Analysis: KKR's Telecom Italia approach may call time on Italy discount

Analysis: KKR's Telecom Italia approach may call time on Italy discount
© Reuters/YARA NARDI FILE PHOTO: The Tim logo is seen at its headquarters

By Joice Alves

LONDON (Reuters) – A $12 billion takeover proposal for Telecom Italia by private equity giant KKR has highlighted an ‘Italian discount’, which a surge in investor interest and a European fund aimed at supporting its struggling economy could help narrow.

At a 36% discount to world stocks, based on 12-month forward earnings, Italian equities trade at the widest discount in nine years and at more than twice their own 20-year average of 16%.

Meanwhile, the broader euro zone equity market trades at a 13.8% discount to world indices and only 1.2 times the discount to its own 20-year average.

Explanations for this disparity include Italy’s index composition, which is heavy in “old economy” energy and banking stocks with nearly two-thirds of Italian blue chips made up of financial firms, utilities, telecom, oil and gas companies, while only around 20% of the 50 largest companies in the euro zone operate in those sectors.

Analysis: KKR's Telecom Italia approach may call time on Italy discount
© Reuters/Brendan McDermid FILE PHOTO: Trading information for KKR & Co is displayed on a screen on the floor of the NYSE in New York

But above all, two decades of near-zero economic growth, an ageing population and Italy’s high debt levels have dragged down equity prices in the country.

“Italian equity markets are cheap in a global context and this has given us the opportunity to own some great companies that would trade on much higher valuations if they were to be listed in other countries like the U.S.,” said James Matthews, European equities fund manager at Invesco, citing small appliances maker De’ Longhi as an example.

Although De’ Longhi shares rose from 11 euros in March 2020 to a price of 29 euros now, after touching record high of 40 euros in September 2021, their price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of 13.5 times is lower than French competitor Seb’s 15.6 and below the average of 17 for the STOXX 600.


In the case of Telecom Italia, even after a 50% share price jump following KKR’s proposal it remains among the cheapest in its sector with the offer implying an enterprise value below 6 times core earnings against a sector average of 7 times, according to BofA Global Research.

But those who are more sceptical on Italian equities say that they can find better returns elsewhere.

“There are some good companies in Italy but on a global basis the same types of businesses in other parts of the world are more profitable and can generate higher returns on capital,” Peter Rutter, head of equities at Royal London Asset Management, said.

Even though Telecom Italia has a higher operating profit margin than rivals Telefonica and BT Group, it has a lower return on equity, according to Refinitiv data.

Meanwhile, investors have started to take a shine to Italy’s mid-cap segment with the FTSE Italia Star index, an index of 75 small and mid-sized companies, soaring 165% since the start of the pandemic to a record high in November.

Alberto Chiandetti, a portfolio manager at Fidelity International has increased allocations to Italy, arguing such a hefty price discount is not justified for many companies as Italy stands to be the biggest beneficiary of the European Union’s 750 billion euro recovery fund.

An iShares MSCI Italy ETF has around 18.7 million shares outstanding, up almost 180% from November last year, far outstripping inflows into an MSCI euro zone ETF, while UBS is advising higher allocations to Italy and Amundi said it is selectively repositioning in Milan-listed stocks.

As Italy plans to use some of the EU cash to upgrade its internet infrastructure, technology enabling companies have been obvious beneficiaries with shares of technology service company Reply climbing 300% since the beginning of the pandemic to reach a market capitalisation of 6.3 billion euros.

“If you think about where the discount is today, I don’t think it is in small caps anymore. The discount today is more in mid, big caps or in single stock names that are still maybe undiscovered,” Chiandetti said.

Italian discount

(Reporting by Joice Alves; Additional reporting by Danilo Masoni; Editing by Saikat Chatterjee and Alexander Smith)

News Related


How to remove tea and coffee stains from mugs - the one easy step

© Getty How to remove stains from mugs: Brits are known for their love of tea, but our obsession with the humble cuppa has its downsides. Are all your mugs ... Read more »

After going to Hull and back, takeover gives Tigers hope

The mood at Hull City suddenly feels transformed after the takeover of Acun Ilicali, which might not be great news for manager Grant McCann.   Never mind just a day ... Read more »

Former Malaysian PM Mahathir Mohamad admitted to hospital

© Reuters/HUSSAIN HASNOOR A woman walks past the logo of the National Heart Institute in Kuala Lumpur KUALA LUMPUR (Reuters) – Malaysia’s former prime minister Mahathir Mohamad has been admitted ... Read more »

Sinn Fein still on course to be Northern Ireland's largest party, poll suggests

Sinn Fein remains on course to emerge from Northern Ireland’s next Assembly election as the largest party, according to a new poll. On 25%, the republican party is eight points ... Read more »

Man City XI vs Southampton: Predicted lineup, team news, injury and Covid latest for Premier League today

© ES Composite ManCityPredictedXIv2.jpg Manchester City will remain without Riyad Mahrez for this afternoon’s Premier League clash with Southampton, despite Algeria’s early exit from the Africa Cup of Nations. Algeria ... Read more »

Breakdown services must ‘do better', says Labour MP after claims the AA no longer prioritises lone women

Labour MP Rosie Duffield has called on breakdown services to “do better” after claims one of them no longer prioritises lone women. The MP for Canterbury said women should be ... Read more »

The story of Jon Newby and his one Premier League game for Liverpool

Jon Newby watched Liverpool at Anfield as a child and still does it today as an adult. In between, he achieved the dream of every fan – to grace the hallowed turf ... Read more »

Dan Evans defeat ends British interest in singles at Australian Open

British interest in singles ended in disappointing fashion at the Australian Open with a straight-sets defeat for Dan Evans against ninth seed Felix Auger-Aliassime in the third round. Evans had ... Read more »

CBI seems to be protecting accused in judge murder case, says Jharkhand HC

Jharkhand High Court has slammed the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) for its “laxity” in probing the murder of Dhanbad judge Uttam Anand, and observed that it seems that the ... Read more »

From today, staying at isolation facility not mandatory for foreign arrivals testing Covid positive

Travellers from any country arriving in India, who test Covid positive, will not mandatorily be managed at an isolation facility from Saturday, but have to quarantine themselves at home according ... Read more »

'Aspirational districts eliminating barriers, becoming accelerators of country's progress': PM Modi

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: Emphasizing that district administration have an important role in good governance, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday that “aspirational ... Read more »

Daniil Medvedev news: Russian rolls on and teases crowd about ‘ups and downs' of their relationship

© PA Images Daniil Medvedev post-match interview Daniil Medvedev booked his place in the fourth round of the Australian Open with a professional win over Botic van de Zandschulp before ... Read more »

‘We love u Tun M', Peja mohon doa rakyat untuk Dr M

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Dr Mahathir Mohamad sebelum ini dimasukkan ke IJN pada 7 Jan dan dibenarkan keluar pada 13 Jan lalu. PETALING JAYA: Menteri Belia dan Sukan ... Read more »

US bans 44 passenger flights to China in a tit for tat move

© Provided by Jagran English Washington/Beijing | Jagran World Desk: In a rather tit for tat counter move by the United States, Washington on Friday announced that it was suspending ... Read more »

Klopp's Kelleher love continues as he gives Corkman huge boost ahead of cup final

Liverpool big cheese Jurgen Klopp has confirmed that he will start Caoimhin Kelleher in next month’s Carabao Cup final against Chelsea. The 23-year-old played in the semi-final second-leg win over ... Read more »

10 most intriguing storylines ahead of the GAA football league return

© Inpho We have a full slate of league games next weekend. THE ALLIANZ FOOTBALL League returns next weekend and we’re set for our first full, uninterrupted season since 2019. ... Read more »

How To Sign In to YouTube On Your Smart TV Using a Smartphone

© Provided by News18 How To Sign In to YouTube On Your Smart TV Using a Smartphone YouTube is the hub of all the latest trends around us and gives ... Read more »

Photography Hacks That Will Boost Your Skill If You Are A Beginner

Photography is a hobby that interests most of us out there. We all have a thing for fancy, good-looking pictures. When it comes to posting pictures and videos on social ... Read more »

‘More people will die': fears for clinically vulnerable as England axes plan B

“We must learn to live with Covid in the same way we have to live with flu,” Sajid Javid told the nation this week. For most people, the parallel with ... Read more »

Hiring good talent top priority for startups in 2022: InnoVen study

© Provided by Business Today Hiring good talent top priority for startups in 2022: InnoVen study Hiring good talent is the top challenge for startup founders in India and managing ... Read more »

UPSC Recruitment 2022: Apply for Senior Administrative Officer, Assistant Professor and other posts on, details here

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) has invited applications from eligible candidates for Senior Administrative Officer and other posts. The commission is looking to ... Read more »

Airport fashion: Deepika Padukone to Katrina Kaif, celebs show how to keep it stylish

It’s always exciting to visit new places. And, like our favourite B-town celebrities, who give us fashion inspiration even while on the run, one should always do it with style. ... Read more »

Where Malgudi meets reality: New book brings fascinating quarantine stories from Kerala

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: A new book titled ‘Onam in a Nightie – Stories from a Kerala Quarantine’ gives a glimpse of the true character of Kerala ... Read more »

Modi government trying to destroy people's rights from beginning: Rahul Gandhi

© Provided by The Financial Express Rahul Gandhi asked people whether they can imagine India without fundamental and public rights? Congress leader Rahul Gandhi today hit out at the Modi ... Read more »

Weekly Tarot (24 to 30 January): See what the upcoming week has in store for Aries, Leo, Taurus

We get to see the silver linings, the life lessons and the insights from our experiences, but what if you could skip ahead and see that for yourself now for the ... Read more »

Product design meets brand strategy

© Provided by The Financial Express Addiction to paid marketing can get you instant results, but at the cost of profitability or LTV By Saksham Mendiratta Product Design comes in ... Read more »

Akhilesh Yadav to Fight UP Polls for the First Time, Will Contest from Stronghold Karhal

© Provided by News18 Akhilesh Yadav to Fight UP Polls for the First Time, Will Contest from Stronghold Karhal Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav will contest the Uttar Pradesh Assembly ... Read more »

Not completing Grade 12 is not end of road - Educational psychologist

© Provided by CapeTalk The class of 2021 got their Matric results on Friday with the pass rate of 76.4% for public schools, and while many are celebrating, others aren’t. ... Read more »

Here's How Much It Costs to Study at Far Eastern University

© Provided by Candy History of the Far Eastern University Dr. Nicanor Reyes founded the Far Eastern University in 1928, through the help of educators from the University of the ... Read more »

Arnold Clavio prays for bashers amid COVID-19 ordeal

© Provided by Nagpapagaling na ngayon si Arnold Clavio matapos siyang tamaan ng COVID-19 virus. Nag-post ang GMA News anchor noong January 9, 2022, para ipaalam na isa siya ... Read more »

GMA-7 may sagot sa "biased against Marcoses" remark ng Bongbong Marcos camp kay Jessica Soho

© Provided by JERRY OLEA Trending sa Twitter ang “Jessica Soho” #MarcosDuwag” matapos mapabalitang tumanggi si Bongbong Marcos (BBM) na magpainterbyu para sa TV special na The Jessica Soho ... Read more »

Your Minimalist Dream Wardrobe Awaits: COS Is Finally Available Online

© Provided by PHOTO BY COS Website ILLUSTRATION War Espejo © Provided by PHOTO BY COS Website ILLUSTRATION War Espejo ( While London-based fashion house COS finally opened its first ... Read more »

Disha Patani can`t stop grooving to modern rendition of ‘Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein

© Provided by Mid-Day Netflix’s ‘Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein’ is winning hearts and topping the charts on everyone’s watch list. Just like the popular 90s thrillers it pays homage to, ... Read more »

Tom Cruise Mission Impossible 7 And 8 Have Been Pushed Back, Here Are The New Release Date

© Provided by Lehren Tom Cruise Mission Impossible 7 And 8 Have Been Pushed Back The release dates for Mission: Impossible 7 and 8 have been pushed back to 2023 ... Read more »

Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin, 22 January 2022, Written Update: Virat leaves the house

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Virat warns Karishma to not speak ill about Shruti. Sonali tells him to lower his voice and Devi tells him that he’s no ... Read more »

BTS: Jimmy Kimmel compares the K-pop band to Covid-19; ARMY is SUPER Upset – View Tweets

© Provided by BTS is undoubtedly one of the most famous K-pop bands. It has seven boys, Jin, Suga, J-Hope, RM, Jimin, V, and Jungkook. The fans of the ... Read more »

'Jeet Ki Zid' role helped Amit Sadh explore himself

© IANS Amit Sadh . Mumbai, Jan 22 (IANS) Amit Sadh’s show ‘Jeet Ki Zid’, where he essayed the role of a former Indian Army special forces officer Major Deependra ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas' baby girl arrived 12 weeks before the due date; Report

© Provided by Pinkvilla Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas have all the reasons to grin from ear to ear. After all, the power couple has recently embraced parenthood and have ... Read more »

Throwback: Priyanka Chopra 'always wanted to be a mother'. Old interview

Priyanka Chopra always wanted to be a mom. Here’s proof! Global power couple Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas have embraced parenthood and fans are super excited for the lovely couple. ... Read more »

Hunarbaaz: Karan Johar turns matchmaker for Parineeti Chopra, says 'Tumhara bhi isi saal ho jayega pakka'

© Provided by Pinkvilla The one-of-a-kind reality show Hunarbaaz Desh Ki Shaan will be launched this weekend. The show will provide a platform for the prodigies from all over the ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic