Beef industry campaign claims cattle carbon emissions can be reduced

In a new campaign, the meat industry is claiming it can significantly reduce methane emissions from cows and be part of the solution to climate change, not the cause.  

That could be a good line for the industry and the federal government to run ahead of the Glasgow climate summit, but a leading greenhouse researcher says a net reduction in methane would not be enough to bring the temperature down, just limit the damage.

Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA) argues methane from cattle is just part of the natural cycle and not nearly as bad as carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels.

It says in its latest marketing campaign that the cattle industry can reduce emissions by using innovative technologies.

Professor Richard Eckard* from Melbourne University, who leads a research centre focused on greenhouse gas, agrees the cattle industry could play a critical role in addressing global warming because, unlike coal, the industry’s emissions break down quickly.

“Methane is a short-lived gas … so a change in methane today will reduce the temperature in 12 years’ time. It’s kind of a get out of jail card,” he says.

But on the industry’s claim that cattle could actually help cool the planet, Professor Eckard is less confident.

“It wouldn’t bring the temperature down; it would stop contributing more to the heating.” 

Why are cattle emissions such a big problem?

The recent Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change (IPCC) report on global warning is the latest catalyst for urgent action to reduce emissions. 

According to the national greenhouse gas inventory, agriculture contributes 14 per cent of Australia’s total emissions, livestock about 11 per cent and methane specifically from livestock about 9.6 per cent.

Fossil fuels contribute over 50 per cent.

Just as the IPCC released its report the meat industry launched its own campaign arguing that the livestock sector could actually help cool the planet. 

So is that true?

What is MLA claiming?

The campaign by MLA includes a short animation that differentiates cattle from coal, arguing that methane emissions are just a part of the natural cycle.

The voiceover in the animation says, “Because of this cycling of carbon, if cattle numbers stay the same, eventually the methane produced by cattle will not contribute additional global warming”.

The narration continues, “However, CO2 produced from burning fossil fuels is CO2 that is new to the atmosphere. It does not stem from the natural carbon cycle, it builds on what’s already there, day after day, year after year.

“What’s really exciting is, if we reduce methane emissions from cows using innovative technologies and grazing practices such as improving their diet, the red meat and livestock industry can be part of the climate solution,”.

The message is that the cattle industry can actually play a part in reducing the temperature of the planet.

What is the research backing up the claim?

Jason Strong from Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA) confirmed the campaign’s message was that cattle could actually help to cool the planet.

“The methane produced by cattle only has a 10-year cycle, so if we reduce the amount of methane produced by the animals and we find ways to capture the methane that is produced then, absolutely, [we can be] contributing to cooling the planet,” Mr Strong says.

“Agriculture has already done much of the heavy lifting on limiting carbon pollution with net greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from red meat production less than half what they were in 2005, representing by far the greatest reduction by any sector of Australia’s economy.”

MLA points to research in the US on emissions which states by “continuously improving production efficiency and management practices, animal agriculture can be a short-term solution to fight climate warming which the global community can leverage while developing long-term solutions for fossil fuel carbon emissions”.

Research has been done in Australia on the options for reducing emissions in the cattle industry, and recent breakthroughs in Australia and the Netherlands using seaweed and other food additives could reduce emissions from cattle by as much as 90 per cent. 

Mr Strong says it’s great news for consumers.  

“This means that in the coming years, consumers will continue to enjoy Australian red meat knowing that it’s good for them and good for the environment.”

Researcher upbeat about reducing cattle emissions

Professor Eckard developed the first greenhouse gas accounting tools and advises the Australian, New Zealand and UK governments on climate change and agricultural policy.

He says while the cattle industry’s emissions break down quickly, emissions from coal take hundreds of years to break down meaning any changes in the sector will take a long time to have an impact on global temperatures.

And he is very upbeat about the industry’s potential to reduce actually reduce emissions overall. 

“We’ve taken a quantum leap with two new supplements or additives on the market, the seaweed and 3NOP from DSM Nutrition.

“Those two have put us into the 70-80 per cent category and it’s given us real hope that we can address this problem to a greater quantum than we ever thought we could.”

Doubt about cooling the planet

He says there is the potential for cattle to stop contributing to the planet’s warming.

“If the technologies reduce the methane in the national herd by more than about 12 per cent per decade, then there would definitely be a net reduction in methane in the atmosphere.”

That would mean less heating due to the livestock industries, according to Professor Eckard.

“We can’t imply cooling as all methane heats and we are not saying methane would be zero, just less than before,” he says.

Assuming the cattle industry in Australia could reduce emissions significantly could that have an impact on global warming?

Not on our own, according to Professor Ekhard, but if all countries worked together it could.

“There’s significant research going on in the European Union, in Canada and the US now, in Brazil and New Zealand [so] if we address this to the global livestock industries then we can make a difference.”

Environment group backs livestock sector

The Climate Council is backing the livestock industry’s push to clean up its image.

The group’s lead researcher Tim Baxter has been watching and reporting on the issue for a decade.

He says there is the potential for this campaign to look like  “greenwashing”, but he thinks the industry is serious about addressing emissions.

“These sorts of initiatives indicate a level of seriousness and we require all shoulders to the wheel, including livestock sector,” Mr Baxter says.

“Every fraction of a degree of warming avoided matters … so the efforts of farmers to prevent further harm is extremely worthwhile.”

He thinks much more work needs to be done to move the sector towards zero emissions, including using food additives, limiting land clearing and improving soil carbon levels. But, he says the main game when it comes to reducing Australia’s emissions is not the livestock sector but coal and gas. 

“The biggest part of the problem that is climate change is burning coal, oil and gas, but there is real room for land sector, ag sector and meat to have a big impact on where we land to undo some of the past harm.”

Market forces also driving change

There are other compelling reasons why the beef industry is pushing hard to address concerns about emissions. 

The EU has signalled it will set up a carbon levy on polluting industries and the US is preparing to do the same. 

Multinational corporations involved in the food chain are also imposing their own standards around sustainability and emissions that suppliers need to meet.

According to Professor Eckard all those things are putting pressure on the Australian livestock sector. 

“All agribusiness supply chain companies are setting greenhouse carbon neutral targets, [so] what governments decide as targets becomes irrelevant. 

“Farmers know they have to be down this track in order have the social licence to operate and that’s what’s going to drive the change.”

The question is, will the meat industries’ efforts to reduce emissions and campaigns like this one appease policymakers, corporates and consumers?

Cattle producers moving to reduce emissions

Some cattle producers are already doing their bit to store more carbon in the soil.

Stuart Austin and Trisha Cowley operate the Wilmot Cattle Company in north-west New South Wales. 

They have changed their grazing management to sequester more carbon and they claim they have become “massively carbon positive”.

“We’re sequestering an enormous amount more than we’re emitting every year all while producing the most nutrient dense beef that a person could eat,” Mr Austin says.

He says he is restoring the health of his soil and the health of this landscape.

“Our ecological health is improving on this farm, and we’ve got all the data to demonstrate that that’s the case.”

Wilmot has also sold carbon credits to Microsoft, which allows the computer giant to continue to produce emissions and claim to be carbon neutral. 

As Professor Ekard points out in an article in The Conversation, “Wilmot will now never be carbon neutral as this offset has left their farm, left their industry and left Australia“.

* Some of Professor Eckard’s projects are funded by MLA and Dairy Australia, including a project he leads on extreme climate events and another on Trees on Farm as well as methane in collaboration with ILRI in Nairobi. He says his work in the methane area was not funded by MLA. He says he analyses all the emissions evidence and provides the collective analysis to the livestock industries. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Cheap flights tips from travel insiders including the best days to book for deals

When it comes to booking flights and holidays, there have always been some easy tricks to help you save money on your trip. However, the pandemic completely changed the world ... Read more »

French intelligence 'unmasks' QAnon conspiracy theorists

French intelligence has revealed a disturbing rise in power of the far-right conspiracy movement QAnon in the French-speaking world, according to a document obtained by Sunday newspaper the Journal du ... Read more »

Fox News's Neil Cavuto ‘begs' viewers to ‘stop the politics' and get Covid vaccine

Photograph: Steven Ferdman/Getty Images The Fox News host Neil Cavuto has “begged” viewers to toss out political talking points about Covid-19 vaccinations and get the shot. Related: Worst of US ... Read more »

Facebook Whistleblower Answers Questions From UK Parliament's Joint Online Safety Committee

Former Facebook employee and whistleblower Frances Haugen answered questions from the UK Parliament’s Joint Online Safety Committee in London on October 25. Haugen — an American data scientist who released ... Read more »

New Zealand media claim Wales players are 'tied up in mental knots' when they play All Blacks

Wales are too “consumed by their desperation” to beat New Zealand – and that desperation only serves to enhance the standing of the All Blacks in “frail Welsh minds”. That’s ... Read more »

17 best Christmas lights, garden illuminations and festive events in the UK for 2021

Visit a UK town, city, country park or garden near you to see some of the best Christmas light events in London and the UK in 2021, including festive garden ... Read more »

Glass-covered tourist attraction in New York warns visitors not to wear skirts incase of ‘unwanted exposure'

A glass covered tourist attraction in New York has advised its visitors not to wear skirts and you can imagine the reason why. © Reuters A woman looks at The ... Read more »

California ports resort to $100-per-container fines to get shipping firms to move cargo from clogged-up docks, as a record number of ships wait off the coast

© Provided by Business Insider Containers are clogging up Southern California ports. Getty Images/Sasin Tipchai California ports will start fining shipping firms if they don’t clear containers in time. Containers ... Read more »

Keiji Ashizawa designs Blue Bottle Coffee shop for "cave-like space" in Maebashi hotel

Japanese studio Keiji Ashizawa Design used bricks and a warm colour palette in its design for the Blue Bottle Coffee shop in the Shiroya Hotel in Maebashi, Japan. © Provided ... Read more »

Pub boss warns price of a pint set to rise by 30p as business costs soar

© PA Archive Pub staff have been trained to recognise the signs that people are vulnerable or in danger (Yui Mok/PA) Pints are set to get more expensive, a leading ... Read more »

Man Utd players arrive at Man Utd training with boss Ole Gunnar Solskjaer under pressure

Manchester United players have reported to training fresh in the knowledge that Ole Gunnar Solskjaer will remain as manager. The humiliated United stars were given a scheduled day off on ... Read more »

Best countries for expats named - Spain and Portugal do not make top 10

There are 760,000 British expats around the world. Would-be expats looking to join the ranks of their fellow Britons overseas may have their eyes set on sun destinations such as ... Read more »

The SEC is likely to get the green light to target stablecoins this week, report says

© Alex Wong/Getty Images SEC Chairman, Gary Gensler. Alex Wong/Getty Images The SEC has secured authority over stablecoin regulation, Bloomberg reported on Monday. A highly-anticipated report laying out the SEC’s ... Read more »

Environmental documentary narrated by Alec Baldwin delays release

(Reuters) – The theatrical and digital release of ‘Flint: Who Can You Trust?’, an environmental documentary narrated by Alec Baldwin, has been postponed, its director said, following the fatal shooting ... Read more »

UK inflation expectations jump again ahead of BoE rate decision - Citi/YouGov

© Reuters/Peter Nicholls FILE PHOTO: Courgettes are seen for sale at a vegetable market, in London LONDON (Reuters) – The British public’s expectations for inflation over the next year jumped ... Read more »

Four of the best: Facials in a jar

© Provided by COVER News India Tata Harper With the fast pace of modern life, it’s not always possible to set aside a few hours for a facial or beauty ... Read more »

Ikea owner buys Topshop's former London flagship store

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Matthew Chattle/Rex/Shutterstock The owner of Ikea has bought Topshop’s former flagship store on Oxford Street, once the jewel in Sir Philip Green’s retail empire, ... Read more »

Two brothers charged with murder of fisherman Max Maguire

Two brothers have appeared in court charged with the murder of an “amazing father with a heart of gold” who died after being stabbed outside a Royal British Legion club. ... Read more »

Cathie Wood responds to Elon Musk flagging the surge in price pressures and says technology like blockchain will 'bend the curve' on inflation

© Cindy Ord and Picture Alliance Cathie Wood and Elon Musk Cindy Ord and Picture Alliance Technology like blockchain could help temper inflation, ARK boss Cathie Wood said on Twitter. ... Read more »

Fendi x SKIMS collection featuring Kim Kardashian is out now — see every look here

© Provided by Lifestyle Asia The rumours are true. Fendi has teamed up with SKIMS, the shapewear brand founded by Kim Kardashian, for a limited-edition collection. The collaboration, which fashion ... Read more »

Diwali Deep-Cleaning Checklist: Tips For Maximizing Hygiene And Ensuring Germ-Free Cleaning

Diwali is up ahead and with it comes the yearly ritual of disinfecting and deep-cleaning our homes. This Diwali, however, your basic cleaning ritual might not be sufficient for the ... Read more »

In Pics: IRCTC's New Executive Lounge At Varanasi Station; Check Facilities, Charges, Other Details Here

© Analiza Pathak | News Desk IRCTC’s New Executive Lounge At Varanasi Station (Image: Twitter/DRM Varanasi) Varanasi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday dedicated a new Executive Lounge at ... Read more »

Yohan Poonawalla to MS Dhoni: 8 Indians who own rare vintage cars

© Provided by Lifestyle Asia From Bollywood celebrities and sportsmen to businessmen, here are 8 famous vintage car owners in India. Much like fashion and technology, automobiles are highly expressive ... Read more »

Australia will be the rich world's weakest link at COP26 with hollow net-zero and emissions pledges

Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison unveiled a long-awaited climate plan on Tuesday, finally announcing that his country would join the other developed nations by aiming to reach net-zero emissions by ... Read more »

Astronomers using a NASA space telescope spotted the first signs of a planet beyond the Milky Way

© Provided by Business Insider A composite image of the galaxy M51, created using X-ray observations from the Chandra telescope and optical light images from NASA’s Hubble Space Telescope. X-ray: ... Read more »

McAuliffe, Democratic groups launch climate ad blitz in Virginia a week out from election

Virginia Democratic gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe rolled out a slate of ads focused on climate and the environment in a joint effort with Democratic groups on Tuesday, marking the start ... Read more »

Biden, Democrats face another deadline on infrastructure, budget bills. Here's what we know about the talks

WASHINGTON – Democratic lawmakers on Capitol Hill are scrambling to make a Sunday deadline to complete two big parts of President Joe Biden’s economic agenda.  House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., earlier this month, set a new ... Read more »

IIM CAT 2021 admit cards to be released tomorrow, know how to download

IIM CAT 2021 admit cards: Indian Institute of Management (IIM) Ahmedabad will release the admit card for CAT 2021 on October 27 at 5 pm. Candidates who have applied for ... Read more »

State pension warning as Britons seeking retirement hotspots will see payment FROZEN

Many people seek pastures new and decide to move abroad after they have finished working, but some could be in for a nasty shock, as their state pension payments could ... Read more »

Prince Andrew lawsuit 'will cast cloud over Queen's Platinum Jubilee': Royal experts warn monarchy 'could be damaged when it should be rejoicing' when key moments in rape case are heard days before celebration

Civil case of rape and sexual assault is to go ahead as quickly as possibleAll disclosures and depositions should be completed before July next yearKey moments in case will be heard in run-up to official national celebrations Royal expert Richard Fitzwilliams says there will be a 'cloud' over festivities Read more »

De Kock pulls out of T20 World Cup match due to 'personal reasons'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo South Africa wicketkeeper Quinton de Kock made himself unavailable for South Africa’s T20 World Cup match against West Indies, shortly after their board ... Read more »

'I want to adopt a disabled child': Katie Price reveals plans to expand her family with a baby with additional needs and says son Harvey's conditions make her 'love him more'

The embattled glamour model, 43, detailed her plans in her new book in which she discusses living with her teenage son and raising him amid his health woes Harvey is on the autism spectrum and was born with disabilities including partial blindness, ADHD and Prader-Willi syndrome, which causes excessive appetite His father is retired footballer Dwight Yorke, 49, although they have no contact Harvey, who was also born with septo-optic dysplasia - a condition that means the development of his optic nerve was unpredictable, is Katie's oldest child She is also mum to Junior, 16, and Princess, 14, with Peter Andre and Jett, eight and Bunny, seven, with Kieran Hayler - and says she would still add to her brood  Read more »

CBI arrests Navy officers in submarine information leak case, Navy orders probe

In a major breakthrough, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has arrested three officials of the Indian Navy, including a serving Commander-rank officer, for allegedly leaking sensitive information related to ... Read more »

Developing Gujarat and Repaying Nature Every Day- Young Entrepreneur, Uttpal Patel

© Provided by DNA India is filled with young entrepreneurs who are making India proud every second. The same goes for 26-year-old Uttpal Patel, CEO, Nakshatra Group, building Gujarat’s tallest ... Read more »

Ahead of Kali Puja, Diwali, special teams and nakas set up in Kolkata to stop entry of illegal crackers

With Kali Puja and Diwali approaching, special teams and nakas have been set up in Kolkata to stop the entry of illegal crackers into the city. Special night checkpoints have ... Read more »

Coastguard rush to ‘urgent incident' off Essex coast as helicopter and plane called to rescue

A HUGE search and rescue operation has been launched off the coast of Essex. A helicopter and plane have been deployed after coastguards and Border Force officers declared an “urgent ... Read more »

Nearly 11 crore people yet to take second COVID-19 dose; Centre calls for meeting tomorrow

© Provided by Firstpost Nearly 11 crore people yet to take second COVID-19 dose; Centre calls for meeting tomorrow After the 100 crore vaccination milestone, Union health minister Mansukh Mandaviya ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin one of four people to blame for Halyna Hutchins shooting as actor should have checked gun, says crew member

ALEC Baldwin was one of four people that should have checked the deadly gun that killed cinematographer Halyna Hutchins, a crew member has said. A location manager for “Rust” says ... Read more »

What to expect from this week's travel update

view of Tayrona National Park beach – Luciano Lejtman /Moment RF Another week, another travel update. You’ll be forgiven for feeling a pang of anxiety at the prospect. During the ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic