Beijing Keeps Trying to Rewrite History

Beijing Keeps Trying to Rewrite History
© Miguel Candela / Anadolu Agency / Getty The Pillar of Shame statue at the University of Hong Kong.

Under the relentless crush of Beijing, the courtrooms of Hong Kong have become some of the few venues safe for protest in the city. Defendants accused or convicted of political crimes have turned otherwise banal hearings and bail applications into opportunities to voice dissent and challenge the arduous legal process.

In mid-November Lee Cheuk-yan, a veteran prodemocracy figure, used his mitigation hearing, where defendants can address the court in hopes of obtaining a lesser sentence, to deliver a stirring and defiant speech. He recounted his memories of the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre, exalted Hong Kongers for never forgetting the tragedy, and excoriated city officials for curtailing basic freedoms. Lee, who for decades helped organize the annual vigil held in Hong Kong’s Victoria Park to mourn the crackdown, choked up as he addressed the courtroom.

“I want to thank the people of Hong Kong who kept the promise of 1989,” he said. “In the face of suppression, they persisted, honoring the memory of the June Fourth Massacre in Victoria Park with their candlelight. Your Honor, the people of Hong Kong who took part needed no person or organization to incite them. If there was a provocateur, it is the regime that fired at its own people.

“For 31 years,” he continued, “our unyielding memory and unrelenting conscience drove us to keep the promise, persist in honoring their memory, demand truth and accountability, and carry on the pursuit of freedom and democracy of the Chinese people.”

[Read: Standing up to Beijing, 30 years apart]

Yet the unyielding memory of which Lee spoke has come under sustained attack this year, part of a broader effort by Beijing, its loyalists in the city, and an ever-growing list of collaborators to erase Tiananmen from public memory. Weaponizing pandemic protocols and vague threats of possible national-security violations, authorities have canceled the once-annual vigil for the past two years. Prominent activists, Lee included, who took part in prior gatherings have been arrested. A museum dedicated to Tiananmen was abruptly closed. Its contents were hauled away by police as evidence against members of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China, which organized the vigil and ran the museum. The group disbanded as a result. Unsatisfied with residents being only physically barred from viewing its displays, Hong Kong officials blocked access to the museum’s website as well. An investigation by Hong Kong Free Press found that dozens of books on the topic of Tiananmen have disappeared from the city’s libraries.  

One monument that has escaped erasure, just barely and perhaps only briefly, is also the city’s most prominent dedicated to Tiananmen, the Pillar of Shame statue. An orange cenotaph of pained, contorted bodies constructed as a memorial to protesters killed in the massacre, it was put on permanent public display to serve, as its creator, Jen Galschiøt, wrote in 1997, as a test of the authorities’ “guarantees for human rights and freedom of expression in Hong Kong.” The pillar was staged at the University of Hong Kong, the city’s oldest and most prestigious institute of higher learning, in 1998, after being displayed at other campuses.

For more than two decades, the city passed Galschiøt’s assessment. Students and activists gathered every spring to ceremonially wash the structure, which across its base reads The old cannot kill the young forever. The ritual was the first in a sequence of events held every year in Hong Kong to mark the anniversary of the Tiananmen massacre culminating with the candlelight vigil. Now, though, the pillar is caught in a sort of purgatory—unwanted by the university, which has tried to remove it but faced fierce resistance, and Galschiøt’s attempts to retrieve it have gone unanswered. The awkward situation is representative of the city itself, not entirely subjugated by Beijing but not as free, open, or vibrant as it once was.

“Many things in the past in Hong Kong that were treated as normal and being a kind of symbol that Hong Kong is still enjoying freedom and a high degree of autonomy … are now facing challenges,” Richard Tsoi, the secretary of the now-dissolved alliance, told me.

The attempts at removing the horrors of Tiananmen from the popular consciousness follow a full-scale effort to rewrite more recent history in Hong Kong. Officials have consistently attempted to twist the narrative of the city’s protest movement, portraying the demonstrations as organized by a small, violent group, conspicuously omitting the occasions when more than 1 million people marched peacefully. The reasons behind the protests have been obfuscated as well. Blame, officials now say, lies with the United States and astronomical housing prices, not the continued erosion of freedoms and broken promises from Beijing. The police have taken part in some of the most blatant acts of historical revisionism, hoping that residents will forget violent actions they witnessed with their own eyes.

“The authorities … are working overtime to teach us what is the official position,” John P. Burns, an emeritus professor at HKU and the former dean of its faculty of social sciences, who has written in support of keeping the statue, told me. “Making Hong Kong more like the rest of China, that is the name of the game.”

In 1989, residents of Hong Kong were horrified by Beijing crushing the protests at Tiananmen Square. Hundreds of thousands of people marched in what The New York Times described as a “long ribbon of humanity” that stretched through the city’s streets. The outrage extended beyond those who supported full democracy. Many who signed published petitions denouncing Beijing’s actions and who took part in demonstrations are pro-Beijing stalwarts today. David Ford, then the territory’s chief secretary, wrote in a letter to the city’s vaunted civil service that residents felt a “profound feeling of shock and grief,” at what had occurred. Authorities in Beijing believed then that the city’s protests would be a one-off event, according to a former Hong Kong government official who requested anonymity because of the sensitivity of the topic, and that the territory would revert to being a purely “economic city,” whose inhabitants were uninterested in politics. This hypothesis—like many made by Beijing about Hong Kong—was totally incorrect. Instead, Hong Kong fostered a lively tradition of protests and demonstrations.

[Read: Remembering Tiananmen Square is dangerous, even in Hong Kong]

Galschiøt’s two-ton sculpture was unveiled in downtown Victoria Park eight years after the massacre and 28 days before the city’s July 1, 1997, handover to China. It was eventually relocated to HKU’s campus, and activists painted it bright orange in 2008. The artist wrote at the time of its installation that “no ban on the sculpture can diminish its symbolic value. No attack, not even the destruction of the sculpture can obliterate the symbolism of the Pillar of Shame.” One of his tenets is now being tested: “No authority will ever succeed in preventing the mounting of the Pillar of Shame in Hong Kong.”

Following the disbandment of the alliance, HKU tried to have the sculpture removed, enlisting the global law firm Mayer Brown to help. In a statement to news outlets, Lisa Sachdev, a spokesperson for the firm, said that Mayer Brown was “asked to provide a specific service on a real-estate matter for our long-term client, the University of Hong Kong.” She continued: “Our role as outside counsel is to help our clients understand and comply with current law. Our legal advice is not intended as commentary on current or historical events.” (The firm regularly comments on U.S. news events, though, including the death of George Floyd and voting-rights issues, and Mayer Brown later relented after its involvement drew considerable press and condemnation, saying, “Going forward, Mayer Brown will not be representing its long-time client in this matter.”)

Galschiøt hired his own lawyers in an effort to reclaim the statue himself. He said in an open letter this month that he would travel to Hong Kong to remove the statue but would need assurances from authorities that he wouldn’t face any legal issues. This seems highly unlikely because Galschiøt has been barred from entering Hong Kong on two previous occasions. He added that HKU has not responded to his inquiries. The university did not address the contents of Galschiøt’s letter and, when asked for comment, said only that it was working to resolve the issue in a “legal and reasonable manner.”

HKU and other universities in the territory have quickly moved to submit to Hong Kong’s new, more authoritarian political order. Maintenance workers at the university removed colorful walls of protest art, and the administration cut ties with the students’ union and barred some of its members from campus because of a union motion expressing sympathy for the “sacrifice” of a man who had killed himself after stabbing a police officer in July. The students later apologized and retracted the statement, but four were arrested under the national-security law and charged with advocating terrorism.

Burns told me that by moving to remove the sculpture, the university is “acknowledging its dependence on the mainland and on authorities in the mainland for the things the university wants.” One professor, who asked not to be named for fear of repercussions, told me that the threat of removal was part of “a wholesale embrace of the wider crackdown that we have seen in the media, civil society, and the general public,” and that the university was in “free fall into a totalitarian-friendly tertiary institution.” Another professor, who also spoke on condition of anonymity, told me about recently going out of their way to walk by the statue with colleagues to confirm that it was still standing. “I find campus very depressing,” the academic said, “because of everything that is no longer there.”

In court, Lee said that even while in jail earlier this year after being convicted for his role in a 2019 protest, he continued to uphold the memory of June Fourth by fasting and, without access to a candle, lighting a single match.  

“I am proud to be a Hong Konger,” he said. “For 32 years, we have marched together in the fight to bring justice to those who put their lives on the line on 4 June 1989, and in the struggle for democracy.”

In the end, he told the judge that he was at peace with any sentence that might be handed down: “If I must go to jail to affirm my will,” he said, “then so be it.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Manfred Thierry Mugler, legendary French designer, dies at 73

French designer Manfred Thierry Mugler, who reigned over the fashion industry in the 1980s, died on Sunday at the age of 73. His agent Jean-Baptiste Rougeot revealed that Mugler passed ... Read more »

After witnessing record rainfall in 122 years, Delhi might not see fresh spell of showers till Jan 29: IMD

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: After receiving record rainfall in the first three weeks of January, the India Meteorological Department (IMD) has said that ... Read more »

Australia mines giant buys Williams F1 battery arm

© Getty Images The mining giant founded by Australia’s richest man is buying the battery and technology arm of the Williams Formula One racing team for $222.15m (£164m). Fortescue Metals ... Read more »

Yanlord pre-sales reach $852.5m in second batch of Shanghai launches

© Provided by Singapore Business Review The Singapore Exchange-listed Yanlord Land Group Limited’s second batch of apartment launches in Shanghai reached a total of $852.2m (RMB 4.02b) pre-sales. It announced ... Read more »

ESR-REIT makes 5.3% higher offer for ARA LOGOS

© Provided by Singapore Business Review ARA LOGOS (ALOG) announced the amendment and restatement of the merger with ESR-REIT on 22 January. The revised scheme consideration by ESR-REIT represents an ... Read more »

MAS, Bank Indonesia beef up bilateral cooperation

© Provided by Singapore Business Review The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) and Bank Indonesia (BI) has agreed to beef up bilateral cooperation and deepen their ties. Under their memorandum ... Read more »

Monthlong pandemic lockdown lifted on China's Xi'an

The Associated PressIn this photo released by Xinhua News Agency, a child gets a throat swab for the COVID-19 test at a residential area in Fengtai District in Beijing, Sunday, ... Read more »

Monthlong pandemic lockdown lifted on northern Chinese city of Xi'an, allowing 13 million residents to travel freely

BEIJING — Monthlong pandemic lockdown lifted on northern Chinese city of Xi’an, allowing 13 million residents to travel freely. Read more »

China sends 39 warplanes toward Taiwan, largest in new year

TAIPEI, Taiwan — China flew 39 warplanes toward Taiwan in its largest such sortie of the new year, continuing a pattern that the island has answered by scrambling its own ... Read more »

Man City transfer round-up: Julian Alvarez 'last details' as Harry Kane talks future

For long spells of the January transfer window, it has looked unlikely that Manchester City would sign any players. But that might be about the change in the coming days. ... Read more »

Uttarakhand schools, anganwadi centres to stay closed till Jan 31 as state govt extends COVID-19 restrictions

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Education Desk: Uttarakhand Govt extends COVID restrictions in the state till January 31, 2022. Owing to this, all Anganwadi Centres and educational ... Read more »

Three ideas to salvage a sagging St. John's season

The season looks bleak now. The high preseason expectations have turned into sad acceptance of another lost year now that St. John’s has lost all six of its Quad 1 ... Read more »

Mayor Eric Adams needs to take action against crime, not just talk about it

Mayor Eric Adams vowed Sunday “to roll out a real plan” this week to try to curb gun violence after Friday’s shooting that left an NYPD rookie cop dead and ... Read more »

Police use Twitter to find stolen transit van that is little boy's ‘lifeline'

Police in Surrey have thanked the public for their assistance in locating a transit van which was stolen from an address in the Epsom area over the weekend. In a ... Read more »

BTS: V shares inspiration behind his go-to dance move but later deletes it; Sherlock ARMY finds the origin of his killer moves

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com BTS member V has mastered the art of Instagram. He recently shared the origin of a signature dance move that he does but later deleted the ... Read more »

Children of Ukraine's 'absurd' separatist war see bleak future

© Alexander NEMENOV The separatist in Donetsk authorities last year introduced mandatory six-month-long military service at the age of 18 Ruslan Chebotayev was just 10-years-old when pro-Russian separatists seized his ... Read more »

US: 8-year-old girl dies after being struck by stray bullet

© Provided by Khaleej Times AFP file A gunman targeting someone else on Chicago’s southwest side instead shot an 8-year-old girl in the head, killing her, police said. The Cook ... Read more »

Italy’s Berlusconi back in hospital for checks

© Provided by Khaleej Times Silvio Berlusconi. — AP file Former Italian premier Silvio Berlusconi was back in hospital on Sunday for “routine” checks, his spokesman said, the day after ... Read more »

Pakistan's star opener Mohammad Rizwan named ICC Men's T20I Cricketer of 2021

© Provided by Khaleej Times Pakistan’s Mohammad Rizwan celebrates after scoring a half-century (50 runs) during the third Twenty20 international cricket match between Pakistan and West Indies at the National ... Read more »

Lara Dutta reveals the reason behind her break from films: Got tired of playing hero's girlfriend or wife

© Provided by Pinkvilla Lara Dutta is an actress who had won hearts with her stunning beauty and impeccable acting prowess. While she has always been a treat to watch ... Read more »

Banking across the GCC: Carving out a new future

© Motivate Publishing Money The traditional world of banking is at an inflection point. The economic upheaval posed by the Covid-19 pandemic, the resurgence of new variants and an accelerated ... Read more »

Covid-19: Indian Vice President Naidu tests positive

© Provided by Khaleej Times Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu, who is in Hyderabad, on Sunday tested positive for Covid-19 infection. After testing Covid-19 positive, Naidu has decided to remain ... Read more »

Palestinian minister says holds first meet with Israel’s Lapid

© Provided by Khaleej Times Israeli Foreign Minister Yair Lapid. — AP file Israel’s top diplomat held an official meeting on Sunday evening with a Palestinian minister, the latter said, ... Read more »

Dubai: Residents warned against feeding birds, violators face Dh200 fine

© Provided by Khaleej Times Representational image (AFP file) Feeding birds publicly is prohibited in Dubai and residents have been warned against this practice due to the health, safety and ... Read more »

Key bond market deals: RIL, LIC Housing Finance, Tata Motors Finance

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Here’s a look at the key bond market deals on Monday. Non-Convertible Debentures: LIC Housing Finance to raise at least INR 500 crore via reissue of ... Read more »

Dubai: German man injured in dune buggy crash airlifted from desert

© Provided by Khaleej Times A 50-year-old German man suffered serious injuries after his dune buggy overturned in a desert in Dubai. The Dubai Police airlifted the rider from the ... Read more »

How to apply for E-Shram portal online

How to apply for E-Shram portal online The E-Shram portal was launched by the Ministry of Labour and Employment under the Government of India to form a database of workers ... Read more »

Dubai: Decomposed body found in building; insects help police find time of death

© Provided by Khaleej Times Dubai Police determine the time of death of unidentified, decomposed body based on forensic entomology. Photo: Supplied Insects have helped the Dubai Police determine the ... Read more »

New UAE law: What happens if postdated rent cheques bounce?

© Provided by Khaleej Times Alamy file Question: I am a Dubai resident and my business has run into some problems. With cheque bounce cases decriminalised in UAE, can you ... Read more »

Boats with urea, drugs seized in Gulf waters

© Provided by Khaleej Times The US Navy says it seized a boat in the Gulf of Oman carrying fertiliser used to make explosives. The same ship was caught last ... Read more »

Covid-19: Russia sets another daily virus record amid Omicron surge

© Provided by Khaleej Times New coronavirus infections in Russia reached an all-time high on Sunday, the third consecutive daily record as the highly contagious omicron variant spreads through the ... Read more »

After Buying Some F1 Knowledge, Fortescue Is Racing Ahead With Battery-Electric Trains

Fortescue Metals Group, the mining giant known in Australia for iron ore, is looking to be known for a little more, scooping up a company famous in the Formula 1 ... Read more »

Dubai: New road to ease traffic to Al Qudra Lakes

© Provided by Khaleej Times Saih Al Dahal Road Improvement Project. Photo: Supplied A new road that will link with the entry points of Dubai’s Al Qudra Lakes is 60 ... Read more »

'Muslimness' sacking claim should be investigated if complaint is made: UK Deputy PM Raab

© Provided by Khaleej Times Reuters A British lawmaker’s claim that she was sacked from a ministerial job partly because of her Muslim faith should be properly investigated if she ... Read more »

Arab League seeks terror tag for Houthis

© Provided by Khaleej Times The Arab League on Sunday said Yemen’s Iran-backed Houthi rebels should be labelled as a “terrorist” group after they attacked the UAE. In a statement ... Read more »

Women’s Asian Cup 2022: China thrash Iran 7-0 as heartbroken hosts India pull out over Covid-19 outbreak

China follow up their 4-0 victory over Taiwan with another dominant performance as they seal their place in the last eight Indian players are devastated at having to withdraw from ... Read more »

Biden Administration to Release Executive Order on Crypto as Early as February: Report

The White House is readying an executive order for release as early as next month that will outline a comprehensive government strategy on cryptocurrencies and ask Federal agencies to determine ... Read more »

US rebuffs sanctioning Russia now, wants to preserve deterrence

© Provided by Khaleej Times Antony Blinken. — AFP US Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Sunday rebuffed calls to immediately impose economic sanctions on Russia, saying that doing so ... Read more »

Is the sun finally setting on Australia's hermit kingdom?

© Provided by ABC NEWS Power outages have left about 4,000 people in the dark across the metropolitan area. (ABC News: Gian De Poloni) WA’s divisive hard border policy still ... Read more »

Goldman appoints Sarsfield to co-run asset management unit - Bloomberg News

© Reuters/ANDREW KELLY FILE PHOTO: The logo for Goldman Sachs is seen on the trading floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City (Reuters) -Goldman Sachs ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic