Analysis: Prosecutors face tough test in trial of U.S. teenage protest shooter Rittenhouse

Asia's Tech News Daily

FILE PHOTO: Kyle Rittenhouse listens to defense attorney

By Nathan Layne

(Reuters) – One of those fatally shot by Kyle Rittenhouse threw a plastic shopping bag containing socks and a deodorant stick at him before appearing to try and grab his rifle. Another struck the teenager with a skateboard. The third person shot was brandishing a handgun when Rittenhouse fired his final round.

Rittenhouse, 18, has been charged with killing two men and wounding a third during demonstrations in Kenosha, Wisconsin, on Aug. 25, 2020. The protests were sparked by the shooting of a Black man, Jacob Blake, by a white police officer a few days earlier. Blake was left paralyzed from the waist down.

As Rittenhouse prepares for trial next week, the chaotic circumstances surrounding the shootings present a formidable challenge for prosecutors, who will seek to portray the teenager as a vigilante killer, legal experts said.

Rittenhouse, who was 17 at the time of the shootings, has pleaded not guilty and is considering taking the stand to offer a firsthand account of his self-defense claims, two people familiar with the matter said.

“If you asked me would I rather be the prosecutor or the defense attorney right now, I would rather be the defense attorney,” said Tom Grieve, a criminal defense lawyer in Milwaukee and former prosecutor. Absent surprise evidence emerging at trial, he added, “This is a strong case for the defense.”

The trial, which kicks off on Monday with jury selection, is arguably the highest-profile test of a civilian's right to self-defense since George Zimmerman was acquitted in the fatal shooting of Trayvon Martin, an unarmed Black teenager, in 2013.

The judge overseeing the trial has vowed to prevent it from becoming political, even as debates over race, guns and policing have raged online in connection with the case.

Rittenhouse, who is white, has emerged as a cause celebre for many conservatives in the perennial battle over gun rights in the United States. He was also viewed by some on the right as a timely counterpoint to the sometimes violent protests against police brutality that rocked large U.S. cities last year. Days after the shootings then-President Donald Trump suggested Rittenhouse had acted in self-defense.

Under Wisconsin law, a person can only use deadly force if he or she “reasonably believes” it necessary to prevent someone from killing or causing great bodily harm to them.

Deciding what is reasonable will be up to a jury of 12 people from Kenosha County, a mix of urban, suburban and rural areas west of Lake Michigan that Trump narrowly won last year.

How sympathetic the jury is to Rittenhouse may shake out along partisan lines, with a right-leaning juror more likely to believe he had a right to defend himself and a more liberal juror more apt to fault him for going out that night armed, said Marquette University Law School Professor Michael O'Hear.

DEFENSE

With ample bystander and surveillance video available as evidence, there is little dispute over what transpired and the two sides are mainly fighting over how to interpret the facts.

Rittenhouse, a resident of nearby Antioch, Illinois, is facing seven charges, including homicide in the fatal shootings of Joseph Rosenbaum, 36, and Anthony Huber, 26, and attempted homicide for wounding Gaige Grosskreutz, 27.

Prosecutors are expected to argue that Rittenhouse, who was armed with a military-style semi-automatic rifle and says he was in Kenosha to help protect a business, was looking for violent conflict.

The defense will likely try and portray the men he shot as bad actors involved in lawless behavior that night, giving him reason to fear for his safety.

But prosecutors will likely say Rittenhouse reacted with disproportionate force, regardless of whether the three men were involved in any wrongdoing prior to their encounters with him.

“Their behavior that night has nothing to do with this case, unless it was witnessed by the defendant,” Kenosha County Assistant District Attorney Thomas Binger said in a hearing this week. “His state of mind is the most important thing.”

Video shows Rosenbaum charging at Rittenhouse when he was gunned down. A reporter named Richard McGinnis told police that Rosenbaum, who threw a plastic bag at the defendant but was unarmed, tried to grab the barrel of Rittenhouse's rifle, according to a criminal complaint filed last year. McGinnis is expected to testify at trial.

Rosenbaum's actions could have caused Rittenhouse to fear his own weapon would be used against him, said Benjamin Van Severen, a defense attorney in Milwaukee. He said law enforcement officers are regularly exonerated for shootings when someone has tried to seize their firearm.

Van Severen said proving that Rosenbaum's death was unlawful was central to the prosecution's entire case given that it appears to have prompted a crowd to start pursuing Rittenhouse, setting the stage for the other shootings.

Prosecutors have said they have FBI surveillance video showing that Rittenhouse followed and confronted Rosenbaum, evidence they could use to try to prove he was the aggressor.

As Rittenhouse flees the scene of the first shooting, protesters can be heard yelling things like “Get his ass!”, according to the complaint. Rittenhouse then stumbles and falls to the ground and shoots Huber, a protester who was swinging a skateboard at him, according to video evidence and the complaint.

Grosskreutz, who was holding a pistol, took a step back and put his hands in the air before then moving toward Rittenhouse, who opened fire again, shooting him in the arm.

“It's not a slam dunk,” said Keith Findley, a professor at the University of Wisconsin Law School, referring to the prosecution's case. “I think they are going to have some challenges.”

(Reporting by Nathan Layne in Wilton, Connecticut, editing by Ross Colvin and Sonya Hepinstall)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Cambria County Prison sees another jump in COVID cases

Dec. 8—EBENSBURG, Pa. — Cases of COVID-19 in the Cambria County Prison continue to be on the rise. First Deputy Warden Bill Patterson told the prison board Wednesday that eight ... Read more »

South Korea hospitals under intense pressure amid record 7,175 Covid cases in a day

Photograph: Jeon Heon-Kyun/EPA South Korea has reported a record daily total of 7,175 new Covid cases as officials urged people to complete their vaccinations. The prime minister, Kim Boo-kyum, warned ... Read more »

Lauren Boebert's Gun Photo Is Doing Exactly What She Intended

© Alex Wong/Getty As families around the country prepare to send out Christmas cards with letters and photos commemorating the year gone by, many elected officials do the same. Representative ... Read more »

New Mexico lawmakers want $100M for 'alternative broadband'

© Provided by Associated Press Disability advocates Ellen Pinnes and Jim Jackson look at proposed redistricting maps posted on a wall inside the state Capitol on Wednesday, Dec. 8, 2021, ... Read more »

Pune completes 100% first dose vaccination of target population

© Provided by The Indian Express The Pune administration has reached the target of administering the first dose of the vaccine against Covid-19 to 100 per cent of the eligible ... Read more »

After Ayodhya verdict, took bench for dinner, wine, picked tab: ex-CJI Ranjan Gogoi

© Provided by The Indian Express AFTER DELIVERING a unanimous verdict in the Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid case on November 9, 2019, the then Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi took ... Read more »

High Court stays DJB defamation case proceedings

© Provided by Hindustan Times Delhi high court (HT Archive) The Delhi high court on Wednesday put on hold the trial court proceedings in a criminal defamation complaint filed by ... Read more »

Centre agrees to withdraw cases, farm stir set to be called off today

© Provided by The Indian Express THE SAMYUKTA Kisan Morcha (SKM) will meet Thursday noon at the Singhu border of Delhi to take a “formal decision” to lift the year-long ... Read more »

Aaj Ka Panchang, December 9, 2021: Check Out Tithi, Shubh Muhurat, Rahu Kaal and Other Details for Thursday

© Provided by News18 Aaj Ka Panchang, December 9, 2021: Check Out Tithi, Shubh Muhurat, Rahu Kaal and Other Details for Thursday Aaj Ka Panchang, December 9, 2021: According to the ... Read more »

CDS Bipin Rawat was scripting roadmap for reforms and upgrade, his boots hard to fill

© Provided by The Indian Express Bipin Rawat was nearly two years into his term as India’s first Chief of Defence Staff and presiding over the most significant transformation of ... Read more »

Nagaland RS member demands withdrawal of AFSPA in House

© Provided by The Indian Express Nagaland People’s Front leader K G Kenye on Wednesday raised a demand in Rajya Sabha for withdrawal of the controversial Armed Forces (Special Powers) ... Read more »

SII executive director Dr Suresh Jadhav dies at 72

© Provided by The Indian Express Dr Suresh Jadhav, one of the executive directors of Serum Institute of India, passed away late Tuesday night at Sahyadri Hospital due to renal ... Read more »

Burning Newscorp Christmas tree a perfectly grim last taste of De Blasio's NYC

It sure feels like one last taste of #DeBlasiosNYC to us: A vagrant set our Christmas tree ablaze late Tuesday night. Craig Tamanaha, a man with a long rap sheet ... Read more »

Charlie Savage sends message to Ralf Rangnick after making Manchester United debut vs Young Boys

Manchester United youngster Charlie Savage has thanked the club’s academy staff and interim manager Ralf Rangnick after making his senior debut for the club against Young Boys on Wednesday evening. ... Read more »

The defense has rested in Elizabeth Holmes' fraud trial, and closing arguments will begin next week

© Provided by Business Insider Elizabeth Holmes. Nick Otto/AFP via Getty Images The defense in Elizabeth Holmes’ fraud trial rested Wednesday after she testified for 7 days. The prosecution offered ... Read more »

A guide to the cast of the ‘SATC' reboot ‘And Just Like That'

Karen Pittman as Dr. Nya Wallace and Cynthia Nixon as Miranda in “And Just Like That.” Photograph by Craig Blankenhorn And just like that, Carrie Bradshaw is back. The much-hyped ... Read more »

Sindiket edar dadah guna kurier tumpas, polis rampas syabu RM10.2 juta

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Pengarah Jabatan Siasatan Jenayah Narkotik Bukit Aman, Razarudin Husain (dua dari kiri) menunjukkan barang rampasan pada sidang media di Ibu Pejabat Polis Kontinjen Kuala ... Read more »

Perak sambut baik pelaksanaan had umur belia

© Provided by Sinar Harian IPOH – Kerajaan negeri Perak mengalu-alukan pelaksanaan Akta 668 melibatkan penurunan had umur belia kepada 30 tahun yang akan dikuatkuasakan mulai tahun hadapan. Exco Belia, ... Read more »

Rundingan sejak 2016, pemilik tanah cukup masa buat keputusan

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA LUMPUR – Proses rundingan dan tawaran terhadap pemilik tanah serta penduduk Flat Perbadanan Kemajuan Negeri Selangor (PKNS) Sungai Baru, Kampong Bharu di sini yang ... Read more »

Nick Cannon thanks fans for support after his son's death

Nick Cannon has thanked fans for their support following the death of his son. © Bang Showbiz Nick Cannon has thanked fans for their support The 41-year-old star announced the ... Read more »

US announces funds to support independent journalism and reporters targeted for their work

The US will provide new funding to protect reporters targeted because of their work and support independent international journalism, Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Wednesday at the opening of ... Read more »

House to advance legislation to combat Islamophobia as pressure mounts to punish Boebert for anti-Muslim comments

The House is planning to advance Democratic Rep. Ilhan Omar’s legislation to create a special envoy to combat Islamophobia on Thursday, marking the first step members are taking since Republican ... Read more »

How to get the Level Checker mount in Final Fantasy XIV

© Provided by GamePur The Level Checker mount is one of the more difficult ones you can try unlocking in Final Fantasy XIV. You’ll need to complete a handful of ... Read more »

How to prevent Armor Locker cosmetic unlock issues in Halo Infinite's campaign

© Provided by GamePur Halo Infinite’s campaign has quite a few Armor Lockers scattered around its open world. Stored in these lockers are cosmetics that you can apply to your ... Read more »

Florida Mayhem signs main support Anamo

© Provided by Dot Esports The Florida Mayhem has been steadily building an international roster full of talented rookies throughout the Overwatch League offseason. One league veteran will be counted ... Read more »

Dramatic Video Shows Car In River 50 Yards From Brink Of Niagara Falls

Sadly, a woman died in the accident. Tragic news today from one of the world’s most popular tourist destinations. Shortly before noon local time at Niagara Falls, New York, reports ... Read more »

Fast-cooking potato on sale in time for Christmas roasts cooks 25% quicker

A FAST-cooking potato that saves on roasting time at Christmas has gone on sale. The Nemo — named after the clownfish from Pixar film Finding Nemo due to its stripy ... Read more »

Student faces year-long suspension after bringing unloaded gun to Cary High School

An unloaded gun was recovered from a student at Cary High School on Wednesday during a search, Wake County Public Schools said. The gun was found during an “unrelated search” ... Read more »

Southern Theatre ideal for setting up joint services command: General Rawat as Army Commander in 2016

© Provided by The Indian Express The Southern Command, headquartered in Pune, would be an ideal theatre where a joint services command could be set up, General Bipin Rawat had ... Read more »

Minister accused of harassment: Will take action if complaint filed, says Goa CM Sawant

© Provided by The Indian Express FOLLOWING THE Congress’s allegations that a minister in his cabinet was involved in a “sex scandal”, Goa Chief Minister Pramod Sawant on Wednesday said ... Read more »

Ambani, Mittal & Birla talk tele collaboration

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: After the bitter acrimony and regulatory and legal fights, it was time to talk collaboration and joint efforts by Reliance’s Mukesh ... Read more »

Orang asli cedera diserang binatang buas

© Provided by Sinar Harian SUNGAI SIPUT – Seorang lelaki orang asli cedera diserang binatang buas dipercayai beruang dalam kejadian di Kampung Kelatap, Pos Perwor di sini pada Rabu. Dalam ... Read more »

35 kenderaan guna lampu HID disaman

© Provided by Sinar Harian SEREMBAN – Seramai 35 individu dikenakan saman oleh Jabatan Pengangkutan Jalan (JPJ) Negeri Sembilan kerana menggunakan lampu High Intensity Discharged (HID) pada kenderaan. Pengarah JPJ ... Read more »

Abang Johari disappointed with Ali's decision to contest as independent

© Provided by New Straits Times KUCHING: Gabungan Parti Sarawak (GPS) is disappointed with the move by Datuk Ali Biju to contest as an independent candidate in the state election. ... Read more »

Nick Cannon says late son Zen's mum Alyssa Scott is 'strongest woman ever'

Nick Cannon has branded the mother of his youngest child Alyssa Scott, 28, the “strongest woman ever” following the tragic death of their son, Zen. Nick, 41, announced the devastating ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's ramshackle government has been holed beneath water line & run aground by a skipper who seems absent

I WATCHED Downing Street’s wine-and-cheese “press conference” then switched to C5’s brilliant film about the sinking of Europe’s biggest cruise liner, the Costa Concordia. It was hard to tell where ... Read more »

Don't let Bill de Blasio silence parents critical of city education

Mayor de Blasio is going to allow the Department of Education to remove elected parents from Community Education Councils if they criticize schools. NYC Mayor’s Office On his way out ... Read more »

Miss airport check-ins? Head on over to an MRT station security screening for a similar experience

© The Independent Singapore Singapore — It’s been almost two years since many former and wannabe’ travellers last transited an airport. But if you’re missing the pre-flight delights of placing ... Read more »

Amad makes apology for miss in Manchester United's draw with Young Boys

Manchester United winger Amad has apologised to supporters after he fluffed his lines on a golden opportunity for the team in the draw with Young Boys. United brought their Champions ... Read more »

The total amount of waste in Norway decreased by 5% in 2020

The total amount of waste in Norway amounted to 11.6 million tonnes in 2020, down 5% compared with the previous year, figures from Statistics Norway (SSB) show. The main reason ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic