Astrological incompatibility can't be an excuse to go back on marriage promise: HC

Rape case, Bombay HC, Astrological incompatibility, marriage promise, Horoscopes

The Bombay High Court refused to discharge a 32-year-old man from a rape and cheating case noting that he had used “astrological incompatibility” of horoscopes as an excuse to resile from his promise to marry the complainant woman with whom he was in a relationship. A single bench of Justice S K Shinde on Monday rejected an application filed by Avishek Mitra seeking to be discharged from the cheating and rape case registered against him by the suburban Borivali police on a complaint lodged by the woman.

The order was made available on Tuesday.

Mitra’s advocate Raja Thakare had argued that the relations between the accused and the complainant could not be taken further due to “astrological incompatibility”. He argued that this was not a case of cheating and rape under the false pretext of marriage but a case of breach of promise.

Justice Shinde, however, refused to accept this contention and noted that there was material to suggest that since the beginning the accused had no intention of upholding his promise to marry the complainant.

“It is apparent that the applicant (Mitra) in the guise of astrological incompatibility of horoscopes, avoided the promise (of marriage). Thus, I am convinced that it is a case of false promise to marry which apparently vitiates the complainant’s consent,” the bench said.

Justice Shinde further noted that prima facie the court was of the view that Mitra assured the complainant that he would marry her when she approached the police just to avoid a case against him.

As per the case details, the accused and complainant knew each other since 2012 when they were working in a five-star hotel and were in a relationship. The complainant had alleged that on several occasions the accused had indulged in physical relations with her by promising marriage.

The complainant also claimed that when she had conceived and asked Mitra to marry her he refused saying they were still young and forced her to abort the pregnancy.

In December 2012, when the accused started avoiding her, she lodged a police complaint. The police then called the accused and counselled the duo following which Mitra told the police in January 2013 that he would marry her.

However, within a few days the accused backtracked following which the police registered a case of rape and cheating, according to the prosecution.

Thakare had argued that there was absolutely no intent on Mitra’s part not to marry the complainant or that his promise to marry her was false.

“Had his intentions been bonafide and true, the applicant would not have resiled from his promise to marry the complainant later,” the bench said while rejecting his plea for discharge from the case.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Taming the tech giants is one thing. Giving free rein to censors quite another

Photograph: AFP/Getty Images Opposition to censorship should not be based on sympathy for the censored but fear of the censors. To loud applause, the UK government says it wants to ... Read more »

Intel expects GPU and CPU shortages to last until 2023

© Provided by GamePur In a recent interview with CNBC, Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger spoke about the ongoing manufacturing crisis. The ramifications of the current semiconductor shortage, which has limited ... Read more »

Judge rules public has 'right' to watch Ghislaine Maxwell trial jury selection

A judge rejected the request of Ghislaine Maxwell, former associate of Jeffrey Epstein, to exclude the public from the jury selection process for her trial. U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan ... Read more »

Ryan O'Donoghue hits key goal as Belmullet knock out last year's Mayo finalists

© Laszlo Geczo INPHO Ryan O’Donoghue file photo . RYAN O’DONOGHUE STRUCK a crucial goal as Belmullet sprung a surprise to knock out last year’s finalists Breaffy at the quarter-final ... Read more »

CDC ‘very carefully' monitoring ‘Delta plus' COVID-19 variant, Walensky says

Dr. Rochelle Walensky stressed that it has still yet to be determined whether the new subvariant is more contagious or is resistant to vaccines Michael Brochstein/Sipa USA Centers for Disease ... Read more »

Mabel 'in talks to be a judge on new show Walk The Line'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Mabel has reportedly signed up to be a judge on the new ITV show Walk The Line alongside Simon Cowell and Craig David. ... Read more »

UK daily Covid cases rise by 39,962 in last 24 hours amid fears work from home & masks could return

DAILY Covid cases in the UK have risen by almost 40,000 in the last 24 hours amid fears working from home and face masks could return. A further 39,962 people ... Read more »

Corey Feldman auctioning off prosthetic ear from Stand By Me

© Bang Showbiz Corey Feldman Corey Feldman’s prosthetic ear from ‘Stand By Me’ is set to go under the hammer. The 50-year-old actor’s character in the 1986 coming-of-age drama, Teddy ... Read more »

Manchester United vs Liverpool LIVE: Premier League latest score, goals and updates from fixture today

© Reuters Premier League – Manchester United v Liverpool LIVE – Updated at 16:24 Manchester United and Liverpool go head-to-head at Old Trafford this afternoon in the latest chapter from ... Read more »

India vs Pakistan Live Score, T20 World Cup: Jadeja joins Kohli after Pant's exit

© Provided by Firstpost India vs Pakistan Live Score, T20 World Cup: Jadeja joins Kohli after Pant’s exit 20:48 (IST) After 15 overs,India 100/4 ( Virat Kohli (C) 37 , ... Read more »

Channel Tunnel chaos: Motorists forced to sleep in their cars after power failure

© PA Channel Tunnel delays 241021.jpg Drivers were forced to wait in their cars overnight at the Channel Tunnel after an electrical fault triggered major delays. Holidaymakers and lorry drivers ... Read more »

Kerala: IMD issues orange alert to 4 districts, yellow to others

Water from overflowing Pampa river enters nearby houses following heavy rainfall in the area in Pathanamthitta, Kerala. (Image: ANI) The India Meteorological Department on Sunday issued an orange alert to ... Read more »

Sainz startet auf falschen Reifen - Ferrari bezwingt McLaren in Austin-Quali

© Motorsport Images Sainz – Leclerc – Ferrari – GP USA – Austin – Samstag – 23.10.2021 Nach dem Freitag war man bei McLaren guter Dinge, in der Qualifikation vor ... Read more »

Bears place Caleb Johnson on COVID-19 reserve list

© Provided by NBC Sports The Bears put tight end Jimmy Graham on the COVID-19 reserve list on Friday and they added another player to the list ahead of Sunday’s ... Read more »

Arkansas governor says mandates are increasing vaccine hesitancy

Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson (R) said on Sunday mandates are increasing hesitancy surrounding COVID-19 vaccines. © The Hill Arkansas governor says mandates are increasing vaccine hesitancy “The resistance is hard ... Read more »

Wie BMW seine neuen Modelle virtuell testen lässt: Geschüttelt und gerührt

Wie gefällt Kunden das Interieur? Kommen sie mit der Bedienung klar? Und wie reagiert das neue Modell auf Vollbremsungen bei minus 35 Grad? Diese Fragen klärt BMW in einem neuen ... Read more »

NFL DFS, Week 7: Top DraftKings, FanDuel daily Fantasy football picks, stacks, lineup advice

Rookie tight end Kyle Pitts finally had the breakout performance that many had been wishing for when he posted a 9-119-1 stat line in his last game. All three numbers ... Read more »

Israel erklärt NGOs zu Terrorgruppen

Sechs palästinensische Organisationen sind betroffen. EU und USA kritisieren den Schritt. © Foto: Atef Safadi (EPA) Greift durch: Der israelische Verteidigungsminister Benny Gantz. Israels Regierung hat sechs palästinensische Nichtregierungsorganisationen zu ... Read more »

Diese Terrorliste ist fragwürdig

Israels Regierung erhebt schwere Vorwürfe gegen palästinensische NGOs, bleibt aber Beweise schuldig. Das nährt einen unguten Verdacht. © Foto: Majdi Mohammed (Keystone) Unter Beschuss: Shawan Jabarin, Chef der NGO Al-Haq, ... Read more »

Bekas Ahli Parlimen PKR ganti pemimpin Bersatu ketuai MPOC

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Larry Sng mengambil alih jawatan Pengerusi Majlis Minyak Sawit Malaysia daripada Osman Sapian. PETALING JAYA: Ahli Parlimen Julau, Larry Sng yang meninggalkan PKR Februari ... Read more »

'Succession' star Nicholas Braun: Greg 'never feels safe'

The season premiere of HBO’s “Succession” saw a lot of moves on the chess board that is the Roy family’s power struggle. © Macall B. Polay/HBO Cousin Greg (Nicholas Braun, ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin reportedly 'cancelling other projects' & is 'absolutely devastated' after prop gun accident

© Provided by Pinkvilla Alec Baldwin is reportedly “cancelling other projects” following an accidental shooting on the sets of his movie Rust which resulted in cinematographer Halyna Hutchins’ passing away, ... Read more »

David Alaba has just scored an absolute screamer to stun Barcelona in El Clasico

David Alaba’s first goal for Real Madrid is one he’ll never, ever forget. © GiveMeSport What a goal by David Alaba! The Austrian defender started in his first El Clasico ... Read more »

MLHP AP Recruitment 2021: 3393 vacancies for Mid Level Health Provider announced, apply before THIS date

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The Commissionerate of Health & Family Welfare, Andhra Pradesh has announced vacancies for Mid Level Health Provider (MLHP) on contract basis. A total ... Read more »

Rains threaten to spoil Indo-Pak T20 broadcast, moon sighting for Karwa Chauth in Delhi

Rains lashed several parts of Delhi on Sunday afternoon, bringing down the temperature in the national capital. However, heavy rains also played a spoilsport for people watching the India-Pakistan World ... Read more »

MoS Ajay Mishra's Son, Accused in Lakhimpur Violence, Contracts Dengue; Condition Stable

© Provided by News18 MoS Ajay Mishra’s Son, Accused in Lakhimpur Violence, Contracts Dengue; Condition Stable Union minister Ajay Kumar Mishra’s son Ashish Mishra, who is currently in jail in ... Read more »

Pelosi plans vote this week as battle over Biden's infrastructure proposal continues

Speaker Nancy Pelosi said the House and Senate plan to begin passage of President Joe Biden’s infrastructure agenda this week after concerns from moderates derailed the bills from reaching the ... Read more »

Paul Pogba omission for Man Utd vs Liverpool adds further weight to Paul Scholes' claims

Paul Scholes’ verdict that Ole Gunnar Solskjaer “does not trust” Paul Pogba was further validated as the midfielder was benched for Manchester United’s clash with Liverpool. Pogba was once one ... Read more »

Manchester United's lineup against Liverpool is back to basics but is it the right decision

Manchester United have announced the team that manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has selected to try and secure three points against Liverpool in Sunday’s Premier League fixture and it will be ... Read more »

The full lowdown on Man City coach Brian Barry-Murphy, his philosophy, and the likelihood of a shock Cardiff City move

There was a viral tweet that did the rounds a while back. You probably remember it. Or at least the memes it spawned. “Right so ROCHDALE scored this goal and ... Read more »

David de Gea angry after former Manchester United player makes Manuel Neuer claim

Former Manchester United midfielder Bastian Schweinsteiger has stated that Manuel Neuer is ‘on an completely different level’ to David de Gea. The United stopper was sad to be angry when ... Read more »

Neighbour heard ‘shouts and screams' at scene of suspected double murder in Essex

A neighbour has described hearing shouts and someone “yelling out in pain” from the scene of a suspected double murder in Essex © PA Wire Brentwood deaths Police were called ... Read more »

In brief: B: A Year in Plagues and Pencils; The Gardener; A Curious Boy – reviews

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Antonio Olmos/The Observer B: A Year in Plagues and Pencils © Photograph: Antonio Olmos/The Observer Salley Vickers: ‘rigorous and charming’. Edward CareyGallic Books, £14.99, ... Read more »

Kyogo Furuhashi is giving Celtic a selection headache and can't play in the same team as Giorgos Giokoumakis - Hotline

Alfredo Morelos hit the ton as Rangers hit the top. The Ibrox fans’ favourite made it 100 goals in 199 appearances with the decisive goal in Sunday’s 2-1 win over ... Read more »

Chelsea, Man U miss £100m ‘bargain' as Rice is worth more – Moyes

Chelsea and Man Utd have missed out on a “bargain” as West Ham United star Declan Rice is now worth more than £100m, according to David Moyes. © PA Images ... Read more »

Opinion: 'The Sopranos' movie was never going to be as good as the TV show

I don’t know what people expected from “The Sopranos” prequel movie, “The Many Saints of Newark,” but many of the reactions have been along the lines of, “It’s good; but ... Read more »

All Blacks run up three figures but it's not all doom and gloom for USA

With minutes to go at FedEx Field the scoreline stood at 14-92. Like Columbus, the All Blacks had wreaked havoc upon the new world. They didn’t stop there, though, scoring ... Read more »

Three shot in Queens, including man struck six times: cops

Three people were shot in Queens early Sunday morning, including a man who was hit six times, cops said. Gunfire rang out at 38-01 Beach Channel Drive during “a dispute” ... Read more »

How Alfredo Morelos and the Rangers players rated in table-topping win over St Mirren

Rangers returned to the top of the league opening up a three-point lead after defeating St Mirren. © How the Rangers players rated in win over St Mirren. (Photo by ... Read more »

DOH gives go signal for booster, additional COVID-19 shots

© LEO UDTOHAN Eulalia Cadeliña- Remolador, 88, a resident of Barangay Poblacion 3 in Tagbilaran City was the first to receive the vaccine as the city government of Tagbilaran City ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic