Art or 'childish graffiti'? Redressing Queen Victoria and Disraeli statues sparks fury on the Mersey

Asia's Tech News Daily

Queen Victoria was dressed in a cotton and hessian dress by Karen Arthur & Laurence WestgaphDavid Edwards

The monument to Queen Victoria in Liverpool has cast an imposing figure on the city's Derby Square since it was erected in 1906.

However a new art project, in which the statue was adorned with a brightly coloured cotton dress, has raised eyebrows in the art world, condemned by some as “childish graffiti” and no more artistic than students putting traffic cones on sculptures.

Statues Redressed sees contemporary artists invited to “creatively reimagine some of Liverpool’s most iconic statues” by dressing the existing works or creating new art around them.

Thomas Brock’s 1904 statue of William Gladstone has been wrapped in a flag representing African countries by Larry Achiampong, as a response to the fact that the former prime minister’s “family fortune came from plantations and slavery”.

Meanwhile, the designer Daniel Lismore has draped Charles Bell Birch’s 1883 statue of Benjamin Disraeli with a “Pride-themed Empress of India dress”, pictured below, as a commentary on the Victorian statesman’s “reputation as a flamboyant dresser and a dandy who wrote love letters to men”.

Disraeli was adorned in a Pride-themed Empress of India dress – Sky UK

Queen Victoria is dressed in cotton and hessian to reflect “Liverpool’s complicity with slavery, and how Queen Victoria and Britain were beneficiaries of that as recently as 150 years ago” – Sky UK

The Queen Victoria monument itself was given a cotton and hessian dress by Karen Arthur & Laurence Westgaph. According to the project's website, the material was chosen as during Victoria's reign, cotton was crucial to Liverpool's economic success, despite being picked by enslaved people in the United States until 1860.

The piece is said to reflect “Liverpool’s complicity with slavery, and how Queen Victoria and Britain were beneficiaries of that as recently as 150 years ago”.

For some though, the interventions are a step too far.

Michael Sandle, a leading sculptor and Senior Royal Academician, believes the project shows a “total lack of respect” for the original statues, their artists and the individuals commemorated.

“This is all wrapped up with tearing down sculptures and political correctness… Appalling decadence,” he told The Telegraph.

The fact that the Liverpool interventions are temporary does not placate him: “It’s like students putting traffic cones on sculptures… Anybody who criticises this will be seen as fuddy-duddies or kill-joys. They won’t understand our outrage at the disrespect. These are bloody people who can’t draw.”

Tom Murphy’s 1997 statue of Liverpool’s legendary football manager Bill Shankly at the Anfield Stadium has been “redressed” by designer and LUFC fan Nadia Atique by draping “a cape fit for a superhero” on the statue.

But Murphy himself is unimpressed: “I don’t think enough thought went into it. I just felt it was nothing,” he said.

Bill Shankley was given a superhero cape – David Edwards

Meanwhile Edward Young, who co-wrote a biography of Disraeli, said: “I do think they have missed the point. Disraeli would not have said he was gay.” – Sky UK

Edward Young, who co-wrote an acclaimed biography of Disraeli, said: “I do think they have missed the point. Disraeli would not have said he was gay. He was mainly in love with himself.

“It’s a bit of a stretch to say he was a warrior for Pride. He certainly wasn’t. It’s us translating our own labels on the past.”

Julian Spalding, a former director of galleries and museums in Sheffield, Manchester and Glasgow, dismissed it as “childish graffiti given contemporary credibility by trivial wokery”.

For Karen Arthur, one of the artists behind the new interpretation of the Queen Victoria monument, the response is water off a duck's back.

She said: “Critics are entitled to their opinion… I’m just thrilled that we’re talking about statues that usually people walk past and don’t take a blind bit of notice of.”

Liverpool was chosen because of its rich history, with the highest number of statues in the UK outside of London.

The city council gave permission for the project as it owns most of the statues. Robin Kemp, its head of creative for Culture Liverpool, said: “I would, on behalf of the artists, take exception to the idea that what they’ve done creatively is tantamount to putting a traffic cone on… It absolutely is art.”

For the organisers, the cultural service of Liverpool city council and Sky Arts, the unveiling of each statue was an opportunity “to look again, think again, and question how we feel about the public art that surrounds us”.

A “Statues Redressed” documentary will air on Oct 18 on Sky Arts and in it, former National Gallery director Neil MacGregor, says: “Statues are about telling stories and what I think is happening in Liverpool is a new way to engage the citizen in the conversation.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

'He is such introvert': Twitter brutally trolls New Zealand's Will Young for late DRS appeal during IND vs NZ 1st Test

New Zealand suffered a horrible start to their chase of 284 as opener Will Young appealed for the DRS late in what would have turned in his favour had he ... Read more »

Michael Beale issues message to Aston Villa players after 'fantastic' Crystal Palace victory

Aston Villa assistant head coach Michael Beale has hailed the ‘fantastic effort’ of his players to win 2-1 at Crystal Palace on Saturday afternoon. Beale and Villa head coach Steven ... Read more »

Powerful 7.5 magnitude earthquake hits Peru

A strong earthquake with a preliminary magnitude of 7.5 has struck northern Peru, the US Geological Survey said. © Pixabay mountains-g44e1b4ae7_1920.jpg The quake took place at 5.52am local time on ... Read more »

Dr Alex George bravely reveals he's taking medication for anxiety

Dr Alex George has bravely revealed he is taking medication to treat his anxiety. In a candid post shared to his Instagram on Saturday 27 November, the former Love Island ... Read more »

Dutch health institute confirms 13 cases of omicron variant among travelers who arrived from South Africa.

THE HAGUE, Netherlands — Dutch health institute confirms 13 cases of omicron variant among travelers who arrived from South Africa. Read more »

COVID-19: Dutch officials find 13 Omicron variant cases among passengers arriving from South Africa

Authorities in the Netherlands have detected 13 cases of the Omicron coronavirus variant among passengers from South Africa. Health officials said the infected people were on flights from the southern ... Read more »

Spain to ban unvaccinated Brits from WEDNESDAY throwing Christmas holidays into chaos

SPAIN has banned all unvaccinated Brits from entering the country from WEDNESDAY in a bid to contain a new strain of coronavirus. It comes as a massive blow to British ... Read more »

Meghan Markle latest news – ‘Prince Charles speculated about skin tone of Prince Harry & Meg's children' claims new book

A NEW book claims that Prince Charles speculated about the skin tone of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s future children — and unwittingly triggered the rift between the couple and the ... Read more »

Cafecito and presidential sightings: A landmark Miami restaurant turns 50

“There’s nothing like Versailles, especially for Cubans. This is kind of their ground zero," says Nicole Valls about the place her grandfather built —now a world-known local and tourist hub. Read more »

13 cases of omicron variant in Dutch testing of travelers

© Provided by Associated Press Travelers walk with their luggage in the Ben Gurion Airport near Tel Aviv, Israel, Sunday, Nov. 28, 2021. Israel on Sunday approved barring entry to ... Read more »

Frontline Soweto: When the power goes out and hope dies

At the time of writing this story, the power had been out in Orlando for six days. The local councillor says it is not her problem. ‘Ask Eskom!’ she says. ... Read more »

61 passengers from SA in isolation in Amsterdam, being tested for variant

© Provided by CapeTalk – 61 people who arrived at Amsterdam’s Schiphol Airport from South Africa have tested positive for Covid-19 – The passengers have been placed in isolation at ... Read more »

France holds emergency talks in Calais over Channel crossings — without the UK

© Provided by dw.com Thousands hope to make the perilous journey across the English Channel and talks in Calais Sunday hope to tackle the smugglers side of the business iin ... Read more »

For some recipe apps, your personal data is gravy

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) By Tatum Hunter Paper-and-ink cookbooks come with a few advantages compared to recipe apps: extra information about origins and ingredients, not having to incorporate ... Read more »

Omicron symptoms are ‘extremely mild' says doctor who discovered it

The doctor who discovered Omicron says symptoms from the variant are “extremely mild” and has accused the UK of “panicking unnecessarily”. © PA Archive Coronavirus – Wed Apr 14, 2021 ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu vs Elena-Gabriela Ruse LIVE: Updates, stream, latest from Royal Albert Hall

Emma Raducanu is playing her first match on home soil since her historic US Open triumph. The Bromley teenager became the first-ever qualifier to win a Grand Slam in Flushing ... Read more »

Boris Johnson faces leadership challenge unless he ‘gets act together', senior Tory MP says

© Getty Images Boris Johnson Holds Press Conference After New Covid-19 Variant Found In UK Boris Johnson risks a leadership challenge unless No 10 “gets its act together”, says a ... Read more »

Swiss reject plan to abolish COVID health pass: projection

© Provided by dw.com Swiss voters took part in a referendum Sunday on whether to abolish the COVID certificate which restricts the movements of unvaccinated peoeple The Swiss public overwhelmingly ... Read more »

Joburg Open shortened to 36 holes after weather, Omicron COVID variant fears

The DP World Tour’s inaugural event was cut short on Saturday amid weather and fears of a new COVID-19 variant. The Joburg Open was abandoned after 36 holes due to ... Read more »

Voices: Norway's ‘gay Santa' advert is achingly beautiful and something we should celebrate

Are you looking for something to warm up your winter? To sweeten your mulled cider? Then Norwegian postal service Posten have got just the ad for you. Their seasonal campaign ... Read more »

Trade Setup: Defending 17100-level key for Nifty50; stick with defensive stocks

Friday came as a massive negative surprise for the equity markets. With US markets closed due to the Thanksgiving holiday on Thursday, no overnight cues were expected. However, renewed Covid ... Read more »

India pushes renewed trade talks with Canada in aftermath of two Michaels China woes

OTTAWA — Canada and India are quietly setting the stage to reboot formal free trade talks as the Trudeau government seeks economic alternatives to China following the dispute over the ... Read more »

UAE legal reforms: What the law says about children born outside of marriage

© Getty Images/EyeEm The rules stipulates that any child conceived a result of the relationship is acknowledged and will be cared for. Getty A new criminal code is among the ... Read more »

2 ADUN PN kekal sokong kerajaan BN di Melaka, kata Peja

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mohd Aleef Yusof mewakili Sungai Udang dan Mohd Yadzil Yaakub di Bemban kekal sebagai ADUN biasa. PETALING JAYA: Dua Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) ... Read more »

Laura Whitmore wraps up in a fur coat as she arrives at radio show

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Laura Whitmore made a stylish arrival at her Radio 5 Live show in London on Sunday morning.  The media personality, 36, wrapped up ... Read more »

ITV I'm A Celebrity: Danny Miller's NHS worker fiancée and childhood sweetheart says he was 'her rock' in anxiety battle

I’m A Celebrity star Danny Miller’s fiancée has revealed how vital and supportive he was for her to overcome the darkest period in her life. Childhood sweetheart Steph Jones – ... Read more »

Former police station up for sale for mystery amount in village

A former Merseyside Police station has been listed for sale. The former station, located on Segars Lane in Ainsdale, has been listed with Eddisons Commercial on Rightmove. The property, thought ... Read more »

New face mask rules: Where are coverings mandatory?

masks Mandatory mask-wearing will return to shops and public transport in England this week, as the Government takes action to try to tackle the omicron coronavirus variant that has arrived ... Read more »

Philippines adds 7 more countries to red list over COVID-19 Omicron variant

Syringes with needles are seen in front of a displayed stock graph and words “Omicron SARS-CoV-2” in this illustration taken, November 27, 2021. REUTERS/ Dado Ruvic/ Illustration The Inter-Agency Task ... Read more »

Czech Republic: Petr Fiala named new prime minister

© Provided by dw.com Petr Fiala has become the new Czech prime minister Czech President Milos Zeman named Petr Fiala as the prime minister of the Czech Republic on Sunday ... Read more »

Live Like High Fashion Royalty at This House of Gucci Airbnb

© Provided by Esquire Philippines Can’t get enough of House of Gucci? The Gucci family crime drama has already premiered abroad, and the stellar trailers are making us excited for ... Read more »

Israel, tiniyak na matutuloy ang Miss Universe 2021 sa kabila ng banta ng Omicron

© Provided by PEP.ph Wala nang dapat ipag-alala ang fans ng Miss Universe dahil matutuloy ang 70th Miss Universe sa Red Sea resort sa Eilat, Israel sa December 12, 2021. ... Read more »

Philippines, Pfizer sign deal for 20M more COVID-19 vax doses

© REUTERS/Denis Balibouse/File Photo Vials of the Pfizer BioNTech vaccine are pictured in a vaccination centre in Geneva, Switzerland, February 3, 2021. REUTERS/Denis Balibouse/File Photo The Philippine government and Pfizer-BioNTech ... Read more »

Palace: Drop in number of families seeing themselves poor indicates progress

Malacañang Palace Malacañang on Sunday said the decrease of Filipino families considering themselves poor shows that progress has been made in the government’s efforts to reopen the economy amid the ... Read more »

Muntinlupa LGU declares BuCor chief Bantag persona non grata

© Mai Bermudez A portion of University Road in Muntinlupa City is closed on Saturday, Nov. 27, 2021, after the Bureau of Corrections (BuCor) constructed a low wall. The BuCor ... Read more »

6 of the Best Art Schools in the Philippines

© Provided by Candy The college application season is upon us once again! Although artistic skills might be inherent, there are numerous ways to further hone and develop these skills, ... Read more »

Richard Mille not ruling out running male driver in 2022 WEC

© JEP / Motorsport Images #1 Richard Mille Racing Team Oreca 07 – Gibson: Sophia Flörsch, Beitske Visser Run by the same Signatech team that is behind Alpine’s Hypercar effort, ... Read more »

'Schitt's Creek' holiday special: For Jews like Johnny Rose, the menorah is still polished and lit, even in diaspora

CBC’s hit show Schitt’s Creek aired its last episode April 2020, and fans clearly miss it. The show followed parents Johnny Rose (Eugene Levy) and his wife Moira Rose (Catherine ... Read more »

Salman Khan requests fans not to 'waste' milk on 'Antim' posters, urges to help poor

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Actor Salman Khan, on Sunday, shared a video on social media in which his fans can be seen pouring milk on ‘Antim’ posters ... Read more »

1st Test: Shaheen Afridi helps Pakistan claw back after Taijul Islam stars with 7-wicket haul for Bangladesh

Shaheen Afridi Pakistan fast bowler Shaheen Afridi tore into the Bangladesh top-order picking up 3 wickets and restricting the hosts to 39/4 at Stumps on Day 3 of their first ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic