BBC accused of unfairly blaming pheasants for adder decline in latest impartiality row

bbc accused of unfairly blaming pheasants for adder decline in latest impartiality row

An adder – John Cancalosi/Photolibrary RM

The BBC has been accused of lacking impartiality in its coverage of the decline of adders in the UK by leading countryside campaigners.

The Countryside Alliance has launched two official complaints over the corporation’s interviews of author Nicholas Milton, who argued adders will be “extinct across most of Britain in the next 15 to 20 years”.

Mr Milton said that one of the major factors behind the rapid decline is “the release of 60 million pheasants”, which target the reptiles.

The Countryside Alliance says there is no scientific research or evidence to support the claim and that it should have been invited to give its point of view.

The two complaints relate to Mr Milton’s appearance on Radio 4’s Today programme and on BBC Radio 2’s Jeremy Vine show, both on March 2.

bbc accused of unfairly blaming pheasants for adder decline in latest impartiality row

A colourful male, ring-necked pheasant – Anne Coatesy/iStockphoto

During the interviews, Mr Milton referenced a study, published in 2019, looking at the decline of adders in the UK.

The Countryside Alliance claims that while Mr Milton used this study to support his argument, it did not suggest that the reason for the decline of adders was a result of the release of the pheasants.

Mr Milton said: “There’s 60 million pheasants, 60 million pheasants are released into the countryside each year that will kill adders, that might surprise people but it’s true.”

In the Jeremy Vine interview, he explained: “The pheasant is a non-native bird, it comes from China and Asia and [they] are therefore very used to dealing with snakes.

“What the pheasant will do is peck out the eyes, the adder will try to defend itself, but the bite doesn’t work. It has a shield of feathers and then other pheasants will join in.”

The study in question, published in the Herpetological Journal, says: “Predation by pheasants may severely reduce reptile populations, particularly where pheasant densities are high, although much of the evidence on the impacts of pheasant predation remains anecdotal due to a lack of quantitative studies of sufficient size.”

Mr Milton said the study found that adders are now restricted to just 260 sites in the whole of the country and 90 per cent of those have 10 or less snakes on them.

bbc accused of unfairly blaming pheasants for adder decline in latest impartiality row

Tim Bonner

Tim Bonner, the Countryside Alliance’s chief executive, claimed there was “no evidence at all” that pheasants were having an impact on adder populations in the UK.

He added: “For the BBC to invite someone on and for that person to express these views in very strong terms, and for that not to be challenged in any way, or to provide an alternative voice is something we are very concerned about.

“The Alliance’s job is to stand up for rural communities and the interest of people in the countryside.

“We see a “metropolitan mindset” consistently. We think it is important BBC news in particular thinks carefully about the claims that are made in relation to rural activities and activities like shooting in particular and ensures people aren’t able to make carte blanche statements without being challenged. “

James Aris, the Alliance’s Shooting Campaign Manager, said: “ Both incidents demonstrated a clear breach of BBC guidelines. The interviews lacked balance and any attempt to counter the arguments being made. This is clearly unacceptable and BBC audiences deserve better”.

A BBC spokesman said: “We take complaints about our output seriously and have a thorough and robust process in place to ensure they are fully considered.”

Mr Milton has been approached for comment.

Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day’s agenda from The Telegraph – direct to your inbox seven days a week.

News Related


MotoGP Portuguese GP: Marc Marquez grabs first pole of 2023, Quartararo 11th

As part of MotoGP’s radical format shake-up for 2023, qualifying now takes place on Saturday morning and sets the grid for both the main grand prix on Sunday and this ... Read more »

Royal Mail warns of new postal delays across the UK this weekend - full list of postcodes

Royal Mail Royal Mail has faced postal delays in the past days and weeks due to a range of factors, such as staff absences. The postal service has warned customers ... Read more »

King by Fishamble review: It takes one to tango in story of an oddball’s damaged life

Fishamble, the New Play Company, are the pioneers of the genre of actor/writers creating shows for themselves, and Pat Kinevane is a master at it. His writing perfectly exploits his ... Read more »

I love my rescue dog to bits - but he's made my life a lot harder

The happy moments outweigh the negatives and we couldn’t imagine life without him (Picture: Jack Wynn) It’s 1pm and Henry, our 18-month-old dachshund, is right on cue scratching at my ... Read more »

Kerry Babies: Man questioned over the 1984 death released without charge –DNA lead to couple ‘who are parents of Baby John’

DNA analysis indicating that a couple were the parents of murdered Baby John led gardaí to make two arrests in the decades-old Kerry Baby case. The man and woman were ... Read more »

Insiders Allege Trump Is 'Very Worried' About Stormy Daniels Case: 'What You See Is a Lot of False Bravado'

“Nobody wants to be led away in handcuffs — even a former president who likes to lead his followers with claims of martyrdom,” attorney Dave Aronberg tells PEOPLE Gary Gershoff/Getty; ... Read more »

BBC Breakfast's Naga Munchetty struggles to pronounce extremely tricky word and has to get help from guest

Naga Munchetty struggled this morning during BBC Breakfast as she failed to pronounce an extremely tricky word and needed help from another guest whilst on-air. On today’s edition of BBC ... Read more »

Germany reaches deal with EU on phaseout of combustion engines

Germany reaches deal with EU on phaseout of combustion engines The European Union and Germany have reached a deal on the future use of combustion engines, officials said on Saturday, ... Read more »

London Underground: Police hunt men who 'threatened to kill woman' on Victoria line train in horror racist attack

Officers are today releasing CCTV images following a report of racist abuse on board a Victoria line train on the London Underground. The incident happened at 1pm on Tuesday, February ... Read more »

RTÉ's own Operation Transformation: What's next for the broadcaster?

With its most gripping drama now playing off-screen, RTÉ is both star of and stage for an existential saga whose outcome cannot be predicted. Ryan Tubridy’s announcement that he is ... Read more »

Storm Keating goes to extreme measures to carry on birthday tradition for Coco

Storm Keating is rising to the challenge to carry on a sweet family tradition for her daughter Coco. The Aussie mum revealed that her youngest turns three in a couple ... Read more »

Do you agree with our Ireland team to face France?

Goalkeeper/defence The goalkeeping call was never in doubt really — Gavin Bazunu will almost certainly come into the side in place of Caoimhin Kelleher barring a late injury. Of the ... Read more »

NASA investigates veteran Mars orbiter to solve a missing fuel mystery

Mars Odyssey has been circling the Red Planet for 22 years and seems to have enough fuel to keep going for a couple of years more. Engineers at NASA and ... Read more »

Ukraine war latest: Wagner tensions blamed for Russian offensive in Bakhmut stalling

TORETSK, UKRAINE – MARCH 24: Civilians carry clean water with wheelbarrows in front of the heavily damaged building after Russian attacks as Russian-Ukrainian war continues in Toretsk, Ukraine on March ... Read more »

Pol Espargaro ruled out of Portugal MotoGP round after horror FP2 crash

The Spaniard was flung from his Tech3-run, GASGAS-branded KTM in the closing stages of Friday’s FP2 session as he headed through the Turn 10 right-hander at the Algarve International Circuit. ... Read more »

Neasa Hourigan, the Green Party TD who wanted to keep ban on evictions, raised concerns about proposals for more than 5,000 new homes in her constituency

Suspended Green Party TD Neasa Hourigan lodged ‘observations’ about proposals for more than 5,000 new homes in her constituency. Ms Hourigan, who was suspended from her party after voting against ... Read more »

BBC repeated same programme 11 times in a month after axing prestigious show

On today’s (March 25) edition of Newswatch on BBC Breakfast, host Samira Ahmed informed viewers about one programme which had been repeated many times this month. The constant repeats left ... Read more »

Meet the couple behind the Edible Flower book on what petals you should be eating

‘Flowers are kind of the source of life. They are what is attracting the pollinators in, the flowers are there to create the thing we are going to eat, the ... Read more »

'She WhatsApped me out of the blue' - English stars plotting Taylor's Dublin downfall

CHANTELLE CAMERON WAS at home in the bath, fresh off a training camp in Manchester, when her phone starting hopping. “Everyone was sending me this post from Katie and I ... Read more »

Gwyneth Paltrow in court as 2016 ski collision trial begins

Actress and Goop CEO Gwyneth Paltrow has found herself in a Park City, Utah courtroom as she is accused of fleeing a skiing accident scene after allegedly ploughing into another ... Read more »

Harry criticised for 'patronising and condescending' comment on Queen in Spare

Prince Harry and his wife Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, stepped down from their senior royal positions three years ago, relinquishing public duty in favour of life overseas. They no longer ... Read more »

Podcast host said politician’s daughter should be raped, trial hears

James Allchurch court case A podcast host accused of stirring up racial hatred suggested a politician’s daughter should be raped to prompt authorities to deal with what he called “Muslim ... Read more »

Royal Family LIVE: Kate sends message to Harry with 'power play' to prove Firm 'matters'

Kate, Princess of Wales Kate, Princess of Wales, is sending a message to Prince Harry and Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, with a “power play” to prove the Royal Family “matters”. ... Read more »

Xi Jinping tells 'dear friend' Putin 'change is coming' in chilling message to West

Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping China and Russia have sent a chilling message to the West as President Xi Jinping told his “dear friend” Vladimir Putin that a “change was ... Read more »

Baz Ashmaw attacked for assisting refugees after DIY SOS

Broadcaster Baz Ashmawy has criticised protesters who ‘attacked’ him after he helped build homes for Ukrainian refugees in the DIY SOS Christmas special. The Christmas episode of the construction programme ... Read more »

Martin Lewis awkwardly changes the subject after woman brings up divorce drama during live ITV Money Show

Martin Lewis was back on ITV tonight (Tuesday, March 21) with a brand new episode of his Money Show Live – and the least one of the season. During the ... Read more »

Ending eviction ban will see 'levels of homelessness nobody thought possible', Dáil told

Sinn Faein’s housing spokesperson Eoin a Broin speaking during this evening’s debate. SINN FÉIN HAS told the Government that the decision to end the ban on evictions at the end ... Read more »

Senior forwards to start for Waterford and Limerick in Munster U20 hurling opener

Patrick Fitzgerald right will be in action for the Waterford U20 team. WATERFORD AND LIMERICK have named their starting teams for tomorrow night’s opening game in the Munster U20 hurling ... Read more »

Different spokes see Brits rule the roads as domestic cycling withers

Tom Pidcock celebrates winning the Strade Bianch (Picture: Rex) As cycling images go, it’s one that deserves a place in the historic iconography of the sport. Tom Pidcock, the prodigiously ... Read more »

Séamus Power confident as Rory McIlroy and Shane Lowry seek putting inspiration at Match Play in Texas

Rory McIlroy, with a new putter in tow, is pictured during practice for the World Golf Championships-Dell Technologies Match Play at Austin Country Club. Photo by Tom Pennington/Getty Images Séamus ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự