Anti-Obamacare Law Comes Back to Bite Republicans on Abortion

anti-obamacare law comes back to bite republicans on abortion

Teton County District Court Judge Melissa Owens.

When a Wyoming judge temporarily blocked an abortion ban last week, she did so on karmically beautiful legal grounds: Republicans hated Obamacare so much that they amended the state constitution more than a decade ago to enshrine the right to make health care decisions.

Earlier this month, lawmakers in Wyoming passed a ban on abortion “at all stages of pregnancy except in cases of rape or incest that’s reported to police, or to save a woman’s life,” as well as a separate ban on medication abortion. They also threw into the text that they don’t believe abortion is health care, per the Associated Press and the Casper Star Tribune.

Abortion rights advocates sued, citing, among other things, the state’s constitutional amendment that guarantees adults the right to make their own healthcare decisions; the one that voters passed in 2012 with nearly 77 percent support. That amendment was passed in response to the Affordable Care Act, which conservatives viewed as an “encroachment” into their medical decisions. (Ohio has a similar anti-Obamacare amendment in its state constitution, as Quinn Yeargain explained in Bolts Magazine earlier this month.)

During a hearing, Teton County District Court Judge Melissa Owens pointed out the fatal flaw in the state lawmakers’ argument: “An abortion can only be performed by a licensed medical professional, so what authority does the legislature have to declare that abortion is not health care?” she asked. Owens made the same case about medication abortion: “How is a doctor actually prescribing those pills not health care?”

The state assistant attorney general’s response was that, in effect, Wyoming wants embryos and fetuses to have more rights than women and pregnant people. “I would concede that if you focus just on the pregnant woman, it becomes a little bit easier to say, well, this has to be health care,” he continued. “But if you view it from that other perspective, it clearly is not.” (Abortion is absolutely health care. More than 1,200 women died from pregnancy and childbirth in 2021, and for every pregnant and postpartum person who dies, another 70 will come close to dying.)

The plaintiffs in the case include an OB/GYN from the state’s only abortion clinic in Jackson and Wellspring Health Access, which was set to open a clinic last year in Casper before a 22-year-old woman set it on fire. That woman was arrested last week and clinic repairs are still ongoing, though they hope to open in April.

John Robinson, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, made this fetal supremacy explicit by arguing that “the legislature does not consider the woman an equal member of the human race and Wyoming.” He also noted that the medication abortion ban has exceptions for treating miscarriages and if the woman’s life is in danger, further proving that abortion is medical treatment. “How can abortion be health care in one statute prohibiting abortion and not the other?” Robinson said.

Owens’ injunction is temporary and the case will now continue with challenges to both laws heard together; it’s not certain if they’ll be struck down permanently or if the state supreme court will get involved.

It’s undeniable that part of the reason we’re even talking about abortion bans taking effect is that President Obama and Democratic lawmakers failed to codify Roe v. Wade when they were in power. But it’s a small delight that conservatives’ disdain of the first Black president and his health care plan could end up being what protects abortion access in a small number of states.

Sign up for Jezebel’s Newsletter. For the latest news, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Click here to read the full article.

News Related


Former Oregon LB announces transfer destination

Former Oregon LB announces transfer destination There has been a lot of roster turnover for the Oregon Ducks this offseason as head coach Dan Lanning continues to mix and match ... Read more »

Special about Ron DeSantis' time at Guantanamo Bay canceled with no explanation

Florida governor Ron DeSantis. The Hollywood Reporter revealed that Showtime pulled a special by Vice News that went into detail about Gov. Ron DeSantis (R-FL) and his time working as ... Read more »

Rose Zhang win in her pro debut, Hovland wins Memorial in playoff

LPGA Tour Golf JERSEY CITY, N.J. (AP) — Rose Zhang became the first player to win on the LPGA in her pro debut Sunday, capturing the Mizuho Americas Open with ... Read more »

French Open Day 8: Sloane Stephens out after battle with world No. 2 Sabalenka, doubles team DQ'd for hitting ball girl

U.S. star Sloane Stephens shakes hands with Belarus’ Aryna Sabalenka after a loss in their French Open women’s singles match. (Photo by Emmanuel DUNAND / AFP) (Photo by EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP ... Read more »

Fugees reunite for maybe the last time, as Pras faces up to 20 years in prison

One of music’s most elusive acts may have just had their final curtain call — at least for the immediate future. At the annual Roots Picnic in Philadelphia on June ... Read more »

Russia says it thwarted major Ukrainian offensive

Ukraine has been planning a counter-offensive for months Russia’s defence ministry says it has thwarted a major Ukrainian offensive and killed 250 Ukrainian troops. There has been no comment from ... Read more »

Police arrest 23 people in Hong Kong on Tiananmen crackdown anniversary

34th anniversary of the 1989 Beijing’s Tiananmen Square crackdown in Hong Kong By Jessie Pang and Ben Blanchard HONG KONG/TAIPEI (Reuters) -Hong Kong police said they detained 23 people on ... Read more »

Deputy US Transportation chief expected to be FAA’s interim leader

FILE PHOTO: Passengers wait for the flights to resume at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport in Atlanta By David Shepardson WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Deputy U.S. Transportation Secretary Polly Trottenberg is expected ... Read more »

Child Hospitalized After Near Drowning in Northbrook Backyard Pool

A young child was hospitalized after nearly drowning in a backyard pool Sunday in suburban Northbrook, according to authorities. At around 4:35 p.m., Northbrook police and firefighters were called to ... Read more »

Fighter Jets Take Off to Shadow Unresponsive Pilot, Cause Sonic Boom Across DC Area

Some viewers reported that the boom shook residences. Read more »

US, UK navies say they responded to distress call as Iran's Revolutionary Guard 'harassed' ship

This still image taken from surveillance video from a U.S. Navy Boeing P-8 Poseidon shows three Iranian Revolutionary Guard fast-attack vessels near a commercial ship in the Strait of Hormuz ... Read more »

Saudi Arabia Says It Will Cut Production to Stem a Slide in Oil Prices

Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman, the Saudi oil minister and the co-chairman of OPEC Plus. The group of major oil-producing countries known as OPEC Plus agreed on Sunday to embark on ... Read more »

Prime Ministers Get Excited About An Airbus A330 Flight

Prime Ministers Get Excited About An Airbus A330 Flight When Heads of Government and Prime Ministers travel thousands of miles to get together it would be logical to assume they ... Read more »

Restaurant chain Cava set to start IPO roadshow this week - report

Mediterranean-themed restaurant chain Cava Group (CAVA) is set to launch a roadshow for its initial public offering as early as Tuesday. Cava (CAVA) plans to sell shares for $17 to ... Read more »

Netflix: This drama is the most-watched movie worldwide only four days after its premiere

Netflix: This drama is the most-watched movie worldwide only four days after its premiere If you are looking for a new movie to watch, you can try with the new ... Read more »

NCAA champ Zhang becomes 1st LPGA Tour winner in pro debut in 72 years, wins Mizuho in playoff

Rose Zhang, center, walks to the fourth hole tee box with Anna Davis, right, during the final round of the Mizuho Americas Open golf tournament, Sunday, June 4, 2023, in ... Read more »

30+ Things Millennials Grew Up With That Would Send Gen Z Alpha Into a Coma

Ahhhh the ’90s and early oughts. What a time to be alive. Kids were raised to believe they could do anything, but were never presented with any sort of path ... Read more »

Legendary Former Notre Dame LB Manti Te'o Makes Significant Decision On His Football Career

Legendary Former Notre Dame LB Manti Te’o Makes Significant Decision On His Football Career The legendary Manti Te’o, a former Notre Dame Fighting Irish linebacker, is hanging up his cleats ... Read more »

Gamers Are Divided Over Spider-Man 2's Symbiote Suit

Gamers Are Divided Over Spider-Man 2’s Symbiote Suit Spider-Man and controversial costumes go hand-in-hand. A couple of years ago, the comics unveiled a blue, white, and orange suit to a ... Read more »

Walmart employees are inundating the company's social-media site with memes making fun of management

One million Walmart workers, or more than half the retailer’s US employee base, have signed up for Workplace. Chris Hondros/Getty Images Walmart started using Workplace, a Meta-designed social-media app, in ... Read more »

How to keep your business moving forward: Tips from experts on managing inflation

How to keep your business moving forward: Tips from experts on managing inflation NEXT AVENUE This article is reprinted by permission from A recent survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of New ... Read more »

Ukraine says it shot down 36 drones in overnight Russian attacks

Russian drone strike in Kyiv KYIV (Reuters) – Ukraine said on Thursday it had shot down all 36 Iranian-made drones launched by Russia in overnight attacks which it said probably ... Read more »

Nine (completely free) ways to save money on your energy bills

Nine (completely free) ways to save money on your energy bills You can hardly move these days for energy-saving hacks, regardless of how helpful they actually are. In the chaos ... Read more »

Apple could take its iPhone chips to the next level with huge 5G investment

null Future iPhones could get a big boost from Apple’s new investment into 5G components, which could see the tech giant make a single chip for cellular, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth ... Read more »

DJ Moore Finding Fit with Bears Easy to Make

Bears wide receiver DJ Moore might be planning a position switch. At least, he’s sort of fantasizing about one after seeing how he fits into the Halas Hall scene. It ... Read more »

Costco Is Offering $2,500 Off EVs Right Now

Prashanth Bala / Costco members shopping for an electric vehicle can save a little extra money on their purchase through July 31. Incentives of $2,500 now are available on ... Read more »

Arne Slot rules himself out of Tottenham job to stay at Feyenoord

Arne Slot will not be Tottenham’s next manager after confirming he will stay at Feyenoord. The Dutchman, who led the club to their first league title in five years this ... Read more »

Cubs Farm Report: Top Prospects Heating Up

The Chicago Cubs minor league system seems to be mirroring their Major League parent club.  Its farm system went 6-0  on Saturday, 0-4 on Sunday, and 4-0 on Tuesday. If ... Read more »

This Live Map Shows Exactly Where Sharks Are Roaming In The Ocean

This Live Map Shows Exactly Where Sharks Are Roaming In The Ocean In general, people have a lot of misunderstandings about sharks, and it makes sense. Most of us only ... Read more »

German economy minister's office receives envelope with white powder

FILE PHOTO: Plenum session of the lower house of parliament, Bundestag, in Berlin BERLIN (Reuters) -German Economy Minister Robert Habeck’s constituency office said on Thursday it had received an envelope ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự