As US credit risk looms, former S&P officials see 2011 downgrade as vindicated

as us credit risk looms, former s&p officials see 2011 downgrade as vindicated

FILE PHOTO: Visitors walk on the plaza at the U.S. Capitol in Washington

By Pete Schroeder

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – As the United States stares at the risk of a credit downgrade, former Standard & Poor’s officials stood firm behind their seminal 2011 call to slash the country’s rating as the right decision.

That downgrade came days after Washington narrowly averted a default, but S&P went ahead, cutting the U.S. pristine “AAA” to “AA-plus,” citing heightened political polarization and insufficient steps to right the nation’s fiscal outlook.

“We thought that the political polarization in the country was likely to endure, and secondly, we were also concerned about the rising trajectory of debt,” said David Beers, the former head of sovereign ratings for S&P. “On both of our counts, our expectations, if anything…have been exceeded. I have no doubt in my mind that was the right call.”

The downgrade was unprecedented and met with fierce criticism from the then-Obama administration and some congressional leaders, who challenged S&P’s methods and analysis.

S&P had actually placed the U.S. government on a negative outlook four months before the downgrade. And S&P notified the U.S. government of its downgrade decision roughly 24 hours in advance of a formal announcement, according to John Chambers, who headed S&P’s sovereign rating committee.

“It was probably, professionally, the most important decision I’ve made in my life,” said Chambers. “When you lower the rating of a government, they’re always very upset. … We think we’ve been vindicated with the passage of time.”

S&P still maintains the downgraded U.S. rating, with a stable outlook. An S&P spokesperson declined to comment further.


As the U.S. again teeters on a debt-ceiling crisis, credit agencies are again assessing the U.S.’s creditworthiness. They are weighing repeated political fights over the nation’s borrowing capacity and a weaker fiscal picture weighing on the nation’s creditworthiness.

Wednesday’s threat by Fitch Ratings that it could downgrade the U.S. credit rating has spiked concerns the nation could see borrowing costs rise and its standing as the backbone of the global financial system weakened.

The move also placed a spotlight on Fitch, which is smaller than the other major rating agencies, Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s Investors Service.

“Rating agencies are for-profit, private companies,” said Steven Schwarcz, a professor at Duke Law School. “Their main stock and trade is reputation. … A credit downgrade watch doesn’t mean there’s a downgrade, but it gets Fitch right out there in the news and that could increase its reputation.”

A Fitch spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment on the motivation behind the decision.

The agency said while it expects policymakers to reach a deal, there are “elevated” risks given the shrinking amount of time. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has said the U.S. government could run out of funds as soon as June 1.

The move leaves Moody’s as the lone major credit rating agency to not take formal steps to reassess the nation’s credit reputation. An agency spokesperson said Thursday that Moody’s still has the nation rated “AAA” with a stable outlook — its highest possible rating.

But Moody’s is leaving the door open to a similar move to Fitch, telling Reuters a change in tone among Washington negotiators could spur such a warning.

“I suspect none of them want to look foolish or overconfident if matters do sour. Thus a credit watch rating is a nice compromise,” said John Coffee, a professor at Columbia Law School.

Moody’s did not comment about the reason it has not yet moved.

Experts said for credit raters, evaluating the U.S. presents a challenge because the concerns are primarily about the political ability to strike compromise and raise the legally-mandated borrowing cap, as opposed to actually raising funds to pay off debtors once permitted.

“It’s kind of symbolic rather than probability of loss because it should be much, much lower if there was a significant probability of loss,” said Edward Altman, a finance professor emeritus at New York University’s Stern School of Business.

(Reporting by Pete Schroeder; editing by Megan Davies and Leslie Adler)

News Related


As rising oceans threaten NYC, study documents another risk: The city is sinking

As rising oceans threaten NYC, study documents another risk: The city is sinking New York City is sinking under the weight of its skyscrapers, homes, pavement and humanity itself FILE ... Read more »

Thousands evacuated as Philippines warns of possible flooding, landslides from Typhoon Mawar

Thousands evacuated as Philippines warns of possible flooding, landslides from Typhoon Mawar Philippine officials are evacuating thousands of villagers, shutting schools and offices and imposing a no-sail ban as Typhoon ... Read more »

Elon Musk says Twitter has no 'actual choice' when complying with authoritarian government requests to restrict content

In this photo illustration, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis joins Elon Musk on Twitter Spaces to formally announce his run for the Republican nomination for president to on May 24, 2023 ... Read more »

Just stop Labour’s oil and gas ban

Just Stop Oil activists at Twickenham Climate change zealots belonging to the organisation Just Stop Oil sought to disrupt the premiership rugby final at Twickenham on Saturday, just a few ... Read more »

Sent money to the wrong person through Zelle? Here's how to get it back

Learn how to navigate and recover from Zelle mistakes, including sending funds to the wrong person, through effective dispute processes and timely actions. Chuck Brown sent money to the wrong ... Read more »

Succession series finale ending, explained

After 4 seasons of arrogance, opulence, and intense familial power struggles, the HBO (now Max) series Succession has finally come to an end. The story began with a sick and ... Read more »

Washington Wizards Expected To Make Major Changes After Hiring New President

The Washington Wizards have been stuck in a cycle of mediocrity for a very long time, missing the NBA Playoffs in three out of the last four seasons. The Wizards ... Read more »

Want Free Overnight At-Home Charging For Your Model 3? Here's What's On Offer From Tesla

Want Free Overnight At-Home Charging For Your Model 3? Here’s What’s On Offer From Tesla EV giant Tesla Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) has commenced a new offer to boost Tesla Electric and ... Read more »

This all-new ‘neighborhood vehicle’ can run on free energy from the sun — and it’s incredibly cheap to drive

WAEV Electric Car with rooftop solar panels In April, microcar manufacturer WAEV announced it would be adding rooftop solar panels as an option for its GEM electric vehicles (EVs), Electrek ... Read more »

Succession Finale Theory Suggests The Biggest Betrayal Was Hiding In Plain Sight

Group photo screencap from Succession This article contains spoilers for the series finale of “Succession.” There have been lots of fan theories flying around about the series finale of “Succession,” but ... Read more »

Another Nosy Question: 'What's Wrong With Your Eye?'

Judith Martin, Miss Manners DEAR MISS MANNERS: I work in retail and have dealt with all types of people. Three years ago, I had cancer in my eye and had ... Read more »

Does Kendall Roy Die In Succession's Series Finale?

Does Kendall Roy Die In Succession’s Series Finale? WARNING! This article contains major SPOILERS for Succession’s series finale!Succession has long been building to a tragic end for Kendall Roy, but ... Read more »

Baby Raccoon Brought into Maine Petco for Nail Trimming Euthanized Over Rabies Concern

“Please ‘Keep Wildlife Wild’ and “If you care, leave them there,'” the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife said of the incident Getty A baby raccoon was euthanized over ... Read more »

Succession series finale reveals who will replace Logan Roy

Warning: This article contains spoilers for the series finale of Succession, “With Open Eyes.” “Big, big day on the old salami line,” announced Fisher Stevens’ communications chief Hugo Baker two-thirds ... Read more »

Boil water alert is issued for parts of Northeast D.C.

Residents of several Northeast Washington neighborhoods were told late Sunday to boil water before cooking or drinking as a precaution after a loss of water pressure. D.C. Water said the ... Read more »

Blue Jays 3, Twins 0: Blue birds & boo-birds

Blue Jays 3, Twins 0: Blue birds & boo-birds This weekend, a rather large contingent of Toronto Blue Jays faithful made the southward border crossing for some Target Field action. ... Read more »

State Farm stops accepting home insurance applications in California: 'Difficult place to do business'

Tech and real estate entrepreneur Peter Rex reacted to State Farm’s decision to cease home insurance applications in California, predicting there was an “unspoken reason” the firm made its decision. ... Read more »

Ukraine will put an end to the history of Moscow's despotism against various peoples – Zelenskyy

President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said that Ukraine will put an end to the history of Moscow’s despotism, which has enslaved various peoples for a long time. Source: President’s evening address Quote: ... Read more »

Gamers Are Divided Over Spider-Man 2's Symbiote Suit

Gamers Are Divided Over Spider-Man 2’s Symbiote Suit Spider-Man and controversial costumes go hand-in-hand. A couple of years ago, the comics unveiled a blue, white, and orange suit to a ... Read more »

Walmart employees are inundating the company's social-media site with memes making fun of management

One million Walmart workers, or more than half the retailer’s US employee base, have signed up for Workplace. Chris Hondros/Getty Images Walmart started using Workplace, a Meta-designed social-media app, in ... Read more »

How to keep your business moving forward: Tips from experts on managing inflation

How to keep your business moving forward: Tips from experts on managing inflation NEXT AVENUE This article is reprinted by permission from A recent survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of New ... Read more »

Ukraine says it shot down 36 drones in overnight Russian attacks

Russian drone strike in Kyiv KYIV (Reuters) – Ukraine said on Thursday it had shot down all 36 Iranian-made drones launched by Russia in overnight attacks which it said probably ... Read more »

Nine (completely free) ways to save money on your energy bills

Nine (completely free) ways to save money on your energy bills You can hardly move these days for energy-saving hacks, regardless of how helpful they actually are. In the chaos ... Read more »

Apple could take its iPhone chips to the next level with huge 5G investment

null Future iPhones could get a big boost from Apple’s new investment into 5G components, which could see the tech giant make a single chip for cellular, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth ... Read more »

DJ Moore Finding Fit with Bears Easy to Make

Bears wide receiver DJ Moore might be planning a position switch. At least, he’s sort of fantasizing about one after seeing how he fits into the Halas Hall scene. It ... Read more »

Costco Is Offering $2,500 Off EVs Right Now

Prashanth Bala / Costco members shopping for an electric vehicle can save a little extra money on their purchase through July 31. Incentives of $2,500 now are available on ... Read more »

Arne Slot rules himself out of Tottenham job to stay at Feyenoord

Arne Slot will not be Tottenham’s next manager after confirming he will stay at Feyenoord. The Dutchman, who led the club to their first league title in five years this ... Read more »

Cubs Farm Report: Top Prospects Heating Up

The Chicago Cubs minor league system seems to be mirroring their Major League parent club.  Its farm system went 6-0  on Saturday, 0-4 on Sunday, and 4-0 on Tuesday. If ... Read more »

This Live Map Shows Exactly Where Sharks Are Roaming In The Ocean

This Live Map Shows Exactly Where Sharks Are Roaming In The Ocean In general, people have a lot of misunderstandings about sharks, and it makes sense. Most of us only ... Read more »

German economy minister's office receives envelope with white powder

FILE PHOTO: Plenum session of the lower house of parliament, Bundestag, in Berlin BERLIN (Reuters) -German Economy Minister Robert Habeck’s constituency office said on Thursday it had received an envelope ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự