Australia's two largest states trial facial recognition software to police pandemic rules

FILE PHOTO: Personnel from the Australian Defence Force and New South Wales Police Force patrol a street in Sydney’s Bankstown suburb during an outbreak of the coronavirus disease

By Byron Kaye

SYDNEY (Reuters) – Australia's two most populous states are trialling facial recognition software that lets police check people are home during COVID-19 quarantine, expanding trials that have sparked controversy to the vast majority of the country's population.

Little-known tech firm Genvis Pty Ltd said on a website for its software that New South Wales (NSW) and Victoria, home to Sydney, Melbourne and more than half of Australia's 25 million population, were trialling its facial recognition products. Genvis said the trials were being conducted on a voluntary basis.

The Perth, Western Australia-based startup developed the software in 2020 with WA state police to help enforce pandemic movement restrictions, and has said it hopes to sell its services abroad.

South Australia state began trialling a similar, non-Genvis technology last month, sparking warnings from privacy advocates around the world about potential surveillance overreach. The involvement of New South Wales and Victoria, which have not disclosed that they are trialling facial recognition technology, may amplify those concerns.

NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian said in an email the state was “close to piloting some home quarantine options for returning Australians”, without directly responding to questions about Genvis facial recognition software. Police in NSW referred questions to the state premier.

Victoria Police referred questions to the Victorian Health department, which did not respond to requests for comment.

Under the system being trialled, people respond to random check-in requests by taking a 'selfie' at their designated home quarantine address. If the software, which also collects location data, does not verify the image against a “facial signature”, police may follow up with a visit to the location to confirm the person's whereabouts.

Though the technology has been used in WA since last November, it has more recently been pitched as a tool to enable the country to reopen its borders, ending a system in place since the start of the pandemic that requires international arrivals to spend two weeks in hotel quarantine under police guard.

Aside from the pandemic, police forces have expressed interest in using facial recognition software, prompting a backlash from rights groups about the potential to target minority groups.

While the recognition technology has been used in countries like China, no other democracy has been reported as considering its use in connection with coronavirus containment procedures.


Genvis Chief Executive Kirstin Butcher declined to comment on the trials, beyond the disclosures on the product website.

“You can't have home quarantine without compliance checks, if you're looking to keep communities safe,” she said in a phone interview.

“You can't perform physical compliance checks at the scale needed to support (social and economic) re-opening plans so technology has to be used.”

But rights advocates warned the technology may be inaccurate, and may open the window for law enforcement agencies to use people's data for other purposes without specific laws stopping them.

“I'm troubled not just by the use here but by the fact this is an example of the creeping use of this sort of technology in our lives,” said Toby Walsh, a professor of Artificial Intelligence at University of NSW.

Walsh questioned the reliability of facial recognition technology in general, which he said could be hacked to give false location reports.

“Even if it works here … then it validates the idea that facial recognition is a good thing,” he said. “Where does it end?”

The government of Western Australia has said it banned police from using data collected by COVID-related software for non-COVID matters. The WA police say they have put 97,000 people through home quarantine, using facial recognition, without incident.

“The law should prevent a system for monitoring quarantine being used for other purposes,” said Edward Santow, a former Australian Human Rights Commissioner who now leads an artificial intelligence ethics project at University of Technology, Sydney.

“Facial recognition technology might seem like a convenient way to monitor people in quarantine but … if something goes wrong with this technology, the risk of harm is high.”

(Reporting by Byron Kaye; Editing by Kenneth Maxwell)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


'Tourists negligent about following Covid-19 prevention SOP'

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA BERANG: Tourists in the state have been negligent in adhering to the Covid-19 prevention Standard Operating Procedures (SOP) especially when taking part in ... Read more »

Austrians turn on ex-chancellor's party after corruption claims

© Reuters/LEONHARD FOEGER FILE PHOTO: Former Chancellor Kurz attends a session of the Austrian parliament in Vienna ZURICH (Reuters) – Austrians have turned on the conservative Austrian People’s Party (OVP), ... Read more »

Erdogan says talks under way with US to buy F-16s

© HO Turkey is looking to upgrade its fleet of warplanes President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Sunday said Turkey was in talks with the United States to buy F-16 fighters ... Read more »

Kerala Floods: Rains to Continue Till Evening, 105 Relief Camps Set up; Red Alert Issued for Dams

© Provided by News18 Kerala Floods: Rains to Continue Till Evening, 105 Relief Camps Set up; Red Alert Issued for Dams A total of 105 relief camps have been set ... Read more »

BSP leader RS Kushwaha, former party MP Kadir Rana join Samajwadi Party ahead of UP polls

BSP leader RS Kushwaha, former party MP Kadir Rana join Samajwadi Party ahead of UP polls Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) leader RS Kushwaha and former party MP Kadir Rana have ... Read more »

Singhu border murder case: All three accused sent to six-day police custody

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: In the latest development to the Singhu border killing, the Sonipat Court on Sunday (October 17, 2021) sent all the three accused, connected ... Read more »

Punjab govt's "5 marla land" card scheme meant to "deceive" people, alleges Sisodia

© Provided by The Statesman Punjab govt’s Senior AAP leader and Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia said on Saturday that the present Charanjit Singh Channi-led Congress government in Punjab ... Read more »

7 wounded, 1 dead in Mitchell's Plain drive-by shooting

© Provided by Eyewitness News CAPE TOWN – A woman has been killed in an attack in which eight people, including three children, were shot in Mandalay, in Cape Town. ... Read more »

Ensure strict adherence of Covid norms: HP CEO to officials

© Provided by The Statesman Ensure strict adherence of Covid norms: HP CEO to officials Himachal Pradesh Chief Electoral Officer C Paulrasu on Friday said strict instructions have been issued ... Read more »

IBPS RRB office assistant main exam held: What's next?

The institute of banking personnel selection (IBPS) conducted the main exam for office assistant post in regional rural banks (RRBs) today, October 17. After this, the IBPS RRB main exam ... Read more »

Zoë Foster Blake at Sydney beach with husband Hamish and their brood

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo She made her debut on Australia’s 2020 Young Rich List and is worth an estimated $36million.    And on Sunday, Zoë Foster Blake, 41, ... Read more »

No end in sight to volcanic eruption on Spain's La Palma - Canaries president

By Miguel Gutierrez © Reuters/SUSANA VERA Cumbre Vieja volcano continues to erupt on the Canary Island of La Palma LA PALMA, Spain (Reuters) – There’s no immediate end in sight ... Read more »

Golf-European quartet set world record for fastest hole

(Reuters) – Professionals usually take 10 to 15 minutes to complete a hole on a golf course but four European Tour players teamed up to break the Guinness World Record ... Read more »

Everton line-ups as Yerry Mina decision made for West Ham visit

‘Ben Godfrey in for Mina’ Chris Beesley: All eyes will be on the two men in the respective managerial dugouts at Goodison Park this afternoon as Rafa Benitez and David ... Read more »

Lyndon Dykes tipped for English Premier League transfer as David Martindale makes 'bigger club watching' claim

Lyndon Dykes’ old boss at Livingston reckons the Scotland star is bound for a money-spinning English Premier League move. And Tony Macaroni gaffer David Martindale claims that “one of the ... Read more »

'Not the boring old white guy again': Black candidates see fundraising windfall

In his bid to hold his Georgia Senate seat, Democrat Raphael Warnock collected a stunning $9.5 million over the last 90 days. Democrat Val Demings, who’s challenging GOP Sen. Marco ... Read more »

Coleen Nolan says she's having the ‘best sex of her life' after Tinder boyfriend ‘awakens a tiger in her'

COLEEN Nolan has said she's having the “best sex of her life” after finding love on Tinder. The Loose Women presenter, 56, went on the dating app back in May ... Read more »

Aldi Specialbuy toy shop hit by shipping delays as parents rush to buy Christmas presents

TOYS due to go on sale today at Aldi have been hit by delays caused by supply chain issues. Over 60 Specialbuy items are not available as expected, including the ... Read more »

Sleep expert shares 15-minute bedtime tweak that'll make the clocks going back a breeze for kids

BEFORE kids, we always secretly enjoyed the hour going back every winter – after all, it basically gives us permission to have a lie-in. But now we're parents, we dread ... Read more »

Strictly's Adam Peaty posts cryptic Instagram message about ‘real ones' after Katya Jones near-kiss scandal

STRICTLY'S Adam Peaty has posted a cryptic Instagram message about “real ones” after the Katyka Jones near-kiss scandal. The Olympian, 26 – who is in a relationship with artist Eirianedd ... Read more »

‘Controlling' school rules could see more kids drop out as pupils are made to show Dr's note to use the toilet in class

CONTROLLING school rules like needing a doctor’s note to use the toilet in lessons could see kids drop out of school, an expert has warned.  Psychologist Emma Kenny says it’s ... Read more »

SBB wollen Sopre aufs Abstellgleis schieben: Pannen-Software verschlingt zu viele Steuermillionen

Zugausfälle, fehl geplanter Einsatz von Lokführerinnen und Lokführern. Das IT-System Sopre für die Personalplanung macht den SBB seit Jahren zu schaffen. Die Pannen bekommen auch die Fahrgäste zu spüren. Jetzt ... Read more »

Hoodies sind unser liebster Herbst-Trend 2021 – so stylst du sie casual, sporty & schick

© Getty Images Herbst-Trend Hoodie: So stylst du ihn casual, sporty und schick Getty Images Hoodies gehören einfach in jede Herbst-Garderobe. Hat man sie vor Kurzem noch ausschließlich als Homewear getragen, ... Read more »

Covid-19: UAE reports less than 100 cases for the first time since March 2020

© Motivate Publishing Covid-19 testing UAE 4 The UAE reported 99 new cases of Covid-19 on Sunday, marking the first time the case count has dropped below 100 since the ... Read more »

UAE: Restaurant shut down for flouting food safety rules

© Provided by Khaleej Times UAE: Restaurant shut down for flouting food safety rules A popular restaurant in Abu Dhabi has been shut down for flouting food hygiene rules. The ... Read more »

Worlds 2021 Pick'em leaderboard

© Provided by Dot Esports Make your predictions for the 2021 League of Legends World Championship with Pick’em. Riot Games has improved upon the already successful Pick’em formula for this ... Read more »

Shoaib Akhtar Chills Out With Kapil Dev, Sunil Gavaskar Ahead of Indo-Pak Clash; See Pic

© Provided by News18 Shoaib Akhtar Chills Out With Kapil Dev, Sunil Gavaskar Ahead of Indo-Pak Clash; See Pic There is not much time left for the mother of all ... Read more »

Politics must be kinder and based on respect, says Speaker after MP's death

The Speaker of the House of Commons has called for politics to be kinder after the death of his colleague and friend Sir David Amess. In an article for the ... Read more »

David Amess's death reminds us of the bravery of those who serve the people

Floral tributes at the scene where the MP for Southend West, Sir David Amess, was stabbed to death in Leigh-on-Sea (EPA) It takes courage to be a politician, even if ... Read more »

Matt Hancock UN job offer rescinded, according to reports

Former health secretary Matt Hancock will not take up a special representative role at the UN, reports suggest (John Walton/PA) (PA Wire) Former health secretary Matt Hancock has seen a ... Read more »

Florida juvenile justice's long history of scandals

For decades, the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice has been beset by periodic scandals. Here is a recount of some of them: 2000 The confrontation between Michael Wiltsie at a ... Read more »

Families of Beirut blast victims back judge amid pressure

Lebanon (Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved) The families of the victims of Beirut’s massive port blast last year reaffirmed Saturday their support for the judge leading the ... Read more »

How Patriots have helped Mac Jones look like best QB from 2021 NFL Draft class

Call him “Easy Mac,” because the Patriots QB has made it look that way this season. The Patriots opened eyes when they released Cam Newton and handed the keys of ... Read more »

Why the Cowboys haven't signed Cam Newton as Dak Prescott's backup after Patriots release

Cam Newton remains unsigned as the NFL season trucks ahead through Week 6. Newton has been a free agent since the Patriots surprisingly released him on eve of the 2021 NFL ... Read more »

Taapsee Pannu reveals she did 'so much of shopping' in Kutch for her apartment while shooting for Rashmi Rocket there

© Provided by Desimartini Taapsee Pannu starrer Rashmi Rocket premiered  on India’s largest homegrown OTT platform ZEE5 on 15th October and ever since, the inspirational movie has been receiving rave ... Read more »

Akshay Kumar is thankful to retired army officer for highlighting mistake in 'Gorkha' poster

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: On Dussehra (October 15), Bollywood’s Khiladi Akshay Kumar had released the first look of his upcoming film ‘Gorkha’ based on the war hero, Major ... Read more »

Vicky Kaushal wants Britishers watching Sardar Udham to realise what they have done in the past, says they are answerable

© Provided by Desimartini Vicky Kaushal spoke about the struggle aspiring actors have to go through before the make it in Bollywood. Trying to convey how stardom doesn’t come easy, ... Read more »

Vicky Kaushal finally BREAKS his silence on engagement rumours with Katrina Kaif!

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The ‘Sardar Udham’ actor Vicky Kaushal responded to the engagement rumours that were circulating a while ago in an interview with a leading ... Read more »

Penerbangan domestik ke Kelantan catat 20 perjalanan sehari

© Provided by Sinar Harian KOTA BHARU – Penerbangan domestik ke Kelantan membabitkan pelancong dan perantau yang pulang ke kampung halaman meningkat sehingga 20 perjalanan sehari menjelang peralihan fasa tiga ... Read more »

‘Proved so many doubters wrong' – Many Nottingham Forest fans discuss one player's role in Blackpool win

© Provided by Football League World Ryan Yates n Nottingham Forest extended their unbeaten run under Steve Cooper with a 2-1 win against Blackpool yesterday and the performance of midfielder ... Read more »