Australia's government gives more support to fossil fuel research than is apparent

A$10.3 billion, Environmental Research Letters, Mission Innovation, McDowall 2021, other measures

TKR Photography/Shutterstock

Australian governments direct billions to fossil fuel companies. Among the projects funded by Commonwealth and state governments are work on coal ports, railways and power stations, and research into “clean coal” or “coal innovation”.

Whether worthwhile or not, this funding is visible and can be debated on its merits, as The Australia Institute has done in a study characterising total government support for fossil fuel industries as hitting A$10.3 billion in 2020-21.

But there’s more that’s invisible. Research I have just published in the journal Environmental Research Letters using new administrative data from tax offices finds Australia has spent more subsidising fossil fuel research indirectly via research and development tax credits than directly via grants.

Between 2012 and 2018 fossil fuel extraction companies received A$1.4 billion in research and development tax credits from the Australian government.

My study examines the R&D tax concessions taken up in Canada, Australia, Norway and the United Kingdom.

Support through tax concessions is near-invisible

Each country has committed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. All are part of the international Mission Innovation initiative, which aims to accelerate the development and diffusion of low-carbon technologies.

The tax data provided was the value of R&D tax credits received by companies whose principal classification code is, or has recently been, related to fossil fuel extraction.

Because some of these grants might have been used to support research into renewable or carbon sequestration technologies, I have also examined the nature of the patents published by those companies in the countries where it is available.

Of the 9,398 patents filed by UK and Norwegian fossil fuel extraction firms between 2012 and 2018, only 3% are related to climate mitigation. I was unable to obtain figures for Australia.


Most patents claimed by fossil fuel extraction companies are for fossil fuels

A$10.3 billion, Environmental Research Letters, Mission Innovation, McDowall 2021, other measures

Number of patents filed between 2012 and 2019 by UK and Norwegian firms whose principal activity is fossil fuel extraction. McDowall 2021


This generous support of fossil fuel innovation through R&D tax credits is unlikely to be deliberate. It is an artefact of the design of Australia’s R&D tax incentive scheme, which is unusually generous to large companies.

But it amounts to a surprisingly big amount, and longer term could be bigger still.

Much support is banked for future use

Australia’s credits can be “carried forward” to reduce future tax bills.

In 2018, the most recent year for which data was available, Australian fossil fuel companies were holding on to A$880 million in R&D tax credits that could be used in future years on top of what they had claimed.

That’s in addition to the A$1.4 billion already received, for a total of well over A$2 billion. It’s a substantial well-hidden public investment in fossil fuel R&D.


Australian fossil fuel companies are amassing credits to carry forward

A$10.3 billion, Environmental Research Letters, Mission Innovation, McDowall 2021, other measures

McDowall 2021


Although done rarely, it is possible to design R&D tax concessions differently.

Between 2003 and 2017, the UK offered a higher rate of R&D tax credits for research on vaccines, malaria, tuberculosis and HIV/AIDS. Several states in the United States offer higher R&D tax credits for research on particular technologies.

A better and more open approach would be to replace R&D tax concessions for fossil fuel research with direct grants for lines of research that might help Australia meet its emission reduction commitments.

Research into cheaper ways of producing fossil fuels will be counter-productive to those efforts. It will create the need for higher carbon prices or other measures down the track to re-tilt the playing field.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

World Bank discontinues Doing Business reports — bank's statement

In June 2020, data irregularities on Doing Business 2018 and 2020 were reported Read more »

Yamal's gas production capacity 25% above planned — governor

At the same time, Dmitry Artyukhov continued, it is not clear whether gas production will grow next year Read more »

Expert: Second Arktika-M satellite launch to assure entire Northern Sea Route coverage

The first special Arktika-M satellite was launched in February 2020 and another such satellite will be launched in 2023 Read more »

Google, Apple fail to explain their position to Russian senators

According to Deputy Head of Roskomnadzor Vadim Subbotin, the Apple representative was unable to explain the motive of the company’s actions and the Google representative had no power of appointment, so he was not questioned Read more »

Bank of Russia developing stress tests on influence of decarbonization on economy

"We will have two variants - by 2030 and by 2050," First Deputy Chief Ksenia Yudaeva noted Read more »

Watchdog ready to fine Google, Facebook, Twitter for refusal to delete banned content

Vadim Subbotin clarified that the decision would be taken regarding those who systematically violate the requirements of the regulator Read more »

Russia demands that Apple, Google eliminate election interference violations

The Russian side drew attention to US IT companies Apple and Google, with their actions during elections in Russia considered illegal and directly related to interference in the internal affairs of Russia Read more »

Bank of Russia leery of using cryptocurrencies for investment purposes

According to First Deputy Chairman Sergey Shvetsov, the regulator considers the ruble in all its forms as the only payment instrument on Russian territory Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Government is shifting gears on growth

File image of Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman (Image: Twitter/@FinMinIndia) Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published ... Read more »

China's Hainan hosts World New Energy Vehicle Congress

Hainan is the first province in China to announce plans to completely stop selling gasoline and diesel vehicles on the island by 2030 Read more »

Commerce Ministry for extending anti-dumping duty on certain steel products

The commerce ministry’s arm DGTR has recommended the extension of anti-dumping duty on imports of certain steel products from countries like China, Japan and Korea to protect the domestic industry ... Read more »

Gas price in Europe keeps declining after hitting record highs on previous day

The price of gas futures for October delivery at the TTF hub in the Netherlands currently stands at $771 per 1,000 cubic meters Read more »

Airlines to lower fuel surcharges on int'l routes in October

SEOUL, Sept. 16 (Yonhap) — South Korean airlines will lower fuel surcharges on international routes next month as jet fuel prices rise at a slower pace, industry sources said Thursday. ... Read more »

'Drastic' measures needed for financially distressed self-employed workers amid pandemic: civic groups

SEOUL, Sept. 16 (Yonhap) — South Korean civic groups called on the government Thursday to come up with “drastic” measures to help lessen the hardship of self-employed workers and small ... Read more »

Dollar up to 72.30 rubles on Moscow Exchange

Euro not changed Read more »

Banks' loan delinquency rate rises in July

SEOUL, Sept. 16 (Yonhap) — The delinquency rate for South Korean banks’ won-denominated loans rose in July due to an increase in overdue corporate loans, the financial regulator said Thursday. ... Read more »

Korea's public account turns to deficit in 2020 on COVID-19 spending

SEOUL, Sept. 16 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s public account surplus turned to deficit in 2020 as the government increased fiscal spending to cushion the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, central ... Read more »

S. Korea to up self-sufficiency of grains, cut carbon emissions at farms

By Kang Yoon-seung SEOUL, Sept. 16 (Yonhap) — South Korea unveiled its new blueprint for the agricultural industry, which centers on expanding its self-sufficiency of major grains while cutting emissions ... Read more »

(EDITORIAL from Korea Times on Sept. 16)

Google should play fairBig tech fined for abusing market dominance Korea’s antitrust watchdog fined Google 207.4 billion won ($177 million) Tuesday for abusing its dominant market position to hamper fair ... Read more »

Consumer financing firms' profit soars in H1 on stock rally

SEOUL, Sept. 16 (Yonhap) — Consumer financing firms in South Korea saw their combined net profit jump 50 percent on-year in the first half, supported by strong gains from stock ... Read more »

Central banks of Russia, Tajikistan agree to cooperate in fighting cyberattacks

According to the National Bank of Tajikistan, the agreement focuses on strengthening information security, developing a strategy to identify the factors of cyberattacks, and eliminating their consequences in banking systems Read more »

Trust between govt, industry critical to leverage opportunities created by COVID: FM Nirmala Sitharaman

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday said that the trust between government and industry is critical for leveraging the opportunities thrown up by the COVID-19 pandemic while assuring that the ... Read more »

Centre responsible for rise in its debt and fall in GDP: Shanti Dhariwal

Rajasthan Parliamentary Affairs Minister Shanti Dhariwal on Tuesday blamed the Centre and its “wrong policies” for the rise in its debt and fall in the country’s GDP. Dhariwal made the ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | A mixed picture on inflation signals caution

Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives a little extra by ... Read more »

Govt approves incentives for autos, relief measures for telecoms sector: Source

Union cabinet on Wednesday approved a much-expected relief package for the country’s cash-strapped telecoms sector, a senior government source said. Shares in wireless carriers Bharti Airtel rose 5.4% and Vodafone ... Read more »

Coal India warned government of coal shortage in February

Coal Coal India’s warned the adviser to the federal power ministry in February of an impending fuel shortage as utilities tapped inventories and curbed purchases despite rising coal-fired power output, ... Read more »

How Raghuram Rajan, Urjit Patel differ on greening of central bank policies

Raghuram Rajan (Image: PTI) Climate change is the most important challenge facing humanity. There are numerous analyses and reports suggesting that if we don’t get our act together, future generations will struggle ... Read more »

India's exports jump 46% to $33.28 billion in August

India’s exports rose by 45.76 percent to $33.28 billion in August, as against $22.83 billion in the same month last year, according to commerce ministry data released on Tuesday. Imports ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Volatility to the fore in taper times

Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives a little extra by ... Read more »

Democrats seek corporate, wealthy tax hikes for $3.5 trillion plan

AP House Democrats unveiled a sweeping proposal Monday for tax hikes on big corporations and the wealthy to fund President Joe Biden‘s $3.5 trillion rebuilding plan, as Congress speeds ahead ... Read more »

Simply Save | What could India's inclusion in global bond index mean for debt investors?

The foreign brokerage house Morgan Stanley last week said that it expects India to be included in global bond index in 2022. Being part of a global bond index, Indian ... Read more »

BBB invites bids for conducting background verification of candidates

The Banks Board Bureau (BBB), the headhunter for state-owned banks and financial institutions, on Monday invited bids from firms to carry out background verification of candidates for director-level vacancies. The ... Read more »

Brent oil surpasses $76 per barrel on London's ICE

The last time the price of Brent surpassed $76 per barrel on July 14 Read more »

Russia should not follow Western countries path in its fuel policy, says Deputy PM

The 2021 Tyumen Oil and Gas Forum is being held at the West Siberian Innovation Center in Tyumen from September 14 to 16 Read more »

Gazprom Neft to increase hydrocarbon output to over 100 mln tonnes in 2021

Head of the company Alexander Dyukov also noted that Gazprom Neft plans to revise the capital expenditure program in 2021 due to the OPEC+ decision Read more »

Russian upper house invites Google and Apple to discuss foreign interference

Andrei Klimov mentioned that as in previous years, "foreign opponents and centers that specialize in anti-Russian activities were very actively trying to use this time [before the elections] in order to promote people, for whom they had staked on," including by using the latest computer technology Read more »

Brent oil surpasses $75 per barrel on London's ICE first time since August 2

WTI crude oil rose in price by 2.15% to $71.74 per barrel Read more »

Sibur, Gazprom analyzing completed feasibility study for joint gas refinery in Tatarstan

In particular, the first roadmap envisages the completion of feasibility studies for projects involving the transportation of ethane-containing gas from deposits in the Nadym-Pur-Taz region and the construction of a gas processing plant in Tatarstan Read more »

Completion of Nord Stream 2 proves Russia's reliability as gas supplier, says Deputy PM

The construction of the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline was fully completed on the morning of September 10 Read more »

(LEAD) S. Korea to extend loan maturity again for pandemic-hit firms, merchants

(ATTN: ADDS remarks, details in paras 3-5) SEOUL, Sept. 15 (Yonhap) — South Korea’s financial regulator said Wednesday local banks will extend loan maturity and delay interest payments again for ... Read more »