Bad air crisis: SC asks 5 states to file reports on what they've done to curb pollution

Bad air crisis: SC asks 5 states to file reports on what they’ve done to curb pollution
© Provided by The Print

New Delhi: The central government Monday sought the Supreme Court’s intervention in the “interest of justice” and “the emerging need to improve air quality”, as it urged the top court to seek compliance reports from five states/UTs — Delhi (UT), Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan — on directives issued by a commission set up to control rising air pollution levels in Delhi.

The Commission for Air Quality Management was constituted after the dissolution of the Supreme Court-appointed EPCA [Environment Pollution (Prevention & Control) Authority] in October 2020, with an objective to coordinate better with states neighbouring and close to Delhi, and find a resolution to air quality issues in the National Capital Region and adjoining areas.

In an affidavit filed in response to 19-year-old Aditya Dubey’s petition on rising air pollution in Delhi, the environment ministry sought the SC’s intervention for “effective implementation” of the commission’s directives to the five states. The five states, it said, have either not complied or have partially complied with the orders.

Taking note of the Centre’s submissions, the court asked the five states to file their affidavits to show compliance with the commission’s orders. An explanation was also sought from the Centre on an allegation made by the petitioner that construction work of Central Vista continued despite the top court’s order prohibiting construction activity in Delhi.

‘Certain shortcomings’

The affidavit listed out “45 directions and seven advisories” issued by the commission in the last 10 months, beginning December 2020, asking the five states to initiate “important steps” in various sectors to prevent deterioration of air quality.

The Centre told the court that during the monitoring of the status of the directions, certain shortcomings were found in the implementation of the same by the respective states.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said although non-compliance with the commission’s directives can lead to the initiation of criminal proceedings, the former has not done that so far.

On its part, the central government told the SC the commission is “regularly and scrupulously” monitoring and ensuring compliance with its directions. The affidavit enumerated data received from different states on action taken by local authorities under areas identified by the commission.

But on the ground, there are reports of “certain shortcomings”, it said. “Thus, in the interest of justice and in interest of the emergent need to improve the air quality in the region, it is respectfully submitted that the respective state governments may be directed to submit its compliance report,” the affidavit said.

According to the central government, in August this year, the states of Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Rajasthan were told to shift industries operating in the NCR districts to cleaner fuels or PNG. “It is submitted that as per the data received by the commission the said direction is either partly complied with or still remains to be complied with,” the affidavit read.

Furthermore, the industries that already have gas supply available to them, but are still using other polluting fuels, were directed to move to cleaner fuel at the earliest. Even on this account, the central government claimed, states have either partly complied or not complied at all.

The central government also asked the SC to call for the status on implementation of the commission’s other directions, including a ban on the use of diesel generator sets, and impounding of petrol and diesel vehicles that are more than 15 years and 10 years old, respectively, and still found plying in the NCR.

On perusal of the document, a bench led by Chief Justice of India N.V. Ramana remarked: “This commission is there for the purpose of preventing pollution. But the commission has been simply forwarding the court orders to states.”

The bench, also comprising justices D.Y. Chandrachud and Surya Kant, added there was non-compliance of directions on the part of the five states. “We will seek answers from them, otherwise, we will create an independent task force,” the court observed orally.

Also read: A solution to stubble burning that gets to its root cause

Delhi should submit status report on bus fleet, Centre says

With regard to Delhi, the Centre added, a status report on the implementation of the greening and plantation action plan should be called for.

It said urgent steps are required to be taken to augment the bus fleet that has come down by 50 per cent of what operated in 2010. The number of buses had come down from 6,000 in 2010 to 3,000 in the last decade, it said. According to a Supreme Court judgment, it added, it should have been augmented to 11,000.

To improve last-mile connectivity in Delhi and boost the transport system, the Centre said the cap on registration of autorickshaws should be removed. According to an earlier SC order, more than one lakh autorickshaws cannot be registered in Delhi.

In response to the Centre’s assessment on the number of buses, Delhi Government counsel, senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, said it was “alarmingly false”. He assured the court the Union territory would provide all details to it in the form of an affidavit and claimed the government had started a special bus service for its employees.

(Edited by Neha Mahajan)

Also read: Why November has brought back Delhi pollution with a vengeance after ‘cleaner’ October

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Human remains found decades ago now tied to 1970s cold case

© Office of the District Attorney County of Riverside Linda LeBeau went missing in 1977, remains found in 1986 have now been identified as belonging to her – Office of ... Read more »

'Title race is on' - Liverpool fans say same thing after Man City draw at Southampton

Liverpool have been handed a new lease of life in the Premier League title race after Manchester City dropped points on Saturday evening. After 12 straight victories, City had to ... Read more »

Nusrat Ghani: Tory MP says she was told she was fired because of her ‘Muslimness’

A Tory MP has accused a Government whip of telling her that she was sacked from her ministerial post because her Muslim faith was “making colleagues uncomfortable”. Nusrat Ghani lost ... Read more »

Mother of alleged NYPD cop killer speaks on ‘distorted' mind of son after Harlem shooting

The mother of the gunman who allegedly killed an NYPD cop and critically injured another in Harlem told The Post Saturday her son is mentally ill. “His mental state is ... Read more »

KMC: Covid vax at home for senior citizens

© Provided by The Statesman KMC: Covid vax at home for senior citizens In the wake of requests from citizens to vaccinate senior citizens at their residence since many are ... Read more »

Congress seeks judicial probe into Mandi hooch tragedy

© Provided by Hindustan Times Addressing a press conference, Himachal Pradesh Congress Committee (HPCC) spokesperson Naresh Chauhan said that a sitting judge of the high court should conduct the inquiry ... Read more »

Mbappe asked Ibrahimovic if he should join Real Madrid - and AC Milan star advised him to leave PSG

© Getty Gianluigi Donnarumma PSG Zlatan Ibrahimovic has revealed that he was approached for career advice by Kylian Mbappe – and told him to leave Paris Saint-Germain for Real Madrid. ... Read more »

Himachal government shielding liquor mafia: Mukesh Agnihotri

© Provided by Hindustan Times Leader of Opposition Mukesh Agnihotri alleged that the Himachal government was sheltering the liquor mafia. (AP File Photo/ Representational image) Leader of Opposition Mukesh Agnihotri ... Read more »

Himachal logs 2,216 fresh Covid cases, 6 deaths; Solan reports highest infections

© Provided by Hindustan Times Kangra is the worst-hit district in Himachal with 58,112 Covid cases reported since the pandemic outbreak in March 2020. Highest 359 cases were reported from ... Read more »

Majithia's sand-mining allegations against me out of revenge: Channi

© Provided by Hindustan Times In reply to Majithia’s allegations, Punjab chief minister Charanjit Singh Channi categorically denied any link with his nephew Bhupinder Singh Honey’s activities and the money-laundering ... Read more »

Tanak retires from Monte Carlo as Hyundai's “tough” WRC Rally1 debut worsens

The Korean marque endured a day to forget as all three of its drivers struck trouble during Saturday’s five stages, leaving only two cars remaining to fight for the minor ... Read more »

Packers vs. 49ers prediction: Green Bay will show why it's top seed

Saturday GREEN BAY PACKERS (-5.5) over San Francisco 49ers Like so many others, we’ve enjoyed the recent positive ride QB Jimmy Garoppolo has provided to the San Fran contingent. Bully ... Read more »

ITV Masked Singer fans all guessing same celebrity for Traffic Cone that judges haven't guessed yet

This year’s series of The Masked Singer is now in full swing, and it is already washing the January blues well and truly away. The quirky ITV singing competition sees ... Read more »

Masked Singer's Poodle unmasked as Keane singer Tom Chaplin in vote-off

The Masked Singer UK fans learned Poodle was Keane singer Tom Chaplin on the ITV series on Saturday night. The character became the latest to be unmasked on the hit ... Read more »

Mom Finds Internet Fame for Looking Just Like Super-Strong Encanto Character: 'I Was Shocked'

Shortly after the release of Disney’s Encanto, TikToker Maribel Martinez soon saw the similarities between her and one of the movie’s larger-than-life characters. Now Martinez, a 23-year-old mom of two, ... Read more »

Some Evive Smoothies Are Being Recalled Because They May Cause Cyanide Poisoning

An Evive smoothie recall is in effect right now in Canada because there’s a risk of cyanide poisoning with the product. © Provided by Narcity On January 21, a notice ... Read more »

Adele's Las Vegas concerts derailed after series of explosive rows about staging

ADELE’s dramatic cancellation of her Las Vegas concerts came after a series of explosive rows about the staging derailed the production. The superstar left fans — some of whom had ... Read more »

Five players to watch in AFCON knockout stages

© Kenzo Tribouillard Jim Allevinah has scored twice for a Gabon side deprived of star man Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang As the Africa Cup of Nations heads into the knockout phase, AFP ... Read more »

'I love Ryan as a character' - Praise for Irish international after match-winning display

© Alamy Stock Photo Ryan Manning r of Swansea City celebrates after scoring. SWANSEA HEAD coach Russell Martin hailed the character of match-winner Ryan Manning after the wing-back’s super strike ... Read more »

Ukrainisches Aussenministerium beruft deutsche Botschafterin ein

© Keystone/ZB/Bernd Wüstneck Vor dem Hintergrund des Ukraine-Konflikts hat ein führender deutscher Militär mit Aussagen zu Russland für Irritation gesorgt. Der Vizeadmiral und Chef der Deutschen Marine, Kay-Achim Schönbach, äusserte ... Read more »

How misidentifying an Asian man led to a false murder conviction and a movement

Nearly 50 years after a Korean immigrant was wrongfully convicted of a gangland murder in San Francisco’s Chinatown, longtime journalists Julie Ha and Eugene Yi have joined forces as co-directors ... Read more »

Video Shows Staff Pinning Teen Down for 30 Mins in Cell Before He Died

© Provided by The Daily Beast YouTube/Sedgwick County Communications Footage released late Friday by authorities in Sedgwick County, Kansas shows employees of a county juvenile center holding a 17-year-old boy ... Read more »

German navy chief Schönbach resigns over comments on Putin, Crimea

© Provided by DW Vice-admiral Kay-Achim Schönbach said the West could give Vladimir Putin respect Germany faced a diplomatic incident on Saturday following comments made by Navy chief Kay-Achim Schönbach ... Read more »

Mahatma's favourite hymn ‘Abide With Me' dropped from Beating Retreat

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Mahatma Gandhi’s favourite hymn ‘Abide with Me’ has been dropped from the Beating Retreat ceremony on January 29 this year, in ... Read more »

Flats for Punjab, Haryana officials: Chandigarh admn may shelve project

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Chandigarh Housing Board has already finalised the architectural plans for the project, which is to come up on 6.73 acres at IT Park. (HT FIle Photo) ... Read more »

The best baby gifts: From practical items to beautiful pieces that will be treasured forever

Whether you’re looking for a baby shower gift, a special something to celebrate bub’s arrival or perhaps an item for a Christening, if you’re stuck for a gift idea for ... Read more »

How we reconcile reality TV stars' alleged moral transgressions

© Provided by ABC NEWS Jerry Harris was a breakout star of Netflix’s docuseries Cheer, before being arrested by the FBI. (Getty images: Jim Spellman) The downfall of a protagonist is ... Read more »

Ana de Armas' Fans File Lawsuit After She Was Cut From 'Yesterday'

© Provided by US Weekly Ana de Armas’ Fans File Lawsuit After She Was Cut from ‘Yesterday’ After Appearing in Trailer Not pleased. After a pair of fans rented Yesterday, expecting ... Read more »

Punjab polls: 43% voters in Mohali below the age of 40

With the Punjab assembly elections scheduled on February 20, a look at the demographic profile of Mohali district, which comprises three assembly seats – Mohali, Kharar, and Dera Bassi, shows ... Read more »

Residents in a troubled group of Palmerston rental properties were warned to evacuate if a cyclone struck

© Provided by ABC Business Lori Montgomery moved into one of the properties in 2017. (ABC News: Michael Franchi) Families living in a group of troubled affordable rentals in Greater ... Read more »

Andy Cohen and Ralph Fiennes debate over a popular children's book

He is well-known for having extended conversations with various celebrities on his talk show, Watch What Happens Live! And on Friday, Andy Cohen showed that he was able to connect ... Read more »

‘Looting-While-Moving' Apex Legends Console Trick Explained

PC players in Apex Legends have long had the luxury of being able to loot death boxes while moving, whereas console players have a harder time performing such a technique. ... Read more »

Fnatic run down Misfits, join Rogue as only undefeated teams after 2022 LEC Spring Split Week 2

© Provided by Dot Esports Once more, Fnatic overcame a major obstacle in their start to the 2022 LEC Spring Split—and in doing so, become one of two teams to ... Read more »

Teck Resources announces new contract with union at British Columbia mine

(Reuters) – Canadian miner Teck Resources Ltd said on Saturday that members of a union representing 1,048 workers at its British Columbia mine have ratified a new five-year collective agreement. ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas 'want more kids'

© Bang Showbiz Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas want more children Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas hope to have “at least two children”. The 39-year-old actress recently announced the arrival ... Read more »

Ex-Yankee Sergio Mitre convicted of murdering child, sentenced to 50 years in prison

Sergio Mitre, who pitched in parts of eight major league seasons and won a World Series ring with the 2009 Yankees, likely will spend the rest of his life in ... Read more »

Look: Aaron Rodgers Shares Honest Admission Before Packers-49ers Game

© Provided by The Spun Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers. It’s no secret that before this season, Aaron Rodgers was always a bit more reserved. He never said too ... Read more »

Joe Burrow's speech before Bengals vs. Titans had team fired up and went viral

© Provided by Bengals Wire The Cincinnati Bengals have plenty of confidence going into the divisonal round against the Tennessee Titans. Joe Burrow and Co., after all, conquered a 31-year drought ... Read more »

Steven Gerrard told to complete Aston Villa transfer for Champions League midfielder

Aston Villa are reportedly interested in signing Juventus midfielder Rodrigo Bentancur. Steven Gerrard is keen to strengthen his squad before the January transfer window slams shut in nine days’ time. ... Read more »

Cincinnati Bengals inactive players vs. Tennessee Titans in playoffs

© File photo Jan 15, 2022; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Bengals free safety Jessie Bates (30) celebrates during the fourth quarter in an AFC Wild Card playoff football game against ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic