Author Bruce Pascoe’s best-selling Aboriginal history book Dark Emu ‘debunked’
Dark Emu author Bruce Pascoe. Picture: Luke BowdenSource:News Corp Australia
An influential Australian bestseller that painted a radically different view of Aboriginal history prior to colonisation has been “debunked” in a “damning” new book by two respected academics.
Dark Emu, author Bruce Pascoe’s smash hit 2014 book that argued Indigenous Australians were not just hunter-gatherers but engaged in agriculture, irrigation and construction, won numerous literary prizes, was adapted into a stage performance by Aboriginal dance company Bangarra and has even made its way into school curriculums.
Pascoe’s claims – including that Aboriginal people built homes, villages, parks, dams and wells, selected seeds for harvesting, sewed clothes, ploughed fields, irrigated crops and preserved food in vessels – have long come under fire from right-wing critics, including the magazine Quadrant and Herald Sun columnist Andrew Bolt.
Other experts have also raised doubts, including Australian National University anthropologist Ian Keen, who described the evidence for farming as “deeply problematic”, and renowned historian Geoffrey Blainey, who said there was “no evidence that there was ever a permanent town in pre-1788 Australia with 1000 inhabitants who gained most of their food by farming”, as claimed in Dark Emu.
Now two leading experts – anthropologist Peter Sutton and archaeologist Keryn Walshe – have taken aim at Pascoe in a new book, Farmers or Hunter-Gatherers? The Dark Emu Debate, set to be released by Melbourne University Press next week.
Author and journalist Stuart Rintoul, writing in The Sydney Morning Herald’s Good Weekend magazine on Saturday, described their rebuttal to Dark Emu as “damning”.
Bruce Pascoe’s Dark Emu has won numerous awards.Source:News Regional Media
“In page after page, Sutton and Walshe accuse Pascoe of a ‘lack of true scholarship’, ignoring Aboriginal voices, dragging respect for traditional Aboriginal culture back into the Eurocentric world of the colonial era, and ‘trimming’ colonial observations to fit his argument,” Rintoul writes.
“They write that while Dark Emu ‘purports to be factual’ it is ‘littered with unsourced material, is poorly researched, distorts and exaggerates many points, selectively emphasises evidence to suit those opinions, and ignores large bodies of information that do not support the author’s opinions’.”
The highly respected academics, who have both spent their careers studying Aboriginal history, write that Dark Emu is “actually not, properly considered, a work of scholarship” and that “its success as a narrative has been achieved in spite of its failure as an account of fact”.
“Pascoe’s approach appears to resemble the old Eurocentric view held by the British conquerors of Aboriginal society,” Dr Sutton writes in the book, according to extracts published by Good Weekend.
“Those were the people who organised mass theft of Aboriginal country and many of whom justified the killing of Aborigines who resisted them, really out of greed and indifference, but often under an ideological flag of social evolutionism. They assumed they had a right to profit from the ‘survival of the fittest’ and were the ‘superior race’. The ‘less advanced’ had to make way for the ‘more advanced’. Pascoe risks taking us back to that fatal shore by resurrecting the interpretation of differing levels of complexity and differing extents of intervention in the environment as degrees of advancement and evolution and cleverness and sophistication.”
Bruce Pascoe reads Dark Emu to Glebe Public School students. Picture: Dylan RobinsonSource:News Corp Australia
He told Good Weekend that the pair began working on a response to Dark Emu in 2019 in order to “set things back to a balanced truthfulness” and “restore the dignity of complex (never ‘mere’) hunter-gathering, and thus First Nations cultural history, that has been eroded due to Dark Emu”.
Dr Walshe, meanwhile, said that when she first tried to read Dark Emu, she was so frustrated by its lack of scholarship that she didn’t finish it.
“I still struggle to believe that this has happened,” she told Good Weekend.
In a written response, Pascoe told the magazine that his book had “encouraged many Australians to recognise the ingenuity and sophistication of the many Aboriginal cultures, societies and land-management practices, which had not previously been brought to mainstream attention”.
“The extent of Aboriginal social and economic organisation has been surprising to many Australians and a nuanced debate needs to be ongoing,” he said, adding it would be “disappointing” if Australia’s understanding of Aboriginal history “digressed to a limiting debate about semantics and nomenclature”.
“Hunter-gatherer and farmer are both settler/colonial labels, and the long prevailing negative interpretation of hunter-gatherer has been used as a weapon against Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples (as a justification for terra nullius),” he said.
“Language can be used to help people to see the world differently, to open minds to new ways of seeing. This is what I tried to achieve with Dark Emu.”
A crew member of the BBC California. Picture: Trevor Collens / AFPSource:AFP Three healthy crew members from a coronavirus-infected cargo ship docked in Perth have been moved to hotel quarantine for their safety, but a fourth person remains on-board with the sick people. West Australian health authorities said the fourth ...
New locally acquired cases have been recorded in Victoria. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Ian CurrieSource:News Corp Australia Victoria has recorded 12 new locally acquired cases of Covid-19 on Saturday. In ... Read more »
Carrie Bickmore and Norman Swan on The Project. Picture: Channel 10.Source:Supplied A health expert has told The Project’s Carrie Bickmore that New South Wales “might not get over” its current ... Read more »
Prime Minister Scott Morrison. Picture: Gary RamageSource:News Corp Australia Backlash against the prime minister has grown overnight with Scott Morrison the topic of conversation from Australian screens to the UK. ... Read more »
Kandasamy and Kumuthini Kannan were jailed on Wednesday. Picture: Andrew Henshaw/NCA NewsWireSource:News Corp Australia Kumuthini Kannan sat rocking in her chair on Wednesday, the same way she had on numerous ... Read more »
.Source:News Regional Media The Press Council considered whether its Standards of Practice were breached by an article published by the Herald Sun online on 21 January 2021 headed “Mill Park ... Read more »
Centrelink at Modbury has become one of the latest Covid-19 exposure locations, listed by SA Health. Picture: Scott Barbour/Getty ImagesSource:Supplied A busy Centrelink office in Adelaide’s north eastern suburbs is ... Read more »
Katie Hopkins takes to Instagram Live to criticise harsh lockdowns as she quarantines in Sydney.Source:Supplied Katie Hopkins has blasted Australia’s handling of the pandemic to her large international following, declaring ... Read more »
Farmer Sam Messina.Source:Supplied Farmer Wants a Wife star Sam Messina has strongly denied seven alleged domestic violence offences against a former girlfriend. A Current Affair reported the bombshell allegations last ... Read more »
A Sydney woman was forced to endure a traumatic procedure without her husband.Source:Supplied A Sydney woman who miscarried twins is among a growing cohort of women who say their treatment ... Read more »
The PM insists AstraZeneca is ‘totally safe’, highlighting it has been given the ‘seal of approval’ from the TGA. Picture: Nikki Short / NCA NewsWireSource:News Corp Australia Prime Minister Scott ... Read more »
Former UTS professor Dianne Jolley has been found guilty of sending herself a bizarre series of fake threats. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Jeremy PiperSource:News Corp Australia A high-ranking Sydney academic ... Read more »
A man was wounded in a daylight shooting in Newcastle on Thursday, officials have said. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Gaye GerardSource:News Corp Australia Newcastle police have asked the public to ... Read more »
The school teaches degrees, certificates and diplomas related to music and speech. Picture: iStockSource:istock A music school in one of Melbourne’s wealthiest suburbs is embroiled in a 17-month court battle ... Read more »
Case numbers continue to soar. Picture: Rachael Tosh-ProvanSource:NCA NewsWire Any “adjustments” to restrictions may be outlined on July 31 when Sydney’s lockdown is due to end, but as case numbers ... Read more »
The new case numbers have been revealed. Picture: NCA Newswire /Gaye GerardSource:News Corp Australia NSW recorded 124 new virus cases overnight as the state continues to grapple with the latest ... Read more »
NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian.Source:Supplied NSW Premier Gladys says beating Delta is almost impossible and the only way NSW opens up fully again is when the “majority are vaccinated”. NSW recorded ... Read more »
No place for crackpots … journalist and author Ross Coulthart is investigating the UFO/UAP phenomenon.Source:News Corp Australia Australia has a long history of encounters with unexplained aerial objects, stretching from ... Read more »
CANBERRA, AUSTRALIA – NewsWire Photos JULY 21, 2021: Prime Minister Scott Morrison addresses the media at a press conference at The Lodge. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Gary RamageSource:News Corp Australia ... Read more »
Prime Minister Scott Morrison has come under pressure over the vaccine rollout. Picture: Gary Ramage / NCA NewsWireSource:News Corp Australia The Prime Minister’s “constant appeal” to the vaccine advisory group ... Read more »
Queensland Chief Health Officer Jeannette Young says despite Covid-19 restrictions easing in the southeast, she remains concerned about the risk of the Delta variant. Picture: NCA Newswire / Dan PeledSource:News ... Read more »
South Australia’s Covid-19 outbreak has risen to 14 infections. Picture: NCA NewsWire / David MariuzSource:News Corp Australia South Australian residents who are required to quarantine after getting Covid-19 tested and ... Read more »
NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian has had her call for more Pfizer doses rejected. Picture: Mick Tsikas-Pool/Getty ImagesSource:Getty Images NSW Health has detected fragments of the virus that causes Covid-19 at ... Read more »