As denying climate change becomes impossible, fossil-fuel interests pivot to 'carbon shaming'

© Marianne Ayala/Insider Marianne Ayala/Insider

  • Fossil-fuel interests no longer bother denying that climate change is real.
  • So they’ve pivoted to new tactics, including painting climate advocates as hypocrites.
  • Drawing attention to advocates’ non-eco-friendly habits undermines their credibility and distracts from policy changes.
  • See more stories on Insider’s business page.

After Prince Harry told Oprah Winfrey that climate change and mental health are two of the “most important issues facing the world today,” the New York Post threw the words back at him. In a story earlier this week, the Post reported that the “double-talking dilettante” had taken a private plane from Colorado to California.

Sky News and The Times too, have lambasted Harry’s carbon-intensive jetsetting. All three publications are tied to Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, which previously denied the science of climate change. Murdoch is on the advisory board of Genie Energy, an energy company that invests in oil and gas projects.

London mayor Sadiq Khan, an anti-pollution advocate, got similar treatment from The Sun, another Murdoch-owned publication, for flying 32,000 miles between 2016 and 2019 and purchasing 4.3 million paper towels in a year.

According to Michael Mann, an atmospheric science professor at Pennsylvania State University, these types of stories are part of a larger strategy: Groups that support the continued use of fossil fuels have increasingly begun to point out climate advocates’ seemingly hypocritical behavior, rather than denying that climate change is real. It’s one of many new strategies the fossil-fuel industry has adopted, according to Mann’s latest book “The New Climate War.”

Mann told Insider that in his view, “2009-2010 was the last hurrah for good old fashioned climate-change denialism.” By 2019, 62% of Americans agreed that climate change was affecting their day-to-day lives.

“It’s beyond not being able to deny the science,” he said. “It’s now a matter of having to deny reality.”

© Marco Bello/Reuters A car moves through a flooded street as Hurricane Delta approaches, in Baker, Louisiana, October 9, 2020. Marco Bello/Reuters

So instead of hammering the “climate change isn’t happening” message, the fossil-fuel industry now seems to be fostering finger-pointing and infighting among environmentalists. That siphons time and attention away from efforts to bring about systemic changes to cut emissions – policies like carbon taxes, incentives for renewable energy, or restrictions on fossil-fuel infrastructure.

“What better way to discredit thought leaders and key messengers than to tar them as hypocrites based on accusations that they don’t walk the walk?” Mann said.

‘Mr. Global Warming?’

© Stefania D’Alessandro / Contributor / Getty Images Actor Leonardo DiCaprio. Stefania D’Alessandro / Contributor / Getty Images

Leonardo DiCaprio, Al Gore, and Barack Obama have all been targets of this “climate hypocrisy” line of attack.

DiCaprio started a multi-million dollar environmental conservation fund and used his 2016 Oscars speech to talk about the climate crisis. But when he flew from France to New York in a private jet to accept an environmental award later that year, the headlines followed.

“Hollywood hypocrite’s global warming sermon,” the Herald Sun‘s read. (The Herald Sun also belongs to Murdoch’s news empire.) The New York Post called DiCaprio a “megapolluter” and “Mr. Global Warming,” and suggested that the actor’s flight “expanded his carbon footprint by 8,000 miles in about 24 hours.”

Gore, meanwhile, is known for the 2006 documentary “An Inconvenient Truth.” But after he starred in a sequel to the film in 2017, an op-ed in The Daily Caller suggested that Gore’s home devoured 34 times more energy than the average US household. The Daily Caller, founded by Tucker Carlson, received $3.5 million in funding from the Koch Family Foundations and the Charles Koch Institute in the last decade. According to Greenpeace, the Koch brothers spent $15 million to finance 90 groups that attacked climate science and policy between 1997 and 2018.

© John Lamparski/WireImage Former US vice president Al Gore signs “An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth To Truth” at Barnes & Noble, 5th Avenue on August 2, 2017 in New York City. John Lamparski/WireImage

The Daily Caller piece was written by Drew Johnson, founder of the Beacon Center of Tennessee, a libertarian think tank. Johnson was, for the most part, doubling down on a tactic that had worked for him a decade earlier.

“He tells other people how to live and he’s not following his own rules,” Johnsen told ABC in 2007, after the center published a report describing how Gore’s 20-room home used 20 times as much electricity as the average American house.

The criticism of Obama came in 2019, when an op-ed in the Hill blasted him for buying a house in Martha’s Vineyard. Purchasing ocean-front property, the piece argued, suggests one isn’t actually worried about sea-level rise. The article was written by Katie Pavlich, an alumna of the Young Americans’ Foundation – an outreach organization of the conservative movement with financial ties to the Koch Brothers.

“If the former president is truly concerned about sea levels rising as a result of climate change,” Pavlich wrote, “his latest real estate purchase places doubts on his sincerity.”

That type of argument, Mann said, directs attention away from the companies emitting the carbon that contributes to sea-level rise.

“It would be funny if it weren’t so pernicious,” he added.

‘Carbon shaming’

© JOKER/Hady Khandani/ullstein bild via Getty Images A Tunisair flight takes off. JOKER/Hady Khandani/ullstein bild via Getty Images

Shaz Attari, a climate-communications researcher at Indiana University Bloomington, thinks this new tactic is working. Her research suggests that scientists and communicators with large carbon footprints have less credibility than those with reduced carbon consumption, and that people are more likely to support policies or recommendations if the leader promoting them has a small carbon footprint.

“When it comes to message uptake, advocates are judged for inconsistency between their behavior and advocacy,” Attari told Insider. “This judgement is dominated by flying or home energy consumption.”

Attari said she even once gave a talk in New York City about reducing personal energy use, and someone in the audience asked: “Hey, you flew to this meeting – why should I listen to what you say?”

“The tactic of carbon shaming is quite an effective way of inciting infighting among climate advocates,” Mann said. “There are armies of bots and trolls deployed to generate these arguments online of, ‘Why do you fly?’ ‘Why aren’t you a vegan?'”

-Paul Powlesland (@paulpowlesland) August 24, 2021

‘Climate sadism’

Mark Maslin, an Earth science researcher at the University College London, told Insider that “attacking the messenger has always been part and parcel” of fossil-fuel interests’ strategy to counter environmental movements.

What’s changed, he said, is the tenor of these attacks, which Maslin says have escalated into a vicious pageantry of “climate sadism.”

Take, for example, the backlash against Greta Thunberg. The teenage activist is a difficult target for the hypocrisy argument, since she doesn’t eat meat or fly. One staff member at the Heartland Institute, a Koch-funded think tank, did point out that the boat Thunberg once used to cross the Atlantic was made of plastic, but for the most part, conservatives and anti-environmentalists have chosen to target Thunberg’s personality instead.

© Thierry Monasse/Getty Images Swedish environmental activist Greta Thunberg speaks at the ‘Friday Strike For Climate’ on March 6, 2020, in Brussels, Belgium. Thierry Monasse/Getty Images

Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro called her a “little brat” in 2019. Donald Trump said she had an “anger management problem.”

Conservative commentator Michael Knowles called Thunberg, who has Asperger’s syndrome, “a mentally ill Swedish child” on Fox News. Fox host Laura Ingraham, meanwhile, compared the Thunberg’s youth climate movement to a murderous cult of children from a Stephen King novel.

“The blowback is directly related to the impact you’re having,” Kristen Cobb, a climate scientist from Georgia Tech, told Insider. Thunberg’s movement, she added, was “striking a nerve with every single human on the planet at that point.”

© Ana Fernandez/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Swedish activist Greta Thunberg takes a selfie during a Fridays for Future demonstration in Brussels, Belgium, February 21, 2019. Ana Fernandez/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty

The Heartland Institute even briefly worked with the German anti-environmental group EIKE to hire a German teenager, Naomi Seibt, to fashion herself as an antithesis to Thunberg.

“Many people believe I’m being pushed as an ‘Anti-Greta,'” Seibt told Insider last year.

“It’s wrong to look up to her as a climate puppet and symbol,” Seibt said of Thunberg, adding, “I don’t want people to panic about the world ending.”

Over the course of four months, for a monthly salary of $2,000, Seibt produced videos for the institute like “Naomi Seibt vs. Greta Thunberg: Whom should we trust?” and spoke at the 2020 Conservative Political Action Conference. Seibt quietly parted ways with Heartland in April 2020.

“The Anti-Greta just shows how cynical they are,” Mann said, adding, “they think it’s all a shell game about distraction and deception – that’s what they’ve got left.”

© Dean Mouhtaropoulos/Getty Images An oil refinery. Dean Mouhtaropoulos/Getty Images

In Prince Harry’s case, reports about his plane flights do seem to have discredited the prince’s climate agenda. A recent Newsweek poll in the UK found that 66% of respondents viewed the prince as “hypocritical on air travel.” But the number most stories about Harry’s trip left out is the US’s total emissions from fossil fuels: 4,853 million metric tons of carbon in 2019 alone.

Harry’s private flight from Aspen to Santa Barbara, meanwhile, emitted at most 9 metric tons of carbon dioxide.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


California court denies Activision Blizzard's efforts to delay bias suit

There has been continuous legal action taken against Activision Blizzard since it was made public that the company was accused of gender discrimination and for having a “frat boy” mentality. ... Read more »

Ty Gibbs takes Kansas Xfinity win as playoff drivers stumble

Gibbs, the 19-year-old grandson of NFL and NASCAR Hall of Famer Joe Gibbs, powered by reigning series champion Austin Cindric with 10 of 200 laps remaining and held on for ... Read more »

Milan vorerst Tabellenführer: Ibrahimovic erst der Depp, dann der Held

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Ibrahimovic erst der Depp, dann der Held Bologna – Milan 2:4Der Siegeszug der Mailänder geht weiter. Der momentane Tabellenführer muss sich die drei Punkte jedoch hart ... Read more »

Stell dir vor es ist keine Feier und alle kommen - Guzzisti feiern ohne Party

Die 100-Jahr-Feier von Moto Guzzi wurde kurzfristig abgesagt. Kein Grund für die Fans zu Hause zu bleiben. © Thomas Schmieder Jedes Jahr am zweiten September-Wochenende zelebriert die Stadt Mandello del ... Read more »

Ein 3:3 als Spektakel

Das Spiel liefert in der ersten Halbzeit aufregenden Fussball, als GC aus einem 0:2 ein 3:2 macht – am Ende rettet Ersatzstürmer Pollero dem FCZ ein Remis. © Foto: Ennio ... Read more »

Grasshoppers schaffen spektakuläre Wende, Zürich schlägt zurück

© KEYSTONE/ENNIO LEANZA Die Grasshoppers und der FC Zürich trennen sich in einem spektakulären Zürcher Derby 3:3. Damit verpasst der FCZ den vorübergehenden Sprung an die Tabellenspitze. Nein, Anlaufzeit brauchten ... Read more »

Hamilton: Mercedes ‘fell back a little bit' through US GP qualifying

© Glenn Dunbar / Motorsport Images Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes W12 Hamilton and Mercedes set a blistering early pace in practice on Friday at the Circuit of The Americas, but Red ... Read more »

Kerala contests HC scholarship order in Supreme Court

© Provided by The Times of India THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: The Kerala government has approached the Supreme Court against the high court order quashing the government scheme to provide minority scholarships to ... Read more »

Tripura attack: TMC gives cops 12 hours to arrest culprits

© Provided by The Statesman Tripura attack: TMC gives cops 12 hours to arrest culprits Tripura Trinamul Congress steering committee members along with Rajya Sabha MP Santanu Sen and state ... Read more »

Richarlison insists it's 'important' footballers get vaccinated

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Everton forward Richarlison says it is important for Premier League footballers to set an example for fans by encouraging them to get fully ... Read more »

Ronaldo hits back at critics accusing him of not pulling his weight

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Cristiano Ronaldo has promised to silence critics of his performances since returning to Manchester United. The Portuguese superstar said he would ‘close the ... Read more »

Dubai diaries: Exploring the world through tea in UAE

© Provided by Khaleej Times Dubai diaries: Exploring the world through tea in UAE Growing up in Britain there were traditionally only two types of tea: with sugar, or without. ... Read more »

UK plans 8 billion pounds of extra health and education spending

By David Milliken © Reuters/Hannah Mckay FILE PHOTO: Britain’s Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak meets U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen in London LONDON (Reuters) -British finance minister Rishi Sunak ... Read more »

Majority of Americans Mistakenly Believe Violent Crime Worse Now Than 30 Years Ago: Poll

A majority of Americans mistakenly believe that violent crime rates are worse today than they were 30 years ago, according to a new poll. © Christopher Furlong/Getty Images A majority ... Read more »

Microsoft reverses controversial .NET change after open source community outcry

© Image by Alex Castro / The Verge Microsoft is reversing a decision to remove a key feature from its upcoming .NET 6 release, after a public outcry from the ... Read more »

Erdogan says 10 ambassadors who backed activist are 'persona non grata' in Turkey

Turkey’s president Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said 10 ambassadors, including those from the US and France, were “persona non grata” after they issued a statement in support of a jailed ... Read more »

James Corden jokes Adele is 'difficult to buy for'

© Bang Showbiz James Corden James Corden has joked Adele is a “difficult person” to buy gifts for. The chart-topping singer recently revealed that James gave her a used piece ... Read more »

Meghan McCain didn't feel her voice was welcome on The View

© Bang Showbiz Meghan McCain Meghan McCain didn’t always feel welcome on ‘The View’. The 37-year-old TV personality starred on the daytime talk-show until earlier this year, but she didn’t ... Read more »

Saints put Chris Hogan on reserve/retired list

© Provided by NBC Sports Wide receiver Chris Hogan appeared to be done with playing football when he signed to play professional lacrosse earlier this year, but he reversed course ... Read more »

Saints' Chris Hogan retires at 32; former undrafted Bills, Patriots WR hangs it up after 8-plus seasons

Five games into his first season with the Saints, Chris Hogan is saying goodbye to both New Orleans and the NFL. Signed this offseason as wide receiver depth, the 32-year-old ... Read more »

Why Does My Dog Always Lick Her Paws?

It can be frustrating if your dog licks his paws a lot, especially since you’re probably worried that something could be wrong with her. According to Dr. Rusty Muse, medical ... Read more »

Here's Why Eating More Dairy May Be Good For Your Heart, Not Bad

In recent years, health-conscious adults have turned away from dairy products, especially milk, opting instead for more plant-based alternatives. Yet, despite milk’s downward trend, yogurt and cheese remain household favorites. ... Read more »

David Johnson shares most difficult part about trade from Cardinals

The Arizona Cardinals changed the trajectory of their franchise by trading away running back David Johnson in 2020. Now Johnson is sharing what the most difficult part about getting traded ... Read more »

Edward Rogers's attempt to name new directors goes against B.C. law, telecom says

© Patrick Morrell/CBC Rogers Communications headquarters are seen in Toronto on Friday. Rogers Communications Inc. (RCI) says it rejected an attempt by former chair Edward Rogers to name a slate of ... Read more »

Super PACs release ad campaign hitting Vance over past comments on Trump

Two super PACs released an ad campaign that criticizing Republican Ohio Senate candidate J.D. Vance for past comments he made about former President Trump. © The Hill Super PACs release ... Read more »

Hurricane Rick forecast to reach major strength ahead of landfall in Mexico

Hurricane Rick, which intensified overnight Friday from a tropical storm, is forecast to grow to major hurricane strength upon its expected landfall on Mexico’s southwestern Pacific coast, according to the National ... Read more »

Max Verstappen pips Lewis Hamilton to claim US F1 GP pole in Austin

A tense scrap from the start is in store on Sunday in Texas after Max Verstappen and Lewis Hamilton qualified first and second for the US Grand Prix. © Provided ... Read more »

Ohio's new license plate got the Wright Bros' plane backward on design

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The Buckeye State became the cockeyed state after botching the design of the iconic Wright Brothers plane while rolling out its new license ... Read more »

'Bringing Up Bates' Star Nathan Is Married to Esther Keyes

© Provided by US Weekly Bringing Up Bates’ Nathan Bates Is Married to Esther Keyes When you know, you know! Nathan Bates and Esther Keyes tied the knot on Saturday, ... Read more »

Ty Gibbs beats out Austin Cindric for win in Xfinity Kansas playoff race

© Sean Gardner Getty Images Ty Gibbs beats out Austin Cindric for win in Xfinity Kansas playoff race Another race, another win taken away from NASCAR Xfinity Series playoff drivers. ... Read more »

United States Grand Prix 2021: Max Verstappen takes pole position in gripping qualifying session

© Getty Images MaxVerstappen2310A.jpg Max Verstappen moved into pole in a dramatic finish ahead of the United States Grand Prix qualifying. The Dutchman earned his ninth pole of the season ... Read more »

Celtic manager Ange Postecoglou reveals how Hibs' Martin Boyle left him “pretty pleased”

Celtic manager Ange Postecoglou won’t need anyone to tell him that Martin Boyle will be one of the major threats when on Wednesday his team seek to end the club’s ... Read more »

All Blacks pile 104 points on USA in ruthless display

New Zealand got back to their winning ways as they romped to a 104-14 victory over the United States on Saturday in Washington during a test match in which the ... Read more »

Lewis Hamilton explains 'struggles' in qualifying as Max Verstappen on top ahead of US GP

Lewis Hamilton admits he was “struggling” in Austin after qualifying second on the grid ahead of the United States Grand Prix, with the seven-time world champion trailing Max Verstappen by ... Read more »

UFC 270 fight card: Francis Ngannou vs. Ciryl Gane, Brandon Moreno vs. Deiveson Figueiredo 3 set to headline

After it was previously rumored that Francis Ngannou would defend his heavyweight championship against interim titleholder Ciryl Gane at UFC 270 on Jan. 22, the promotion confirmed the event during ... Read more »

10 Of The Best Dog Birthday Cards For The Dog Lovers In Your Life

© Zazzle We independently pick all the products we recommend because we love them and think you will too. If you buy a product from a link on our site, ... Read more »

Illinois outlasts Penn State in record-breaking nine overtime win

Illinois finally finished the game that would never end.  It took 60 minutes of regulation, two overtime periods starting at the 25-yard line, and seven periods made up of two-point ... Read more »

The 20 Favorite Tax Havens of the Very Wealthy

Companies and wealthy individuals can legally keep money in tax havens, while avoiding higher taxes at home. And some tax havens are more popular than others. © Mike Coppola/Getty Images ... Read more »

All secrets in the After the Fall chapter of House of Ashes

© Provided by GamePur There are plenty of secrets to find in The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes. In fact, you will be able to find 50 secrets scattered ... Read more »

EU Ambassador visits Baguio City

© The Manila Times European Union Ambassador Luc Veron. Photo courtesy from Twitter account BAGUIO CITY : The delegation of European Union Ambassador Luc Veron visited the Summer Capital and ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic