Assange extradition block risks rewarding fugitives for fleeing, court hears

Asia's Tech News Daily

Blocking Julian Assange’s removal to the US due to his mental health risks “rewarding fugitives for their flight” and giving a “trump card” to people looking to avoid extradition, the High Court has heard.

Assange, 50, is wanted in America on allegations of a conspiracy to obtain and disclose national defence information following WikiLeaks’ publication of hundreds of thousands of leaked documents relating to the Afghanistan and Iraq wars.

After a multi-week extradition hearing, then-District Judge Vanessa Baraitser ruled in January that Assange should not be sent to the US, citing a real and “oppressive” risk of suicide.

She found that “the procedures described by the US will not prevent Assange from finding a way to commit suicide”.

On Wednesday, the US authorities began their attempt to overturn the district judge’s decision at the High Court.

After initially indicating he would not attend Wednesday’s hearing, Assange observed via videolink from Belmarsh Prison in south-east London, appearing to wear a black face covering and a burgundy tie.

James Lewis QC, for the US, told the court that the district judge based her decision on Assange’s “intellectual ability to circumvent suicide preventative measures”, which risked becoming a “trump card” for anyone who wanted to oppose their extradition regardless of any resources the other state might have.

He continued: “The district judge’s approach carries with it the risk of rewarding fugitives for their flight, and of creating an anomaly between the approach of the courts in domestic criminal proceedings and in extradition.

“In the domestic context, it would never be said that an individual accused of crimes of the severity of Mr Assange’s could not be put on trial, despite being fit to be tried, because of his determination to commit suicide.”

Assange supporters demonstrated outside the High Court in London (James Manning/PA)

The US authorities have also argued Assange is well enough to be extradited, with Mr Lewis telling the court his mental illness “does not even come close” to being severe enough to prevent being sent to the US.

The barrister later said there was a “need for anxious scrutiny” and “caution” regarding Assange’s self-reported mental health, adding: “Mr Assange had every reason to exaggerate his symptoms.”

Mr Lewis also told the court the district judge “entirely based her decision” on the risk Assange would be submitted to special administrative measures and detained at the ADX Florence Supermax jail, if extradited.

However, he said four “binding” diplomatic assurances had been made, including that it would consent to him being transferred to Australia to serve any prison sentence he may be given, which “fundamentally change the factual basis” of her judgment.

A crowd of Assange supporters, including his partner Stella Moris, gathered outside the Royal Courts of Justice in central London ahead of the hearing, chanting and playing loud music.

Ms Moris, who was later seen in the public gallery of the court, told reporters: “I hope the courts will end this nightmare, that Julian is able to come home soon and that wise heads prevail.”

Edward Fitzgerald QC, for Assange, told the court in written arguments that the US authorities had “sought to minimise the severity of Mr Assange’s mental disorder and suicide risk”.

Stella Morris, the partner of Julian Assange, speaks to the media (James Manning/PA)

He continued: “It is perfectly reasonable to find it oppressive to extradite a mentally disordered person because his extradition is likely to result in his death.”

He added the assurance that Assange could be transferred to a prison in Australia if convicted was “meaningless”, adding that Assange “will most likely be dead before it can have any purchase, if it ever could”.

Mr Fitzgerald said that the district judge correctly relied on the “inevitable fact” Assange would be detained in isolation and deprived of protective factors he experiences in Belmarsh if extradited.

Mr Fitzgerald concluded: “None of the assurances now belatedly offered, even if admitted, would actually address the district judge’s concerns about the likelihood and effect of the imposition of extreme isolation, or the very prospect of it, on Mr Assange’s fragile mental health.

“All are caveated, vague, or simply ineffective. None offer any concession or ‘assurance’ against the application of existing US practice.”

Assange has been held in Belmarsh Prison since 2019 after he was carried out of the Ecuadorian embassy in London by police before being arrested for breaching his bail conditions.

He had entered the building in 2012 to avoid extradition to Sweden to face sex offence allegations, which he has always denied and were eventually dropped.

The hearing before the Lord Chief Justice Lord Burnett and Lord Justice Holroyde is expected to end on Thursday with a decision at a later date.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Gutsy NY diner waitress boots patron for creeping on ‘underaged girls'

An outspoken waitress at Long Island’s Massapequa Diner kicked out a creepy customer after he allegedly tried giving his cell phone number to “underaged girls,” made “loud” anti-LGBTQ slurs, and ... Read more »

Video: South Africa's Covid cases TRIPLE in a week: Daily infections hit level 15 times higher than a fortnight ago as Omicron continues to sweep across the country

Read more »

Video: Cagney & Lacey star Sharon Gless questioned her sexuality after kissing and hitting on Rosie O'Donnell

Read more »

Marjorie Taylor Greene claims jailed Capitol riot suspects' own public defenders call them ‘white supremacists'

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) speaks at a news conference at the U.S. Capitol Building on December 07, 2021 with Rep. Paul Gosar (R-AZ), Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL), and Rep. ... Read more »

Duke of Sussex backs campaign to scrap visa fees for Commonwealth Army veterans

Prince Harry, the Duke of Sussex, has backed a campaign to scrap visa fees for Commonwealth veterans who fought in the British Army – CHRIS JACKSON /AFP The Duke of ... Read more »

McDonald's workers shelter from active shooter in terrifying video

A video of McDonald's employees in Fort Meyers, Florida, sheltering during an active shooter situation has gone viral on TikTok, racking up more than 1.8 million views. The video appears ... Read more »

Tiger Woods may be set to return to the golf course in as little as 2 weeks so he can play with his son

© Ben Jared/PGA TOUR via Getty Images Tiger Woods may be set to return to the golf course in as little as 2 weeks so he can play with his ... Read more »

'Championship level', 'Not a chance' - Many Leeds fans fume as links to 'no-name' 28 y/o emerge

© Provided by This is Futbol Elland Road Leeds United fans have been reacting to claims about a potential swoop for Mariano Diaz in the upcoming transfer window. Leeds are ... Read more »

Man (70s) dies in Galway crash

© Leah Farrell via RollingNews.ie A MAN IN his 70s has died following a road crash in Galway this afternoon.  The incident happened on the N18 at Kiltartan at around ... Read more »

Voices: Boris Johnson's two most shameful lies just blew up in the most spectacular way

© ITV News The footage was obtained by ITV News – ITV News Boom. Boom. Two horrific blows, one after the other. Both on their own would be enough to ... Read more »

2023 Audi A6 Renderings Try To Predict Sedan's Mid-Cycle Refresh

2023 Audi A6 Sedan Unofficial Renderings 2023 Audi A6 Sedan Unofficial Renderings © Motor1.com Copyright 2023 Audi A6 Sedan Unofficial Renderings Don’t expect a radical redesign. Two weeks ago, spy ... Read more »

Uber, Deliveroo could be hit by draft EU rules for gig workers

1 / 2Uber, Deliveroo could be hit by draft EU rules for gig workersFILE PHOTO: A Deliveroo delivery rider cycles in London, Britain By Foo Yun Chee BRUSSELS (Reuters) – ... Read more »

Greene decries treatment of Capitol riot defendants, urges Jan 6. panel to tour DC jail

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene criticized the “outrageous” treatment of the Capitol riot defendants in a Washington DC jail at a press conference on December 7, 2021. Photo by BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP ... Read more »

Guardian owner switches on to Channel 4's Gurassa as next chairman

The publisher of The Guardian newspaper is lining up the outgoing chairman of Channel 4, the state-owned broadcaster, to take the helm in the aftermath of a row that saw ... Read more »

‘She should have trouble sleeping. I know I do': Holocaust survivor, 86, addresses trial of 96-year-old Nazi ‘secretary of evil' accused of being accessory to more than 11,000 murders at Polish death camp

Irmgard Furchner has been dubbed the 'secretary of evil' for death camp workShe is on trial in Germany accused of murder of over 11,000 people during WWIIOn Tuesday, Holocaust survivor Josef Salomonovic gave harrowing testimony The 83-year-old, six at the time, said Furchner was indirectly guilty of murders Read more »

New Covid-killing steel that reduces presence of the virus by 99.75% within three hours could make it easier to disinfect mass-transit areas and crowded venues

The stainless steel was created by adding copper to the mixtureIt kills the presence of the coronavirus by 99.99% in six hours and completely eliminates any traces in 24 hours The team wants to create lift buttons, doorknobs and handrails for further tests and trials of their new stainless steel Read more »

This Is The Stephen King Novel Guillermo Del Toro Really Wanted To Adapt

Andrea Raffin/Shutterstock If you enjoy watching horror movies, the odds are high that you’ve watched at least one Stephen King adaptation. The iconic horror writer’s stories have been made into ... Read more »

Embattled Florida Keys county commissioner resigns following his domestic violence arrest

Embattled Florida Keys county commissioner Eddie Martinez resigned from office Tuesday citing “health issues,” Monroe County announced in a press release. His resignation comes a week after he was arrested ... Read more »

Vanderbilt vs. Temple total, prediction: Don't expect many points

Scotty Pippen Jr. leads Vanderbilt in scoring. AP The Vanderbilt Commodores have been playing without a pair of potential starters to begin the season, and on Tuesday, they will play ... Read more »

Voices: It's raining cats and dogs – and Boris Johnson is getting soaked

Boom. Boom. Two horrific blows, one after the other. Both on their own would be enough to knock out a man with even a nanogram of shame left in his ... Read more »

Change yourself, or changes will happen: PM to truant BJP MP

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Upset over the stubborn truancy among BJP MPs, Prime Minister Narendra Modi dropped a stern hint that attendance in Parliament could ... Read more »

Second accuser takes stand in Ghislaine Maxwell sex trafficking trial

© Provided by WION A woman testified Monday that Ghislaine Maxwell groomed her to engage in sexual activity with Jeffrey Epstein, the second of four women alleging abuse to take ... Read more »

Every day another minister crashes and burns. Today it was Dominic Raab

It’s getting to be something of a habit. Every morning a minister gets sent out to face the national media and every morning he or she crashes and burns. For ... Read more »

Olympics Diplomatic Boycott

Olympics Diplomatic Boycott Read more »

Afghans 'Left To Die' Amid Chaos At Foreign Office, Whistleblower Claims

Evacuation efforts at Kabul airport. (Photo: Ministry of Defence via PA Media) A whistleblower has claimed he was left to deal with thousands of emails pleading for help from desperate ... Read more »

Selfies left on victim's phone help ID carjacking suspect in North Carolina, cops say

An armed carjacking suspect in Indiana inadvertently got himself arrested, when detectives realized he left behind incriminating selfies, the Indianapolis Police Department says. Dustin Curry, 30, was captured about three ... Read more »

Same-sex marriage now legal in 30 countries

© LISELOTTE SABROE On October 1, 1989, for the first time in the world, gay couples in Denmark tied the knot in legal civil unions, but would have to wait ... Read more »

Oslo University Hospital is considering reducing surgical activity due to sick leave levels and corona pressure

Oslo University Hospital (OUS) is considering reducing its surgical activity due to an increasing number of corona patients and high sickness absence levels.  The OUS has already reduced planned surgery ... Read more »

Dröge und Hasselmann neue deutsche Grünen-Fraktionsvorsitzende

© Keystone/dpa/Kay Nietfeld Die Grünen-Fraktion im deutschen Bundestag hat eine neue Doppelspitze. Die Wirtschaftsexpertin Katharina Dröge und die bisherige Erste Parlamentarische Geschäftsführerin Britta Hasselmann wurden am Dienstag als neue Vorsitzende ... Read more »

Wie die Renten-Ausfälle kompensiert werden sollen

Der Nationalrat setzt auf ein abgespecktes Modell, um Rentenkürzungen in der Pensionskasse zu vermeiden. Die Linke droht bereits mit dem Referendum – und will lieber eine «Mini-AHV». © Foto: Michael ... Read more »

What TV channel is the Ashes on? Watch Australia vs England on BT Sport

England have plenty to do in the latest round of the Ashes down under, as they seek to bring an end to their poor record when visiting Australia. It’s been ... Read more »

Israel stellt unterirdische Mauer entlang des Gazastreifens fertig

© Keystone/AP/Tsafrir Abayov Nach rund vier Jahren Bauzeit hat Israel eine 65 Kilometer lange, unterirdische Mauer entlang des Gazastreifens fertiggestellt. Sie soll die Möglichkeit von Angriffen durch Tunnel der in ... Read more »

Moyes must end injury crisis with £9m-rated “Rolls-Royce,” he's what WHU are missing - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Bournemouth defender Lloyd Kelly West Ham United must sanction a move for Bournemouth defender Lloyd Kelly in the upcoming January transfer window, ending David Moyes’ ... Read more »

Police question Detroit artist to see if he had ‘role' in hiding Ethan Crumbley's parents

The artist who owns the Detroit studio where Ethan Crumbley’s parents were caught hiding out has been questioned by police who also searched his home, according to authorities and his ... Read more »

'Omicron', 'Cheugy' and 'Billie Eilish' are among 2021's most mispronounced words

Omicron and Cheugy ranked on a list of the most mispronounced words this yearBillie Eilish and Jason Kelce's names were commonly said wrong by newsreadersOther words that tripped people up were dalgona, chipotle, Shein and EthereumThe tongue-twisting list commissioned by language-learning platform Babbel Read more »

Jake Tapper 'is poised, by a long stretch, to replace axed Chris Cuomo' at troubled CNN

CNN host Jake Tapper is rumored to be the top choice candidate to replace former anchor Chris Cuomo after he was fired from the network on SaturdayTapper has been called 'a logical choice' among a series of candidates as the network has scrambled to look for Cuomo's replacementThe former anchor was fired from CNN for defending his brother former Governor Andrew Cuomo against multiple sexual harassment chargesTapper was one of the reported staff members angered at the network for not taking action sooner against Cuomo Other rumored candidates have been CNN's Reliable Sources anchor Brian Stelter, MSNBC host Brian Williams and political commentator S.E. Cupp Read more »

Cases of anorexia among teens aged 13 to 16 jumped 65% during first wave of pandemic, study finds

The first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic caused a surge of teens developing anorexia, a new study finds New cases of anorexia among those aged 13 to 16 jumped by 65% during the first Covid waveDuring that same period, hospitalizations related to the condition jumped by 166% as wellResearchers also found that those who were diagnosed with the condition during the pandemic were also in worse shape on average Read more »

Two arrested for robbery in Richmond

Dec. 7—Aaron M. Bowles and Shalyn E. Brewer, both of Richmond, were arrested on Dec. 4 and charged with first-degree robbery (Brewer was complicit), possession of marijuana, and possession of ... Read more »

Ex-Missouri police chief granted probation in beating of man who tried to drown baby

A federal judge in Kansas City sentenced a former Missouri police chief to five years of probation in the beating of a man who tried to drown his own infant ... Read more »

Billionaire hedge funder hands over $70M in stolen antiquities

Billionaire Michael Steinhardt agreed to surrendor 180 antiquities valued at $170 Million in order to avoid criminal charges. Bloomberg via Getty Images New York hedge fund billionaire and philanthropist Michael ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic