Are Canada's competition laws outdated? Some say it's time for change

are canada's competition laws outdated? some say it's time for change

Rogers and Shaw applications are seen on a cellphone in Ottawa on May 9, 2022. The Competition Bureau sought to block the companies’ recent merger, fuelling criticism of Canada’s competition laws.

Whether checking in at the airport or checking out at the grocery store, it seems everywhere you turn these days, you find frustrated consumers. Many complain about high prices or limited choices across sectors — and blame lack of competition.

But now, the federal government is looking to update Canada’s competition laws — possibly the most significant review in decades. Everything seems to be on the table, from tiny tweaks to a major overhaul. Commissioner of Competition Matthew Boswell is one of those pushing for reforms.

“I think it’s fair to say, unfortunately, that the Competition Act is lagging behind our international peers,” said Boswell. He heads up the Competition Bureau, which aims to boost competition within sectors to benefit consumers. It’s recommending more than 50 changes to the act.

The changes aren’t radical, he says.

“They are really aimed at bringing us to the starting line in terms of competition law enforcement in the modern, digital world.”

For one, the bureau wants the power to compelcompanies to share information. It’s currently studying the rise in food prices at grocery stores, for example, but the companies involved only have to provide details about their business voluntarily. The bureau says changing that would allow it to conduct stronger investigations.

Another recommendation is to enact tougher rules on mergers. One of the most high-profile mergers recently was the massive tie-up of Rogers Communications and Shaw Communications, which was approved by the government in March.

Boswell calls that outcome “a big disappointment.”

If the Competition Bureau believes a merger will lead to less competition, it can apply to the Competition Tribunal to block the deal. But in the case of Rogers-Shaw, the tribunal sided with the companies, and it went to the federal industry minister for final approval.

Boswell says the current rules can lead to greater concentration, and are out of step with those of peer countries like the U.S. or Australia.

Keldon Bester, a fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation think tank, agrees, and wrote a report on the gaps in Canada’s merger laws last fall.

“We rarely, if ever, intervene against mergers,” Bester told CBC News. “Even ones that we know are going to make things worse for consumers, worse for producers or worse for workers.”

Bester says as other nations like the U.S., U.K. and Australia retool their competition laws, Canada needs to keep pace or risk falling behind.

“They’re looking at the past 40 or 50 years of how they’ve treated monopoly and concentrations of power, and they’re saying we need to take a different path.”

But Michael Osborne, who works on competition issues at the law firm Cozen O’Connor, cautions against a wholesale revamp. He says if regulations become too stringent, it could deter business and end up limiting competition.

“I think that the structure of the act is sound,” he said. “That doesn’t mean that there aren’t things that couldn’t be improved. There’s always things that can be improved.”

Osborne says, ultimately, what worries him are efforts to change the essence of the law.

“We’re at an interesting inflection point, I think, where we have a number of groups that are pushing for competition law to do things that competition law is not traditionally meant to do,” he said. “They’re pushing for it to be a device to control inflation, and it’s not a device or tool to control inflation.”

It’s not yet clear what changes, if any, could come out of the federal review process. After gathering feedback earlier this year, the government says next steps could include further consultations or a published report, though it did not provide a timeline.

Boswell says he’s encouraged, because a more competitive marketplace isn’t just about lower prices.

“It drives innovation in the country. It drives productivity growth. And I don’t accept the notion that we’re somehow so different that we can’t have healthy competition in this country,” he said.

News Related


Pivetta throws 7 innings as Red Sox blank AL East champion Orioles 3-0

Pivetta throws 7 innings as Red Sox blank AL East champion Orioles 3-0 BALTIMORE (AP) — Four starts into his comeback from Tommy John surgery, John Means believes he can ... Read more »

Bell's 2-run double keys 4-run 8th as Marlins beat Pirates 4-3 to close in on playoff spot

Bell’s 2-run double keys 4-run 8th as Marlins beat Pirates 4-3 to close in on playoff spot PITTSBURGH (AP) — The Miami Marlins arrived in Pittsburgh bleary-eyed. There’s an increasingly ... Read more »

Perplexing puzzle: Solve the riddle by moving just one match

This perplexing puzzle has taken the internet by storm, leaving countless users scratching their heads. It originally appeared on TikTok, courtesy of an account known for sharing brain teasers and ... Read more »

What postpartum depression medications can you take while breastfeeding?

Many breastfeeding women who suffer from postpartum depression fear that taking medication will harm their baby through their breast milk. This misconception often leads them to suffer in silence, avoiding ... Read more »

Conrad Black: Heather Stefanson's PCs the only sensible choice for Manitoba

Premier Heather Stefanson makes a campaign announcement at the 300 Main Street apartments in Winnipeg on Mon., Sept. 11, 2023. KEVIN KING/Postmedia The Manitoba general election on Tuesday is one ... Read more »

Honda makes MotoGP technical reshuffle amid Marquez uncertainty

Kokubu has been a mainstay at the Japanese manufacturer for over three decades, having joined Honda in 1986, working on its MotoGP project and even briefly in Formula 1. He ... Read more »

Rugby Canada looking to expand blue card concussion protocol across Canada

Rugby Canada is poised to expand access to a program aimed at making it easier to track players after they’ve been removed from the field with a suspected concussion. The ... Read more »

Quebec in talks with battery, auto makers for C$15 billion in EV-related investments

By Divya Rajagopal TORONTO (Reuters) – Quebec is in talks with battery makers and automobile companies looking to invest about C$15 billion ($11 billion) in the Canadian province over the ... Read more »

Tyrese Gibson Says He 'Will Not Back Down' in Lawsuit Against The Home Depot

Tyrese Gibson filed a $1 million lawsuit against The Home Depot alleging racial profiling against him and two associates during a Feb. 11 incident in California Rodin Eckenroth/WireImage Tyrese Gibson ... Read more »

Who Had the Best Performance in Make-or-Break Second Republican Debate?

Many pundits have suggested that the second Republican debate was a make-or-break event for several of the presidential hopefuls. Therefore, having a solid performance was vital for the candidates. According ... Read more »

United Airlines' pilots accept new labor contract

United Airlines pilots protest for a new contract in downtown Chicago (Reuters) – United Airlines’ pilots have ratified a new four-year contract that includes a significant pay increase and other ... Read more »

Wells Fargo sells $2 billion of private equity investments

FILE PHOTO: A Wells Fargo logo is seen in New York City (Reuters) – Wells Fargo said on Friday it had sold about $2 billion of its private equity investments ... Read more »

We Test Thousands of Travel Products Each Year, and Our Top 10 Picks Are Now on Sale

Shop the best luggage, backpacks, and accessories while they’re seriously discounted ahead of Amazon Prime Big Deal Days. Travel + Leisure / Reese Herrington As a travel writer who tests ... Read more »

Where is ‘College GameDay’ this week? Location, schedule, guest picker for Week 5 on ESPN

Where is ‘College GameDay’ this week? Location, schedule, guest picker for Week 5 on ESPN ESPN’s “College GameDay” was in familiar South Bend last week, which came as no surprise. ... Read more »

9 Ways to Make Your Luggage Stand Out at Baggage Claim

If you don’t want a bright orange suitcase, we also found other accessories that even make a standard black suitcase easy to spot at baggage claim. Travel + Leisure / ... Read more »

Guide to Global Entry Interviews — Including How to Schedule and What to Bring

Here’s everything you need to know about the Global Entry interview process. Chris Hondros/Getty Images If you travel internationally (even just once or twice a year), chances are you’ve heard ... Read more »

Mediterranean Diet May Lower Your Risk & Severity of COVID-19 By Up to 77%, According to New Research

Discover the relationship between your eating pattern and susceptibility to infection. Getty Images Reviewed by Dietitian Jessica Ball, M.S., RD As the world grapples with post-pandemic life, a new study ... Read more »

Head of Canadian Ukrainian group defends man who fought for unit created by Nazis

Head of Canadian Ukrainian group defends man who fought for unit created by Nazis The president of the Ukrainian National Federation of Canada is defending a Second World War veteran ... Read more »

2 Artificial Intelligence-Powered Growth Stocks to Buy Right Now

Businessman holding AI cloud The artificial intelligence (AI) boom may very well be just getting started. Though numerous tech companies with skin in the game have surged through the year, ... Read more »

US STOCKS-Wall St advances as softer PCE data supports rate-pause hopes

(For a Reuters live blog on U.S., UK and European stock markets, click or type LIVE/ in a news window.) * Nike jumps on Q1 profit beat * Aug PCE ... Read more »

Three quarters of Karabakh population already out in swift exodus

Refugees from Nagorno-Karabakh, a region inhabited by ethnic Armenians, make a drink on a roadside as they queue to reach the Armenian border, in Nagorno-Karabakh, September 26, 2023. More than ... Read more »

Canada disagrees with inclusion of Russians, Belarusians in 2024 Paralympics

Canada disagrees with inclusion of Russians, Belarusians in 2024 Paralympics OTTAWA — The Canadian Paralympic Committee disagreed with the International Paralympic Committee’s decision to allow Russian and Belarusian athletes to ... Read more »

Daniel gets first major league win as Angels beat A's 5-1 in Oakland's 111th loss

Daniel gets first major league win as Angels beat A’s 5-1 in Oakland’s 111th loss ANAHEIM, Calif. (AP) — Davis Daniel pitched five scoreless innings for his first major league ... Read more »

Freeman hits 59th double, Asian American managers make history in Dodgers' win over Giants

Freeman hits 59th double, Asian American managers make history in Dodgers’ win over Giants SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Dodgers manager Dave Roberts and acting Giants skipper Kai Correa stood for ... Read more »

The 2 Stocks I’d Buy With $10,000 Today

edit Business accounting concept, Business man using calculator with computer laptop, budget and loan paper in office. After the latest seasonal pullback, it seems wise to put your next $10,000 ... Read more »

‘Two-eyed seeing’ touted for therapy

The key to better mental health and addictions care for Indigenous Peoples might just lie in having the right perspective – or perspectives. That’s where the concept of “two-eyed seeing” ... Read more »

Urquidy brilliant in emergency start, pitches Astros to crucial 2-1 win over Diamondbacks

Urquidy brilliant in emergency start, pitches Astros to crucial 2-1 win over Diamondbacks PHOENIX (AP) — José Abreu hit a two-run double, José Urquidy pitched six shutout innings in an ... Read more »

TSX climbs as GDP data cements hopes of interest rate pause

Toronto Stock Exchange’s S&P/TSX composite index rises to a record high By Khushi Singh (Reuters) – Canada’s main stock index edged higher on Friday, the last trading day of the ... Read more »

Carlos Alcaraz and Daniil Medvedev untroubled in the first round at the China Open

BEIJING (AP) — Second-ranked Carlos Alcaraz made a comfortable debut in China on Friday with a 6-4, 6-3 victory over qualifier Yannick Hanfmann in the first round of the China ... Read more »

Malone scores in OT as Oilers rally to beat Flames 2-1

Malone scores in OT as Oilers rally to beat Flames 2-1 CALGARY — Brad Malone scored 2:24 into overtime and Jack Campbell made 33 saves as the Edmonton Oilers rallied ... Read more »
Top List in the World