Are two medicines instead of three the future of HIV treatment?

The era of exclusive triple therapy for the treatment of HIV may be coming to an end as evidence mounts in support of the safety and efficacy of new dual-therapy (two-drug) regimens.

Are two medicines instead of three the future of HIV treatment?
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

One of the biggest breakthroughs in HIV treatment in the 1990s came when three different antiretrovirals (ARVs) were used together, suppressing viral replication in multiple ways and preventing the development of drug resistance. Now, trials are showing that certain combinations of just two antiretrovirals might be as good as three, potentially bringing an end to a quarter of a century of triple therapy dominance. 

The medicines available for the treatment of HIV infection in the public sector in South Africa have changed significantly over the years. But one thing that hasn’t changed is that the standard treatment is made up of three different ARVs – even if they come co-formulated in one pill.

The discovery of triple therapy for the treatment of HIV back in the 1990s turned HIV from a death sentence into a manageable disease. The triple was critical, since people who only took one or two ARVs soon developed drug resistance and fell sick again. The idea that you need three ARVs accordingly became one of the cornerstones of HIV treatment for the quarter-century since.

But, as discussed at the recent 2021 Southern African HIV Clinicians Society (SAHCS) conference, the era of exclusive triple therapy may be coming to an end as evidence mounts in support of the safety and efficacy of new dual therapy (two-drug) regimens.

But why dual therapy if triple therapy is already so good?

Speaking at the SAHCS conference, Dr Pedro Cahn, scientific director of the Huesped Foundation in Argentina, acknowledged that the current three-drug regimens are very effective and said that the aim of introducing dual therapy is to make treatment more comfortable for people living with HIV.

A dual therapy regimen firstly reduces the drug burden (from three to two), which Cahn said can improve patient adherence and quality of life. He said this can help meet the needs of the ageing HIV population, by reducing antiretroviral exposure, making treatment safer without sacrificing virologic control, as well as reducing drug-drug interactions and costs.

Dr Michelle Moorhouse, senior global medical director at the pharmaceutical company ViiV Healthcare, elaborated on the potential benefits of two-drug regimens. 

“For example, fewer ingredients mean a smaller pill size, which means smaller and lighter packaging,” she said. This can reduce transport and distribution costs, and more stock can be stored in facilities.

“Fewer ingredients should also reduce long-term exposure to additional antiretrovirals which may have long-term toxicity… and of course fewer ingredients should also directly reduce costs,” she said.

Dual therapy could be particularly beneficial for older people living with HIV. 

“Management of the older person living with HIV is complex as they often have multiple comorbidities and are at risk of polypharmacy. Two-drug regimens offer exposure to fewer drugs [and] reduced risk of unmanageable drug-drug interactions,” said Moorhouse.

Evidence for dual therapy

Historically, dual therapy has not been as effective as the current three-drug regimens, according to Cahn, but new drug combinations have shown promise in the last few years.

During his presentation, Cahn unpacked results from the landmark Gemini-1 and Gemini-2 studies. These were two identical double-blind, randomised, non-inferiority, Phase Three trials that compared a once-daily two-drug regimen of dolutegravir and lamivudine to a once-daily three-drug regimen of dolutegravir, tenofovir disoproxil fumarate, and emtricitabine. The study enrolled patients who had not taken antiretroviral treatment before.

According to Cahn, dolutegravir + lamivudine has demonstrated long-term durability and efficiency in patients with high viral load and CD4+ T-cell count of <200 cell/mm3. No treatment-emergent resistance was observed among participants who met virologic withdrawal in the Gemini-1 and Gemini-2 studies at week 48 or week 96, according to Cahn, and the safety and biomarkers generally favoured dolutegravir + lamivudine.

The studies also showed that there was a significantly lower risk of drug-related adverse events with the two-drug combination (20%), compared to 27% for the three-drug combination. But a higher mean weight gain of 3.7kg was observed with dual therapy, compared to 2.4kg with triple therapy.

While Cahn said that optimal two-drug regimens are potent, convenient, well-tolerated, and have a high barrier to resistance, he also stressed that more research for these regimens needs to be done in pregnant women, children, and people with HIV and TB coinfection.

Promising two-drug regimens

A systematic review, published in 2020 in the Infectious Diseases and Therapy journal, looked at 33 studies conducted on dual therapy, either as an initial treatment option or as a switch option.

The review concluded that lamivudine was the most commonly used Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitor in two-drug regimens that “met non-inferiority” in both treatment-naïve and treatment-experienced populations.

For now, it seems lamivudine is best paired with the integrase inhibitor dolutegravir, as was done in the Gemini studies.

According to the review, dolutegravir + lamivudine is the most promising NRTI-inclusive two-drug regimen for patients initiating antiretroviral therapy, so much so that recent guidelines updates for the European AIDS Clinical Society, as well as the Department of Health and Human Services in the US, recommend that the combination is considered as a treatment option in treatment-naïve patients, except for individuals with viral loads above 500,000 copies/ml, or active hepatitis B virus (HBV) coinfection.

According to the review, lamivudine in combination with a boosted protease inhibitor also showed efficacy in treatment naïve patients. For example, the Andes and Gardel studies found that lamivudine + darunavir/ritonavir and lamivudine + lopinavir/ritonavir were non-inferior to three-drug regimens.

Are two medicines instead of three the future of HIV treatment?
© Provided by Daily Maverick hiv dual therapy Trials are showing that certain combinations of just two antiretrovirals might be as good as three, potentially bringing an end to a quarter of a century of triple therapy dominance. (Photo: Spotlight)

Long-acting, injectable dual therapy 

While dolutegravir + lamivudine is the front-runner for dual therapy taken as a pill, other combinations are leading the way when it comes to dual therapy taken as a long-acting injection.

In her conference presentation, Moorhouse focused on the long-acting injectable combination of cabotegravir and rilpivirine. According to Moorhouse, the Atlas and Flare studies demonstrated that a monthly injection of this combination was non-inferior to daily oral antiretroviral therapy. Preliminary data from the Atlas 2M study went further to show non-inferiority of two-monthly compared to monthly dosing.

Injectable dual therapy consisting of cabotegravir and rilpivirine was approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration in January 2021. It is not listed as a registered product on the website of the South African Health Products Regulatory Authority.

Challenges in South Africa 

While developments in dual therapy are exciting, there are also potential barriers to rolling out two-drug regimens in South Africa, according to Professor Francois Venter, division head of Ezintsha at the University of the Witwatersrand.

One concern for Venter is that women, particularly pregnant women, are underrepresented in a lot of studies on new HIV drugs, including studies on two-drug regimens. He says more data for this population is required.

Another barrier that can hinder the adoption of dual therapy, particularly the dolutegravir+ lamivudine regimen, is the high prevalence of hepatitis B in the country. 

“It’s important to understand that in many ways, hepatitis B is the biggest gatekeeper to two drug therapies at the moment, including dolutegravir+ lamivudine,” Venter said.

As Moorhouse points out, dolutegravir + lamivudine may treat HIV, but is insufficient to treat hepatitis B. It thus follows that people should be screened for hepatitis B before being started on dual therapy – in the absence of such screening, triple therapy would be a safer option.

According to the 2019 National Guidelines for the Management of Viral Hepatitis, hepatitis B “is endemic in South Africa, resulting in a significant burden of clinical disease as a result of the progression to cirrhosis and the development of the complications of liver failure or hepatocellular carcinoma”. 

Hepatitis B prevalence estimates for South Africa vary widely, with the best evidence suggesting that it is around 6.7% overall, with higher rates in people living with HIV. Tenofovir, which forms part of standard triple therapy HIV treatment in South Africa, is also used to treat hepatitis B.

“If we can’t screen for hepatitis B, we can’t use it [dolutegravir + lamivudine]…. I don’t think HIV programmes should be held hostage for the rest of time to the hepatitis B programme,” Venter said. “We do acknowledge that’s important, but it’s not important enough to inform first-line therapies to the detriment of people having access to new and innovative therapies.”

TB drug interactions

Another problem is that rifampicin, a critically important medicine for the treatment of drug-sensitive TB, interacts with many of the drugs found in the current dual therapy HIV regimens.

“TB is a constant problem and rifampicin is such a potent driver of drug interactions and it has drug interactions with almost every one of the dual therapy agents we’re looking at at the moment other than lamivudine,” Venter said.

Yet, Venter explained that there are excellent first- and second-line treatment options for people living with HIV who also have a TB infection, and those drugs can be used to treat those patients instead of dual therapy regimens. “We have potent drug programmes for these patients and it’s not a deal-breaker any more,” he said.

Programmatic issues

For Venter, the programmatic issues in South Africa are the biggest headache.

He explained that while patients are closely monitored and there are follow-ups during clinical trials, patients in the real-world setting in clinics are not followed up as closely. This poses a big problem when rolling out dual therapies, particularly long-acting therapy. If patients miss their appointments for long-acting treatments, this can be disastrous from a resistance perspective.

He said that healthcare workers and patients would need to undergo training for using dual therapy, particularly the long-acting injectables. He added that the cost of dual therapies and potential logistical challenges like some long-acting injectable dual therapies requiring cold-chain storage would also need to be considered.

Another factor that the government and donors will need to consider, according to Venter, is whether dual therapy will be licensed and if generics will be produced, as this will also affect cost.  

“We must not underestimate the programmatic issues,” Venter said, “and we must start thinking hard now, starting to put our heads together, start thinking [about getting these] things out to everyone that needs them. Because if it does come, we need to make sure that we’re in a much stronger position to milk the benefits of this new, exciting innovation as quickly as humanly possible in first- and second-line therapy as we go forward.” DM/MC

This article was produced by Spotlight – health journalism in the public interest.

Are two medicines instead of three the future of HIV treatment?
© Provided by Daily Maverick

[hearken id=”daily-maverick/8881″]

News Related


7 Effective Astrological Tips for Bliss And Success in Your Love Life

© 7 Effective Astrological Tips for Bliss And Success in Your Love Life Ah, how beautiful is love! You have to agree that love can make life so much ... Read more »

'Set to undergo surgery' - Hay shares more LUFC injury news; ‘outstanding' talent's season over

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Mateusz Bogusz in action for Leeds Leeds United youngster Mateusz Bogusz has suffered a cruciate ligament injury during his loan spell at Ibiza, as The ... Read more »

UPSC ESE 2022: Prelims exam schedule out at; check details here

© Provided by Firstpost UPSC ESE 2022: Prelims exam schedule out at; check details here The timetable for the Engineering Services Examination (ESE) prelims 2022 has been released by ... Read more »

Eight people reportedly dead after crush at Africa Cup of Nations match

A minimum of eight people have died as a result of a crush prior to Cameroon vs Comoros at the African Cup of Nations, according to reports. Cameroon had been ... Read more »

Mounting concern as Russia to hold ‘war games' off southwest coast of Ireland

The Minister for Foreign Affairs has accused the Russian Ambassador to Ireland of ‘downplaying the significance’ of a planned military exercise by the Russians off Ireland’s southwest coast. It comes ... Read more »

'Work of Art': Rare Pristine Coral Reef Discovered in Tahiti

© Provided by News18 ‘Work of Art’: Rare Pristine Coral Reef Discovered in Tahiti In a rare find, a research team supported by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural ... Read more »

Shilpa Shetty-Richard Gere Kissing Case: Court Calls Actress 'Victim' In Obscenity Case, Grants Her Relief

© Provided by News18 Almost 15 years after Shilpa Shetty landed in an obscenity case Richard Gere kissed her in a public event, the actress was discharged from the case ... Read more »

Priti Patel's immigration bill will ‘all but destroy' main safe and legal route for refugees, charity warns

© Getty Images The Nationality and Borders Bill seeks to penalise asylum seekers who arrive in the UK via unauthorised routes by limiting their family reunion rights – Getty Thousands ... Read more »

LPGA Q-Series 'like walking on a tight rope'

© Getty Meghan MacLaren narrowly missed out on securing her LPGA Tour card last month The first full-field event of the LPGA Tour season takes place this week at the ... Read more »

IPL 2022: South Africa sends proposal to BCCI to host T20 League, says report

© Provided by Zee News The 15th edition of the Indian Premier League (IPL) in 2022 is just a couple of months away and Cricket South Africa (CSA) have thrown ... Read more »

German firms fear supply chain pain from China's battle with Omicron

FILE PHOTO: Workers stand at a residential area under lockdown following COVID-19 outbreak in Xian By Christian Kraemer BERLIN (Reuters) – German companies doing business in China are worried the ... Read more »

Australian Open: 'Where is Peng Shuai?' T-shirts now allowed after backlash

Tennis stars joined in the criticism after footage emerged on Sunday of a woman being intercepted at Melbourne Park wearing a shirt with an image of Peng on the front and the message "Where is Peng Shuai?" on the back. Read more »

Selin Kiazim's recipe for butter beans, paprika and piquillo peppers

Simple, quick and bursting with flavour, you’ll find most of this dish’s ingredients in your store cupboard I love this recipe and others of its kind because it’s simple, quick ... Read more »

Merc, Red Bull named in wanting $5m sprint boost

Mercedes and Red Bull have been named as the teams wanting an extra $5 million added to their budget to account for sprint qualifying, according to a report from Corriere ... Read more »

Prem Bandini: Ekta Kapoor approaches Anchal Sahu to play the lead role in the new show?

© Provided by TV czarina Ekta Kapoor is all set to entertain viewers with her upcoming new shows. Well, a few days ago there were reports that Ekta is ... Read more »

For the love of craft: Dibyendu recalls bleaching his hair for 'Looop Lapeta'

© IANS Dibyendu Bhattacharya. Mumbai, Jan 25 (IANS) Actor Dibyendu Bhattacharya, who will be soon seen in the upcoming comedy thriller ‘Looop Lapeta’, bleached his hair for his part in ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra Jonas Having A Daughter Via Surrogacy Is None Of Your Business

A few days ago, Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Nick Jonas broke the internet with the arrival of their baby via surrogacy. They took it to their Instagram handles and wrote ... Read more »

North Korea Conducts Cruise Missile Test, Its Fifth This Year: Report

© Provided by News18 North Korea Conducts Cruise Missile Test, Its Fifth This Year: Report South Korea on Tuesday said that it detected two cruise missiles into the sea off ... Read more »

Soha Ali Khan wishes Kunal Kemmu on 7th anniversary, reveals what makes them the perfect match

Soha Ali Khan and Kunal Kemmu are celebrating 7 years of marriage. Soha Ali Khan and Kunal Kemmu make an adorable couple. The two are clocked in seven years of ... Read more »

Pokémon Masters EX update teases upcoming events and new Sync Pairs

© Provided by Dot Esports Game producers Yu Sasaki and Tetsuya Iguchi today shared their latest dev blog for Pokémon Masters EX and it has provided players a glimpse of ... Read more »

Adivi Sesh-starrer 'Major' postponed due to Covid

© IANS Major. Mumbai, Jan 25 (IANS) Makers of ‘Major’ starring Adivi Sesh have announced the postponement of their film, after the new regulations about curfews and restrictions have been ... Read more »

Le Mans Virtual Series von Motorsport Games wird von mehr als 81 Millionen Fans verfolgt

© Deutschland Motorsport Games’ Le Mans Virtual Series followed by more than 81 million fans Die fünf Runden der Le Mans Virtual Series 2021/2022, die am vergangenen Wochenende mit ... Read more »

Alfa-SUV erwischt - erste Daten und Debüt bekannt - Alfa Romeo Tonale (2022)

Präsentiert wurde der Alfa Romeo Tonale als Studie in Genf 2019. Zu den Händlern rollt der kleine Alfa-SUV nach vielen Verzögerungen ab Mitte 2022. Sein Debüt als Serienmodell gibt der ... Read more »

Coin Master free spins and coins links (January 25, 2022)

© Provided by GamePur The main objective of Coin Master is building your village by spinning a slot machine and collecting coins to buy upgrades. Additionally, you can raid and ... Read more »

From Aparna Yadav to Imran Masood to Harak Singh Rawat: Curious Case of Party Hoppers Awaiting Tickets

© Provided by News18 From Aparna Yadav to Imran Masood to Harak Singh Rawat: Curious Case of Party Hoppers Awaiting Tickets Jumping parties just before elections is an old phenomenon ... Read more »

Weltraumteleskop «James Webb» erreicht Zielorbit

© keystone James Webb © keystone James Webb Rund einen Monat nach dem Start ins All hat das Weltraumteleskop «James Webb» nach Angaben der US-Raumfahrtbehörde Nasa seinen Zielorbit erreicht. «Webb, ... Read more »

Diese 6 Schnitte sind jetzt Trend - Männerfrisuren 2022

© James Barr / Die besten Männerfrisuren 2022 Nicht zu verachten, wenn es um deinen individuellen Look geht, ist die Frage: Was hast du auf dem Kopf? Nein, keinen ... Read more »

‘Balance? Average' – The incredible scouting report of Xavi aged 14

Some elite footballers take a while to show their class, but Barcelona legend Xavi clearly doesn’t fall into that category. The World Cup winner and multiple Champions League victor was one ... Read more »

Supreme Court notices to Centre, Election Commission on PIL against poll freebies

© Provided by The Financial Express A bench comprising Chief Justice N V Ramana and Justices A S Bopanna and Hima Kohli sought the response in four weeks on the ... Read more »

ANC MP Dirks wants court to declare his suspension unlawful and unconstitutional

© FILE: Mervyn Dirks. CAPE TOWN – African National Congress (ANC) member of Parliament (MP) Mervyn Dirks wants the Western Cape High Court to declare his suspension unlawful and ... Read more »

TOWIE's Cara is pregnant with third child following ectopic pregnancy

Photo credit: Instagram/carakilbey The Only Way is Essex star Cara Kilbey has announced that she is expecting her third child. The reality TV personality is already a mum to a ... Read more »

Asian shares decline amid omicron, Fed, Ukraine jitters

The Associated PressA currency trader watches monitors at the foreign exchange dealing room of the KEB Hana Bank headquarters in Seoul, South Korea, Tuesday, Jan. 25, 2022. Asian shares skidded ... Read more »

77 years after Auschwitz, Jews honor those who rescued them

The Associated PressThe 93-year-old Polish citizen Andrzej Sitkowski, who was named “Righteous Among the Nations” by Yad Vashem in 1995 talks to the Associated Press during an interview in Durach, ... Read more »

Emmerdale's Dawn left alarmed as character returns amid doomed wedding fears

Emmerdale spoilers tease a big return next week on the ITV soap, that leaves Dawn Taylor panicked. Dawn is looking forward to her upcoming wedding to Billy Fletcher but it’s ... Read more »

‘We will regret this', ‘Nightmare' – These Derby County fans react as transfer update shared

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Peterborough United v Derby County Festy Ebosele is set to leave Derby County before the transfer deadline with plenty of interest in ... Read more »

GTO Engineering 250 SWB California Spyder review

© Provided by Motoring Research GTO Engineering 250 SWB California Spyder In 2008, for Top Gear presenter DJ Chris Evans splashed out $10,894,000 (£7,850,000) on a Ferrari 250 GT SWB ... Read more »

Nick Kyrgios fever taking grip at Aus Open as home favourite prioritised over Rafael Nadal

Nick Kyrgios and Thanasi Kokkinakis are through to the last four of the doubles after another crazy win in a wild KIA Arena. The Aussie wildcards beat the world No.1s ... Read more »

Analysis-After explosion in costs, central Europe's factories are passing on the pain

By Jason Hovet and Krisztina Than © Reuters/JIRI SKACEL Employees work at Madeta dairy factory in Plana nad Luznici PRAGUE/BUDAPEST (Reuters) – Czech foundry Benes a Lat has seen its ... Read more »

Airtel shares rise 4% as firm to consider fund raising

Bharti Airtel shares went up more than 4% on the back of the telco’s plans to consider raising funds via a preferential share issue to investors other than its promoter ... Read more »

Forbidden Fruit: Ford Bronco Raptor revealed as 300kW SUV with mega attitude

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Dearborn, Michigan – Ford’s desert-conquering high performance off-roading family has a new member following the reveal of the new Ford Bronco Raptor. Set to ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic