Banking | The impossible trinity of India's banking policy

Asia's Tech News Daily

#bank ownership, #corporate banks, #India's banking policy, #opinion, #RBI report, #RBI working group, the RBI received 26 applications, received four applications

Last November, a storm brewed in stock markets over an RBI Internal Working Group (IWG) report, constituted to review the ownership structure of Indian Private Sector Banks. The storm was due to one IWG recommendation that the RBI could consider allowing large corporates/industrial houses to become promoters of private banks. A year later, the RBI in a December 2021 press release said that it had accepted 21 of the 33 IWG recommendations, staying silent on the controversial recommendation.

What is it about corporate ownership of banks in India? There is a history which needs to be reviewed to understand the current situation.

Historically, India has been home to moneylenders and indigenous banks, most engaging in commerce and trading. With the advent of British, they started organising both industry and banking under a common roof of the managing agency (MA) system. The first such bank viz. the Bank of Hindustan was organised under an MA by M/s Alexander and Company.

Indians also learnt the trade, and began to organise banking along with industry/commerce. Most of the Indian banks that started in the 19th and early 20th century were under the MA system with industrialists at the helm. It was also fashionable to add industry to the bank name as seen in the case of Syndicate Bank which started as Canara Industrial and Banking Syndicate. Under the MA, banks lent freely, even irresponsibly, to their group companies.

In 1935, the RBI was established, and the regulator prohibited managing agencies in banking. The banks had to reorganise themselves as a separate banking company. However, this did not mean industrialists stopped controlling banks. Industrialists not just remained promoters, but also established banks such as UCO Bank by GD Birla in 1942.

Post-Independence, policymakers expressed concern over corporates controlling the banking sector, and not channelising funds for national development. The bank boards were filled by corporate directors. In 1969, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi nationalised 14 of the largest private banks. Nationalisation sent a strong signal and corporates stayed away from banking.

Following the 1991 economic reforms, in 1993, the government and the RBI decided to license new private banks to bring more competition to the sector. The 1993 guidelines did not explicitly ban corporates/industrial groups from setting banks. They vaguely said that interested corporates should avoid the shortcomings that existed before nationalisation, such as monopolisation of economic power, cross holdings with industrial group, and so on.

Since 1993, the guidelines have been revised multiple times with different views on corporate ownership of banks. In 2001, the RBI barred corporate/industrial houses from owning banks. However, companies connected directly/indirectly with industrial groups could be promoters, provided their equity was limited to 10 percent.

In 2005, the new guidelines allowed corporates to acquire up to 10 percent in private banks by way of strategic investment. In 2013, it was proposed that banks be held by a holding company, and there was no bar on large corporate/industrial house to be promoters.

In 2016, the RBI decided to award bank licenses in a continuous ‘on tap’ basis. It excluded corporates, but allowed them to invest in banks up to 10 percent. In 2020, the IWG suggested corporates to be given licences after ensuring legislation changes to deal with connected lending. Apart from ownership, the guidelines have also raised minimum capital to open banks overtime from Rs 100 crore in 1993 to Rs 1,000 crore in 2021.

The major objective of the new guidelines was to encourage applications, and award new licences. In 1993, the RBI received 143 applications, accepted 21, of which only 10 resumed operations. Of the 10, two banks were promoted by business groups — Times Bank by Bennett Coleman, and IndusInd Bank by the Hinduja Group. Of the 10, four, including Times Bank which merged with the HDFC Bank, failed.

In 2001, two banks were given licenses: Kotak Mahindra Bank fared well, whereas Yes bank went through a major crisis. In 2013, the RBI received 26 applications including from large industrial groups such as Tata Sons, Bajaj Finserv, Aditya Birla Nuvo. The RBI gave license to just two entities: Bandhan Bank, and IDFC Bank. In 2021, the RBI received four applications, but licenses are yet to be given.

The end result has been that the number of private banks has barely increased. We had 654 private banks in 1947; currently there are just 22. Post-1991-reforms, the share of the private sector in banking has increased to around 30 percent with around 26 percent contributed by new private sector banks. This implies that the increase has been concentrated in a few banks, which is contrary to the original (1991) idea of opening up the banking sector. The concentration has also not led to large banks at a global level, which is a long-standing goal of the government.

#bank ownership, #corporate banks, #India's banking policy, #opinion, #RBI report, #RBI working group, the RBI received 26 applications, received four applications

The RBI has tried to work around this growing concentration by giving licences to differentiated private banks. In 1999, the RBI awarded 10 licences to Local Area Banks (LABs), In 2014, it awarded 10 licences to Small Finance Banks (SFBs), and 11 licences to Payment Banks (PBs). However, only the SFBs have been successful with all 10 functional, and one new Unity SFB joining the club recently. The RBI has also received six SFB applications. However, only three LABs and six PBs are functional. As these are small entities, they are unlikely to shake up the sector.

One way to bring more competition could be to encourage foreign banks as they constitute barely 2-3% of banking sector. The policy on this front has been muted but RBI allowing foreign owned DBS Bank to buy Lakshmi Vilas Bank has been welcome.

To sum up, in its banking outlook, the RBI has three goals: competition, scale and financial stability. Achieving this trinity is near impossible, and the RBI has always had to settle for two of these three goals. Under nationalisation, scale and financial stability were chosen. Post-1991, the RBI chose competition and financial stability, giving up scale and corporate participation.

The RBI has wisely not given into the temptation of choosing scale and competition as this would mean squandering financial stability. The discussion on Indian private banks has to also think on how we overcome this trinity.

Amol Agrawal is faculty at Ahmedabad University.

Views are personal and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Reliance Jio Q3 | Tariff hike improves profitability, subscriber base falls on SIM consolidation

File image Reliance Jio beat street estimates on the profitability front in the third quarter while the revenues were in-line with expectations. Revenues for Q3 came in at Rs 19,347 ... Read more »

ESG: Better governance for an authentic identity

Nilanjan Roy, Chief Financial Officer, Infosys, and Vivek Prasad, Markets Leader, PwC India, share their insights on the role of governance in helping businesses become more sustainable, in line with ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Is Omicron losing its sting? 

Omicron | Representative image Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives ... Read more »

Inani Marbles Standalone December 2021 Net Sales at Rs 19.16 crore, up 6.43% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Inani Marbles are: Net Sales at Rs 19.16 crore in December 2021 up 6.43% from Rs. 18.00 crore in December 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

FTSE 100 joins Wall Street sell-off on rate rise and tech stock jitters

Shares in London's leading stock index were more than 100 points lower during Friday trading as the outlook for interest rates in the year ahead and faltering prospects for stay-at-home stocks seized investor attention, Read more »

Talks about extra support for entrepreneurs are still ongoing

Photo: ANP Talks between the Ministry of Economic Affairs and the trade association Koninklijke Horeca Nederland (KHN) and employers’ organizations VNO-NCW and MKB-Nederland about extra corona support for entrepreneurs are ... Read more »

Is Tata cheating, now that the factory appears to be emitting more? You can't just conclude that

Once again there is a critical report from the RIVM about steel manufacturer Tata Steel. More than four months after RIVM researchers reported that harmful amounts of metals (such as ... Read more »

L&T Finance Holdings' net profit rises 12% to Rs 326 crore in December quarter

Representative image L&T Finance Holdings on Friday reported a 12 per cent increase in its net profit to Rs 326 crore for the quarter ended December 2021. The non-banking finance ... Read more »

Govt extends HLL Lifecare bid submission deadline till February 28

Source: Shutterstock The government has extended the deadline by about a month till February 28 for prospective buyers to submit the expression of interest (EoI) for strategic sale-bound HLL Lifecare. ... Read more »

GM renovating NY factory so it can make electric motor parts

LOCKPORT, N.Y. — General Motors says it will spend about $154 million to revamp an aging factory near Buffalo, New York, so it can make a key part for electric ... Read more »

Unilever will not raise rejected 50 bn pound bid for GSK consumer arm

Unilever PLC on Wednesday effectively abandoned its plans to buy GlaxoSmithKline’s consumer healthcare business, saying that it would not raise its 50 billion pound ($68 billion) offer that GSK previously ... Read more »

Gokaldas Export Standalone December 2021 Net Sales at Rs 520.18 crore, up 96.67% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Gokaldas Exports are: Net Sales at Rs 520.18 crore in December 2021 up 96.67% from Rs. 264.49 crore in December 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

Technical View | Nifty forms large bearish candle on weekly charts, expert say pullback possible

Technical View The Nifty continued to see a sharp correction for the fourth consecutive session on January 21 amid consistent selling by FIIs, inflation concerns and caution ahead of the ... Read more »

Bandhan Bank Q3 Results: Net profit jumps 35.7% YoY to Rs 859 crore

Operating profit increased by 1.4 percent YoY to Rs 1,950.1 crore. Bandhan Bank on January 21 posted a net profit of Rs 859 crore for the third quarter of financial year ... Read more »

Vatican appeals court upholds convictions of ex-bank chiefs

ROME — A Vatican appeals court has upheld the convictions of two former managers of the Vatican bank and ordered them to pay back some 40 million euros from bad ... Read more »

Cadila re-appoints Sharvil P Patel as MD for another five-year term

Cadila Healthcare on Friday said it has re-appointed Sharvil P Patel as Managing Director of the company for a period of five years with effect from April 1, 2022. The ... Read more »

Budget 2022: What's in store for Indian Railways?   

Indian Railways. Representative image. Expanding Vande Bharat train sets, innovating new wagons, including one specifically targeted at carrying lightweight cargo from small businesses and promotion of new technologies like Hypeloop ... Read more »

Market selloff: Investors lose Rs 10.36 lakh crore in 4 days

Representative image Investors have become poorer by over Rs 10.36 lakh crore in the last four trading sessions as the domestic equity benchmarks extended their losses amid weak global trends. ... Read more »

How long does it take to migrate Magento 1 to 2?

Online store owners have been worried about Magento’s upgrade to Magento 2 for a long time now, and they have expressed their fears in a lot of ways. This is ... Read more »

Can Thane's home prices ever rival Mumbai's?

Representative image. In a messy divorce case, the man and the woman traded various nasty allegations. The man alleged that the woman misled him from the very beginning. He thundered ... Read more »

Akshay Kumar buys apartment in Mumbai for Rs 7.8 crore

Akshay Kumar had sold an office for Rs 9 crore in December 2021. Actor Akshay Kumar has bought an apartment in Mumbai for Rs 7.8 crore, documents accessed by showed. The ... Read more »

Budget 2022 | Three expectations for food processing and agribusiness

Representative image: AP The agriculture sector is one of the mainstays of the economy, with approximately half of India’s working population involved in the sector. Interestingly, the percentage share of ... Read more »

Budget 2022 | Support to real estate sector will positively impact entire economy

The year 2022 is dubbed as a year of opportunity for the real estate industry. As per estimates, the economy is expected to grow steadily at 8-9 percent, stimulating demand ... Read more »

PVR says January, February will be muted due to deferred releases, bets big on March

The recent spike in coronavirus cases and the spread of the more infectious Omicron variant is a cause of concern for exhibitors, including multiplex operator PVR which is expecting low business ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Rural demand fails to shape up. Will the Budget step up?

Representative Image (Source: Reuters) Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives ... Read more »

Rattan Power Standalone December 2021 Net Sales at Rs 804.79 crore, up 164.86% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for RattanIndia Power are: Net Sales at Rs 804.79 crore in December 2021 up 164.86% from Rs. 303.86 crore in December 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

PVR consolidated loss narrows to Rs 10.2 crore in Q3

Multiplex chain operator PVR Ltd on Friday reported narrowing of its consolidated loss after tax at Rs 10.2 crore for the third quarter ended December 2021, on the back of ... Read more »

Pil Italica Standalone December 2021 Net Sales at Rs 19.50 crore, up 4.1% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Pil Italica Lifestyle are: Net Sales at Rs 19.50 crore in December 2021 up 4.1% from Rs. 18.73 crore in December 2020. Quarterly Net Profit ... Read more »

Taking Stock | Market recovers but not enough, ends lower for the fourth day

Indian equity benchmarks continue to be spooked by surging bond yields, FII selling and mixed global cues as both the indices slumped for the fourth consecutive day on January 21, ... Read more »

Moneycontrol PRO & Espresso present Nifty Banker 2.0 on Friday, 21st January, at 8 pm, with Arjun Bhatia on “How to Trade Bank Nifty for a living”

Nifty Banker 3 | Representative image In this third Nifty Banker 2.0 webinar, watch Arjun Bhatia, Founder, share insights on ‘How to Trade Bank Nifty for a living’ Click ... Read more »

Inox Leisure reports Q3 net loss of Rs 1.32 crore

Multiplex chain operator Inox Leisure Ltd on Friday reported narrowing of its consolidated net loss at Rs 1.32 crore for the third quarter ended December 2021 as the film exhibition ... Read more »

Explainer | Artificial Intelligence, and its impact on advertising

Representational image. Srivibhu Timmaraju and K Rajeshwari “Artificial Intelligence is a tool, not a threat”: Rodney Brooks, Professor of Robotics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Ever been in a situation where ... Read more »

‘I don't like to play first violin'

Marietta: „I am a violin maker. Crazy that it’s called that, because I also make cellos and violas. And I don’t build much anyway. Most of the time I repair ... Read more »

RIL Q3 Results Highlights | Consolidated EBITDA at Rs 33,886 crore, oil & gas segment revenue up 493.7% YoY; 'stellar performance', says Mukesh Ambani

RIL Q3 Results Highlights | “I am happy to announce that Reliance has posted yet another quarter of stellar performance in 3Q FY22. We have delivered record operational results with strong ... Read more »

Moldova's Prime Minister calls Gazprom's demand to pay off debt ‘unfriendly move'

According to Natalia Gavrilita, Gazprom could "find a commercial solution" Read more »

Tork Kratos finally launches on January 26. Here's what we know so far

Tork Kratos is set for launch on January 26 with bookings expected to begin in March. The electric vehicle (EV) segment seems to be powering on in India even as ... Read more »

World Economic Forum has new date for summit in Davos

Photo: ANP The organizers of the World Economic Forum (WEF) have set a new date for the international summit. It will now be held in the Swiss ski village of ... Read more »

Borrow, borrow, then also pay, pay

While he provided a number of loans to his own BV a year earlier, totaling €400,000. The tax authorities therefore also charge him for those 4 tons plus €35,000 in ... Read more »

Bitcoin Continues Down, Drops Below $39,000

Photo: ANP Bitcoin’s value continued to fall on Friday. The digital currency fell almost 9 percent to USD 38,950 (EUR 34,390). That is the lowest level in more than five ... Read more »

EU complaints against Russian lumber export restrictions not justified — Economy Ministry

Russian representatives "intend to give exhaustive clarifications in respect of applied measures" within the framework of consultations on the WTO floor, the ministry’s press service said Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic