Auckland hospital projects delayed by fire concerns

Auckland hospital projects delayed by fire concerns

By Phil Pennington of RNZ

Vital hospital building projects in Auckland are being delayed for months by questions over fire designs – and especially the safe evacuation of smoke-filled rooms.

Stroke, rehabilitation and baby care units are all affected as well as a catheter lab and renal dialysis project.

Fire engineers have lacked clear design rules and guidelines for hospitals and care homes for years, and now Auckland Council, and Fire and Emergency (FENZ) are increasingly questioning the engineers’ designs, causing delays to building consents.

Auckland engineer Simon Weaver said “building consents take quite a long time to process as it is. And then you can have a hospital job that might be in building consent for a year, while various experts argue different points of view”.

‘Ignored for such a long time’

Council lead fire engineer Ed Claridge told an industry webinar the extra questioning is justified.

“We haven’t got people modelling realistic fires in a building with realistic performance,” he said.

“We’ve got a foundation in this country of a problem and a disconnect with fire engineering designs, that means the evacuation and management of buildings has been practically ignored for such a long time, because it’s been left to the evacuation regulations after the building has been built.”

Many engineers believe the council and FENZ are going too far, beyond the Building Code in their demands.

But FENZ rejects that.

At the same webinar, FENZ’s lead fire engineer Etienne Hermouet cited three recent smouldering fires in care homes – two in 2019, one last year – too small to set off sprinklers but that exposed residents and staff to smoke inhalation nonetheless.

The threat was real, Hermouet said.

“I have been asked a couple of times how many of those fires that we had, how much of a problem is it?” he told the engineers online.

“I will turn it around and ask you all, if you want to wait until somebody’s died in a hospital [fire] before you accept there’s a problem.

“I’d like to think that gives you some points to think about in your next design.”

‘A health sector-wide issue’

The webinar was meant to help fix the problem – but has not.

One engineer commented online: “This webinar has not done a thing to advance the current blockage.”

Months on, Auckland region’s district health boards have had to set up a group to tackle this, and are asking the Health Ministry for help.

At Counties Manukau DHB’s Middlemore Hospital, delays have pushed back their new catheter and dialysis project more than six months, and raised costs.

FENZ had recently raised “fire design expectations to a standard many consider above code. As it stands there are situations whereby you can meet the Building Code but not FENZ requirements”, the DHB told RNZ.

“Acquiring building consent in time for upcoming projects is a new risk being recognised by all projects especially around fire engineering design aspects. This is a health sector-wide issue,” its committee minutes say.

Fire engineers are also frustrated.

“With the current situation of Covid, it’s not good at all that we can’t get these consents through and fire is holding them up,” Weaver said.

Engineers faced a lack of clear guidelines, but also a lack of real-world data about how evacuations worked, to feed into their designs, he said.

FENZ agreed clear guidance “is currently missing” from the documents that back up the Building Code.

Waitematā DHB put it this way: “We have experienced some uncertainty with receiving a clear direction from… FENZ and Auckland Council on requirements and have requested formal instructions.”

FENZ told RNZ it supports the council in requiring changes to designs that are not robust enough.

It was bound, when it had technical “concerns that a design would not keep people safe”, to tell councils but the scope of that advice was tightly defined by law and closely followed, manager of fire engineering Simon Davis said in a statement.

Veteran fire engineer Robert Peart did not believe FENZ or the council were going too far.

But he questioned council delays, for instance, over a Special Care Baby Unit design that he reviewed and approved recently.

“I was surprised to hear that several months after, they still hadn’t resolved all the fire engineering issues,” Peart said.

“I would have hoped I would have been able to resolve some of the issues had I been asked.”

But he was not asked.

Some councils were “ignoring” peer reviews generally, and not just of hospital designs, he said.

‘Not unreasonable’

The industry must step up, into the rules vacuum left by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment under changes in 2017, by improving engineer training, Peart said.

Fire engineer Daryn Glasgow is doing a peer review at Starship children’s hospital, of a fire compliance master-check that he said had taken almost a year longer than expected due to debate about methodologies.

His solution was that engineers check with councils and FENZ earlier, like he does.

“If those conversations had happened earlier, then it would have been resolved earlier, no doubt,” Glasgow said.

“So FENZ and council are asking questions of fire engineers to demonstrate, for example, whether they’ve appropriately incorporated the effect of smoke on staff that are assisting with evacuation of patients in their calculations.

“That is really challenging technically, but it’s not unreasonable.”

Auckland DHB said there were no safety concerns that prompted the Starship review, rather it was using it to check on what other projects it might do in future.

There is a virtual consensus on the need for specific fire safety design guidance for hospitals and care homes – though this could take many months to develop, and FENZ has warned engineers prescriptive rules would limit design flexibility.

The Health Ministry has not said if it is taking up a FENZ offer to develop this guidance.

Some industry players say it is up to the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, to step in.

The ministry indicated to RNZ it is not in a hurry, saying it had signalled since the 2017 rule change that it would in due course review the C/VM2 fire rules.

“As part of this [we] will consider whether further fire safety guidance specific to hospital designs could be beneficial,” it said.

MBIE said it had met Auckland Council to talk about building consent processing options. It remains unclear where that has got to.

Any solution to the delays will carry costs. As one fire engineer told the webinar: “Ultimately the cost [is] levied on hospitals, who aren’t made of money. So over-conservatism is indirectly causing injury as well.”


News Related


Man charged with murder after death of baby in Christchurch

A man has arrested in relation to the death of a 3-month-old baby in Christchurch on January 2. A 34-year-old man has been charged with murder and is due to ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron outbreak: Benee cancels NZ leg of world tour

The New Zealand leg of pop star Benee’s world tour is the latest to be cancelled in the red traffic light setting. It’s the second time the Kiwi artist has ... Read more »

Hawke's Bay couple's sage advice after 70 years of marriage

It may have been a case of “who you know” when Gwen (nee Waites) and Derrick White met more than seven decades ago. The couple celebrate their 70th wedding anniversary ... Read more »

Talking Point: SH5 - bring back traffic cops and Ministry of Works

Since the late 1980s, road improvements have kept up with different improved means of transport. That is until now. Much of the current Napier-Taupo road was designed and built by ... Read more »

Two new Hawke's Bay cases: Person admitted to hospital for Covid treatment

One person has been admitted to Hawke’s Bay Hospital for treatment of symptoms from Covid-19, and two new Covid cases have been announced for the region. A Hawke’s Bay DHB ... Read more »

The Spinoff: Covid 19 Omicron: What can New Zealand learn from Queensland's surge?

Overseas examples should be approached with caution. But the Australian state shares a lot of important characteristics. Vaccination levels. Public health measures. Historic immunity. Testing strategies. Demographic differences. Weather. There ... Read more »

Mighty Ducks star shares incredible transformation after overcoming addiction

Mighty Ducks star Shaun Weiss reached an epic milestone in his battle against methamphetamine addiction, with the former child actor celebrating two years of sobriety. Taking to Instagram, his good ... Read more »

Police searching for Ute driver after alleged hit and run in Cromwell

Police are asking the public to help them find a vehicle in relation to a crash in Cromwell which left a cyclist injured. A cyclist suffered serious injuries after being ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: 15 cases of new variant, 105 total community cases

A string of Omicron locations of interest have been revealed, with 15 new cases of the variant reported today. The Ministry of Health reported 105 new community cases of Covid-19, ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: One new case in Northland

Northland has recorded one new Covid case in the 24-hours to midnight last night. The district health board announced the case is a household contact of a known case but ... Read more »

Talking Point: Urgent action needed on special forestry test

Federated Farmers is calling on the government to live up to its pledge and review the Overseas Investment Act “special forestry test” and be fair to sheep and beef farmers ... Read more »

Auckland $15b light rail project will largely be paid for by Government and built by 2033, say ministers

The Government will pay the “lion’s share” for a $15 billion light rail line from the city centre to the airport in Auckland and is confident of having it built ... Read more »

The Country - Shock edition

Today on The Country, Jamie Mackay accused Central Hawkes Bay farmer Jeremy Rookes of being a rural shock jock. On with the show: Christopher Luxon: In his first appearance on ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Person admitted to Hawke's Bay Hospital for Covid treatment

One person has been admitted to Hawke’s Bay Hospital for treatment of symptoms from Covid-19. A Hawke’s Bay DHB spokeswoman said the person did not require intensive care and that ... Read more »

Golf: Red-hot Lydia Ko fires into the lead at the Gainbridge LGPA after strong first round

Lydia Ko has rocketed to the top of the leaderboard at the Gainbridge LPGA event in Florida after a red-hot opening round. The Kiwi world No 3 shot a blemish-free ... Read more »

Covid chance to explore more creative endeavours

Covid-19 restrictions have literally played right into Kathy Murray's creative hands. Read more »

Four injured after two-car crash near Levin

Four people have been injured after a two-car crash near Levin. A police spokesperson told the Herald they are attending the crash at the intersection of Opiki Rd and Makerua ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Māori health leader calls for targeted strategy

Māori health leaders say something needs to be done to close the Covid-19 vaccine gap for Māori. With a growing number of community cases of Omicron, health providers are finding ... Read more »

The Spinoff: Is it time to ask your boss for a pay rise?

With inflation at a three decade high, New Zealanders face another year of shrinking pay cheques as costs soar, Justin Giovannetti writes. Inflation is soaring around the world and NZ ... Read more »

From the MTG: Celebrating the Chinese New Year

If you are gifted an ornate red packet, sometimes embellished with shiny golds and inscribed with the characters pinyin: Xīn Nián Kuài Lè), you must first thank the giver, take ... Read more »

Taradale Primary School teachers learn mindfulness techniques to help kids cope as Covid bears down

Taradale Primary School is bracing for Omicron to arrive in Hawke’s Bay as kids return to school, and is trying to make the first few weeks in the classroom a ... Read more »

Scott Morrison addresses Grace Tame controversy at Australia Day event

Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison has broken his silence on the Grace Tame controversy, suggesting she’s had “a terrible life” but that he will always greet guests with a smile. ... Read more »

Covid 10 Omicron outbreak: Short notice bus cancellations likely as Omicron spreads

Short notice cancellations to Baybus services are anticipated as Omicron spreads in the community, the Bay of Plenty Regional Council warns. Bus services continue to operate as normal but the ... Read more »

Tennis: Nick Kyrgios blasted over hypocritical outburst at Australian Open

Nick Kyrgios and Thanasi Kokkinakis may have set up a dream all-Australian men’s doubles final — but it came after an ugly tantrum that sparked outrage from the tennis world. ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Positive case visited Far North marae for tangihanga

A Far North marae visited by a person positive with Covid-19 had strict protocols in place to mitigate the risks posed by the virus. Wainui Marae, around 24km north of ... Read more »

Driverless, low-emissions tractor in development for NZ orchards

An innovative, low-emissions, driverless tractor able to perform up to three tasks at once is on the cards for New Zealand orchards. The prototype tractor aims to transform the productivity ... Read more »

Travel time restrictions removed for Waikato SuperGold cardholders

The removal of travel time restrictions on buses and trains will be a game changer for Waikato’s ageing communities using their SuperGold card concession. From February 1, free travel will ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron: Supermarket veggie supplier anxious after Covid tests seized

A supermarket vegetable supplier says it is among companies fearing the Omicron outbreak could wreak havoc on its output now it can’t get access to rapid antigen tests (RATs). Morgan ... Read more »

Focus Sport: RJ Hampton reflects on his time with the Breakers

NBA star RJ Hampton reflects on his time playing for the NZ Breakers. Video / NZ Herald Read more »

'Continued upward trend': Where in Auckland rent is rising the fastest?

Auckland rents showed a “continued upward trend”, rising fastest for one-bedroom places and particularly in the south and west, a property management business says. Barfoot & Thompson, which manages more ... Read more »

Covid 19 MIQ: Mum's managed isolation complaint goes viral

A mum with two young children has been savaged online after sharing a complaint about her treatment in managed isolation. Returning from a trip to Australia, she was faced with ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Today's cases, has Soundsplash become a super-spreader event?

As Omicron surpasses Delta as the dominant variant revealed in New Zealand’s daily Covid-19 numbers, all eyes will be on today’s latest figures to see if the trend continues. The ... Read more »

Travel inspiration: Where Robyn Malcolm loves to holiday in New Zealand

The much-loved Kiwi star reveals her favourite NZ holiday destinations What are your favourite memories from childhood family holidays in NZ? Every year we travelled in the big white family ... Read more »

What does 'flight attendants arm your doors' mean? Door ripped off BA flight

The door of a British Airways flight was ripped clean off at Cape Town International Airport, Yesterday. The incident, which is being blamed on a ‘breakdown in communication’, resulted in ... Read more »

The summit of Mokoia falls to musket power - Ka tanuku kai raro te tihi ki Mokoia

“With the morning sun we will attack.” Read more »

TVNZ host Hilary Barry's awkward homemade gift for Seven Sharp co-host Jeremy Wells

Togs, togs .. undies, undies … crocheted Speedos? Hilary Barry likes to get creative when it comes to Christmas gifts for her colleagues – and the Seven Sharp presenter has ... Read more »

Tauranga CBD greeting card store closes after 18 years

Allen Hickson will close the doors to his greeting card store in Tauranga’s CBD after nearly two decades. Hickson has been the smiling face behind the counter of the Piccadilly ... Read more »

Kāhu ki Rotorua:The summit of Mokoia falls to musket power - Ka tanuku kai raro te tihi ki Mokoia

Public Interest Journalism funded through NZ On Air Click here for English translationKa karangatia nuitia a Hongi, ” Mō te atatū tātou ka haere!”. Nō te ata awatea ka puta ... Read more »

Demolition team at Tauhara College

During the summer holidays 2021/2022 the water damaged classrooms and teaching areas at Tauhara College were pulled down, following on from a catastrophic downpour in November 2020. Video / Rachel ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Students stuck in New Zealand flooding job market

Two years of border unpredictability, expensive flights and the risk of catching Covid and being stuck overseas has meant most young Kiwis have put their OE on the shelf. But ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic