Apple, Google raise new concerns by yanking Russian app

FILE - In this Friday, Sept. 17, 2021 file photo, The app Smart Voting is displayed on an iPhone screen in Moscow, Russia. Big Tech companies that operate around the globe have long promised both to obey local laws and to protect civil rights while doing business. But when Apple and Google capitulated to Russian demands and removed Smart Voting, a political-opposition app from their local app stores, it raised worries that two of the world's most successful companies are more comfortable bowing to undemocratic edicts — and maintaining a steady flow of profits— than upholding their stated principles.(AP Photo/Alexander Zemlianichenko, File)
1 / 2Big Tech-Government PressureFILE – In this Friday, Sept. 17, 2021 file photo, The app Smart Voting is displayed on an iPhone screen in Moscow, Russia. Big Tech companies that operate around the globe have long promised both to obey local laws and to protect civil rights while doing business. But when Apple and Google capitulated to Russian demands and removed Smart Voting, a political-opposition app from their local app stores, it raised worries that two of the world’s most successful companies are more comfortable bowing to undemocratic edicts — and maintaining a steady flow of profits— than upholding their stated principles.(AP Photo/Alexander Zemlianichenko, File)

BERKELEY, Calif. (AP) — Big Tech companies that operate around the globe have long promised to obey local laws and to protect civil rights while doing business. But when Apple and Google capitulated to Russian demands and removed a political-opposition app from their local app stores, it raised worries that two of the world's most successful companies are more comfortable bowing to undemocratic edicts — and maintaining a steady flow of profits — than upholding the rights of their users.

The app in question, called Smart Voting, was a tool for organizing opposition to Russia President Vladimir Putin ahead of elections held over the weekend. The ban levied last week by a pair of the world's richest and most powerful companies galled supporters of free elections and free expression.

“This is bad news for democracy and dissent all over the world,” said Natalia Krapiva, tech legal counsel for Access Now, an internet freedom group. “We expect to see other dictators copying Russia’s tactics.”

Technology companies offering consumer services from search to social media to apps have long walked a tightrope in many of the less democratic nations of the world. As Apple, Google and other major companies such as Amazon, Microsoft and Facebook have grown more powerful over the past decade, so have government ambitions to harness that power for their own ends.

“Now this is the poster child for political oppression,” said Sascha Meinrath, a Penn State University professor who studies online censorship issues. Google and Apple “have bolstered the probability of this happening again.”

Neither Apple nor Google responded to requests for comment from The Associated Press when the news of the app's removal broke last week; both remained silent this week as well.

According to a person with direct knowledge of the matter, Google faced legal demands by Russian regulators and threats of criminal prosecution of individual employees if it failed to comply. The same person said Russian police visited Google’s Moscow offices last week to enforce a court order to block the app. The person spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue.

Google's own employees have reportedly blasted the company's cave-in to Putin's power play by posting internal messages and images deriding the app's removal.

That sort of backlash within Google has become more commonplace in recent years as the company's ambitions appeared to conflict with its one-time corporate motto, “Don't Be Evil,” adopted by cofounders Larry Page and Sergey Brin 23 years ago. Neither Page nor Brin — whose family fled the former Soviet Union for the U.S. when he was a boy — are currently involved in Google's day-to-day management, and that motto has long since been set aside.

Apple, meanwhile, lays out a lofty “Commitment To Human Rights” on its website, although a close read of that statement suggests that when legal government orders and human rights are at odds, the company will obey the government. “Where national law and international human rights standards differ, we follow the higher standard,” it reads. “Where they are in conflict, we respect national law while seeking to respect the principles of internationally recognized human rights.”

A recent report from the Washington nonprofit Freedom House found that global internet freedom declined for the fifth consecutive year and is under “unprecedented strain” as more nations arrested internet users for “nonviolent political, social, or religious speech” than ever before. Officials suspended internet access in at least 20 countries, and 21 states blocked access to social media platforms, according to the report.

For the seventh year in a row, China held the top spot as the worst environment for internet freedom. But such threats take several forms. Turkey’s new social media regulations, for instance, require platforms with over a million daily users to remove content deemed “offensive” within 48 hours of being notified, or risk escalating penalties including fines, advertising bans and limits on bandwidth.

Russia, meanwhile, added to the existing “labyrinth of regulations that international tech companies must navigate in the country,” according to Freedom House. Overall online freedom in the U.S. also declined for the fifth consecutive year; the group said, citing conspiracy theories and misinformation about the 2020 elections as well as surveillance, harassment and arrests in response to racial-injustice protests.

Big Tech companies have generally agreed to abide by country-specific rules for content takedowns and other issues in order to operate in these countries. That can range from blocking posts about Holocaust denial in Germany and elsewhere in Europe where they're illegal to outright censorship of opposition parties, as in Russia.

The app's expulsion was widely denounced by opposition politicians. Leonid Volkov, a top strategist to jailed opposition leader Alexei Navalny, wrote on Facebook that the companies “bent to the Kremlin’s blackmail.”

Navalny’s ally Ivan Zhdanov said on Twitter that the politician’s team is considering suing the two companies. He also mocked the move: “Expectations: the government turns off the internet. Reality: the internet, in fear, turns itself off.”

It's possible that the blowback could prompt either or both companies to reconsider their commitment to operating in Russia. Google made a similar decision in 2010 when it pulled its search engine out of mainland China after the Communist government there began censoring search results and videos on YouTube.

Russia isn't a major market for either Apple, whose annual revenue this year is expected to approach $370 billion, nor Google's corporate parent, Alphabet, whose revenue is projected to hit $250 billion this year. But profits are profits.

“If you wan to take a principled stand on human rights and freedom of expression, then there are some hard choices you have to make on when you should leave the market,” said Kurt Opsahl, general counsel for the digital rights group Electronic Frontier Foundation.

—-

Ortutay reported from Oakland, California. Associated Press writers Daria Litvinova in Moscow and Kelvin Chan in London contributed to this story.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Facebook rebrands as Meta as it bets on the future of the metaverse

Facebook (FB) is changing its name to Meta as it focuses on the metaverse, a series of interconnected, persistent virtual worlds that let people interact with digital objects and avatars. ... Read more »

Facebook is now called… Meta

The Facebook transformation we’ve all been waiting for has finally arrived. No, Mark Zuckerberg hasn’t resigned. And no, the company hasn’t been broken up. It’s a lot more significant than ... Read more »

30 thoughtful last-minute DIY gifts anyone would love

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Another year at home has kept everyone either binge-watching TV shows ... Read more »

How Did Elephants and Walruses Get Their Tusks? It's a Long Story.

How Did Elephants and Walruses Get Their Tusks? It’s a Long Story. Elephants have them. Pigs have them. Narwhals and water deer have them. Tusks are among the most dramatic ... Read more »

UAE has made significant progress to advance human rights, says committee

© stock Dr Anwar Gargash, diplomatic adviser to President Sheikh Khalifa and chairman of the National Human Rights Committee. Getty Images The UAE has made significant progress to advance human ... Read more »

Amazon just dropped new early Black Friday deals - here are the 13 best picks

Amazon has been dropping early Black Friday deals throughout the month of October, and today’s new batch of bargains don’t disappoint. We’ve sorted through Amazon’s early Black Friday sale to ... Read more »

New Oculus VR headset officially teased at Facebook Connect 2021

Mark Zuckerberg finally lifted the lid on Oculus’ next VR headset at Facebook Connect 2021 – and it’s called Project Cambria. Coming at some point next year, Project Cambria isn’t ... Read more »

Experts name new species of human ancestor who lived 500,000 years ago

Researchers have announced the naming of a new species of human ancestor, Homo bodoensis. This species lived in Africa, about half a million years ago – during the Middle Pleistocene ... Read more »

A ‘pancake' on Jupiter: Juno probe reveals details of Great Red Spot

Two new studies of the gas giant’s biggest storm verify that it’s not so deep after all. Read more »

iPhone users can finally report dodgy apps to Apple

After announcing its new App Privacy Report at WWDC 2021, the feature has now begun rolling out to iPhones and iPads with the release of the iOS 15.2 beta and ... Read more »

Best secure email providers of 2021

Cut to the chase: The best secure email provider is Securemyemail . Sign up for a no-obligation 30-day free trial to make your email communication safer. The best secure email ... Read more »

Sitting Bull's great grandson identified after new DNA method analyses hair from Native American leader

It is the first time that ancient DNA has been used to confirm a familial relationship between living and historical individuals. Read more »

Dell comes out swinging with a brand new XPS desktop model

Dell’s laptop XPS laptop line include some of the best laptops and Ultrabooks out there, such as the recent Dell XPS 15 OLED and Dell XPS 17 models. However, the ... Read more »

Grand Theft Auto San Andreas is in development for Oculus Quest

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced that the classic Rockstar Games title Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas is coming to Quest 2. The project has been in development for some time, ... Read more »

It's black and white: Scientists finally work out secrets behind giant panda colours

Male giant panda Jiao Qing tucking into the bamboo at Berlin Zoo (EPA) The secret of precisely why giant pandas are coloured black and white has been uncovered by a ... Read more »

I tried these AirPods Pro alternatives, all priced $90 or less. Which ones were the best?

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. It’s too bad you only have two ears! These affordable earbuds ... Read more »

Mark Zuckerberg unveils wild AR plans at Facebook Connect event

At the Facebook Connect event, Mark Zuckerberg’s opening keynote detailed the plans he has for a metaverse that combines the real virtual world that allow people to connect wherever they ... Read more »

44 perfect last-minute gifts people actually want that don't require shipping

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Maybe you put off shopping until the last minute. Fear not—you ... Read more »

Darnold: In vier Wochen vom Helden zum Bankdrücker

München/Carolina – 3:25 gegen die New York Giants verloren. 16 von 25 angebrachte Passversuche für 112 Passing Yards, kein Touchdown und eine Interception. © Getty Images Darnold, Panthers, 1600 Dazu ... Read more »

Apple to report earnings amid chip shortage and supply crunch

Apple CEO Tim Cook speaks during Apple‘s annual Worldwide Developers Conference in San Jose, California, U.S. June 3, 2019. REUTERS/Mason Trinca Apple (AAPL) will report Q4 earnings after the closing ... Read more »

Horizon Home announced at Facebook Connect 2021

Announced during the Facebook Connect 2021 event, Horizon Home, Horizon Worlds, create games, throw parties, chat with friends’ avatars. Built on last year’s beta. Announced during the Facebook Connect 2021 ... Read more »

'The Long Call' and 'Guilt': The 5 best things on TV on Thursday, 28 October

‘The Long Call‘ and ‘Guilt’ both feature in Thursday’s dramas. (ITV/BBC) Drama takes centre stage in Thursday's schedules, with ITV's Ann Cleeves adaptation The Long Call concluding its week at ... Read more »

Why has France detained a British fishing ship and threatened sanctions?

France has accused the UK of not granting enough fishing licences. The government is facing calls to defend British fishermen after a UK boat was detained by French authorities as ... Read more »

Best cameras for photos and videos

With so many different types of photographers out there, it’s hard for camera manufacturers to fit everything into one device. In fact, by doing so you rule out a vast ... Read more »

U.S. congresswoman Greene bought Trump SPAC shares

U.S. Rep. Greene speaks to reporters about being temporarily suspended from Twitter By Anirban Sen (Reuters) – U.S. Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, an ally of Donald Trump, bought as much ... Read more »

Mom realizes she's been flashing neighbors from bathroom window in hilarious video

Jill Santom’s TikTok videos have since gone viral after discovering her frosted glass bathroom window isn’t as frosted as she thought. mama_jill34/TikTok Who doesn’t like the idea of having a ... Read more »

How to watch UFC 267: time, card and Blachowicz vs Teixeira live stream details

Making just his second title title defence, Polish light heavyweight top dog Jan Blachowicz takes on former title hopeful Glover Teixeira as UFC heads back to Fight Island this weekend. ... Read more »

Battlefield 2042 reveals three massive multiplayer maps ahead of launch

EA DICE has released deep-diving details on three enormous maps coming to the all multiplayer Battlefield 2042 at launch. While today’s action-packed trailer feels like it’s over in a flash, ... Read more »

How to turn your smart home into a haunted haven this Halloween – for free

The scariest part of Halloween this year could be how much we’re spending on it. American’s are shelling out more than $10 billion – a whopping two billion dollars more ... Read more »

Apple sued by Chinese students over iPhone's lack of cables

A group of Chinese students is suing Apple for not providing a charger with the iPhone. © Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Apple China Removed Apps – ... Read more »

Don't miss this top-rated Chromebook on sale for just $199 on Amazon

Looking for more of the best deals, sales and product recommendations? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! This affordable Chromebook is on sale for under $200. Yahoo Lifestyle Canada ... Read more »

LG CineBeam HU810P 4K UHD Projector review

Two-minute review Laser projectors are starting to get a little cheaper, finally, thanks to 4K projectors like the LG CineBeam HU810P. It’s still on the expensive side, but it’s half ... Read more »

Suncor is an 'underappreciated' cash machine: analyst

Suncor Energy’s (SU.TO)(SU) plan to double its payout to shareholders on the heels of a strong quarter boosted by higher oil prices sent the company’s stock to its highest level ... Read more »

Everyone wants CoComelon toys this year—here are 20 great ones to buy

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. These days, you won’t be hard-pressed to find a kid who ... Read more »

Lawyers use Voller defamation case to demand Facebook group admins remove posts

Photograph: Dado Ruvić/Reuters A Perth law firm has cited the Australian high court decision in the Voller case in a letter calling on an administrator of a Facebook community group ... Read more »

Edgar Wright says directors have a ‘duty' to make original films whenever possible

Edgar Wright says that he believes directors have a “duty” to make original films if they are in a position to do so. Speaking to TechRadar ahead of the release ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic