Arthur Labinjo-Hughes: Murdered boy ‘failed' by the authorities, says grandmother

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes was failed by the very authorities tasked with keeping him safe, his grandmother said (West Midlands Police/PA) (PA Media)

A six-year-old boy murdered by his stepmother “was failed by the very authorities” tasked with keeping him safe, his grandmother has told a court ahead of the killers’ sentencing.

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes was left with an unsurvivable brain injury while in the sole care of “evil” 32-year-old Emma Tustin, after she had cruelly abused, starved and poisoned him.

She fatally assaulted the boy in the hallway of her home in Cranmore Road, Solihull on June 16 2020, using severe force.

He died in hospital the following day.

Tustin was unanimously convicted on Thursday of Arthur’s murder after an eight-week trial at Coventry Crown Court, with the boy’s “pitiless” father, Thomas Hughes, 29, found guilty of his manslaughter, after encouraging the killing.

(PA Media)

It emerged at trial that Arthur had been seen by social workers just two months before his death, after concerns were raised by his paternal grandmother, Joanne Hughes, but they concluded there were “no safeguarding concerns”.

At the start of the pair’s sentencing hearing at Coventry Crown Court on Friday, Ms Hughes read a victim impact statement on behalf of her family.

The secondary school teacher said Arthur, as a “happy, contented, thriving seven-year-old” would “be alive today” had her son not met Tustin.

But she added: “It is also clear that Arthur was failed by the very authorities that we, as a society, are led to believe are there to ensure the safety of everyone.”

Arthur’s maternal grandmother, Madeleine Halcrow, in a victim impact statement delivered on behalf of the boy’s natural mother, recalled his “beautiful smile” and his “kind, nurturing spirit”, adding that he had been “the light of my life”.

The hole left in me and those who loved Arthur will never be repaired

Madeleine Halcrow, Arthur's maternal grandmother

“He was let down by a person he trusted and should have protected him, left alone and isolated, and then they took him away from me,” she said.

“My child, my little love, defenceless, trusting and nothing but loving, was killed.

“His short life stolen and the hole left in me and those who loved Arthur will never be repaired.

“Sleep well, my angel – you are truly loved.”

As the hearing began Mr Justice Mark Wall QC said Tustin had been brought to court for her sentencing but had “refused to come up” to the dock.

Mary Prior QC, in mitigation for Tustin, told the court her client had made two attempts to take her life during the trial.

Accepting Tustin had shown no real remorse for the death of Arthur, she also said Tustin was “relatively young”, and “likely to spend the very best part of her life – at least – in custody”.

“None of what I have said is intended to justify Ms Tustin’s actions, in any way.”

Bernard Richmond QC, representing Hughes, said: “He was a weak person who gave in to the darkest recess of his personality which, before meeting Ms Tustin, he did not know existed.

“It will be a matter of bitter shame and and bitter regret to him for the rest of his life that he behaved in a way abhorrent to any right-thinking person and let down the person who most needed his love and protection.”

After fatally assaulting Arthur, Tustin then took 12 minutes to call 999.

Instead she first rang Hughes, then lied to medics and police that Arthur “fell and banged his head and while on the floor banged his head another five times”.

Tustin, who once referred to Arthur as “Satan”, later claimed he must have thrown himself down the stairs, despite evidence that he was barely strong enough to pick up his own bedding, or stand.

Hughes, of Stroud Road, Solihull, was convicted of encouraging the killing, including by sending a text message to Tustin 18 hours before the fatal assault telling her “just end him”.

I am in danger with you, Dad

Comment by Arthur to his father, Thomas Hughes

On one occasion before his death, Arthur told his father: “I am in danger with you, Dad.”

Tustin was also convicted of two counts of child cruelty, including salt-poisoning and withholding food and drink from Arthur.

Partway through the trial, she admitted two other cruelty counts – wilfully assaulting Arthur on three occasions and isolating him, including by forcing him to stand in the hallway for up to 14 hours a day as part of a draconian punishment regime.

Labourer Hughes was also convicted of the cruelty offences which Tustin had admitted – but was cleared of withholding food and drink, or of poisoning his own son with salt.

An independent review is now under way into the authorities’ contact with Arthur before his death.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

PICS: Rubina Dilaik, Urvashi Dholakia glam up Bigg Boss 15 sets ahead of finale; Miesha, Ieshaan arrive

Bigg Boss 15 is all set to come to an end after an exciting and entertaining season that went on for four months. With the BB 15 grand finale finally ... Read more »

Charlie Puth baffled by Benny Blanco jibes

© Bang Showbiz Charlie Puth is baffled by Benny Blanco’s TikTok jibes Charlie Puth thought that he and Benny Blanco were “friends”. The music producer has posted a series of ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: Here's why Shweta Tiwari likes Tejasswi Prakash

© Provided by Pinkvilla Earlier today, popular actress Shweta Tiwari was spotted on the sets of Bigg Boss as season 15 is headed to the finale. Shweta, who is also ... Read more »

Two Plate Under-19 World Cup matches cancelled after nine Covid-19 cases in Canada squad

© ICC via Getty Canada’s remaining two Plate matches now stand cancelled © ICC via Getty Nine Covid-19 cases in the Canada Under-19 camp has ended their World Cup campaign ... Read more »

Repsol executives barred from leaving Peru over oil spill

© Cris BOURONCLE Peruvian soldiers help clean up one of around 20 beaches affected by the oil spill blamed on Spanish energy giant Repsol A judge in Peru on Friday ... Read more »

Posthaste: Inflation adds new uncertainty to Canadians' financial future

© Provided by Financial Post A woman shops for groceries at Toronto’s Yao Hua Supermarket on Gerrard Street East on Jan. 19, 2022. Good morning! The worst inflation scare in ... Read more »

Punjab CM's brother files nomination as independent candidate, says no differences with Channi

© Provided by Zee News Chandigarh: Punjab Chief Minister Charanjit Singh Channi’s brother Manohar Singh on Friday filed his nomination papers from Bassi Pathana seat as an independent candidate. The ... Read more »

Teachers in dry Bihar get an addl job — to report drinking on the sly

© Provided by Hindustan Times School teachers and headmasters have been directed to keep an eye on people consuming liquor on the sly in dry Bihar. (HT Photo) Now, school ... Read more »

Minor daughter not a property to be given away as Daan: HC

© Provided by Hindustan Times The court had asked the minor’s father to file an affidavit on December 8, 2021, but it was filed by the “baba” instead due to ... Read more »

Travelling to Canada now becomes easier as country lifts India-specific testing rules

© Provided by WION Ottawa has now lifted India-specific Covid testing requirements making it easier to travel between India and Canada. The latest travel advisory no longer requires a negative ... Read more »

Olympics: Canada's top gold medal contenders heading to Beijing Games

In any Olympic year, the Games are the highlight of the sports programming calendar. Unfortunately, the usual wait between Olympics is a two-year slog. From Winter Olympics veterans to starry-eyed ... Read more »

NSE-BSE bulk deals: BofA Securities buys Rs 10 cr worth of shares of Ganesha Ecosphere

NEW DELHI: BofA Securities Europe SA bought 1,62,830 shares of Ganesha Ecosphere at an average price of Rs 624.51 per share, bulk deal data published by NSE showed. The transaction ... Read more »

Delhi records 4,044 new Covid-19 cases, 25 deaths; positivity rate down to 8.6 percent

© Provided by The Financial Express There are 15,420 beds for COVID-19 patients in Delhi hospitals and 1,928 (12.50 per cent) of them are occupied. Delhi on Friday reported 4,044 ... Read more »

Tamil Nadu Police releases woman who killed her husband in self defence

Jail In a first, Tamil Nadu Police released a woman who killed her husband in self defence. The 41-year-old woman was released under Section 100 of the Indian Penal Code ... Read more »

Akhilesh Yadav's Chopper Delayed Due to High Air Traffic at Delhi, Say Top Govt Sources

© Provided by News18 Akhilesh Yadav’s Chopper Delayed Due to High Air Traffic at Delhi, Say Top Govt Sources Hours after Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav alleged that his helicopter ... Read more »

Buxar hooch tragedy: SHO among three cops suspended

© Provided by Hindustan Times Police at a site where at least six people died after allegedly consuming spurious liquor in Buxar. (ANI) Three policemen, including station house officer (SHO) of ... Read more »

Charles Barkley, Shaq react to 76ers fans heckling Lakers' Carmelo Anthony: 'That ain't gonna stop me'

Lakers forward Carmelo Anthony had heard enough from a few 76ers fans at the Wells Fargo Center. © Provided by Sporting News During the fourth quarter of Thursday night’s game between ... Read more »

Pittsburgh bridge collapses hours before Biden visit to discuss infrastructure

A snow-covered bridge in Pittsburgh collapsed Friday morning, just hours before President Joe Biden was expected to visit the city on a previously scheduled trip to discuss infrastructure. © courtesy ... Read more »

Teacher, 76, accused of sexually assaulting 15 boys at two private schools between 1965 and 1986 made pupils swim naked and rubbed soap over them as they showered, court hears

Piers Le Cheminant has been accused of assaulting 15 boys at two schoolsSome 10 incidents 'happened at Oakwood Preparatory School in Chichester' And another five are believed to have happened at Salisbury Cathedral School  Read more »

Pirelli's most beautiful faces: Italian tyre maker re-issues vintage photos from former calendars including a young Cindy Crawford and Nicole Kidman to mark its 150th anniversary

Italian tyre maker Pirelli's yearly star-studded calendar has been a staple ever since it debuted in 1964Today, to mark its 150th anniversary, the brand has re-issues old photographs from calendar's past issuesThey include a young Cindy Crawford in 1994 and a gritty portrait of makeup-free Nicole Kidman in 2017 Read more »

What the No Surprises Act means for your medical bills

The Associated PressFILE — In this Aug. 24, 2021, file photo an ambulance sits outside the emergency room at The Queen’s Medical Center in Honolulu. As of Jan. 1, 2022, ... Read more »

FAA clears Verizon and AT&T to turn on more 5G cell towers

Federal safety regulators say they have cleared the way for Verizon and AT&T to power up more towers for new 5G service without causing radio interference with airplanes. The Federal ... Read more »

Hooters waitress blasted for being ‘ungrateful' for small tips

A Hooters waitress named Ali is catching online backlash for her seemingly “ungrateful” attitude towards the smaller tips she received during a daytime work shift. NYPost Composite Knockers are digitally ... Read more »

Ex-prisoner, 43, is guilty of murdering his Virgin Atlantic stewardess lover, 49, by stabbing the mother-of-two in the eye with cutlery knife during blazing row over their sweet and sour dinner

Lee Kendall, 43, killed mother-of-two Michaela Hall, 49, at her home in Truro He stabbed Ms Hall in the eye after a row over their sweet and sour dinner Court heard details of the catalogue of abuse Ms Hall suffered from KendallHe was found guilty of her murder and has been sentenced to life in prison with a minimum of 21 years  Read more »

Robinhood shares recover sharp losses after posting an earnings flop

Robinhood shares have been hammered since the company went public in July. Getty Images Robinhood shares dropped sharply early Friday after posting an earnings flop that saw its number of ... Read more »

Comedian Joe Lycett speaks out after sparking chaos for ‘leaking' Sue Gray report on Twitter

COMEDIAN Joe Lycett has spoken out after sparking chaos for “leaking” Sue Gray's 'partygate' report on Twitter. The hilarious version of the impending probe seemed to strike a nerve in ... Read more »

Gordon Ramsay mocked for £16 ‘burnt' pizza that was ‘cooked in crematorium' as foodies say they wouldn't eat it for FREE

GORDON Ramsay has been mocked for serving up a £16 “burnt” pizza that fans said looked like it was “cooked in a crematorium.” The sweary chef, 55, was savaged for ... Read more »

National Insurance rise: tax calculator shows how much MORE you'll pay this April

NATIONAL Insurance rates will rise in April and will mean millions of people paying more tax. The rise was first announced last year and is designed to help cover the ... Read more »

Strictly's Maisie Smith smiles in crop top as she leaves hotel with Max George on tour

STRICTLY'S Maisie Smith was all smiles as she left a Newcastle hotel with Max George ahead of their next tour show. The former EastEnders star, 20, who is best known ... Read more »

Virologin Ciesek „nicht glücklich“ mit Verkürzung des Genesenen-Status

© Bereitgestellt von Berliner Zeitung Auch die Frankfurter Virologin Sandra Ciesek sieht die Verkürzung des Genesenen-Status von sechs auf drei Monate kritisch. Die Direktorin des Instituts für Medizinische Virologie an ... Read more »

Ausgerechnet gegen Ex-Klub Luzern: Males muss den Cabral machen!

Am Sonntag dürfte Darian Males (20) Tor-Granate Arthur Cabral im Sturm ersetzen. Weshalb er als Teenager bis spät in die Nacht noch arbeiten musste. Und was Ex-Coach Michel Renggli sagt. ... Read more »

Staatssekretärin Leu spricht mit russischem Vertreter über Ukraine

© KEYSTONE/ALESSANDRO DELLA VALLE Staatssekretärin Livia Leu vom Aussendepartement hat mit dem russischen Vize-Aussenminister Wladimir Titow in Bern über die Spannungen an der Grenze zur Ukraine gesprochen. Dort soll der ... Read more »

Feds allow AT&T, Verizon to add more 5G towers near airports

The Federal Aviation Administration says AT&T and Verizon can station more 5G towers closer to airports. Federal regulators will allow telecom giants AT&T and Verizon to station more 5G towers ... Read more »

Video: Katie Price unveils her short blonde bob after having her extensions taken out... as she goes back to her glamour girl roots by signing up to OnlyFans

Read more »

Upcoming Lotus EV Looks More Than a Bit Like an Esprit

Lotus today announced a partnership with battery-maker Britishvolt to develop new technology for its upcoming EV sports car and released a teaser sketch of the car to get us excited. ... Read more »

Video: Addison Rae sports a body-hugging little black dress while heading to Craig's in West Hollywood

Read more »

WhatsApp typing hack ‘you probably didn't know will make your pals jealous'

WHATSAPP users need to try a clever hack that lets you change how your texts look. The genius trick is a must-know for all regular WhatsApp users. There's a clever ... Read more »

Pagasa sees warmer days ahead

© PAGASA Pagasa sees warmer days ahead MANILA, Philippines — Though the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) is yet to declare the end of the northeast monsoon ... Read more »

Does Pokémon Legends: Arceus have trainer encounters?

© Provided by Dot Esports Trainer encounters, also known as trainer battles, have been one of the driving forces of Pokémon since Generation I. Trainer battles generally take more skill ... Read more »

Supply Chain Management: The Need to Pivot to a Sustainable Future

© Provided by The Financial Express Top businesses worldwide are taking various initiatives to meet their sustainability targets. By Kushal Nahata The recently concluded United Nations Climate Conference (COP26) brought ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic