Andrew Neil reveals reason he quit GB News – but not everyone is buying it

© BBC andrewneil1.png

Andrew Neil has revealed why he stepped down as chairman of GB News, hinting that he was unhappy with the way the channel covered news and describing how he was a “minority of one” when it came to its future direction.

The journalist and broadcaster, 72, made his first TV appearance on BBC’s Question Time since announcing his departure, blaming the move on a difference in opinion with “other senior managers and the board of GB News.”

Neil said: “I thought it wasn’t for me, I had wanted a different route – it doesn’t mean that I’m right or they’re wrong but it certainly was a difference.

“More and more differences emerged between myself and the other senior managers.”

Broadcaster @afneil says he left GB News because the direction of the channel “wasn’t the direction that I outlined” and that he wanted to take “a different route”. #bbcqt pic.twitter.com/Bun7Oh4CfR

— BBC Question Time (@bbcquestiontime) September 16, 2021

“The differences were such that the direction they were going in was not the direction that I had outlined, it was not the direction I had envisaged for the channel.

“But I was in a minority of one, so it’s doing what it’s doing and it’s up to them. Good luck to them if that’s what they want to do.”

Neil went on to address comparisons between GB News and Fox News, saying he had “always made it clear it wouldn’t be a British Fox news”.

He blasted Fox, saying the channel “deals in untruths, deal with conspiracy theories and deals in fake news.”

“That’s not my kind of journalism and I would never have set out to do that,” he added.

Sign up to our free Indy100 weekly newsletter ‘The Viral Democracy’

When host Fiona Bruce asked whether that was the reason he quit GB News, Neil made a not-so-subtle dig at his former channel, adding: “I’ll let you draw your own conclusions as to why I’m here and not with GB News.”

But not everyone was convinced Neil’s explanation on why he quit the channel with fellow Question Time panellist, former banker and writer Nels Abbey, challenging him on these points.

Abbey began by revealing two copies of a pre-launch exclusive on GB News in The Sunday Express’, with the headline: “Why Britain’s new TV news channel won’t be woke”.

Came for the posting on #bbcqt, and boy, I did not leave disappointed: pic.twitter.com/ecavgQaVq5

— William Kedjanyi (@KeejayOV3) September 16, 2021

“I posit it to you, Andrew, that you actually knew exactly what you guys were setting up,” said Abbey. “When you used the word ‘woke’ as a pejorative, I put it to you that… you exactly knew the dog you were blowing that whistle at.”

But Neil questioned in response: “So, why am I not still there? If you’re saying that what’s happened is what I wanted, why would I be here tonight and not still there?”

He added: “You don’t know me. You are assuming things of which you have no knowledge whatsoever.”

Abbey hit back, describing how GB News was a very “shoddy” channel and that, when it came out, “it was embarrassing to watch.”

Neil, who is also chairman of The Spectator, hit back: “For somebody who has never met me you seem to know a hell of a lot about me. When you do your homework maybe you’ll come back and apologise and we can have a sensible conversation.”

Question Time viewers took to Twitter to share their thoughts on the exchange, with many doubting Neil’s reason for leaving, suggesting he always knew what the channel would become.

Andrew Neil sets up anti- woke far right news channel. It’s dire, he’s embarrassed & resigns. Straight on to #bbcqt

— Mr Ethical (@nw_nicholas) September 16, 2021

It’s lovely to think that more people watched Andrew Neil attempting to disappear into the puce-coloured wallpaper on Question Time as he tried to explain away accidentally setting up a far-right wingnut echo chamber than will ever watch said far-right wingnut echo chamber. pic.twitter.com/hnvqg8GMkE

— Mark Kermode (@KermodeMovie) September 17, 2021

Andrew Neil being called out for legitimising dog whistling is beautiful. #bbcqt pic.twitter.com/7GjIohJFsw

— Eddie Burfi (@EddieBurfi) September 16, 2021

Andrew Neil currently being slapped around on Question Time. He’s not enjoying it. 😉

— Withnail Jones (@withnailjones) September 16, 2021

Neil gets his pants pulled down https://t.co/QSnfRuFXzU

— Ben Murphy (@BenM_Kent) September 17, 2021

I started a far-right news channel by mistake pic.twitter.com/BAmOZ4wcGY

— Craig (@craigare) September 16, 2021

My man came with receipts the way his face dropped at the 10 second mark💀💀💀 https://t.co/EPvgR4XjJy

— MCMXCVI (@safeeyah__x) September 17, 2021

He got out the RECEIPTS and said here’s the A4 and the A1 in case you couldn’t see it the first time 😂😂 https://t.co/eZ4yXKZrgt

— B 🇱🇨✝️ (@honeycombcookie) September 17, 2021

Many, including a former GB News colleague, praised Neil for the way he explained his departure:

A calm, considered, explanation from @afneil, countered by incoherence and the waving of a little placard, said it all.#BBCQT

— Alastair Stewart (@AlStewartOBE) September 16, 2021

Since launching back in June, GB News has been plagued with mishaps, with Neil admitting during his appearance on Question Time that it wasn’t a “startling success”. A number of staff have also left, including Guto Harri, who quit the channel following a row over him taking the knee during a debate on the racism directed towards England football players.

In response to Neil’s departure, GB News said in a statement: “Andrew is, without doubt, one of the finest journalists and interviewers in this country.

“GB News thanks him for his 12 months of leadership, wisdom and advice and we wish him well.”

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Sir David Amess: Conservative MP's murder could put people off a career in politics, warns expert

People who aspire to be an MP may be discouraged from the career following the murder of Sir David Amess, experts fear. Many may believe the role “seems frankly too ... Read more »

Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz's ‘America First' fundraising committee is running out of money

© AP Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz It was a troubled tour from start to finish. Controversial US representatives Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz, who represent Georgia and ... Read more »

David Amess killing latest: MPs discuss security arrangements following death

© Photograph: Kirsty O’Connor/PA Flowers and tributes at the scene near Belfairs Methodist Church in Eastwood Road North, Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, where Conservative MP Sir David Amess died after he was ... Read more »

Almost 350 pubs have closed down since pandemic began

Some 349 pubs have closed since the start of the pandemic with industry representatives warning of the ongoing crisis facing the sector amid doubts about October 22 seeing full restrictions ... Read more »

Chrissie Swan is ELIMINATED from Celebrity MasterChef Australia

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Chrissie Swan was eliminated on Sunday night’s episode of Celebrity MasterChef Australia after failing to impress the judges with her dish centred around ... Read more »

Professional orchestras are featuring works by Black composers while paying homage to their oft-forgotten history

Jazz artist and composer Terence Blanchard never thought his work would be performed on the Metropolitan Opera Stage. © Matthew Murphy/Kia Caldwell/Cedric Angeles/Jiyang Chen Adapted from Charles M. Blow’s memoir ... Read more »

Singer Meat Loaf's legendary career started in Michigan: The story in his own words

NOVI, MI – His powerful operatic voice is unmistakable. He’s sold more than 60 million albums worldwide over his more than 40-year career and starred in dozens of movies and ... Read more »

Names of Note: Modesto Youth Symphony has new conductor. Vaccine success in Patterson

Oct. 17—Wayland Whitney is the new conductor for one of the youth groups that are part of the Modesto Symphony Orchestra. He will lead the Symphony Orchestra for high school ... Read more »

Vendor at Florida bike fest defends selling hats with Nazi symbols on: ‘It doesn't mean what people think'

© Getty Images Bikers in Dayton Beach – Getty Images A vendor has been criticised for selling merchandise featuring Nazi symbolism at a Florida biker rally. The vendor, named Jenny, ... Read more »

Sidharth Shukla, Shehnaaz Gill's last music video gets release date.

© Provided by Khaleej Times Sidharth Shukla, Shehnaaz Gill’s last music video gets release date. Nothing beats the sheer happiness of seeing late actor Sidharth Shukla impressing the audience with ... Read more »

Wonder Woman 3 in works! Patty Jenkins confirms third Gal Gadot led film

© Provided by WION Wonder Women will be back soon! During the DC FanDome event, ‘Wonder Woman’ and ‘Wonder Woman 1984’ director Patty Jenkins took part in a conversation with ... Read more »

Taapsee Pannu says 'shooting at Rann of Kutch was my favourite schedule from Rashmi Rocket'

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Taapsee Pannu starrer ‘Rashmi Rocket‘ premiered on India’s largest homegrown OTT platform ZEE5 on 15th October and ever since the inspirational movie has ... Read more »

West Ham XI vs Everton: Confirmed lineup, team news for Premier League - Vladimir Coufal fails fitness test

© ES Composite WestHamPredictedXIAntoniov1.jpg Vladimir Coufal has failed a late fitness test so Ben Johnson starts at right-back for West Ham against Everton today. That is the only change from ... Read more »

Secret plans to cut British army exposed: U.K. force to be smaller than Germany

© GETTY british army It comes as experts warn the state of current cuts, due to be confirmed next month, have already rendered the service incapable of defending against Russian ... Read more »

I've been through the pain of miscarriage – it's time the law stopped treating it like an illness

© iStock/Getty Images ‘Being forced to take sick leave wrongly reinforces a woman’s feeling that her body has failed her’ – iStock/Getty Images I wasn’t prepared for the grief of ... Read more »

Czech opposition parties plan lower 2022 budget deficit after election win

© Reuters/BERNADETT SZABO FILE PHOTO: Leaders of political parties attend the radio debate in Prague PRAGUE (Reuters) – Czech opposition parties seeking to form a new government will aim to ... Read more »

Rainford-Brent surprised at diversity programme growth

© PA Ebony Rainford-Brent set-up the Afro-Caribbean Engagement (ACE) project in January 2020 Ebony Rainford-Brent admitted her surprise at how popular her Afro-Caribbean Engagement programme has proven and is optimistic ... Read more »

‘Very polite, very kind': Neighbours' ‘shock' as police search London flat in Sir David Amess murder probe

© Getty Images PRI205343770.jpg Forty miles from the church in Leigh-on-Sea where Tory MP Sir David Amess was fatally stabbed, police officers spent Sunday morning searching a north London flat ... Read more »

Elvis Presley's drummer Ronnie Tutt dies aged 83

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Elvis Presley’s drummer, Ronnie Tutt, has died aged 83.  The sticksman was a member of the TCB, or Taking Care of Business, Band, ... Read more »

Dapat Alam Mo! pilot telecast airs October 18

© Provided by PEP.ph Simula ngayong Lunes, October 18, ay ihahatid ng GMA Public Affairs ang ipinapangakong  parehong Serbisyong Totoo at good vibes sa mga manonood sa bagong news magazine ... Read more »

Did you know Sushmita Sen doesn't allow beau Rohman Shawl to gift her diamonds?

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The bold and beautiful Sushmita Sen has always advocated for women to buy their own diamonds and to date, she revealed, she doesn’t ... Read more »

Alex Gonzaga reveals miscarriage: "We finally closed the book of our first pregnancy."

© Provided by PEP.ph Isiniwalat ng TV host at social media influencer na si Alex Gonzaga na nakunan ang kanyang una sanang ipinagbubuntis. Ito sana ang panganay na anak nila ng asawang si ... Read more »

Sharon Cuneta slams trolls: "Pag sumagot ka sa bashers, galit sila."

© Provided by PEP.ph Nagpupuyos pa rin ang galit ni Sharon Cuneta sa mga bashers at trolls. Hindi kasi siya tinantanan ng mga ito dahil na rin sa kanyang mahabang ... Read more »

Tropang LOL perfect chemistry key to Lunch Out Loud's success

© Provided by PEP.ph Nagdarasal ang hosts ng Lunch Out Loud (LOL) on camera bago magtapos ang kanilang programa. Ipinagpapasalamat siyempre nila sa Panginoon na magdiriwang na sila ng unang ... Read more »

Ebony Rainford-Brent astonished at growth of ACE diversity programme

© PA Images England v New Zealand – Second LV= Insurance Test – Day One – Edgbaston Ebony Rainford-Brent admitted her surprise at how popular her Afro-Caribbean Engagement programme has ... Read more »

Security fears as China test potential nuke that can circle the globe

© Provided by Extra.ie Security fears are mounting after it was revealed that China tested a potential nuclear missile that can circle the globe. It is understood that China tested ... Read more »

The day I cooked timpano with Stanley Tucci

Getting your homework marked by Stanley Tucci is terrifying. Not because he is scary. On the contrary. He has impeccable, courtly manners. It’s terrifying because of what is at stake. ... Read more »

Man arrested for impersonating police officer to kidnap girl

© Provided by Extra.ie A 32-year-old man has been charged with impersonating a police officer and kidnap with intent to carry out a sex offence in connection with a 14-year-old ... Read more »

Kourtney Kardashian accused of 'acting like a brat' after she 'causes flight delay'

Kourtney Kardashian has reportedly been accused of “acting like a brat” during a “row” on a flight. The 42 year old allegedly left her fellow passengers reeling after spending a ... Read more »

Ireland 'must reopen' on October 22 as Professor Luke O'Neill labels lack of one thing 'disgraceful'

© Getty Reopening Ireland “must reopen” on October 22 according to Professor Luke O’Neill. The well-respected expert said it is time to “get on wit things” and that the Government ... Read more »

Surge in number of Covid-19 patients being treated in hospital

There has been a dramatic rise in the number of people being treated in hospital for Covid-19. The Department of Health this afternoon said another 1,380 cases of the virus have ... Read more »

Female personality, more than P70M ang kakabigin sa kandidatura?

© Provided by PEP.ph GORGY RULA Narinig ko na naman ang kasabihang pinaniniwalaan ng iba: “When money talks, people listen.” Eto pa rin kaya ang masasaksihan sa darating na eleksyon? ... Read more »

WION exclusive: Salim-Sulaiman- Art is one aspect, humanity has gone out the window in Afghanistan

© Provided by WION Straight shooters. High achievers. No-holds-barred interviewees. The Merchant brothers—popularly known as Salim-Sulaiman in Indian music industry—have no qualms about sharing space with other musicians. “(One) should ... Read more »

Demi Moore's Daughter Scout Willis Seriously Strips Down In Her New Music Video

© J.M. HAEDRICH/SIPA. Instead of conquering the acting world like her parents, Demi Moore and Bruce Willis’s daughter, Scout Willis, has decided to take on the music world. On Oct. ... Read more »

Black Poetry Day | A Louisville poet's perspective on recognizing the work of people who paved the way

Sunday is Black Poetry Day. It is the birthday of Jupiter Hammon, who was the first African American to have poetry published in the United States. This day celebrated the ... Read more »

Vatsal Sheth shares a throwback photo with Shahid Kapoor, fans go ‘aww'

© Provided by The Indian Express Vatsal Sheth on Sunday surprised his fans by sharing a throwback photo. Apart from seeing his younger self, fans were also treated to a ... Read more »

Stratford's Westfield shopping centre evacuated after fire breaks out

© Provided by City AM Westfield shopping centre in Stratford has been evacuated after a fire broke out in one of its stores. Around 60 firefighters arrived on the scene ... Read more »

Valorant: Who Is Jett's Voice Actor?

© GiveMeSport Who is the voice actor for Jett in Valorant? Jett is one of the most popular Agents in Valorant, but who exactly is the voice actor behind one ... Read more »

‘A need to go further': Labour warns government against complacency over vaccine rollout

© AFP via Getty Images coronavirus Labour has written to health secretary Sajid Javid to express concern over the current state of England’s Covid vaccination programme and call upon the ... Read more »

David Amess stabbing — latest: Priti Patel considers social media anonymity ban to stop ‘relentless' MP abuse

© UK Parliament/AFP via Getty Images david amess LIVE – Updated at 12:10 Police have been given six more days to question the man suspected of murdering Tory MP Sir ... Read more »