Behind Modi & Dr Tedros' smiles in Gujarat, India & WHO are at war over Covid deaths, Covaxin

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

Behind modi & dr tedros’ smiles in gujarat, india who are at war over covid deaths, covaxin
© Provided by The Print

New Delhi: World Health Organization Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus is on a three-day trip to India and, Tuesday, tweeted his thanks for a “warm welcome” from the government after landing in Gujarat’s Rajkot the previous night.

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

Dr Tedros is scheduled to attend events with Prime Minister Narendra Modi across the latter’s home state, including laying the foundation stone of the WHO Global Centre for Traditional Medicine (GCTM) in Jamnagar, which was done Tuesday, and inauguration of the Global AYUSH Investment and Innovation Summit.

“This is a truly global project… This means that India will go to the world and the whole world will come to India,” the WHO chief said at the GCTM ceremony, while the PM noted Dr Tedros’s “affection for India”.

Global Tech News Daily

Beneath these niceties, however, all is not well between the top world health body and the Indian government. And it’s out in the open.

The two have been at odds over the Covid mortality rate in India, with a WHO analysis putting the figure at “more than 4 million” while the government’s official toll is 5,20,000, or just over half a million.

Global Tech News Daily

The health ministry Saturday issued a tough statement in response to an article titled ‘India Is Stalling the WHO’s Efforts to Make Global Covid Death Toll Public’, published in The New York Times. The Indian side questioned the methodology used by the WHO to estimate coronavirus deaths in the country.

“It is very surprising that while The New York Times purportedly could obtain the alleged figures of excess Covid-19 mortality in respect to India, it was ‘unable to learn the estimates for other countries’,” the sharp Indian statement read, adding that “India has shared its concerns with the methodology along with other member states through a series of formal communications including six letters issued to WHO”.

The other move that has caused much discomfort in India is that the WHO, earlier this month, suspended the supply of India-made Covaxin through UN procurement agencies, and recommended that countries using the vaccine take action “as appropriate”.

According to sources, while India is hopeful that the Covaxin imbroglio will resolve itself over time, it is the matter of Covid death estimates that has left health officials smarting.

In a recent meeting, Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya expressed his displeasure about the issue in no uncertain terms, a source said.

“The minister was visibly upset when he said that if ICMR (Indian Council of Medical Research) or any other Indian institute does not go about estimating excess mortality in the US, Italy or any other foreign country, why should foreign institutes bother themselves with India’s death numbers,” the source explained.

Government officials also believe that the reports in global media on Covid mortality estimates for India are “deliberate leaks” by the WHO. “This has been going on for a long time. We did not choose to go to town on this. But they have clearly been talking to foreign publications,” an official said.

A WHO official who did not wish to be identified told ThePrint over WhatsApp messages that the estimates are yet to be released.

ThePrint reached both the WHO headquarters and WHO’s South-East Asia Region Office (WHO SEARO) over email for comments on the issue, but received no response. There was no response either to a WhatsApp message to WHO’s South-East Asia Regional Director Dr Poonam Khetrapal Singh.

Also read: Age of traditional medicine will start with establishment of WHO centre in Jamnagar, says PM Modi

‘A conspiracy’

Speaking in private, senior functionaries in the Ministry of Health call the WHO modelling projections a “typical” foreign conspiracy to defame India.

“They do not understand our country. They had predicted that India would have death and devastation throughout the pandemic and now that we have proved them wrong, they cannot digest it. It is a conspiracy to malign us. The fact that we did not go with a begging bowl to the world, did so well both on vaccinations and disease control is something that they are finding tough to stomach,” said a functionary who did not want to be named.

That is why, the officials said, India’s rebuttal to the alleged estimates came in strong statistical terms rather than the usual official language that is used in press releases.

India has been vociferous in its protests to the WHO about the modelling projections, and said in its rebuttal statement that the matter was raised through six letters issued to WHO (on 17 November, 20 December and 28 December 2021, and 11 January, 12 February and 2 March 2022); virtual meetings held on 16 December and 28 December 2021, and 6 January and 25 February 2022; as well as the SEARO Regional Webinar held on 10 February 2022.

An expert retorts

One of the experts associated with WHO’s mortality estimation exercise, Jonathan Wakefield, Monday tweeted a retort to India’s rebuttal of the NYT report.

Wakefield is professor of Statistics and Biostatistics at University of Washington, which has published papers earlier on India’s Covid mortality estimates, but had them debunked by the Indian government, and whose top experts are part of the WHO panel looking at excess mortality during the pandemic.

Wakefield also tweeted some excerpts from a yet-to-be published paper looking at all-cause mortality in different countries.

“For India, we use a variety of sources for the registered number of deaths at the state and union-territory level. The information was either reported directly by the states through official reports and automatic vital registration, or by journalists who obtained death registration information through Right To Information requests (the Supplementary Materials of the full paper, contains full details). We stress that for India the global predictive covariate model is not used and so the estimates of excess mortality are based on data from India only,” reads the extract from the upcoming paper ‘Estimating Country-Specific Excess Mortality During the Covid-19 Pandemic’ that the professor uploaded.

Last month, another study led by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation at University of Washington published in The Lancet estimated that the highest numbers of cumulative excess deaths due to Covid-19 were estimated in India at 40.7 lakh (37.1–43.6 lakh).

India followed own path 

It is not that everything was hunky dory between New Delhi and Geneva earlier either. India, through the two pandemic years, often chose to sidestep WHO advice and carved out its own path, which was often contrary to the world health body’s recommendations at that point of time.

From its reluctance to conduct large-scale testing for Covid, to the early travel restrictions to and from China, and then the quick lockdown, India built its own battle strategy during the global pandemic.

WHO’s advice as articulated by its chief on 16 March 2020, was “test, test, test”. On 22 March that year, the DG of ICMR, Dr Balram Bhargava, retorted: “There will be no indiscriminate testing. Isolation, Isolation, isolation.”

India also braved much criticism for its recommended preventive use of the rheumatoid arthritis drug hydroxychloroquine for healthcare workers and caregivers, and also started using HIV drugs lopinavir and ritonavir as therapeutics for Covid patients early on in the pandemic, even though WHO guidelines at that point clearly said that evidence was lacking for any specific treatment for the viral illness. The medicines eventually proved to be ineffective for Covid.

Among the WHO guidance documents for countries is a fairly elaborate one on how to reach out to and plan for marginalised groups, including migrants. But India apparently ignored this when it announced a countrywide lockdown on 25 March 2020, with a four-hour notice to the public.

India did take recourse to WHO guidance when it suited the country. In the second half of 2021, when many countries were rolling out third and some even fourth booster vaccine shots, India repeatedly cited WHO’s stance on boosters to defend its own.

There have been other instances when India has gone out of its way for WHO. In an unusual move, the Dr Balram Bhargava authored Going Viral — on the development of Covaxin — was released in Geneva with top WHO officials in attendance, at a time when the vaccine itself was still awaiting inclusion in the EUL list

High hopes on Covaxin

The other festering issue between the WHO and India has been Covaxin.

On suspension of supplies of Covaxin, the WHO stated this was being done to allow the manufacturer to upgrade facilities and address deficiencies found in an inspection.

The vaccine, developed as a joint venture between the ICMR and Hyderabad-based Bharat Biotech, has been a matter of much pride for the Indian government.

According to Bharat Biotech officials, the shortcomings flagged by WHO in the inspection may take up to six months to fix. Officials in the Ministry of Health are, however, hopeful of an early resolution to the matter and quick resumption of global supplies of the vaccine.

“The WHO has sent a small query, which is normal whenever inspections are undertaken. We are constantly monitoring the situation and Bharat Biotech has assured us that they will rectify the issue quickly and respond to the WHO within 15 days,” a top health ministry functionary had told ThePrint earlier this month.

The WHO had given emergency use approval to Covaxin in November, with the approval process being long and complicated, and even PM Modi pushing the vaccine’s case.

‘Little doubt that deaths were undercounted’

Covaxin’s troubles with WHO and the ongoing bitter exchanges over Covid death estimates make it easy to forget that one of the senior-most people in the WHO’s present dispensation is an Indian.

Former Director General of ICMR Dr Soumya Swaminathan, who moved to the WHO in 2017 and is currently the chief scientist there, has so far maintained a studied silence on the death estimates.

Throughout her tenure at the WHO, Dr Swaminathan has, in her utterances, struck a balance. “I have to work with the ICMR,” she has replied on multiple occasions when probed for comments.

When asked whether India, through this public tussle with the WHO, had reached out to Dr Swaminathan, a senior official said “it does not concern her department”.

On the counting of Covid deaths, Gautam Menon, professor of physics and biology at Ashoka University, said “we need to come to terms with the toll for many reasons, including our responsibility to those who lost loved ones during the pandemic”.

Advising that India “needs to collect data better”, he pointed out: “According to India’s submissions to WHO, we are still not in community transmission. How can we say that when 80-90 per cent of the country has been infected, according to reasonable estimates as well as serosurvey data collected by the government”

“As for the question of mortality, counting deaths is a sensitive issue throughout the world. It is natural for governments to worry about models whose conclusions portray them in a bad light. But for India the difference is quite stark. The model estimates are more than the official estimates by a factor of 8,” he said.

Menon added: “We need to come to terms with the toll for many reasons, including our responsibility to those who lost loved ones during the pandemic, but who do not reflect in official statistics. But also so that in future we ensure we collect data better, to make sure it’s trustworthy. We should incentivise data collection in a way that it is authentic. All of the estimates for Covid deaths in India have been pieced together using indirect methods. One can raise questions about those, but there is little doubt that deaths were undercounted. It happened all over the world. There is no shame in that. Indian government should welcome approaches that attempt to calculate Covid 19 mortality more accurately, while raising legitimate scientific questions about methodology, if they are warranted.”

(Edited by Nida Fatima Siddiqui)

Also read: Covaxin granted WHO emergency-use nod, gets thumbs up on quality, efficacy

News Related


This is America: It's not just Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month anymore

Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month was already a lot to take in. There are so many distinct cultures and disparate experiences within these two massive identity groups, so ... Read more »

Red-hot inflation is probably costing you an extra $311 per month

Financial squeeze stems from the rising cost for a number of everyday goods Read more »

How Kurtwood Smith Approached His Character In Firestarter - Exclusive

Blumhouse/Universal Stephen King’s 1980 novel, “Firestarter,” was the celebrated horror author’s first full-fledged foray into science fiction, after incorporating elements of the genre into his two previous books, “The Stand” ... Read more »

The Devastating Death Of Tremors Star Fred Ward

Kevin Winter/Getty The entertainment world is reeling today at the news that character actor extraordinaire Fred Ward has died at the age of 79. No cause of death has been ... Read more »

Formula shortage reveals GOP's compassion for American babies, anger over nourished immigrant ones

Cearly these Republicans are addressing the baby-formula shortage through the scriptural philosophy of: “All lives are precious, expect these little immigrant whiners over here. They can pound sand.” Read more »

Self-driving truck company looks to fix supply chain issues for the long haul

Embark Trucks successfully completes autonomous driving tests in winter conditions Read more »

A timeline of billionaire Elon Musk's bid to control Twitter

Elon Musk announced on Friday that his plan to buy Twitter in a proposed $44 billion deal is “ temporarily on hold ” as he tries to pinpoint the exact ... Read more »

Protesters demand arrest of former Sri Lankan PM over attack

The Associated PressSri Lankans protest demanding president Gotabaya Rajakasa resign and decrying the appointment of Prime Minister Ranil Wickeremesinghe in Colombo, Sri Lanka, Friday, May 13, 2022. Five-time former Sri ... Read more »

Law & Order: SVU Fans Are Outraged With Olivia Benson After Season 23, Episode 21

Michael Greenberg/NBC Since the series debuted in 1999, “Law & Order: SVU” fans have rallied behind the exploits of protagonist Captain Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay). As the Commanding Officer of ... Read more »

Here's Who's Hosting The Saturday Night Live Season Finale

Amy Sussman/Getty The untold truth of “Saturday Night Live” involves all sorts of behind-the-scenes shenanigans, but when it comes to the show’s guest hosts, few things are left untold. There’s a ... Read more »

Woman arrested in 2002 Missouri hospital patient's death

On Location: May 13, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press CHILLICOTHE, Mo. — A former respiratory therapist charged with first-degree murder in the death of ... Read more »

Inflation has eroded 40% of Social Security's purchasing power since 2000

Social Security would need to increase by $539 per month to offset inflation Read more »

Toddler weighing under 10 pounds dies; parents arrested

The Associated PressThis photo provided by Polk County, Florida, Sheriff’s Office shows Arhonda Tillman and Regis Johnson. A 2-year-old girl in Florida weighing less than 10 pounds (4.5 kilograms) died ... Read more »

Jesse Spencer Responds To Those Leaked Chicago Fire Finale Images

Timothy Hiatt/Getty Matthew Casey (Jesse Spencer) has been a fixture on “Chicago Fire” ever since the very first episode. Originally starting off as a lieutenant for the first six seasons, ... Read more »

Multiverse Of Madness Screenwriter Reveals Elizabeth Olsen's Reaction To Scarlet Witch's Violent Scene - Exclusive

Kevin Mazur/Getty Images Spoiler warning: This article includes major plot details from “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.” Arguably one of the most dramatic character arcs in the history ... Read more »

Pilots at United will vote on contract after tentative deal

The Associated PressFILE – In this July 2, 2021 file photo, a United Airlines jetliner taxis down a runway for take off from Denver International Airport in Denver. United Airlines ... Read more »

Unionists block new N Ireland govt over Brexit trade rules

The Associated PressFILE – Democratic Unionist Party leader Jeffrey Donaldson pauses as he speaks to the media at Parliament Buildings, Stormont, Belfast, Monday, May 9, 2022. Britain and the European ... Read more »

Five-year-old girl dies after being found unconscious in the sea in Stavanger

The five-year-old girl who was found lifeless in the sea in Stavanger on Thursday night was declared dead at the hospital on Friday. The police do not suspect that the ... Read more »

Mixed Texas ruling allows trans youth parent investigations

AUSTIN, Texas — The Texas Supreme Court on Friday allowed the state to investigate parents of transgender youth for child abuse while also ruling in favor of one family that ... Read more »

Mimi Rogers Cried When She Learned About Her Bosch Character's Fate - Exclusive

Tyler Golden/Amazon Freevee Emmy-nominated actress Mimi Rogers has more than 100 IMDb credits to her name, but dedicated fans of “Bosch” almost certainly know her best from her role as the ... Read more »

Severe storms blamed for 2 deaths in South Dakota, Minnesota

Severe weather hits the Heartland and moves East Chief meteorologist Ginger Zee has the latest forecast after damaging storm reports from Kansas to Minnesota. The Associated Press SIOUX FALLS, S.D. ... Read more »

Jesse Williams addresses leak of Broadway nude scene

The Associated PressMichael Oberholtzer, from left, Jesse Williams and Jesse Tyler Ferguson attend the Tony Awards: Meet The Nominees media day at the Sofitel New York on Thursday, May 12, ... Read more »

House of Representatives to give staff free Peloton memberships, costing taxpayers

The benefit is is being offered to Capitol Police officers and House staff Read more »

Elon Musk pausing Twitter deal because of spam accounts not a ‘legitimate excuse': Market expert

Musk could be putting the Twitter deal on hold to renegotiate the price, says Gregg Smith Read more »

Here's Why Moon Knight Could Suddenly Fly In The Final Episode

Disney+/Marvel Studios Marvel’s “Moon Knight” wraps up its six-episode run with an epic battle between Marc Spector/Steven Grant (Oscar Isaac) and the powerful zealot Arthur Harrow (Ethan Hawke). It’s a ... Read more »

The Fed raising interest rates will ‘create a recession,' Dick Bove warns

The Fed ‘can’t avoid’ a recession, the chief financial strategist stresses Read more »

German police investigate possible terrorism in knife attack

VIENNA — Police have arrested an Iraqi-born man and are investigating a possible Islamic extremist motive after five passengers received knife wounds on a regional train in western Germany, authorities ... Read more »

German police investigate possible Islamic extremist motive after 5 wounded in knife attack on train

BERLIN — German police investigate possible Islamic extremist motive after 5 wounded in knife attack on train. Read more »

Doctor Strange 2 Star Benedict Wong Recalls His Longtime Friendship With Benedict Cumberbatch - Exclusive

Noam Galai/Getty Images Thanks to the sprawling narrative of the MCU, many of the film saga’s actors have had the opportunity to work together again. That’s a good thing when ... Read more »

Queen attends horse show in first public appearance in weeks

The Associated PressBritain’s Queen Elizabeth II is joined by Prince Edward and Sophie, right, the Earl and Countess of Wessex as they sit in the Royal Box at the Royal ... Read more »

UN humanitarian official urges attention to drought in Kenya

The Associated PressVillagers gather during a visit by United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs Martin Griffiths, in the village of Lomoputh in northern Kenya Thursday, May 12, 2022. Griffiths visited ... Read more »

Film Review: ‘Firestarter' remake fails to ignite

The Associated PressThis image released by Universal Pictures shows Ryan Kiera Armstrong as Charlie in a scene from “Firestarter.” (Ken Woroner/Universal Pictures via AP) For a movie about a girl ... Read more »

Report: Austria sees record number of antisemitic incidents

VIENNA — Antisemitic incidents reached a record high in Austria last year, according to a report published Friday. The statistics, compiled by the Jewish Community of Vienna, recorded 965 incidents ... Read more »

Germany: Over 300 far-right extremists at security agencies

VIENNA — The German government said Friday that it has identified more than 300 employees of national and state military, police and security agencies with links to far-right extremists or ... Read more »

38 rescued, 11 dead as US searches waters near Puerto Rico

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — At least 38 people have been rescued and 11 bodies found as the U.S. Coast Guard scoured the open waters northwest of Puerto Rico on ... Read more »

Becki Newton On The Joy Of Working With Neve Campbell On The Lincoln Lawyer And Her Dream Co-Star - Exclusive

Lara Solanki/Netflix Throughout her career, Becki Newton has worked with a string of talented actors, including Judith Light and Vanessa Williams on “Ugly Betty,” Neil Patrick Harris and Cobie Smulders ... Read more »

As the United States grapples with abortion law, what is the situation here in Norway?

The recent leaking of a draft decision, by the United States Supreme Court, to overturn more than 5 decades of the legal protection of a woman’s right to seek an ... Read more »

Nasdaq's nosedive nears pandemic crash of 2020

The 10-year yield hit 3.203% Monday – a 3.5 year high Read more »

Croatia passes law paving way for euro currency introduction

ZAGREB, Croatia — Croatian lawmakers on Friday approved a law that paves the way for the introduction of the euro currency next year. Croatia is due to replace the Croatian ... Read more »

Report: Missile attack kills 10 Syrian soldiers in the north

BEIRUT — A missile struck a Syrian military bus in the country’s north early on Friday, killing 10 soldiers, Syria’s state-run media and an opposition monitor said. It wasn’t immediately ... Read more »