Appeals court finds Helpling cleaners are temporary workers

Amsterdam appeals court found on Tuesday, FNV won a lawsuit against Uber

House cleaners hired via the app Helpling are temporary workers and must be given paid sick leave and compensation if they lose their jobs, Amsterdam appeals court found on Tuesday.

But the court, however, stopped short of including them in the collective agreement for cleaners which would have treated them as permanent workers.

Trade union FNV brought the case together with a cleaner, in 2019, arguing that the app is an employer and must pay its cleaners accordingly. The app, launched in 2012, allows households looking for domestic help to search its database for cleaners.

A lower court found that the payment structure – charging a commission from the cleaner of between 23 and 32% – created an employment relationship. Both sides appealed that decision.

According to Tuesday’s ruling, Helping is not a traditional employer. Wages are set by the household and cleaner and the instructions about the work are given by the household, not Helping. However, the contractual agreements between the London-based app and the cleaners mean that it does have some characteristics of regular employment.

The FNV says it is ‘very happy’ with the outcome but calls on politicians to do more to help gig workers.


‘We win lawsuits and the sham constructions of so-called modern platforms are painfully exposed,’ Zakaria Boufangacha, vice president of the FNV said in a statement.

‘The only modern thing about these platforms is that they come up with all kinds of ways to undermine the rules of our labuor market. It is even more painful that politicians are watching passively,’

Helpling said in an emailed statement that it is analysing the ruling.

Earlier this month, FNV won a lawsuit against Uber, when a court concluded that its drivers were, in fact, employees not self-employed.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Russian Armed Forces officer sets new Guinness World record in bar exercise

Denis Yakovlev performed a total of 255 exercise cycles in one go Read more »

Open Russia ex-leader charged with heading undesirable organization

According to investigators, being a member of a foreign non-government organization recognized as undesirable in Russia, Andrei Pivovarov posted in the public domain in August 2020 information in support of this organization Read more »

Moscow still lacks COVID-19 herd immunity — hospital chief

"If such inoculation rates persist, it [the virus] will surely get adapted sooner or later to what surrounds it," Maryana Lysenko explained Read more »

Crimea views court trial on Scythian Gold's ownership delayed with excuse of COVID-19

Crimea’s Minister of Culture Arina Novoselskaya noted that Crimea still hoped for the return of the collection Read more »

Some 2,000 are on new Afghan evacuation list, minister tells MPs

Destroyed tanks, abandoned in a field in Afghanistan. Photo: The Netherlands would still like to bring back over 2,000 people from Afghanistan, caretaker foreign minister Ben Knapen has told ... Read more »

IT crimes show 50%-growth over two years — Russian Interior Minister

"Fraud is the most typical type of the offense," Vladimir Kolokoltsev pointed out Read more »

Russia sees mounting threat of Afghan drugs transit through Ukrainian ports

"I want to note that Russia continues to strictly follow the policy of preserving and strengthening the current international system of control over narcotic drugs based on three basic conventions and other international documents," Russian Interior Minister Vladimir Kolokoltsev said Read more »

Teen stabbed to death during fight in Dagestan high school, police say

According to investigators, a fight broke out between a 15-year-old teenager and his classmate, during which one of them took out the knife and stabbed his opponent Read more »

Sinterklaas showdown looms as rivals organise separate parades in Amsterdam

Femke Halsema with Sinterklaas in happier times last November. Photo: ANP/Koen van Weel The annual arrival of Sinterklaas has become a polarising event in the last decade, but it has ... Read more »

Dutch court's verdict on Scythian gold likely to be postponed to late 2021 — museum

"The court of appeal is being postponed all the time due to COVID-19, no one knows when it will take place," Director of the Central Museum of Tavrida Andrei Malgin noted Read more »

High mortality, new waves of pandemic in Russia caused by low inoculation rates — Kremlin

"The pandemic is not going away, it is returning in new waves, as new more aggressive strains that are more virulent, this represents a great danger," Dmitry Peskov stressed Read more »

Express COVID-19 test helps to avoid tightening restrictions — crisis center

"The opportunity to take a rapid test is an example of a soft but effective way to interrupt the chain of propagation of the virus," the crisis center noted Read more »

Two men jailed for 30 years for killing lawyer Derk Wiersum

Flowers outside Derk Wiersums office. Photo: Two men have been jailed for 30 years for the murder of lawyer Derk Wiersum outside his home in the Amsterdam suburb of ... Read more »

LGBTI organisations say next government must enshrine rights in coalition deal

Gender equality organisations will be urging the future coalition parties to include LGBTI rights in the government accord at a symposium being held in Assen on Monday. ‘We are counting ... Read more »

TASS announces kickoff of second international News Photo Awards contest

Applications for the contest will be accepted until December 24, 2021 Read more »

Saakashvili needs hospitalization as his health deteriorated - doctor

Georgian ex-President went on a hunger strike as he claims to be a political prisoner Read more »

Sputnik V production in Serbia to ensure interests of country's people - Lavrov

n September, Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic said his country had manufactured 545,000 doses of the first and second components of the Russian vaccine Read more »

Roscosmos to suspend engine tests to share oxygen with hospitals

According to chief of Russia’s state space corporation Dmitry Rogozin, this enterprise donates up to 33 tonnes of oxygen to medical institutions a day Read more »

Russia reports 28,647 new coronavirus cases

Coronavirus death toll across Russia grows by 962 Read more »

Special accommodation for pseudo refugees set to close end 2021

Photo: Two centres for pseudo asylum seekers from safe third countries are set to close at the end of the year and no alternative locations have yet been found. ... Read more »

Boar bonanza over as 5,000 are culled on Veluwe, with more to go

Young wild boar at rest A record number of wild boar have been shot in the Veluwe heathland area in the last three months in an effort to control numbers, ... Read more »

Government to do everything to ensure prosperous life in rural regions, Putin pledges

Rural tourism is getting increasingly popular in Russia, President said Read more »

Suicides of minors down 1.6-fold in Russia — Health Ministry

In his words, attitude of parents and school teachers plays a great role in prevention of suicides among minors Read more »

About one million of Russians die of cardiovascular diseases every year — scientist

"Nevertheless, the novel coronavirus infection and some other diseases remain in the spotlight," he added Read more »

US embassy staffers suspected of theft opt for leaving Russia — diplomat

The stolen backpack has not been returned to its legitimate owner Read more »

22 people died after Covid vaccination in Lithuania - report

According to Lithuanian State Medicines Control Agency spokeswoman Aiste Tautvidiene, Lithuania reports every lethal case to the European Medicines Agency Read more »

Amsterdam bans consumer fireworks at New Year, plans Museumplein ‘spectacular'

New Year fireworks in Amsterdam. Photo: Amsterdam is pressing ahead with plans to ban consumer fireworks during the New Year festivities but officials admit it would ‘not be realistic’ ... Read more »

968 die from Covid-19 in Russia in past 24 hours, new record high since onset of pandemic

In the past 24 hours, 29,362 new Covid-19 cases were registered in Russia - the highest daily increase since December 24 and the second highest number since the onset of the pandemic Read more »

UNESCO Director-General welcomes awarding Nobel Peace Prize to Muratov, Ressa

According to Audrey Azoulay, "reporters are at the frontline of a fight for shedding light where necessary, oftentimes facing a huge risk" Read more »

Expert says coronavirus pandemic forecast in Russia still pessimistic

Andrei Shkoda, chief physician of Moscow’s hospital No. 67 stressed that progress in combating the coronavirus pandemic depends on the activity of society Read more »

9 reporters, 3 companies included in foreign agents list by Russian Ministry of Justice

The mentioned journalists are current and former reporters of BBC Russia, Dozhd TV channel, Nastoyascheye Vremya, 7x7, and Radio Liberty Read more »

This week in photos: Film crew goes to ISS, D. Craig on Walk of Fame and Mandalorian in NY

Take a look at the world in pictures from a TASS photo gallery Read more »

Judges slate way the courts treated alleged benefit fraudsters: report

Photo: A committee of judges has slated the way the Dutch legal system treated parents who were accused of childcare benefit fraud in a report out on Friday. The ... Read more »

Kremlin congratulates Russian journalist Muratov on Nobel Peace Prize

"He consistently works in line with his ideals, he is committed to [them]," Dmitry Peskov noted Read more »

Police handed out 850 fines a week for cycling while using a mobile phone

Photo: Police have handed out an average of 850 fines a week in the two years since the introduction of a ban on using a mobile phone without a ... Read more »

Court to decide next week if Eindhoven terror suspects should stay in jail

Photo: Judges will decide next week if nine young men from Eindhoven should remain in custody while police continue to investigate them for possible terrorist offences. The nine were, ... Read more »

Russia records over 27,000 COVID-19 daily cases for second time in row

In relative terms, over the past day, Russia’s coronavirus incidence increased by 0.35% Read more »

‘Bring back human dimension to shrink income gap': SCP

Photo: The income gap in the Netherlands is not shrinking despite years of government measures, the government’s socio-cultural think-tank SCP said in a new report. The SCP looked at ... Read more »

Ministers to discuss evacuation plans for some 2,000 Afghans

Photo: Ministers will discuss on Friday how to evacuate hundreds of people who worked with or for Dutch aid organisations in Afghanistan. In total, some 900 people, including their ... Read more »

EMA delegation's visit to Russia could occur in December, says health ministry

Currently the details of the EMA delegation’s visit are being coordinated as a part of the certification procedure for the Sputnik V vaccine Read more »