda ha servido como base para la petición de algunos funcionarios demócratas de realizar una investigación federal. TALLAHASSEE (NSF) — After pushing a congressional redistricting plan through the Legislature ... Read more »

Officials Blast Decision Allowing Dredge Spoil Dumping In LI Sound

New York State Assemblywoman Jodi Giglio cried out against a decision by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to allow dredge spoil dumping in the Long Island Sound. NORTH FORK, NY ... Read more »

'I don't understand what Klopp says!' - Darwin Nunez speaks out on Liverpool struggles

The Uruguayan has not scored since the opening match of the season (Picture: Getty) Darwin Nunez admits he is struggling to find his confidence in front of goal after blanking ... Read more »

Golden Retriever's 'Crawl of Shame' Leaves Internet in Hysterics

A stock image of dog sitting on a couch surrounded by ripped up toilet tissue. A post about a golden retriever dog doing a “crawl of shame” has gone viral ... Read more »

Ohio pastor facing multiple Jan. 6 charges

Ohio pastor facing multiple Jan. 6 charges Federal authorities on Wednesday arrested an Ohio pastor and charged him with felony and misdemeanor charges after he allegedly entered the Capitol during ... Read more »

Joel Klatt Names His Big Ten Championship Sleeper Team

BEVERLY HILLS, CA – AUGUST 07: Reggie Bush, Joel Klatt and Kevin Burkhardt of Fox Sports speak during the Fox segment of the 2019 Summer TCA Press Tour at The ... Read more »

5 Flagrant Murders That Killers Got Away With

5 Flagrant Murders That Killers Got Away With Sometimes, we’re all but certain a murder suspect did it, and they’re found not guilty anyway. They had motive, means, and opportunity. ... Read more »

How the ‘Rust’ settlement could affect any criminal case. What to know

News that the husband of Halyna Hutchins has reached a settlement with actor Alec Baldwin and other producers over her shooting on the set of “Rust” stunned many in Hollywood ... Read more »

Nurses start voting on strikes over pay

The Royal College of Nursing is launching its first UK-wide ballot on industrial action. Read more »

Why The Onion filed a Supreme Court brief

In this drawing by court artist Dana Verkouteren, the Supreme Court hears arguments on the opening day of its new term, in Washington, Monday, Oct. 3, 2022. This is not ... Read more »

Julia Bradbury shares fears that having kids later in life increased her risk of breast cancer and reveals how she has 'reset' her lifestyle since diagnosis

Julia Bradbury has spoken about her fears that having children later in life increased her risk of breast cancer. The TV presenter, 52, announced her cancer diagnosis in September 2021 ... Read more »

The Tesla-Killer Poised to Soar in 2023!

It may be hard to believe. But back in May 2019, a ton of Wall Street analysts were calling Tesla (TSLA) stock dead money. But while Morgan Stanley (MS) and ... Read more »

138-year-old lighthouse survives Hurricane Ian, but not unscathed

The historic Sanibel Island Lighthouse has weathered many a hurricane, but the fortitude of the skeleton lighthouse was put to the test once more when Hurricane Ian roared ashore. The ... Read more »

Mum who survived sepsis battle has all four limbs amputated

A mum is lucky to be alive after having all four limbs amputated has been labelled a ‘medical miracle’. At the end of last year, 35-year-old Sadie Kemp went into ... Read more »

When Do We Turn Our Clocks Back for Daylight Saving Time?

It doesn’t matter if you live in a northern, central, or southern state—the end of summer is a sad time indeed. And then it happens just a few weeks after ... Read more »

Arlington Police Pilot Program Aims to Curb Gun Violence

Arlington PD Arlington police have launched a pilot team aiming to curb gun violence and solve crimes across North Texas. NIBIN Engagement Team (“NET”) consists of a nine-person group and ... Read more »

NFL World Worried About Kenny Pickett On Sunday

PITTSBURGH, PA – AUGUST 13: Kenny Pickett #8 of the Pittsburgh Steelers takes the field for warm ups before a preseason game against the Seattle Seahawks at Acrisure Stadium on ... Read more »

Kyle Walker World Cup worry as Pep Guardiola confirms he will be out ‘a while’

Walker is a regular in Gareth Southgate’s England squads. Read more »

The Challenge star Suzan Mutesi suffers a major wardrobe malfunction at the VIP opening of Bar Lulu

Suzan Mutesi ensured that all eyes were on her on Wednesday night. The actress showed off a lot more than she expected while attending the VIP opening of Bar Lulu in ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network