Apple's plans to scan users' devices raises Big Tech trust issues

Apple, tech, Microsoft, Google, IPhone, Amazon.com

Apple’s plan to for images depicting child sexual abuse generated a over privacy concerns, which led the company to .

Apple, Facebook, Google and other companies have long scanned customers’ images that are stored on the companies’ servers for this material. Scanning data on users’ devices is a .

However well-intentioned, and whether or not Apple is willing and able to follow through on its promises to protect customers’ privacy, the company’s plan highlights the fact that people who buy iPhones are not masters of their own devices. In addition, Apple is using a complicated scanning system . Thus, customers face a stark reality: If you use an iPhone, you have to trust Apple.

Specifically, customers are forced to trust Apple to only use this system as described, run the system securely over time, and put the interests of their users over the interests of other parties, including the most powerful governments on the planet.

Despite Apple’s so-far-unique plan, the problem of trust isn’t specific to Apple. Other large tech companies also have considerable control over customers’ devices and insight into their data.

What is trust?

Trust is “the willingness of a party to be ,” according to social scientists. People base the decision to trust on experience, signs and signals. But past behavior, promises, the way someone acts, evidence and even contracts only give you data points. They cannot guarantee future action.

Therefore, trust is a matter of probabilities. You are, in a sense, rolling the dice whenever you trust someone or an organization.

Trustworthiness is a hidden property. People collect information about someone’s likely future behavior, but cannot know for sure whether the person has the ability to stick to their word, is truly benevolent and has the integrity – principles, processes and consistency – to maintain their behavior over time, under pressure or when the unexpected occurs.

Trust in Apple and Big Tech

Apple has stated that their scanning system will and has multiple strong privacy protections. The indicate that Apple has taken steps to protect user privacy unless the targeted material is detected by the system. For example, humans will review someone’s suspect material only when the number of times the system detects the targeted material reaches a certain threshold. However, Apple has given little proof regarding how this system will work in practice.

Apple, tech, Microsoft, Google, IPhone, Amazon.com
Credit: Apple
Apple’s new system for comparing your photos with a database of known images of child abuse works on your device rather than on a server.

After analyzing the “ that Apple is basing its scanning system on, security researchers and civil rights organizations warn that the system is likely to hackers, in contrast to .

Critics also fear that the system will be , such as indications of political dissent. Apple, along with other Big Tech players, has caved to the demands of authoritarian regimes, notably China, to allow government surveillance of technology users. In practice, the Chinese government has . What will be different this time?

It should also be noted that Apple is not operating this system on its own. In the U.S., Apple plans to use data from, and report suspect material to, the nonprofit . Thus, trusting Apple is not enough. Users must also trust the company’s partners to act benevolently and with integrity.

Big Tech’s less-than-encouraging track record

This case exists within a context of and moves to . The companies have positioned themselves as responsible parties, but many privacy experts say there is too little transparency and scant technical or historical evidence for these claims.

Another concern is unintended consequences. Apple might really want to protect children and protect users’ privacy at the same time. Nevertheless, the company has now announced – and staked its trustworthiness to – a technology that is well-suited to spying on large numbers of people. Governments might pass laws to extend scanning to other material deemed illegal.

Would Apple, and potentially other tech firms, choose to not follow these laws and potentially pull out of these markets, ? There’s no telling about the future, but Apple and other tech firms have chosen to acquiesce to oppressive regimes before. Tech companies that choose to operate in China are , for example.

Weighing whether to trust Apple or other tech companies

There’s no single answer to the question of whether Apple, Google or their competitors can be trusted. Risks are different depending on who you are and where you are in the world. An activist in India faces different threats and risks than an Italian defense lawyer. Trust is a matter of probabilities, and risks are not only probabilistic but also situational.

It’s a matter of what probability of failure or deception you can live with, what the relevant threats and risks are, and what protections or mitigations exist. , the existence of strong local privacy laws, the strength of rule of law and your own technical ability are relevant factors. Yet, there is one thing you can count on: Tech firms typically have extensive control over your devices and data.

Like all large organizations, tech firms are complex: Employees and management come and go, and regulations, policies and power dynamics change.

A company might be trustworthy today but not tomorrow.

Big Tech has shown behaviors in the past that should make users question their trustworthiness, in particular when it comes to privacy violations. But they have also defended user privacy in other cases, for example in the .

Last but not least, Big Tech does not exist in a vacuum and is not all-powerful. Apple, Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook and others have to respond to various external pressures and powers. Perhaps, considering these circumstances, greater transparency, more independent audits by journalists and trusted people in civil society, more user control, more open-source code and genuine discourse with customers might be a good start to balance different objectives.

While only a first step, consumers would at least be able to make more informed choices about what products to use or buy.

Article by , Lecturer in Cybersecurity,

This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

‘I wrote better pleadings in law school': Trump lawsuit likely to be rejected by courts, experts say

(Getty Images) The courts are likely to reject the lawsuit former President Donald Trump filed on Monday in hopes of stopping the House of Representatives’ investigation into the 6 January ... Read more »

Shop The Trend: Over-The-Knee Boots That Don't Look Cheap

If you subscribe to the Nancy Sinatra view that boots are made for walking, then we’ve got good news for you. It’s boot season! While boots come in a variety ... Read more »

Best phones in SA - latest arrivals

Creating the best phones in the world has become as much art as it is science and engineering.  © Provided by TechRadar The OnePlus 9 Pro, iPhone 13 Pro and ... Read more »

Microsoft alertó a Gates sobre correos inapropiados en 2008

© AP MICROSOFT-BILL GATES Los ejecutivos de Microsoft advirtieron en 2008 a Bill Gates que dejara de enviar correos electrónicos coquetos a una empleada, pero desistieron del asunto cuando éste ... Read more »

Apple Music Voice Plan: everything we know (and what we don't)

Apple kicked off its Apple Unleashed Event coverage by letting the world know that a new Apple Music plan was coming – the Voice Plan. Half the price of the ... Read more »

Apple October event: 5 things you might have missed at Unleashed

Apple’s October event was all about computing with a decent amount of audio thrown in for good measure. While the reveals of the new 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pros took ... Read more »

Walmart Black Friday deals are live: shop early sales on TV, toys, laptops and more

Black Friday deals are live at Walmart, and yes, you heard that right! The retailer is kicking off the Black Friday 2021 shopping season with early deals that you can ... Read more »

RICHARD KAY: The BBC should be royally afraid of Earl Spencer in dock

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo For 25 years the BBC’s most senior staff concealed the truth that Princess Diana was tricked into giving her explosive 1995 Panorama interview. Lies ... Read more »

Best online learning platforms of 2021

The best online learning platforms make it simple and easy for educators and trainers to manage course materials online. The best online learning platforms Click the links below to go ... Read more »

GameStop PS5 restock in-store event time on Friday – all locations with stock listed

The next GameStop PS5 restock in-store event in the US will happen in seven cities on Friday, October 22, and if you follow our PS5 and Twitter tracker Matt Swider ... Read more »

Microsoft warned Bill Gates over 'inappropriate' emails to female staffer in 2008, report says

Microsoft executives warned Bill Gates to stop sending flirtatious emails to a female employee in 2008 but dropped the matter after he told them he would stop, The Wall Street ... Read more »

MasterChef at Home: Nick Riewoldt's Dippy Eggs Will Amp up Your Dessert Game

Celebrity MasterChef is ticking along nicely with all kinds of sweet feeds popping up on our screens each week. And lucky for you, we’re following the season closely, sharing any ... Read more »

IT firms cautious about ending work-from-home under 'Living with COVID-19'

Seen above is a night scene of Pangyo Techno Valley at around 9 pm, July 12. Korea Times photo by Lee Hae-rin By Kim Bo-eun With the government preparing to ... Read more »

Can a long-life soup really be good for you? A dietician assesses

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo As more of us buy tinned and long-life soups — sales rose by more than 35 million last year — maybe it’s no ... Read more »

Helmet that zaps brain with infrared light 'could help cure dementia'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A helmet that zaps your brain with infrared light could help cure dementia, a study has found. Researchers from Durham University have developed ... Read more »

Giant space bubble reveals reverse shockwaves from a catastrophic star explosion

© Provided by Space Supernova remnant G344.7-0.1, located 19,600 light years from Earth, is the result of a white dwarf stellar explosion that occurred between 3,000 and 6,000 years ago. ... Read more »

Roger Chaffee: Engineer, aviator and Apollo 1 astronaut

© Provided by Space Roger Chaffee Since childhood, Roger Chaffee dreamt of becoming an astronaut and, when he was selected to be in NASA’s third group of astronauts, that goal ... Read more »

Microsoft Outlook extension finally comes to Google Chrome

Microsoft is making it even easier to access your email in Outlook from Google’s browser with the release of its new Chrome extension. As reported by Windows Central and first ... Read more »

The new MacBook Pro is everything you missed about Apple's best laptop

The rumors leading up to the latest Apple event 2021 offered a ton of hype. Word on the street suggested we were about to get a new MacBook Pro that ... Read more »

Dyson Black Friday sale 2021: When does it start and what deals can you expect?

The brand has many third party stockists, such as Amazon, John Lewis and Argos, that offer big discounts during the event (iStock/The Independent) The start of autumn signals the countdown ... Read more »

macOS Monterey will have the old Safari tab design

Apple debuted a controversial new Safari tab design this summer at WWDC 2021, and since then, it has tweaked that look and even let you turn off many of the ... Read more »

Video Games Are Now More Popular In Australia Than Free-To-Air TV

If it wasn’t already clear from the studies of years past, Australians love video games. That’s only been further affirmed by Bond University’s regular Digital Australia report, which has found ... Read more »

Apple's rumored Beats Fit Pro earbuds could have ear-fitting wingtips

Apple has just announced the next generation of AirPods, but if you’ve been waiting for new Beats earbuds, you may also have something to look forward to there. A report ... Read more »

Amazon Black Friday deals 2021: When does it start and what UK offers can you expect?

The online giant is known for its huge discounts on everything from vacuum cleaners to TVs (iStock/The Independent) The Black Friday 2021 sales are inching closer every day, with thousands ... Read more »

Colin Powell, who died on Monday from COVID-19, had a blood-cell cancer that likely weakened his immune system

Former Secretary of State Colin Powell. Paul Morigi/Getty Images for Capital Concerts Colin Powell, former US secretary of state, died on Monday from COVID-19 complications. Powell was vaccinated but was ... Read more »

A piece of cloth to clean your Apple devices will cost you $19

If you were ever concerned about safely cleaning your Apple products, now you can use an official $19 piece of cloth made by Apple to do so. Apple released this ... Read more »

Apple's website indicates macOS Monterey will launch without Universal Control

Universal Control, Apple’s upcoming feature that lets you control multiple devices with the same mouse and keyboard, will probably not be launching at the same time as macOS Monterey. While ... Read more »

Want a fully specced-out MacBook Pro? You'll have to pay more than $6,000

© Image: Apple Apple’s most expensive laptop is, well, expensive. Apple announced new M1-equipped MacBook Pros on Monday, and they look like very good upgrades, with powerful chips, adaptive refresh ... Read more »

Call for armchair astronomers to help search for new planets

A call has been made for armchair astronomers to help in a search for extrasolar planets. The online citizen project is enlisting the help of the public to examine five ... Read more »

Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz Mourn the Death of Their Dog Frankie: 'My Heart Is Shattered'

Brooklyn Beckham Brooklyn Beckham/instagram Brooklyn Beckham Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz are mourning the death of their beloved dog, Frankie. The couple, who got engaged last year, announced the sad ... Read more »

Regulators say GameStop rally ‘raises questions of market efficiency'

On Monday, the Securities and Exchange Commission published an official staff report on the GameStop rally earlier this year, calling for more scrutiny of both short-seller activity and broker-dealers like ... Read more »

PLACES+FACES teams with Xbox for limited controller and apparel

© Provided by Windows Central Tees, hoodies, and a custom Xbox controller from the UK label. What you need to know PLACES+FACES has teased an upcoming Xbox-themed capsule collection, including ... Read more »

List of Xbox Series X, Series S games with 120 FPS

© Provided by Windows Central Smoother, faster, cleaner. With a new generation of consoles comes new hardware capabilities. One of the exciting new features of the Xbox Series X and ... Read more »

Alibaba launches fast-fashion shopping site allyLikes for overseas shoppers, taking on shooting star Shein

Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba Group Holding recently launched fast-fashion e-tailer allyLikes targeting the North American and European markets, in an attempt to rival Chinese shopping site Shein, which has taken ... Read more »

MS drug does NOT improve condition of hospitalized COVID-19 patients

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A multiple sclerosis drug combined with the antiviral remdesivir did not improve the conditions of COVID-19 patients, a new federal study reveals. The ... Read more »

Universal Control likely won't be coming with macOS Monterey

Universal Control, Apple’s upcoming feature that lets you control multiple devices with the same mouse and keyboard, will probably not be launching at the same time as macOS Monterey. While ... Read more »

'Smart' cane helps blind avoid obstacles with autonomous car tech

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Researchers at Stanford University have developed a robotic ‘smart’ cane that guides people with visual impairments using technology originated for autonomous vehicles.    Most ... Read more »

Doogee V10 rugged smartphone

© Provided by TechRadar Doogee V10 Review Listing Two minute review Doogee introduced a new line of flagship rugged smartphones eschewing the S-prefix for the V one. The first in ... Read more »

The Best Smart Home Hubs to Control All Your Devices

Whether you’ve just screwed in new Wi-Fi controlled light bulbs or installed the latest video doorbell camera, you may have noticed that each smart home device requires its own app ... Read more »

Emergency services at the scene after being called to house explosion in Ayr

Three people have been taken to hospital following an explosion at a housing estate in the Scottish town of Ayr. Residents have been evacuated from the Kincaidston area, near the ... Read more »