Aryan bail hearing: Links absurd, case farfetched, HC told

Asia's Tech News Daily

Aryan bail hearing: Links absurd, case farfetched, HC told
© Provided by Hindustan Times The Bombay HC was hearing the bail pleas of actor Shah Rukh Khan’s son Aryan Khan, Arbaaz Merchant and Munmun Dhamecha, who were all arrested by the NCB October 3 after a raid on a cruise ship and charged under stringent sections of the NDPS Act. (AFP)

The arrest of Aryan Khan and at least two others by the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) violated constitutional provisions, and claims of international trafficking were “absurd and false”, lawyers for the accused told the Bombay high court on Wednesday, poking holes into the agency’s arguments in the high-profile case.

The high court was hearing the bail pleas of actor Shah Rukh Khan’s son Aryan Khan, Arbaaz Merchant and Munmun Dhamecha, who were all arrested by the anti-drugs agency on October 3 after a raid on a cruise ship and charged under stringent sections of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act.

They have all been in custody for 23 days — through hearings, delays, and bail denials by two other courts. The pace of proceedings, given the nature of allegations, has been criticised by several legal experts. Wednesday was the second day of the bail proceedings in the high court before justice Nitin Sambre, and the hearing will continue on Thursday.

Senior advocate Amit Desai, who was representing Merchant, rubbished the agency’s claims that Aryan’s WhatsApp conversations revealed that he was in contact with a person involved with an international drugs syndicate. “Somebody talking to somebody, they call it international drug trafficking. Absurd and false,” Desai said, arguing that the arrests were illegal.

Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, who made the bulk of his submissions for Aryan on Tuesday, argued that the arrest was a direct infringement of constitutional provisions as the arrest memo did not give the “true and correct grounds”. He said that the arrest memo mentioned recovery but didn’t specify from whom it was made.

“The law requires that you have to give true and correct grounds for arrest. Under section 50 of the Criminal Procedure Code, there is an obligation to inform a person of the ground of his arrest,” argued Rohatgi on Wednesday.

Aryan and the others were arrested by NCB’s Mumbai zonal director Sameer Wankhede on October 3 after a raid on a rave party on the cruise ship Cordelia off Mumbai. Wankhede said that 13 grams of cocaine, 5 grams of mephedrone, 21 grams of Charas, 22 pills of MDMA (ecstasy), and 1.33 lakh in cash were recovered from the ship. The 23-year-old was charged with alleged consumption and conspiracy under the NDPS Act.

But the case has turned increasingly murky, especially after a key witness alleged that Wankhede was part of a 25 crore extortion racket targeting Aryan. The witness, Prabhakar Sail, also alleged that he was forced to sign 9-10 sheets of blank paper. The agency has constituted a vigilance probe to look into the allegations and if confirmed, the charges can upend the high-profile case.

Experts have questioned if protocol was breached after private individuals were seen present during the raid and seemingly assisting NCB officials, despite not being part of any law enforcement agency. They have also asked why only a handful of the 1,300 people present on the ship were charged under the NDPS Act, questions that got louder after two others arrested from the cruise got bail on Tuesday.

Opposition parties have also alleged that the raid was conducted at the behest of local Bharatiya Janata Party leaders, who were also present during the event. The NCB and BJP have denied these allegations.

Bail pleas of Aryan, Merchant and Dhamecha were denied by the sessions court on October 20. All three then approached the high court, which started hearing their petitions on Tuesday.

On Wednesday, Desai submitted that Aryan, Merchant and Dhamecha were arrested primarily for alleged possession and consumption. There was no conspiracy and therefore the first remand did not mention any charge of conspiracy.

He pointed out that unlike others, whose statements mention the sale and purchase of contraband material, Merchant’s statement only mentioned consumption, but the agency slapped the charge of conspiracy and abetment under section 29 of the NDPS Act. It is only on this ground that the lower court rejected their bail plea, he argued.

Desai also pointed out to the single judge bench of justice Nitin Sambre that the arrests themselves were illegal. In this regard, the senior advocate submitted that the agency failed to first issue notices to the accused persons under section 41A of the Criminal Procedure Code to secure their cooperation in the investigation.

He pointed out that in case of minor offences, the settled legal position was that arrest was permitted only in exceptional cases. “Bail is the rule and jail is exception, now arrest is the rule and bail is exception,” Desai said.

“Since NCB has not given notices, there is violation of 41A and on that ground alone the accused should be released on bail,” Desai insisted.

He said that the special NDPS court granted bail to two people arrested by the NCB for drugs consumption. He claimed the NCB’s reply in the case of the two – Avin Sahu and Manish Rajgaria – was the same.

He also pointed out that when mobile phones of the arrested people were seized, no panchnama was recorded and submitted that NCB officials claimed that the accused voluntarily surrendered their mobile handsets. “But, in case of seizure of a personal device, there has to be a memorandum for ascertainment of its veracity,” he submitted.

Desai also objected to the agency’s reliance on the chats and other past communications. “Past events are connected for securing custody,” he said.

Advocate Ali Kashif Khan Deshmukh, representing Dhamecha, said that she was invited on the holiday cruise by a crew member and was promised payment. “Immediately after she walked in on the vessel, the raid happened and there were already two people present in the room (booked for her),” Deshmukh submitted.

Pointing out that it was NCB’s own case that 5 grams of charas was found lying in the room and that her person did not yield anything, the lawyer said the seizure memorandum was silent about the exact place where the contraband material was found. “They say it was found on the cruise, but nothing is mentioned as to who brought it in, etc,” Deshmukh said.

Deshmukh said Dhamecha hailed from a small town and had been on the cruise for work. He insisted that there were over 1,300 others on board the vessel and if she was apprehended merely on the basis of suspicion, then all others should have been arrested.


Sign on to read the HT ePaper

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Letak CCTV di posisi sesuai, mudah kesan penjenayah

© Provided by Sinar Harian KOTA KINABALU – Polis Diraja Malaysia menyarankan pemilik premis pasar raya mini di negeri ini supaya meletakkan kamera litar tertutup (CCTV) di posisi yang sesuai ... Read more »

The British Fashion Council launches new award category for Roblox designs

As part of its annual fashion awards, the British Fashion Council is adding a new category for 2021: an award for “metaverse design.” As broad as that might sound, the ... Read more »

Botswana loses court bid to revoke gay rights

© Monirul Bhuiyan Rainbow campaign: Activists gathered outside the Botswana High Court on October 12 to press their case Botswana’s government on Monday lost a legal attempt to overturn a ... Read more »

A 21-year-old MMA fighter was DQ'd for holding the cage while repeatedly stomping on his opponent's head

© Photo by Rizin FF A 21-year-old MMA fighter was DQ’d for holding the cage while repeatedly stomping on his opponent’s head Yusaku Kinoshita almost scored the fifth MMA win ... Read more »

HP bypoll result won't have any impact on 2022 assembly polls: Jai Ram

© Provided by The Statesman HP bypoll result won’t have any impact on 2022 assembly polls: Jai Ram Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur on Monday said the results ... Read more »

News 18 Evening Digest: Scam 1992 Co-director Shooting in South Africa Amid Omicron Outbreak; India Cricketer Shardul Thakur Gets Engaged and Other Stories

© Provided by News18 News 18 Evening Digest: Scam 1992 Co-director Shooting in South Africa Amid Omicron Outbreak; India Cricketer Shardul Thakur Gets Engaged and Other Stories Scam 1992 Co-director ... Read more »

MI must retain Rohit Sharma, Jasprit Bumrah, Kieron Pollard and Ishan Kishan, says Irfan Pathan

© Provided by The Indian Express Former India pacer Irfan Pathan believes that five-time Indian Premier League (IPL) champion Mumbai Indians will retain skipper Rohit Sharma, Jasprit Bumrah, Kieron Pollard, ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand: Ajinkya Rahane defends timing of declaration after Kanpur Test ends in draw

Ajinkya Rahane India’s stand-in captain Ajinkya Rahane said on Monday that the hosts couldn’t have done anything differently when it came to the timing of their declaration on Day 4 ... Read more »

This Samsung QLED TV deal is an absolute steal

© Expert Reviews cyber monday samsung qled tv deal samsung q75a TVs Online retailer Hughes has got the best Samsung Cyber Monday TV deal going at the moment. The Samsung ... Read more »

Tesco Bank closing all current accounts today - what it means for your money

© Getty Images Tesco Bank customers will see their current accounts closed from November 30 Tesco Bank is closing all its current accounts today – meaning you have just hours ... Read more »

Futurists predict how we'll one day eat, vacation and work

Futurologists already have a glimpse at what it may be like in the future and some of it may surprise you. NY Post photo composite Forget about Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook ... Read more »

Developing nations may give up on the WTO for good if it won't budge on vaccine patents

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Denis Balibouse/Reuters Late on Friday, with only days to go until its 12th summit was due to commence, the World Trade Organization (WTO) announced ... Read more »

OAP will be evicted from her ‘forever home' in two days and homeless at Christmas as developer demolishes her estate

A DEVASTATED pensioner is being kicked out of her 'forever home' with nowhere to go just three weeks before Christmas. Linda Elsworth, 71, says she has nowhere to go if ... Read more »

Best Edinburgh Films: 22 movies set in Edinburgh ranked from best to worst including Trainspotting, Avengers and Fast and Furious

© F9 – Fast and Furious 9: Chris ‘Ludacris’ Bridges and Roman Tyrese Gibson in action in Edinburgh Do you agree or disagree with these rankings? Let us know what ... Read more »

Omicron shows need for global accord on pandemics, says WHO chief

© Frank Augstein Passengers arrive at Heathrow Airport in London as travel restrictions return because of the new variant of coronavirus (Frank Augstein/AP) The World Health Organisation is pushing for ... Read more »

See Who Your Favourite Celebrity Is Married To

Nothing makes us happier than a South African celebrity wedding. When A-list celebrities arrange their big day, no cost is spared, from the pricey designer gowns to the five-star reception ... Read more »

Man United appoint Ralf Rangnick as interim manager

© PA Ralf Rangnick. MANCHESTER UNITED HAVE confirmed the appointment of Ralf Rangnick as their interim manager until the end of the season. The German joins from Lokomotiv Moscow where he was ... Read more »

Storm Arwen: Guests snowed inside pub hope for rescue after coldest night of season

© PA Autumn weather Nov 28th 2021 Guests stuck inside a Yorkshire pub for three nights were hoping to finally leave on Monday as staff told how an Oasis tribute ... Read more »

Horrific Omicron variant causes hospitalisations to TRIPLE in two weeks in South Africa as mutant Covid sparks panic

THE new Omicron variant has caused hospitalisations in South Africa to treble in two weeks, worrying new figures reveal. The new data, taken from the NICD, showed that hospital admissions ... Read more »

Crocodile Dundee star David Gulpilil dies aged 68 as fans pay tribute to groundbreaking actor

CROCODILE Dundee star David Gulpilil has died at the age of 68 as fans pay tribute to the groundbreaking actor. The “iconic” indigenous Australian actor, who was was diagnosed with ... Read more »

Tributes to ‘loving' mum, 47, found dead as three men, 21, 57 and 46, quizzed over murder and family beg for answers

DETECTIVES  have launched a murder investigation after a ‘loving mum’ was found dead at her home last week.  Malak Adabzadeh, 47, was pronounced dead at the scene after officers were ... Read more »

Last chance to save on Amazon Echo Dot 3rd gen in the Cyber Monday and Black Friday sales

© Provided by Pocket-lint Get an Amazon Echo Dot for 99p with Amazon Music Unlimited image 1 (Pocket-lint) – If you’ve been after an Echo Dot, then there’s no better ... Read more »

Apple AirPods 2 drop to just £99 in this Cyber Monday deal

© Expert Reviews apple airpods 2 black friday cyber monday deal charging case Headphones The iconic Apple AirPods have fallen below £100 for the first time ever on Amazon in ... Read more »

Father and daughter stabbed to death in Wood Green flat horror

© PA 2.64007214.jpg Police are continuing to question a suspect over the double murders of a man and his daughter found stabbed to death at a flat in north London. ... Read more »

Philanthropist and fashion maverick: Virgil Abloh was one of the industry's brightest stars

© Getty Images GettyImages-1157153084.jpg “Even when the world felt sad, he brought laughter and colour and beauty.” It’s a beautiful sentiment, written by Bella Hadid, and it’s just one of ... Read more »

Big restaurant chains including Olive Garden, Applebee's, IHOP, and Cheesecake Factory are cutting back on delivery amid staff shortages

© Provided by Business Insider Olive Garden takeout. Lea Suzuki/The San Francisco Chronicle via Getty Images IHOP, Applebee’s, and Olive Garden are halting online ordering services at peak times. Staffing ... Read more »

Emmerdale fans 'work out' Danny Miller's ITV soap exit storyline after Ben's murder

He’s starred on ITV’s Emmerdale for the past thirteen years, but actor Danny Miller, who plays fan favourite Aaron Dingle, recently revealed he’s waving goodbye to the village. Now the ... Read more »

Headie One at Wembley review: A good-natured homecoming for the London rapper

© Ashley Verse Headie One at Wembley On the last night of Headie One’s Edna tour, his closing appearance at Wembley Stadium was perhaps a case of relying a little ... Read more »

Stage set for Ghislaine Maxwell's sex trafficking trial

FILE — Ghislaine Maxwell, founder of the TerraMar Project, attends a press conference on the Issue of Oceans in Sustainable Development Goals, at United Nations headquarters, June 25, 2013. Maxwell ... Read more »

Are we all dehydrated? Here's what you should really be drinking

In a shocking addition to the usual hellish challenges, Richard Madeley was recently rushed from the I'm a Celebrity castle suffering a 'mystery illness.' It turned out that the presenter, ... Read more »

'Saya lelaki, kalau perempuan tak nak stay...' - Suami sedia lepaskan Nynaa Harizal seandainya...

KEMELUT rumah tangga yang berlaku di antara pelakon baharu, Nynaa Harizal dan suaminya, Mohamed Fahmi Mohamed Ilyas terus menjadi perhatian ramai. Menerusi sidang media khas yang diadakan Fahmi pada Jumaat, ... Read more »

Boots launches huge No7 sale for Cyber Monday

The No7 deals to snap up today. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life’s editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a share from ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing survivor Dan Walker leads the studio departures

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Spirits remained high on Saturday evening as Dan Walker left Elstree Studios after making it through to the Strictly Come Dancing quarter-final at ... Read more »

Oppositionsparteien in Kirgistan beklagen Wahlfälschung

© Keystone/AP/Vladimir Voronin Nach der Parlamentswahl in Kirgistan haben mehrere Oppositionsparteien eine Annullierung der Ergebnisse und Neuwahlen gefordert. Es habe Fälschungen gegeben, teilten vier Oppositionskräfte am Montag in einer gemeinsamen ... Read more »

Das große Kia Multimedia-Special - Sorento PHEV, Marke und Zukunftsausrichtung

Tauchen Sie interaktiv in die Markenwelt von Kia ein. In unserem Multimedia-Special erfahren Sie alles über die Neuausrichtung des Herstellers. © Kia / Patrick Lang Beim Autohersteller Kia hat sich ... Read more »

Omikron: China sieht sich als "uneinnehmbare Festung"

© Keystone/AP/Andy Wong Vor dem Hintergrund der sich weltweit verbreitenden neuen Coronavirus-Variante Omikron sieht China sich in seiner strikten Null-Covid-Strategie bekräftigt. China sei eine “uneinnehmbare Festung” für das Virus, kommentierte ... Read more »

Royal Enfield Interceptor 650 and Continental GT 650 Special Editions: What's different?

© Neil Nair Royal Enfield Interceptor 650 and Continental GT 650 Special Editions: What’s different? Royal Enfield took the wraps off the 120th Anniversary editions of the INT 650 and ... Read more »

SUVs with panoramic sunroof under Rs. 20 lakh: Hyundai Creta to Mahindra XUV700

© Provided by The Financial Express A lot of bespoke features have filtered down to the mass-market cars from expensive luxury vehicles. One of which is the sunroof, and it ... Read more »

Trump defence secretary sues Pentagon over memoir redactions

© Provided by Al Jazeera Former Secretary of Defense Mark Esper has sued the Pentagon over redactions to his unpublished memoir [File: Alex Brandon/AP] Former Pentagon chief Mark Esper has ... Read more »

Exclusive-Russian developer Samolet targets New York listing in 2023

© Reuters/SHANNON STAPLETON FILE PHOTO: A street sign, Wall Street, is seen outside New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City, New York By Andrey Ostroukh MOSCOW (Reuters) – ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic