Are US booster shots sapping the world's vaccine supply?

Asia's Tech News Daily

In fall 2020, Johnson & Johnson announced a deal with Aspen Pharmacare, a pharmaceutical company based in South Africa. Once Johnson & Johnson gained approval from the World Health Organization (WHO) and South Africa for its COVID-19 vaccine, Aspen Pharmacare would manufacture millions of doses for use in that country and abroad. The deal included a major shipment for South Africa: 31 million doses, enough to inoculate over half of the country’s residents with this one-shot vaccine.

© Bork/Deposit Photos Booster shots essentially further extend the scarcity of COVID-19 vaccines worldwide by presenting wealthy nations with an opportunity to jump to the front of the vaccine line again.

But once Aspen began actually producing vaccines in summer 2021, the vast majority of these doses were not used to vaccinate South Africans. Instead, the doses were sent out to Europe— as South Africa was hit hard by the Delta variant.

Aspen agreed, “or was forced to agree, that the South African government wouldn’t impose export restrictions,” says Fatima Hassan, founder of Health Justice Initiative, a research and advocacy group based in South Africa. The company’s contract stipulated that “basically, Aspen had to send the vaccines wherever Johnson & Johnson wants.”

“They [Johnson & Johnson] would have no power to extract such a concession from the US government or the EU,” Hassan says. “But they can do that in Latin America and Africa.” 

Thanks to pressure from South African activists and others, spurred by a New York Times investigation, the country was eventually able to put a temporary pause on vaccine exports. This allowed millions of Johnson & Johnson vaccines to stay in South Africa. As of October 15, the country has administered about 14 million vaccine doses, according to Our World in Data.

Aspen’s contract represents just one example of the vaccine inequity brought on by companies that prioritize their highest-income clients over the rest of the world. Booster shot campaigns are now exacerbating this divide, as limited vaccine supplies continue to go to wealthy countries first and manufacturers in low-income countries are barred from accessing vaccine technology.

Popular Science talked to six experts from around the world, all of whom agreed that the major pharmaceutical companies that developed COVID-19 vaccines have limited amounts they can supply to lower income companies mainly because they insist on controlling the manufacturing of all doses of those vaccines.

“We basically have artificial scarcity of vaccine doses,” says Robbie Silverman, a vaccine advocate at Oxfam America. The pharmaceutical companies control “where doses are produced, where they’re sold, and at what price.” The world’s vaccine supply is thus limited by contracts signed by a small number of big companies; and many of those contracts, Hassan says, are kept secret behind non-disclosure agreements.

When companies have absolute control of where to send their vaccine doses, it serves their best interests to send those doses to wealthy nations first, says Margaret Harris, spokesperson for the WHO. Wealthy nations are “easier markets to service,” she says, with high prices and already-established infrastructure to deliver doses.

“If that market continues to purchase,” Harris says, vaccine companies are “not going to be interested in contracting in other markets.”

Booster shots essentially extend the scarcity further by presenting wealthy nations with an opportunity to jump to the front of the vaccine line again. “Supplies that are currently available are diverted” for boosters, says Hassan. “Just to serve preferred customers in the richer North.”

As a result, countries like the U.S., the U.K., and Israel have ample supplies for booster shot campaigns while countries like Botswana—which signed a contract with Moderna in June—have not received a single dose. Shipments to this African nation were supposed to start arriving in August.

In addition, Hassan notes that centralizing all vaccine production with a small number of manufacturers can be dangerous when an error occurs, like the contamination that shut down a Maryland factory making Johnson & Johnson vaccines in April. “If you only have a handful of suppliers,” Hassan says, “when there’s a problem in Baltimore, it affects the entire global supply chain.”

When booster shot campaigns in wealthy nations delay dose shipments to other countries, the delays don’t just impact dose supplies themselves. These delays also bring logistical uncertainty, making it difficult for low-income countries to plan effective vaccination campaigns.

“We can’t tell countries what’s coming,” Harris says. Public health leaders need to know when their vaccine shipments are coming, how many doses they’ll receive, and other crucial information. She says, “You need to plan your cold chain, you need to plan your campaigns, you need to tell people, ‘vaccination will be available these days in these places.’”

The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines in particular require a lot of preparation, Harris says, because of their mRNA technology. To administer these vaccines, countries need to obtain special low-temperature freezers and train health workers to handle the products.

But storing vaccines and training staff will mean little if people don’t show up to get vaccinated. For successful vaccine campaigns, public health leaders need to have “so many ducks in a row,” Harris says. These details include logistics, staff, advance communication with communities, and actually delivering on planned vaccination events.

“If the day that people have been told to come, they turn up and there’s no vaccine, they probably won’t come back the second time,” she says.

If the coronavirus continues spreading anywhere in the world, it has the capacity to spread everywhere. Every new infection provides the virus with an opportunity to mutate, potentially generating a new variant—like the Delta variant, first identified in India in early 2021.

“Variants arise when there is a lot of infection,” says Senjuti Saha, a microbiologist who works on coronavirus sequencing and leads the Child Health Research Foundation in Bangladesh. “The less we vaccinate around the world, the higher the chance that we will get variants, newer variants circulating very soon.”

Saha finds it concerning that right now, many countries with lower vaccination rates are also densely populated, poised for continued coronavirus spread. In Bangladesh, about 23 percent of the country has received at least one dose, according to Our World in Data. For many countries in Africa, this number is under five percent.

Plus, many current vaccine campaigns in low-income countries are relying on doses of the Sinovac and Sinopharm vaccines. These two vaccines, produced in China, are “proving far less effective than some of the other vaccines,” says Peter Maybarduk, director at the DC-based nonprofit Public Citizen. In fact, the WHO recently recommended that recipients of these two vaccines over age 60 should get booster shots of the same or different vaccines. “We’re now entering an era of second-class vaccines for second-class people,” Maybarduk says.

Harris argues that vaccinating people in low-income countries may actually be a better return on investment for the U.S. than providing booster shots at home. The Americans who are willing to line up for booster shots have already received one or two vaccine doses, she says—meaning that they are already well-protected from severe COVID-19 disease and death, unlike the millions of unvaccinated people in both the U.S. and low-income nations.

“All the work in countries where you’ve got good [vaccine] coverage should be on getting those unvaccinated people vaccinated,” Harris says. 

The Biden administration has argued that the U.S. is capable of both vaccinating the world and providing booster shots at home. But so far, the administration has focused on pledging donations—which experts say is not the long-term way out of the pandemic. 

“We’ve had many, many pledges,” Harris says. “We haven’t seen much delivery on those pledges.” For example, Biden’s pledge to donate one billion Pfizer doses will not be realized until the end of 2022, if it meets its deadline at all. As of late September, under 200 million donated doses have gone out from the U.S.

“The only way you’re going to be able to do booster shots and vaccinate the whole world is if you actually open up the technology and scale up manufacturing,” Hassan says.

Saha agrees: “Increasing production is the only way out.” Currently, a small number of companies have a monopoly on producing COVID-19 vaccines, but it doesn’t have to stay that way. She says countries like the U.S. can “put their foot down and say, ‘hey Moderna, hey Pfizer, you have to let local companies manufacture and export at low prices.’”

Moderna may be particularly poised for such pressure because the U.S. invested $2.5 billion in its vaccine development and production, says Marcela Vieira, project coordinator for medicine access at the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies in Geneva, Switzerland. The company has sent fewer doses to low-income countries than any other vaccine manufacturer; and the Biden administration is pushing Moderna to send more doses abroad, according to the New York Times. 

Vieira says there’s more that the Biden administration could do to pressure Moderna. One option is a forfeiture agreement that would “attach conditions to public funding of R&D [research & development].” In other words, Moderna would be required to make their technology more broadly available to other manufacturers in order to receive further funding from the U.S. government.

Another option, Vieira says, is called march-in rights. “When a significant amount of government funding was received for a company to obtain a patent,” she says, “the government can exercise its march-in rights and can claim ownership over the technology.” The U.S. government has invested enough money into Moderna’s vaccine that it could essentially seize that technology—then share it with manufacturers in other countries.

Noubar Afeyan, Moderna’s chairman, has said that vaccine production would be most “reliable” if the company controls all manufacturing. But Vieira and Saha both argue that plenty of companies in the Global South are already set up to produce other vaccines, and are capable of quickly pivoting to make COVID-19 vaccines if they gain access to the technology. Some companies have even made direct offers to Johnson & Johnson and AstraZeneca—only to be rejected.

Popular Science spoke with Saha on October 14, as the Food and Drug Administration’s vaccine advisory committee discussed authorizing booster shots for Moderna’s vaccine. She was unsurprised—yet disappointed—at the ease with which U.S. experts discussed boosters while people in low-income nations, including healthcare workers and other vulnerable groups, remain without first or second shots.

“I cannot be angry at people who are getting those booster shots,” she says. “It’s not an individual problem. It’s not like if one person doesn’t take a booster shot in the United States, that vaccine comes to Bangladesh, or goes to Malawi.”

Instead, Saha says, booster shots in the U.S. and other wealthy nations provide another example of the global health inequity that she’s faced throughout her career, working on childhood vaccinations in Bangladesh. “Our experience of trying to work with policymakers, both nationally and internationally, has taught us that all lives are not valued equally around the world,” she says.

This is a systemic, policy issue that cannot be changed overnight, Saha says. Yet if solutions are implemented—for example, opening up COVID-19 vaccine technology for manufacturing in low-income nations—the shift may have implications for future global health crises.

“It’s not only about this pandemic,” she says. “There are other pediatric vaccines that are still scarce, that children are not getting around the world. The same facilities [that make COVID-19 vaccines] can then be used to manufacture other vaccines—and to manufacture vaccines for the next pandemic.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Moore carries San Jose State over South Dakota 61-52

SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) — Omari Moore had 18 points and six rebounds as San Jose State beat South Dakota 61-52 on Tuesday night. Tibet Gorener had 14 points for ... Read more »

Nigeria confirms first cases of Omicron among travellers from South Africa

ABUJA (Reuters) –Nigeria confirmed its first cases of the Omicron COVID-19 variant among two travellers who arrived from South Africa last week, the Nigeria Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) said ... Read more »

Mourners pack church to grieve shooting victims

Mourners pack a Michigan church to grieve those killed and injured in a school shooting (Dec. 1) Read more »

It looks like Omicron variant causes milder illness – is this how Covid-19 becomes endemic?

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) By Hamish McCallum These are very early days in terms of our understanding the Omicron variant. What is known is that it has a ... Read more »

'COVID-19 has brought significant challenges in fight against HIV/Aids'

© Provided by 702 As the world commemorates World Aids Day, South Africa has made gains in the treating of HIV. However, there is still much work that needs to ... Read more »

Video: 'We don't have a motive at this point' say police after Michigan school shooting

Student is apprehended by law enforcement officers after fatal shooting spree at a school which also left some critically injured. Read more »

Reliever Daniel Hudson returns to Dodgers on 1-year deal

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Right-handed reliever Daniel Hudson has returned to the Los Angeles Dodgers on a one-year contract. The Dodgers announced the deal Tuesday night for Hudson, who pitched ... Read more »

Sheriff: gun bought 4 days before school shooting

Oakland County, Michigan Sheriff Michael Bouchard says the gun used in a school shooting on Tuesday was purchased by the suspect’s father on November 26th. Three people were killed and ... Read more »

I bought my home for $30,000, but now it's worth almost $3 million. How can I avoid a massive tax bill?

I bought my home for $30,000, but now it’s worth almost $3 million. How can I avoid a massive tax bill? Capital gains aren’t the only factor to consider in ... Read more »

Trail Blazers snap 3-game skid with 110-92 win over Detroit

PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — CJ McCollum scored 28 points and the Portland Trail Blazers handed the Detroit Pistons their seventh straight loss with a 110-92 victory on Tuesday night. Ben ... Read more »

Binnington rebounds, Blues rally to beat Lightning 4-3 in SO

ST. LOUIS (AP) — Jordan Binnington was looking for a place to hide. The St. Louis goalie gave up three goals on the first nine shots he faced Tuesday night ... Read more »

Video: CCTV shows portable toilet arson with fireworks in Texas

Explosion damages a building, a trailer and the toilet, but fortunately no one was hurt. Read more »

Suns beat Warriors to match team record with 17th consecutive win despite losing Devin Booker to injury

PHOENIX (AP) — Deandre Ayton scored 24 points, Chris Paul added 15 points and 11 assists, and the Phoenix Suns tied a franchise record of 17 straight wins by beating ... Read more »

Sherfield leads Nevada past Pepperdine 79-66

RENO, Nev. (AP) — Grant Sherfield had 24 points and 10 assists as Nevada beat Pepperdine 79-66 on Tuesday night. Desmond Cambridge Jr. added 21 points for the Wolf Pack. ... Read more »

Japan starts booster COVID vaccinations amid omicron scare

The Associated PressA medical worker of Tokyo Medical Center receives a booster shot of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021 in Tokyo. Japan has started administering the booster ... Read more »

Kyle Rittenhouse says he is destroying the AR-15 rifle he used in Kenosha and doesn't want anything to do with it

Kyle Rittenhouse said during a podcast that he did not want “anything” to do with the firearm he used last August in Kenosha.Mark Hertzberg-Pool/Getty Images Kyle Rittenhouse said on a ... Read more »

Suns win 17th straight by beating Warriors 104-96

PHOENIX (AP) — Deandre Ayton scored 24 points, Chris Paul added 15 points and 11 assists, and the Phoenix Suns tied a franchise record of 17 straight wins by beating ... Read more »

Mariners sign Cy Young winner Robbie Ray to $115M, 5-yr deal

SEATTLE (AP) — AL Cy Young Award winner Robbie Ray and the Seattle Mariners finalized their $115 million, five-year contract Tuesday night. Ray is coming off the best season of ... Read more »

Lakers overcome James' absence to beat Kings 117-92

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — Anthony Davis scored 25 points, Russell Westbrook added 23 and the Los Angeles Lakers overcame the absence of LeBron James to beat the Sacramento Kings 117-92 ... Read more »

Analysis-Japan keen to speed up digital yen launch as China adds geopolitical twist

FILE PHOTO: A man wearing a protective mask stands in front of the headquarters of the Bank of Japan in Tokyo By Leika Kihara TOKYO (Reuters) – Japan's new political ... Read more »

Gisborne's Tatapouri Bay campsite to allow unvaccinated visitors this summer

In a region with one of the lowest vaccination rates in the country, one campsite has announced all are welcome to visit this summer. This morning Tatapouri Bay campsite in ... Read more »

Pulliam scores 16, Aztecs rout Long Beach State 72-47

SAN DIEGO (AP) — Trey Pulliam scored 16 points, including the first four in an 18-2 run in the first half that gave San Diego State control en route to ... Read more »

95 per cent of people infected with HIV in Mumbai taking treatment: Study

© Provided by Mid-Day About 95 per cent of city residents infected by HIV are aware of their disease status and living with it with treatment, says a survey carried ... Read more »

Bandelier National Monument seeks help finding those who killed elk and mule deer

Dec. 1—Law enforcement rangers at Bandelier National Monument are hoping members of the public can help them track down those responsible for killing an elk and a mule deer on ... Read more »

Capitol riot's 'QAnon Shaman' appeals guilty plea and 41-month prison sentence

WASHINGTON — The Arizona man who wore face paint and horns during the Jan. 6 Capitol riot filed an appeal Tuesday of his guilty plea and sentence of 41 months ... Read more »

Trial to determine if requiring women board members is legal

The Associated PressFILE – Then-California Gov. Jerry Brown talks during an interview in Sacramento, Calif., on Dec. 18, 2018. When former Gov. Brown signed the nation’s first law requiring that ... Read more »

Space junk forces astronauts to delay spacewalk to replace antenna

It’s the first time a spacewalk has been canceled because of a threat from space junk. Read more »

Ohio State ices out No. 1 Duke in final minutes, wins 71-66

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — Zed Key scored a career-high 20 points and Ohio State held top-ranked Duke scoreless for the final 4 1/2 minutes, completing a rally from a 15-point ... Read more »

Louis Vuitton's first ever U.S. fashion show becomes somber, whimsical Virgil Abloh tribute

MIAMI BEACH, Fla. — Louis Vuitton’s first ever U.S. fashion show turned into a somber yet whimsical tribute to groundbreaking designer Virgil Abloh days after his death. The Miami menswear ... Read more »

Astros sign RHP Neris to $17 million, 2-year deal

HOUSTON (AP) — The Houston Astros signed right-hander Héctor Neris to a $17 million, two-year contract Tuesday with an option for 2024, bringing an experienced closer to the American League ... Read more »

Correa trial continues with testimony on DNA evidence, phone tracking

Dec. 1—Red, blue, black and purple circles dotted a map on display in New London Superior Court on Tuesday. Each color represented the whereabouts of a different cell phone on ... Read more »

St. Cloud woman charged with murder of infant son whose body was found in dumpster

Dec. 1—ST. CLOUD — A St. Cloud woman appeared Tuesday in Stearns County District Court for allegedly killing her child and throwing the body in a dumpster Sunday. Fardoussa Omar ... Read more »

Search warrant suggests mix of live, dummy rounds from supplier used on 'Rust' set

Dec. 1—A search warrant from the Santa Fe County Sheriff's Office suggests a new theory for the prop gun shooting on Bonanza Creek Ranch that killed Rust cinematographer Halyna Hutchins ... Read more »

Man gets 10 years prison for sexually assaulting EC woman

Dec. 1—EAU CLAIRE — A 42-year-old Onalaska man will spend 10 years in prison for sexually assaulting a woman in April inside her Eau Claire home. Robert B. Smith was ... Read more »

Case against Jussie Smollett focuses on how 'hoax' unraveled

The Associated PressActor Jussie Smollett, center, arrives Tuesday, Nov. 30, 2021, at the Leighton Criminal Courthouse for day two of his trial in Chicago. Smollett is accused of lying to ... Read more »

Wright scores 20 to lead SIU-Edwardsville over Omaha 75-65

OMAHA, Neb. (AP) — Lamar Wright had a career-high 20 points as Southern Illinois-Edwardsville defeated Nebraska Omaha 75-65 on Tuesday night. Shaun Doss Jr. had 15 points for Southern Illinois-Edwardsville ... Read more »

Ohio State upsets No. 1 Duke with second-half rally in Big Ten/ACC Challenge

Mike Krzyzewski’s final season as the Duke men’s basketball coach already has been a see-saw experience and November isn’t even over. Just four days after knocking off No. 1 Gonzaga, ... Read more »

Nero, Bruns spark North Dakota past Presentation 72-55

GRAND FORKS, N.D. (AP) — Caleb Nero had 18 points and six rebounds and Paul Bruns scored 15 as North Dakota defeated Presentation College 72-55 on Tuesday night. Bentiu Panoam ... Read more »

US has 'tools' to combat omicron variant; FDA experts give OK to antiviral pill; judge blocks vaccine mandate: Latest COVID-19 updates

For anyone on the fence about whether to get a COVID-19 vaccine or a booster shot, the emergence of the omicron variant should provide ample motivation to seek the nearest ... Read more »

These are the top 10 things Yahoo users bought on Amazon Canada during Black Friday and Cyber Monday

Looking for more Cyber Week deals, gift guides and holiday tips? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! Did your favourite items make the list of top purchases? Yahoo Lifestyle ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic