Basic income is myopic antidote to 'Hell Joseon'

Basic income is myopic antidote to 'Hell Joseon'

Koh Woo-sung

By Koh Woo-sung

In 1953, the Korean Demilitarized Zone (DMZ) split Korea in half. Decades later, one half evolved into an economic beacon iconized by a vibrant market economy, while the other remains untethered from the world. Capitalism has undoubtedly improved the welfare of the South Korean people but at the cost of socioeconomic equity.

Consequently, the Korean people have become malcontent with their country. In 2020, amongst 38 OECD countries, Korea came 9th in income inequality and 4th in relative poverty. The modern Korean language captures their collective frustration well, anointing their homeland with the title, “Hell Joseon.”

In response, a populist idea has been gaining traction: basic income.

Its popularity is growing ― nurtured by the misfortunes of those on the bottom-right of the recent K-shaped recovery. It is hardly a new idea, aiming to guarantee minimum welfare through non-discriminatory cash handouts.

Indeed, at face value, it is seductive and straightforward; but like most utopian ideas, the devil is in the details. Basic income will impose steep opportunity costs for the public while failing to address socioeconomic issues at their root.

It is in society’s best interest to pursue policies that mostly improve the aggregate welfare per won expended. Meaning, lawmakers should pass the basic income bill if ― and only if ― there is no better alternative.

This is imperative as wealth transfer mechanisms face the timeless equity-efficiency trade-off.

A former economic adviser to U.S. President Lyndon B. Johnson, Arthur Okun summarizes the trade-off with the “leaky bucket” metaphor. Although policymakers would like to simultaneously grow and divide the economic pie fairly, the two interests are often at odds. Transferring wealth by decree is akin to redistributing water with a leaky bucket.

The leakage primarily represents incentive distortions. Generous welfare tends to discourage individuals from participating in and maximizing contributions towards the labor market. As a result, economic advancement stagnates, and the aggregate welfare growth, too, slows.

On the other hand, proponents argue that basic-income-induced behavioral changes do not distort incentives to the extent that economists fear. Articles such as, “Stockton study shows that universal basic income can be life-changing,” in The Los Angeles Times emphasize positive behavioral observations.

However, we should remain cautious for two reasons.

One, these studies often highlight positive effects of welfare programs in general, not basic income. Case in point, the participants of the aforementioned study are under the median income level, making it inconsistent with the very definition of basic income.

Two, these short-term studies are unable to capture longer-term behavioral changes.

Consider the “Peter Pan Syndrome” in small-medium enterprises (SMEs) ― a long-term observation of Korea’s fiscal intervention. An ample array of supportive policies are available for SMEs. For example, in 2016, Korea’s guaranteed loans for SMEs to GDP was 3,700 percent of the U.S.

Strangely, however, they have repeatedly failed to raise their competitiveness.

A leading hypothesis is that they remain their size to receive generous benefits. To avoid the same fate as the Peter Pan SMEs, we should support carefully designed fiscal interventions, instead of unnecessarily leaky ones, like basic income.

Effective interventions are granular because targeting problems at a fundamental level require an individualized approach.

At the root of modern Korea’s dissatisfaction is the perception of viscous socioeconomic mobility and inequality. This perception is brought forth by the ruthless winner-takes-most environment. To illustrate this institutional problem, consider our labor market and corporate landscape.

Relative to Japan, large firms pay 55 percent more, while SMEs pay significantly less. Moreover, this gap has been widening for decades. On top of this, Korea’s labor market has a sizable ratio of underappreciated irregular and self-employed workers. Unfortunately, this trend is worsening: from 2014 to 2020, the proportion of irregular workers has risen from 33 percent to 37 percent.

Mirroring the stark contrast between large and small firms, the full-time-to-irregular wage gap is substantial. Irregular workers at large firms earn 35 percent less, while those at SMEs earn 75 percent less than their large firm full-time counterparts. Comparably, the monetary conditions of the self-employed are poor.

Deservedly, social assistance should be expanded for irregular and self-employed workers. To this end, vocational training programs must be accessible and modified to aid human capital development dynamically, responding to the rapidly changing demands of the market.

Additionally, SME support programs should take the form of milestones that incentivize meaningful growth. Other policies that target or amend the root cause of structural dualisms should also be considered.

Although an introductory look at the Korean labor market and the corporate landscape showcases only one of many systemic polarizations, it is apparent that these issues cannot be remedied by universal cheques alone.

Basic income is a stimulating food for thought which raises meaningful criticisms of our welfare system. Accordingly, it is perhaps time we widen and deepen our social safety net. Nonetheless, the public should remain pragmatically skeptical of the efficiency and effectiveness of basic income.

Instead of masking structural problems with bandage-like policies, we should continue fostering sophisticated programs that target socioeconomic challenges at a fundamental, systemic level.

Messiness is a feature, not a bug of social welfare.

Koh Woo-sung is a student at Yonsei University.

News Related


LGES, GM to build $2.6 billion EV battery plant in Michigan

LG Energy Solution (LGES) Head of Advanced Automotive Battery Division Kim Dong-myung, left, and General Motors Chair and CEO Mary Barra pose at the Michigan State Capitol in Lansing, Tuesday ... Read more »

Moon hopes for free trade deal with Mexico

This photo shows President Moon Jae-in speaking to his aides at a meeting at Cheong Wa Dae in Seoul on Jan. 10, 2022. (Yonhap)President Moon Jae-in expressed hope Wednesday for ... Read more »

Hyundai Engineering & Construction 2021 net income up 141.3 pct. to 549.5 bln won

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — Hyundai Engineering & Construction Co. on Wednesday reported its 2021 net income of 549.5 billion won (US$458.9 million), up 141.3 percent from a year earlier. ... Read more »

Hyundai E&C turns to black in Q4

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — Hyundai Engineering & Construction Co. on Wednesday reported its fourth-quarter net income of 121.8 billion won (US$101.7 million), swinging from a loss of 122.1 billion ... Read more »

S. Korea's AI defense technologies catching up with US equivalents: report

This photo released by the Korea Research Institute for Defense Technology Planning and Advancement on Wednesday, shows the cover of a new blueprint offering the development strategy of AI technology ... Read more »

Court grants Ahn's request to stop TV debate between Lee, Yoon

From left: Yoon Suk-yeol, Lee Jae-myung and Ahn Cheol-sooA court on Wednesday ruled in favor of minor party presidential candidate Ahn Cheol-soo in a lawsuit he filed to stop TV ... Read more »

Russian stocks open higher on Wednesday

MOEX Index up 2.65% Read more »

US tax credits for wind and solar mostly benefit big banks

Vast wind farms are more likely to be funded than smaller, community-based projects. Joseph Sohm/Shutterstock How can countries build renewable energy at the scale and rate needed to prevent dangerous ... Read more »

Hanwha heir aims to build solar energy ecosystem

By Kim Hyun-bin Hanwha Group has been working to create a comprehensive solar energy ecosystem to transform the conglomerate into a renewable energy powerhouse in the increasingly environment-conscious business world, ... Read more »

Samsung Electro-Mechanics Q4 net profit down 58.7 pct. to 84.7 bln won

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — Samsung Electro-Mechanics Co. on Wednesday reported its fourth-quarter net income of 84.7 billion won (US$70.7 million), down 58.7 percent from a year earlier. The company ... Read more »

Samsung Electro-Mechanics 2021 net income up 46.7 pct. to 915.4 bln won

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — Samsung Electro-Mechanics Co. on Wednesday reported its 2021 net profit of 915.4 billion won (US$764.8 million), up 46.7 percent from a year earlier. The company ... Read more »

Dollar exchange rate up to 78.7 rubles on Moscow Exchange

Euro rises to 89.07 rubles Read more »

Smuggled drugs hit record high in 2021 amid pandemic

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — Drug smuggling caught by South Korea’s customs agency hit a record high last year as trafficking via non-contact delivery means shot up amid the COVID-19 ... Read more »

S. Korea's childbirths at record low in Nov.

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — The number of babies born in South Korea fell to a record low in November last year, data showed Wednesday, underpinning the country’s gloomy demographic ... Read more »

NSC discusses measures over risk of Russia-Ukraine conflict

A view of Cheong Wa Dae in Seoul (Yonhap)The presidential National Security Council (NSC) has discussed tensions between Russia and Ukraine, including how the crisis will affect South Korea’s economy ... Read more »

Kakao Games invests $20 million in US game developer Frost Giant Studios

Kakao Games headquarters in Pangyo, Gyeonggi Province / Courtesy of Kakao Games South Korean game developer Kakao Games Corp. said Wednesday it has invested $20 million in U.S.-based independent game ... Read more »

Samsung's chipmaking plant in Xi'an begins normal operation as China lifts lockdown

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — Samsung Electronics Co. said Wednesday its chipmaking facility in the Chinese city of Xi’an has returned to normal as the city has lifted a lockdown. ... Read more »

Future of beauty and fragrance is at SCAD

Meloney Moore, Associate dean, School of Business Innovation of the Savannah College of Art and Design (SCAD) / Courtesy of SCAD For more than 40 years, the Savannah College of ... Read more »

POSCO International Q4 net profit up 245 pct to 68.4 bln won

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — POSCO International on Wednesday reported its fourth-quarter net profit of 68.4 billion won (US$57.1 million), up 245 percent from a year earlier. The company said ... Read more »

POSCO International 2021 net income up 55.3 pct to 356.5 bln won

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — POSCO International on Wednesday reported its 2021 net profit of 356.5 billion won (US$297.9 million), up 55.3 percent from a year earlier. The company said ... Read more »

Moon to preside over COVID-19 response meeting amid rapid spread of omicron

People wait in line to get tested for COVID-19 at a makeshift testing booth set up at a parking lot of the Jamsil Olympic Stadium in Seoul’s eastern district of ... Read more »

Yoon leads Lee 44.7% to 35.6%: poll

This compilation image shows (from L to R) presidential candidates Lee Jae-myung, Yoon Suk-yeol, Sim Sang-jeung and Ahn Cheol-soo. (Yonhap)Main opposition presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol is leading his ruling party ... Read more »

N. Korea's agricultural ministry elevated to state commission amid food shortages

(Yonhap)North Korea has decided to upgrade its agricultural ministry to a state commission, according to Pyongyang’s media Wednesday, as the country has tapped agricultural development as one of its top ... Read more »

[Contribution] Future of Chinese growth and implications for Korea

Pushan Dutt By Pushan Dutt When economists talk of growth miracles, they refer to countries that grew rapidly and caught up with the level of the development of the U.S. ... Read more »

US remains prepared to engage in dialogue with N. Korea: State Dept.

US Department of State spokesperson Ned Price is seen answering a question in a press briefing at the department in Washington on Tuesday in this image captured from the department’s ... Read more »

Korea's daily COVID-19 cases exceed 13,000 for first time

A health worker wearing protective gear holds plastic gloves for visitors at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus in Seoul, Jan. 25. AP-Yonhap South Korea’s daily coronavirus cases have ... Read more »

Doubts grow over Glenwood PE's exit from PI Advanced Materials

Glenwood Private Equity CEO Lee Sang-ho, left, and PI Advanced Materials CEO Kim Tae-lim By Park Jae-hyuk Glenwood Private Equity is facing growing skepticism over its forthcoming divestment from PI ... Read more »

El Salvador's president uses McDonald's uniform for Twitter profile after bitcoin plunge

Bukele’s new Twitter profile has a reference to an internet meme indicating future career prospects as McDonald’s employees and getting as low as $11 per hour when bitcoin slumps. El ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution, GM to build US$2.6 bln joint EV battery plant in Michigan

By Kim Seung-yeon SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — LG Energy Solution Ltd. (LGES) and General Motors Co. unveiled a US$2.6 billion plan Wednesday to build a new electric vehicle (EV) ... Read more »

US has sanctions on Russia ready in case of escalation with Ukraine

Asked whether he would support expelling Russia from the Swift system of international payments, Deputy Treasury Secretary Wally Adeyemo said: "All options are on the table" Read more »

Twitter creates account at Russian regulator's website under ‘localization' law

Under the new law, overseas Internet companies with a daily audience exceeding 500,000 users must open their authorized representative offices in Russia Read more »

Consumer sentiment up in January amid toughened virus curbs

SEOUL, Jan. 26 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s consumer sentiment improved in January as health authorities’ tough antivirus rules mitigated worries over the spread of the coronavirus, the central bank said ... Read more »

Russian Ambassador: Sanctions may speed Russia and China switching to national currencies

But a complete shift is not expected, Andrey Denisov said Read more »

IMF downgrades forecast for global GDP growth in 2022 to 4.4%

In 2023, the IMF expects growth of 3.8% Read more »

Northern Sea Route may take up to 10% of Suez Canal traffic — Rosatom

According to Deputy CEO of Rosatom Vyacheslav Ruksha, NSR will not compete with transportation over the Suez Canal Read more »

Russian Energy Ministry supports stronger coordination of energy systems

Nikolay Shulginov noted that there was a need to sort out causes of such operation of automatic and control equipment, to prevent outages in future Read more »

Tajikistan to join Central Asian energy system — press secretary

Tajik energy company Barqi Tojik plans to complete activities by the end of 2022 Read more »

Authorities may come to compromise on cryptocurrencies in Russia, lawmaker believes

Head of the State Duma committee on the financial market Anatoly Aksakov suggested that the Bank of Russia, if there are serious arguments, could agree with the option of stricter regulation, rather than a ban Read more »

CNBC Fed Survey forecasts more aggressive Fed, but better economic growth

Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell testifies during a Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee hearing on the CARES Act, at the Hart Senate Office Building in Washington, DC, U.S., ... Read more »

US can limit high tech export to Russia — official

Export control restriction options considered by the US will impair industrialization of Russian economy, the official noted Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic