As Maple Leafs Fans, Are We Sure Dubas Traded Nazem Kadri?

as maple leafs fans, are we sure dubas traded nazem kadri?

As Maple Leafs Fans, Are We Sure Dubas Traded Nazem Kadri?

In a recent article by Joseph Zita of LeafsNation, he noted the five worst moves Toronto Maple Leafs general manager Kyle Dubas made during his tenure with the team. Right at the top was the trade between the Maple Leafs and the Colorado Avalanche that moved Nazem Kadri out and brought in Tyson Barrie and Alex Kerfoot. [By the way, there’s no blame pointed at Zita for this post. He’s simply echoing the feelings of most Maple Leafs’ fans. And to Zita’s credit, this post followed another one where he pointed out Dubas’ five best moves.]

How Can We Be Sure Who Did What with the Maple Leafs?

In the post, Zita noted that the trade where the Maple Leafs acquired Tyson Barrie, Alex Kerfoot, and a 2020 3rd-round pick from the Colorado Avalanche in exchange for Nazem Kadri, Calle Rosen, and a 2020 sixth-round pick, was indeed a significant move made by Maple Leafs general manager Kyle Dubas. My quibble with this is not to argue whether it’s the best or worst trade Dubas made. Rather, what I wonder about is whether Dubas actually made the trade.

Given what we’ve learned about the way the Maple Leafs’ leadership decision-making worked, we really can’t be certain Dubas made the trade at all. Nor can we be sure what decisions he made – or was directed to make – by Maple Leafs’ president Brendan Shanahan.

Dubas is blamed for the moves; but, if he didn’t make them – or did them under executive order but didn’t agree – he carries too much responsibility for the errors.

We’ve Learned More About the Maple Leafs’ Chain of Command Recently

Obviously, I am just speculating; however, the moves of the past two weeks have given us more insight into how the Maple Leafs’ chain of command worked. Dubas, in his final act before being dismissed, sought a more direct leadership role – more autonomy to make decisions. That suggests he felt he didn’t have it.

Again, I’m not arguing that he should have had autonomy – just that he felt he didn’t and he wanted it. The decision is a “pay-grade” choice; and, it wasn’t in Dubas’ authority to make that decision. That’s ok. While I wouldn’t do it that way, I have authority no quibble with it. The organization bears the weight of that choice – for good or for ill.

What I do quibble with is that, if indeed, Dubas made the decisions, why is he left to shoulder the responsibility for their success or their failure? Again, I’m only speculating based on the logic of what I saw occur. And, I might be wrong.

What We Know about the Kadri Trade

What we do know is that, to Maple Leafs’ fans, Nazem Kadri was a beloved player and a fan favourite. He was known for his physicality and offensive contributions. However, Kadri’s suspensions in consecutive playoff series against the Boston Bruins probably also factored into the decision to trade him.

What we also know is that he didn’t want to move. He bled blue blood in his veins. He wanted to stay in Toronto so badly that he nixed a trade to the Calgary Flames, ironically the team he suits up for today.

The trade from a Maple Leafs’ perspective didn’t work out well for the team. Tyson Barrie, the key piece acquired in the trade, did not provide offensive production from the blue line. He struggled to find his footing in Toronto’s defensive system and didn’t meet the expectations placed on him. Additionally, Alex Kerfoot, although a capable player, didn’t have as significant an impact as some fans had hoped.

In hindsight, the trade didn’t yield the planned results for the Maple Leafs. Losing a fan favourite like Kadri, combined with Barrie’s underperformance, might lead some to consider this a questionable move by Dubas.

However, what if he didn’t do it?

What If the Trade Went Down Like This?

Let’s assume for a minute that the trade worked out this way. In a meeting between Dubas and his team with Shanahan, there was a discussion. Shanahan then decided to move Kadri. He left the how and where to Dubas, who set about talking trade to several possible teams. Then, Dubas had to come back to Shanahan to seek his approval.

It could be that this happened several times until Dubas finally created an acceptable scenario. In such a scenario, correct or incorrect, Shanahan decided to trade Kardi. Dubas did the work and got his president’s okay.

If Brendan Shanahan was responsible for this trade, it suggests that throughout Dubas’ tenure, he had a hand in shaping the team’s direction and roster changes. The decision to trade Kadri would have been made to address specific team needs or make strategic changes. Some trades work out and some don’t.

The Same Could Be True for the Nick Foligno Trade

The trade for Nick Foligno from the Columbus Blue Jackets was seen as Dubas second-worst move. Now we aren’t sure he was responsible for the trade. A similar scenario might have been at play within the organization’s decision-making structure.

Again, no quibble with the intent of the trade. It would have been motivated by the desire to bring in a veteran player with leadership qualities to positively impact the team. The fact that Foligno might have been injured when he reported to the team was an issue. The fact that he played just a few games was the bigger issue.

In short, it didn’t work out, and people blamed Dubas for the poor decision. Considering the attribution of bad decisions in retrospect is moot. They are done and Dubas is gone.

Still, it just strikes me as problematic that the general manager (in this case, Dubas) carries significant responsibility for player personnel decisions. However, the overall direction and strategic decisions the team made look like they were typically made (or at least influenced) by the president (in this case, Shanahan).

Because No One Can Be Certain, No Sense in Blaming Anyone

Without detailed information or access to specific events, it is challenging to definitively attribute specific decisions to either Shanahan or Dubas. What we do know is that the dynamic between Dubas and Shanahan fell apart, in part because Dubas wanted more autonomy in the decisions that were made.

No blame is involved – either way. That’s the way the organization did things; and, it’s a way many organizations work.

The bottom line is that we can’t be sure who did what; and, perhaps until we do – if ever – it isn’t wise to point fingers at anyone.

Want more articles like this? Follow NHL Trade Talk on MSN to see more of our exclusive NHL content.

More must-reads:

    News Related


    Canadian Investors: 2 Oversold Canadian Stocks to Buy Now

    Technology In the ever-evolving world of finance, investors constantly seek opportunities that offer a balance between security and growth. And what better time to explore this strategy than when certain ... Read more »

    'Oo, I’m so scared': A Canadian house responds to Ottawa’s pledge to make it affordable

    Canada’s greatest national triumph: single-family homes that command the same price as a good-sized Irish island. The Trudeau government has recently been championing the issue of housing affordability — which ... Read more »

    Blue Planet Energy Has a Solar Battery With Character

    The BlueWave is a small battery with a lot to offer Blue Planet Energy Blue Planet Energy, a clean energy company based in Hawaii and founded by Henk Rogers, founder ... Read more »

    Hellebuyck, Scheifele Likely Gone by Season's End, According to THN Staff Poll

    Thirty-four members of The Hockey News’ staff cast their votes in a pre-season poll in relation to predictions for the 2023-24 NHL season. With questions ranging from trophy predictions to ... Read more »

    Before You Buy NVIDIA, Here’s an AI Stock I’d Buy First

    Businessman holding AI cloud NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA) is one of the hottest stocks of 2022. Up 206% for the year, it has vastly outperformed the markets. NVIDIA is well known for ... Read more »

    Letters: September 23, 2023

    From gas to groceries and everything in between, the global chaos we are experiencing is making itself felt here at home. Grocery tax won’t work Trudeau thinks that taxing grocers ... Read more »

    Murray Mandryk: Sask. concerns over India worsened by old politics in play

    While Trade Minister Jeremy Harrison may have been overly political in his criticism of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, the trade issue with India is a real one for Saskatchewan. It ... Read more »

    The Best Times to Visit India for Good Weather, Lower Rates, and Festivals

    Tips from an expert to make the most of your visit. Gautier Houba/Travel + Leisure India is a massive country, home to more than 1 billion people. Complex, intricate, overwhelming, ... Read more »

    These Are The Top Canadian Companies Of 2023 With The Happiest Employees

    The top Canadian companies with the best work well-being were ranked and Petro-Canada managed to top the list. Indeed announced its winners of the Best Work Awards 2023, which highlights ... Read more »

    Tampa Bay Rays call up 20-year-old infield prospect Junior Caminero

    ST. PETERSBURG. Fla. (AP) — The playoff-bound Tampa Bay Rays have called up 20-year-old minor league prospect Junior Caminero from Double-A Montgomery. The Rays announced before Friday night’s game against ... Read more »

    This 10-Day Journey Through Norway Celebrates Strong Women, From a Remote Distillery Founder to the Country’s First Female to Summit Everest

    Norway is one of the most gender-equal countries in the world. A-List travel advisor Torunn Tronsvang shines a light on some of the country’s inspirational women. Courtesy of Up Norway ... Read more »

    Russian Naval Assets Evacuated from Black Sea Harbor After Devastating Ukrainian Missile Strikes: Reports

    Russian naval assets are being shifted out of Sevastopol harbor in Crimea in the wake of the most recent blow to Russia’s Black Sea holdings. has learned that a ... Read more »

    Wang Xiyu beats Magda Linette in Guangzhou to win her first WTA title

    GUANGZHOU, China (AP) — Local favorite Wang Xiyu won her first WTA title by beating top-seeded Magda Linette 6-0, 6-2 at the Guangzhou Open on Saturday. “It was very exciting ... Read more »

    Series of gaffes sink Virginia in late loss to North Carolina State

    Series of gaffes sink Virginia in late loss to North Carolina State Virginia did everything imaginable to lose its game to North Carolina State in the final minutes on Friday ... Read more »

    Springwater adopts bollards as traffic-calming measure

    They’re called temporary bollards and they’ll be popping up across Springwater Township next year. A flexible plastic sign with a laminated speed limit, it’s attached to a rubber-covered hinge anchored ... Read more »

    Canadian women's volleyball team fails to clinch Olympic spot for Paris

    Hilary Howe, right, and the Canadian women’s volleyball team defeated Mexico 3-0 on Saturday but failed to clinch a berth in the Olympic tournament next summer. Serbia and the Dominican ... Read more »

    1992 Lancia Delta Integrale Martini 6 Evoluzione, Today's BaT Pick

    Built as a homologation special for Group A rallying, the Lancia Delta Integrale could be considered the ultimate Italian hot hatchback. All-wheel drive and a turbocharged engine provide grip and ... Read more »

    UFC Vegas 79 predictions

    UFC Vegas 79 predictions Rafael Fiziev and Mateusz Gamrot are tasked with bringing the UFC back to the APEX in style. Believe it or not, the UFC APEX hasn’t hosted ... Read more »

    Drew Barrymore Explains Decision To Resume Talk Show Amid Strikes, Planned Picketing: ‘I Own This Choice’

    Drew Barrymore Last week, it was announced that “The Drew Barrymore Show” was resuming production, with the fourth season kicking off in mid-September. When the WGA initiated strike action back ... Read more »

    Jakobi Meyers injury update: Raiders WR leaves game after taking scary hit vs. Broncos

    Jakobi Meyers injury update: Raiders WR leaves game after taking scary hit vs. Broncos The Raiders were able to beat the Broncos 17-16 on Sunday, but they suffered a key ... Read more »

    ‘Next Goal Wins’ Review: Taika Waititi’s Soccer Film Sacrifices Sincerity for Self-Conscious Humor

    ‘Next Goal Wins’ Review: Taika Waititi’s Soccer Film Sacrifices Sincerity for Self-Conscious Humor Before the world premiere of his latest film, Next Goal Wins, Taika Waititi offered a few introductory ... Read more »

    Intelligence chief gives Russia no more than a year: ‘Down’ and ‘panicking’

    Russia will not last another year in the ongoing Ukraine war. Ukrainian Lieutenant General and head of the Military Security Service Kyrylo Budanov is convinced of this at the “Yalta ... Read more »

    Rubiales resigns as Spain's soccer president 3 weeks after kissing player at Women's World Cup final

    Rubiales resigns as Spain’s soccer president 3 weeks after kissing player at Women’s World Cup final BARCELONA, Spain (AP) — Luis Rubiales, the suspended head of the Spanish soccer federation, ... Read more »

    Islanders’ Line Options for Oliver Wahlstrom

    Islanders’ Line Options for Oliver Wahlstrom The NHL season is around the corner with opening night a month away. Recently, the New York Islanders writers at The Hockey Writers (THW) ... Read more »

    Zach Bryan Spends Second Week Atop Billboard 200 With Self-Titled Album

    Zach Bryan Spends Second Week Atop Billboard 200 With Self-Titled Album Zach Bryan’s self-titled album spends a second week atop Billboard 200 chart (dated Sept. 16), as the set earned 115,000 ... Read more »

    Toronto: “Hotline Bling” Director X Calls for Training Black Talent to Break Down Barriers to Racial Justice

    Toronto: “Hotline Bling” Director X Calls for Training Black Talent to Break Down Barriers to Racial Justice New Canadian Black talent faces many obstacles to making real inroads on film and TV ... Read more »

    Braves become 1st MLB team to clinch playoff spot as Acuña and Olson lead rally past Pirates

    Braves become 1st MLB team to clinch playoff spot as Acuña and Olson lead rally past Pirates ATLANTA (AP) — The Atlanta Braves became the first team to clinch a ... Read more »

    TIFF Tribute Awards: Spike Lee, Pedro Almodovar, Colman Domingo Provide Star Power Despite Strikes

    TIFF Tribute Awards: Spike Lee, Pedro Almodovar, Colman Domingo Provide Star Power Despite Strikes Despite the first simultaneous strikes of actors and writers since 1960 — 16 years before the first ... Read more »

    Halton Healthcare Takes Innovative Step to Combat Opioid Crisis

    In a groundbreaking initiative, Halton Healthcare, encompassing Oakville Trafalgar Memorial Hospital, Milton District Hospital, and Georgetown Hospital, has emerged as one of the foremost community hospital organizations to offer free ... Read more »

    Trudeau's plane grounded in India by technical issues after G20 summit conclusion

    NEW DELHI — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s return to Canada from the G20 summit in India has been delayed by problems with his plane. The Prime Minister’s Office says it ... Read more »
    Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự