Analysis-Europe faces sceptical globe with carbon border levy

Analysis-Europe faces sceptical globe with carbon border levy

By Philip Blenkinsop

BRUSSELS – The European Union faces an uphill battle to convince trading partners that the world’s first levy on carbon imports is fair, workable and a necessary part of the bloc’s attempted green revolution as opposed to a protectionist tool.

The EU is due on July 14 to unveil a package of legislation to cut net greenhouse gas emissions by 55% by 2030 from 1990 levels.

As part of the plan, it will outline what it terms a carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM), designed to cut emissions by creating financial incentives for greener production and by discouraging “carbon leakage,” as the transfer of operations to countries with less onerous emission restrictions is known.

The bloc will want to avoid the type of fallout it incurred after a separate environmental move in 2018, when it excluded palm oil from its list of sustainable biofuels and sparked legal challenges from Indonesia and Malaysia at the World Trade Organization.

Before that, an EU attempt to charge foreign airlines for carbon emitted on flights in and out of Europe threatened a trade war after the U.S. aviation industry mustered fierce political opposition and China said it would withhold aircraft orders. The European Union was forced to announce in 2012 it would suspend the law.

Bernd Lange, chair of the European Parliament’s trade committee, said the CBAM could prove the source of trade disputes – notably with the United States, if Brussels does not find an agreement with Washington.

“We have to look to an understanding so that this CBAM will not land in a WTO case. This is a big task for the next months,” he told a webinar.

The Commission has said its plan will be WTO-compatible and fair, requiring importers of goods such as steel to buy emissions certificates at the same price as domestic producers.

However, a demand by EU producers that they continue to benefit from free EU carbon market certificates could create problems if imports are not afforded a similar advantage.

A draft of the July 14 proposals shows free permits would end, but manufacturing sectors are expected to lobby hard to retain them.

Benchmark prices on the EU’s emissions trading system (ETS), the largest carbon market in the world, have this month hit records above 58 euros a tonne, partly in response to expectations of the border levy.

While the EU says it and Washington have agreed to discuss the plan, other countries have signalled concerns. Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison calls any carbon tariffs “trade protectionism by another name”. Russia has said it may break trade rules.

Andre Sapir, a senior fellow at Brussels-based think tank Bruegel who has testified before parliament on the CBAM, says the European Union needs to look beyond mere legality.

“There’s the issue of fairness too. Advanced countries have been long-term emitters. Deforestation, advanced countries did it too,” he said.

BURDEN OF PROOF

The WTO grants preferential treatment to developing countries, as does the EU with arrangements for the poorest states. If they do not extend to the CBAM, charges could hit $16 billion of developing country exports to the EU, the Centre for European Reform think tank says.

Even a WTO-compatible system with allowances for emerging countries could disrupt trade if it adds an unwieldy administrative burden.

Companies in countries, such as South Korea, with existing emissions trading schemes might smoothly adapt to the CBAM. Elsewhere, exporters would need to provide extensive data on their direct carbon emissions and those of their energy sources and then convince the European Commission the data is reliable.

Otherwise, they could face an unfavourable default calculation.

“The burden of proof is on the other side,” said Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, director of trade think tank ECIPE. “CBAM may be a great gambit for trade negotiations, but will it actually incentivise cutting CO2 emissions?”

The system’s complexity has persuaded the European Commission, initially at least, to concentrate on a few basic materials – iron and steel, aluminium, cement, electricity and fertilisers, which represent about 5% of EU goods imports.

However, there may be ways for exporting countries to circumvent these. Thijs Vandenbussche, climate policy analyst at think tank the European Policy Centre, points to possible substitutes, such as fuel ash or blast furnace slag, for cement, which may not be subject to carbon charges.

Downstream, the CBAM could persuade manufacturers of end-use products to switch components. In some cases, these might be greener, in others just not subject to extra emission costs despite being as or more polluting. In the latter case, global emissions would not fall.

If the EU wants its experiment to be a success, it will need partners. A transatlantic alliance could drive widespread acceptance. However, comments from U.S. climate envoy John Kerry that a carbon border tax should only be a “last resort” suggest such an alliance is some way off.

Just over 50 WTO members have begun talks in the last year on climate issues such as carbon border adjustments, but these are at an early stage. One function of the CBAM is to have made the debate more pressing.

“International carbon pricing is one of the slowest items to advance,” Vandenbussche said. “Without this proposal, there would just be more debate. This could lead to negotiations and perhaps adjustments based on the international reaction.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

SCO nations to set up mechanism of discussing industrial issues

SCO nations noted the necessity to boost cooperation on the issues of high technologies, the creation of industrial parks, and a trade-industrial cluster Read more »

GST Council Meet| GST exemption on Covid essential medicine extended till December

Compulsory licensing in emergency situations lets drugmakers manufacture the medicines without permission from the patent holder. (Remdesivir Image: Reuters) The GST Council has extended the GST rate cuts on Covid ... Read more »

What's behind the energy crunch - and why it's hurting UK industry

Gas prices are running at about £162 per therm - when for most of the past decade they have been around £40 therm - and the increase has been astonishingly fast. Read more »

‘It was impossible to make a living from clothes'

in ‘When my daughter (28) was one year old, I started making children’s clothes. You try something, sometimes things go wrong, but as I got better at it, I switched ... Read more »

Nazara Technologies' Nodwin Gaming acquires OML Entertainment's IP and gaming business

NODWIN Gaming, an esports company and an independent subsidiary of Nazara Technologies Limited has acquired the gaming and adjacent IP (intellectual property) business of OML Entertainment, a media and entertainment ... Read more »

Petrol, diesel prices may rise as international oil rates surge

Representative image A surge in international oil prices may translate into an increase in the retail selling price of petrol and diesel in India as oil companies face extreme margin ... Read more »

The working student: from tapping beers to vaccinating – and never going back

‘I would rather not have had it necessary, but working at the GGD was really a godsend for me,’ says 25-year-old Marjolein. Her side job at a museum in Utrecht ... Read more »

GST Council refers Swiggy, Zomato GST issue to GoM

The GST Council on September 17 referred the issue pertaining to the tax to be levied on online food aggregators such as Swiggy and Zomato  to the group of ministers, said West Bengal Minister ... Read more »

Spain announces small rise in minimum wage, by €15 to €965

The Spanish government, together with the CCOO and UGT trade unions, have agreed to increase the minimum wage from €950 to €965 gross per month, and which will be backdated ... Read more »

Nong Khai plans for rail link with China New depot taking shape to handle increased trade once Laos-China line opens in December

Thailand hopes a rail link with China will offer faster delivery of goods to southern Chinese provinces. (Bangkok Post photo) The Rail Transport Department has unveiled a plan to develop ... Read more »

Will import duty cut on edible oils offer the much-needed relief to consumers?

The government has yet again slashed import duty on edible oils. Earlier this week, a notification from the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs informed that the base import ... Read more »

Looking to gain from sustainability efforts? Sign a green property lease

positive-environmental-footprint-04_84156053 As we move towards achieving carbon neutrality for a more sustainable world, green leases seem to be the future of real estate. But what exactly is a green lease? ... Read more »

Biocon, SII deal to extend to exploring partnership in biologics, mRNA vaccines

Representative picture: AFP Biocon Biologics and Serum Institute of India (SII) on September 17 said their strategic alliance goes beyond the fill-finish, or filling up of vials and packaging them ... Read more »

Developments in Afghanistan could lead to an uncontrolled flow of drugs, illegal weapons and human trafficking: PM Modi

PM Modi Prime Minister Narendra Modi on September 17 said the recent developments in Afghanistan will have the greatest impact on neighbouring countries like India and continuing instability in that ... Read more »

Four Years of GST: Charting the Road Ahead for the Real Estate Sector

The Central government’s decision to introduce Goods and Services Tax (GST) in 2017 was a game changer for not just the real estate sector but the entire Indian economy. By ... Read more »

‘I don't like numbers, so we complement each other well'

Kirsten: “We wake up at six thirty without an alarm clock.” Danny: „We can go back to the business! No really, we do the work with great pleasure.” Kirsten: “First ... Read more »

Asian-Pacific Bank acquired for $193 mln by investor from Kazakhstan

Three out of the four participants invited by the Bank of Russia participated in the auction — Promsvyazbank, Sovcombank, Pioneer Capital Invest LLP Read more »

TSB turns to insurance veteran Prettejohn as next chairman

The Spanish-owned high street bank will announce Nick Prettejohn’s appointment as its new chairman within days, Sky News learns. Read more »

JM Financial Products Limited Announces Tranche I Public Issue of upto Rs 500 Crore of Secured, Rated, Listed, Redeemable NCDs

Representative image JM Financial Products Limited, the flagship NBFC arm of the JM Financial Group, announced Tranche I public issue of Secured NCDs of face value of Rs. 1,000 each. ... Read more »

IPL effect: Disney+Hotstar to dialup subscribers, price hike in plans to have no impact, say experts

The remainder of the 14th edition of the Indian Premier League (IPL) will start from September 19 and this will attract many new subscribers, say experts in video streaming space. Last year, ... Read more »

If your colleague loses a loved one

What do you do when a colleague loses a loved one? I wondered after reading the moving interview with State Secretary Paul Blokhuis. Among other things, about the loss of ... Read more »

Budget Day: battle for billions for abolition of dividend tax breaks loose again

The 1.9 billion euros that would once be spent on abolishing the dividend tax will definitely not go to the business community, according to the documents for Budget Day. The ... Read more »

SCO Secretary General urges its members to develop joint transport projects

Vladimir Norov noted that in order to overcome the crisis caused by the pandemic, the SCO countries should do more towards eliminating trade barriers, developing investment cooperation, as well as industrial cooperation Read more »

Most Indian firms believe revival of MSME sector can boost rural employment: Report

Representative image A majority of Indian companies (57 per cent) believe there is a need to revive the micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) sector, which has been hit due ... Read more »

Housing demand to rise on SBI's decision to offer home loan at 6.7% interest rates: Realtors

SBI | Representative image India’s residential property market is expected to witness a strong consumer demand during the festival season with various banks, including SBI, providing concessional interest rates on ... Read more »

Gas prices in Europe may break records in near future — Gazprom

On September 15, the cost of natural gas at an auction grew by $159, and several times broke a historical record, at its peak, the price reached $970 per 1,000 cubic meters Read more »

Gas supplies to China via Power of Siberia hit 10 bln cubic meters, says Gazprom CEO

"The cooperation between Russia and China is the cooperation of the largest producer with the largest importer," Alexei Miller stressed Read more »

Manchester United posts £92m annual loss as it counts cost of pandemic

The Old Trafford club said matchday revenues were down by 92% over a period when all but one of its matches were played behind closed doors due to COVID-19 restrictions. Read more »

Piyush Goyal asks G-33 nations to strive for permanent solution to public stockholding

Piyush Goyal | PC-MoneyControl Ministry of Commerce & Industry Piyush Goyal on September 16 said that as part of the trust-building exercise for Ministerial Conference (MC) 12, G-33 must strive ... Read more »

SCO countries to restore, expand economic cooperation, says Putin

The pandemic has led to a reduction of the international trade, triggered volatility on the financial and commodities markets, limited investment flows, Vladimir Putin noted Read more »

Hong Kong proposes SPAC listings, restricts to professional investors

Hong Kong will only allow large blank-cheque companies that raise at least HK$1 billion (US$128 million) to list on its main board and ban retail investors from buying these so-called ... Read more »

Travel hopes, retail slump, four-day week

Listen to “Travel hopes, retail slump, four-day week”. Ian discusses the travel sector’s hopes that the government’s about to announce a big relaxation of COVID travel rules for people living ... Read more »

Stanlow Refinery owner faces new financial crunch as HMRC deadline looms

Essar Oil UK, which owns the site that supplies about one-sixth of Britain's road transport fuels, is in renewed talks with HM Revenue & Customs about its financial position, Sky News learns. Read more »

Gas reserves in Russia will last more than 100 years — Miller

Chairman of the Gazprom Board of Directors Alexei Miller noted that Russian gas reserves are the largest in the world Read more »

China says it agrees with S Jaishankar; says Sino-India ties have their own 'intrinsic logic'

MEA S Jaishankar. China on Friday said it agrees with External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar’s assertion that Beijing should not view its relations with India through the lens of a ... Read more »

Buy GNA Axles: target of Rs 948: Sharekhan

Sharekhan’s research report on GNA Axles GNA is well placed to benefit from sharp improvement in commercial vehicle sales across geographies and healthy outlook for the farm sector. GNA’s earnings ... Read more »

Rupee settles 4 paise higher at 73.48 against US dollar

Representative image The rupee closed 4 paise higher at 73.48 (provisional) against the US dollar on Friday, tracking the broad weakness of the American currency in the overseas market. At ... Read more »

Taking Stock | Sensex, Nifty end lower after hitting record highs; mid, smallcaps suffer more

The market ended its three-day winning streak as investors embarked on profit-booking after a stellar bull run in the market which shot up the valuation of many stocks higher. The ... Read more »

Buy Sunteck Realty: target of Rs 580: ICICI Securities

ICICI Securities research report on Sunteck Realty Sunteck Realty (SRIN) has announced a new residential project acquisition of 10msf in Shahad, located in Mumbai Metropolitan Region’s (MMR) extended Eastern suburbs. ... Read more »

Tata Motors drives in Safari Gold Edition at Rs 21.89 lakh

Tata Safari | Representative image Tata Motors on Friday said it has launched a special edition of its flagship model Safari priced at Rs 21.89 lakh (ex-showroom) to further spruce ... Read more »