Amy Coney Barrett says the supreme court aren't ‘partisan hacks'. Oh really?

War is peace, freedom is slavery, and the supreme court is a dispassionate nonpartisan branch of government free of bias – this is the Orwellian fable that Justice Amy Coney Barrett is now asking Americans to believe.

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Timothy D Easley/AP

And Barrett is asking us to believe it not merely after the court’s wildly partisan ruling on abortion rights, but also just months after she promoted climate denialism to a national audience and refused to recuse herself as she helped secure a legal victory for the fossil fuel giant that employed her father for decades.

This is a tale not just of cartoonish hypocrisy but also of deception – a frantic attempt to prevent more of the country from realizing the court is a corporate star chamber that has become one of the most powerful partisan weapons in American politics.

First, the blatant hypocrisy: In an event that seems torn out of the pages of the Onion, Barrett this weekend appeared with the Senate’s Republican minority leader Mitch McConnell at a celebration of a University of Louisville facility he named after himself. After she was introduced by the most partisan Senate leader in American history, Barrett declared that the supreme court – which now includes three people who worked directly on the Republican campaign to pilfer the 2000 election – “is not comprised of a bunch of partisan hacks.”

If that wasn’t absurd enough, Barrett then declared that judges must be “hyper vigilant to make sure they’re not letting personal biases creep into their decisions, since judges are people, too.”

That demand for ethical vigilance came less than four months after Barrett discarded her own past recusal list and opted to participate in the adjudication of a major climate case against Shell Oil – the fossil fuel giant that employed her father for nearly three decades. Barrett declined to recuse herself even though an amicus brief was filed in the case by the American Petroleum Institute, the lobbying group that her father helped steer – and even though one prominent supporter of the case said her father could be subpoenaed for a deposition because of his potential “direct knowledge of and operational involvement in how Shell managed climate threats.”

© Photograph: Timothy D Easley/AP ‘In an event that seems torn out of the pages of the Onion, Barrett appeared with Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell at a celebration of a University of Louisville facility he named after himself.’

But no recusal came – and, with Barrett’s help, the supreme court sided with Shell and other fossil fuel giants, delivering a big procedural win for the oil and gas industry.

Barrett’s participation in that case followed her Senate confirmation hearing, in which she refused to acknowledge the undisputed science of climate change (and in which flaccid Democrats decided not to bother to push her on recusal). She cast her position as an attempt to avoid being opinionated about the matter, but of course refusing to stipulate basic scientific fact is the opposite of dispassionate. It is an ideological and partisan expression of Republican orthodoxy wholly disconnected from empirical data.

And in case you thought Barrett’s zealotry, hypocrisy and conflicts of interest are germane only to one isolated case, remember that in the coming years, the fossil fuel industry will almost certainly ask the high court to shield it from legal consequences for its climate crimes.

Barrett’s motives here, though, are not just about war-is-peace-ing her way through her own ridiculously obvious conflicts of interest. She is also trying to preserve the image of the court as a transcendent fount of apolitical morality at a time when more and more Americans may be finally – belatedly – realizing that the panel is, in fact, made up of hacks.

As the Daily Poster has been reporting for quite a while, the panel has become the most conservative supreme court in modern history. This is a group of judges who now loyally rubber-stamp legal requests from the US Chamber of Commerce and other corporate groups bankrolling the politicians and the nomination campaigns that install rightwing appointees on the court. The justices have become so politically brazen that they now quietly issue landmark rulings in total secrecy through a so-called shadow docket.

Despite this, corporate media has typically portrayed the court as a moderating force above politics, and even putatively liberal or centrist pundits have periodically touted some of the most rightwing justices.

This propaganda campaign has worked – even as the court exacerbates the climate crisis, restricts abortion rights, tramples voting rights and issues ever-more-extreme rulings helping corporations crush workers, nearly two-thirds of Americans say they approve of the court’s work, according to the latest survey.

However, that’s down a sizable six points since last year – which suggests that more of the country is beginning to realize that a fetid form of corporatism and partisanship is quietly rotting the judiciary from within.

Barrett rightly senses that this realization threatens the perceived legitimacy of the justice system, and therefore could create momentum for real reform – whether it means term limits for supreme court judges or an expansion of the court.

Any of those reforms are a threat to her power, and the power of all the corporate forces that bought high-court jobs for rightwing justices. So she’s trying to do whatever she can to prevent America from understanding how nefarious the upreme court has become.

That’s what her speech was really all about – and we shouldn’t be fooled. We should be emboldened behind the cause of finally fixing a star chamber that is causing so much harm throughout the country and the world.

  • David Sirota is a Guardian US columnist and an investigative journalist. He is an editor at large at Jacobin and the founder of the Daily Poster. He served as Bernie Sanders’ presidential campaign speechwriter

  • This article was originally published in the Daily Poster, a grassroots-funded investigative news outlet

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Austria's $3.50 go-anywhere Klimaticket aims to fight climate change

You wake up in suburban Innsbruck, the snowcapped peaks of the Austrian Tyrol glistening in the distance. After breakfast you hop a tram to Innsbruck Hauptbahnhof, the city’s main railway ... Read more »

Business lobby calls for administration to 'pump the brakes' on vaccine mandate

© Associated Press – Lynne Sladky Coronavirus vaccine getting put into arm The Biden administration’s looming vaccine-or-test mandate has unsettled several business groups, who are calling for the rule to ... Read more »

Miles Donations Providing Flights for Afghan Refugees

The group Miles4Migrants is coordinating the effort with the help of major airlines to use donated miles and credit card points to help refugees. Read more »

Retired marine raising money to help interpreter, afghan family

Retired marine raising money to help interpreter, afghan family Read more »

Paul Pierce rips Sixers' Ben Simmons

One former NBA star who played for Doc Rivers thinks that Ben Simmons is being a real piece of work. © Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports Philadelphia 76ers guard Ben Simmons ... Read more »

Adele's Ex-Husband Simon and Son Angelo Attend Concert Special Taping

© Provided by US Weekly Adeles Ex Husband Simon Son Angelo Attend LA Taping CBS Special Biggest fans! Adele’s ex-husband, Simon Konecki, and their son, Angelo, were in attendance during ... Read more »

TV's 'Ghosts,' 'Wonder Years' are long-view ratings winners

LOS ANGELES (AP) — At first glance, broadcast newcomers “Ghosts” and “The Wonder Years” have barely had a chance to prove themselves in the ratings. © Provided by Associated Press ... Read more »

Rust Gaffer Shares 'Last Photo' of Halyna Hutchins on Set with Alec Baldwin Before Fatal Shooting

© Provided by People facebook Halyna Hutchins‘ colleague has shared a photo of one of the cinematographer’s last moments on the set of Rust before she was fatally shot. Serge ... Read more »

This Pre-Shampoo Mud Mask Helps Encourage Hair Growth and Detoxifies the Scalp

Raise your hand if you’ve ever made a mess in your bathroom mixing bentonite clay with water, apple cider vinegar, and whatever other additives your little DIY heart desired to ... Read more »

This $14 Azelaic Acid-Infused Serum Exfoliates and Treats Breakouts, Rosacea, and Hyperpigmentation

Let’s be honest. Thousands of skincare products probably cross your screen as you scroll through social media — so many that it becomes hard to pay attention (and get excited) ... Read more »

FDA vaccine advisers vote to recommend Pfizer's Covid-19 vaccine for children 5 to 11

Vaccine advisers to the US Food and Drug Administration voted 17-0 with one abstention Tuesday to recommend emergency use authorization of Pfizer’s Covid-19 vaccine in children ages 5 to 11. ... Read more »

CRDL Stock: 7 Things to Know About Healthcare Play Cardiol Therapeutics

© Source: Shutterstock A close-up concept image of a tiny glass vial with a strand of DNA in it. Today, Canadian clinical-stage biotech company Cardiol Therapeutics (NASDAQ:CRDL) is seeing impressive investor ... Read more »

Immunocompromised people may need a fourth Covid-19 shot, CDC says

People with certain health conditions that make them moderately or severely immunocompromised may get a fourth mRNA Covid-19 shot, according to updated guidelines from the US Centers for Disease Control ... Read more »

Warrant issued for Texas man charged for deaths of two Grand Forks teens

Oct. 26—A Texas man has been charged for the deaths of two Grand Forks teenagers earlier this year. According to charging documents, Valentin Mendoza IV, 20, told his girlfriend he ... Read more »

11-year-old boy dies after being struck by vehicle on West Loop 820, police say

A child was killed in a vehicle crash on West Loop 820 near Camp Bowie West Boulevard late Tuesday afternoon, police said. Fort Worth Officer Tracy Carter, a department spokesman, ... Read more »

Tri-Five Chevys on the Quarter-Mile at Historic Famoso Dragstrip

Famoso Dragstrip was Tri-Five Chevy heaven when the American Tri-Five Association brought the Western Invasion presented by Danchuk to Bakersfield’s historic race track in October 2021. The American Tri-Five Association ... Read more »

Trump issues endorsement for Bolsonaro

Former President Trump shared his endorsement for Brazil President Jair Bolsonaro’s reelection amid backlash in Brazil over Bolsonaro’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic. © Getty Images Trump issues endorsement for ... Read more »

Bullet train project: 75 evicted slum dwellers not entitled to policy on rehabilitation, HC told

© Provided by The Indian Express In a petition on rehabilitation of 75 slum dwellers evicted for the Mumbai-Ahmedabad bullet train project, the state, Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) and bullet ... Read more »

Wankhede's wife lashes out at NCP leader Nawab Malik

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: Amid the bitter and personal feud that erupted with NCP leader Nawab Malik’s slew of allegations against NCB zonal director Sameer Wankhede ... Read more »

Marriage used as conversion tool: UP defends its law in HC

© Provided by The Times of India PRAYAGRAJ: The Uttar Pradesh government has defended its anti-conversion law in its affidavit before the Allahabad high court, stating that “since marriage is ... Read more »

Angels star Shohei Ohtani receives Commissioner's Historic Achievement Award

MLB commissioner Rob Manfred announced that he was awarding Angels star Shohei Ohtani an Historic Achievement Award. Ohtani becomes the 16th recipient of the award, which was first given to ... Read more »

NY Attorney General warns parents of candy and snacks in 'deceptive' packaging containing 'dangerously high concentrations of THC'

© Getty Getty The New York AG advised parents to look out for deceptively packaged products. She says these products contain “dangerously high concentrations of THC.” It is unlikely for ... Read more »

Overnight Energy & Environment — Presented by American Clean Power — Dems see path to deal on climate provisions

Welcome to Tuesday’s Overnight Energy & Environment, your source for the latest news focused on energy, the environment and beyond. Subscribe here: © Greg Nash Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) ... Read more »

Ryan Gosling's Wolfman Reboot Has Made A Big Behind-The-Scenes Change

As the classic horror cinema characters such as Frankenstein’s monster and Dracula maintain their everlasting fandoms through celebrations such as Universal Studios’ Halloween-themed events, Hollywood continues its attempts to reboots ... Read more »

Alphabet's income zooms on soaring services revenue

© BRYAN R. SMITH Google’s third-quarter sales surged 41 per cent annually to $65.1 billion. Photo: AFP Alphabet reported a 68.4 per cent jump in its third-quarter net profit on ... Read more »

Neom Tech and Holding and OneWeb join in $200m venture for satellite connectivity

© Provided by The National Nadmi Al Nasser, CEO, NEOM speaking at FII in Riyadh on Tuesday. Neom Tech & Digital Holding Company and its strategic partner, One Web, on ... Read more »

Genshin Impact: The Black Sword – how to get it, stats, and ascension materials

© Provided by GamePur The Black Sword is a 4-star weapon in Genshin Impact that’s unfortunately only available to players who pay. More specifically, you’ll need to purchase the Battle ... Read more »

Home minister: Govt has no intention to amend Sosma, needed by enforcement agencies to maintain public order

© Provided by Malay Mail Home Minister Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin noted that his ministry was committed to further improving the law, further stating that such improvement measures are continually ... Read more »

Jeff Bezos Is Building a Space Station That's Basically a Giant Business Park

© Orbital Reef Seems pretty on-brand. Jeff Bezos-run Blue Origin announced this week that it is partnering with other giants in the astronautics field to develop a space station. Orbital ... Read more »

Watch This Cat's Reaction When Sat on by His Dog Sibling in Comical Viral Video

This cat sat on by a dog might’ve had it coming after laying in the Great Pyrenees‘s bed one too many times. But whatever the cause, the video of the ... Read more »

3 Ways to Sneak More Money Into Your IRA

© Provided by The Motley Fool 3 Ways to Sneak More Money Into Your IRA © Getty Images Happy couple sit in front of computer with paperwork . Saving for ... Read more »

Day care group warns vaccine mandates will lead to less access

Operators of licensed day cares in Illinois say the governor’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate on the industry will make a staffing crisis even more acute. © Provided by Washington Examiner Gov. ... Read more »

Facebook is having a tougher time managing vaccine misinformation than it is letting on, leaks suggest

In public, Facebook has touted the resources it has dedicated to tackling Covid-19 and vaccine misinformation, even scolding US President Joe Biden for his harsh criticism of the company’s handling ... Read more »

Sunak is mocked for wearing 'teenage' flip-flop footwear in photoshoot

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Twitter users mocked Rishi Sunak last night for wearing £95 ‘teenage’ flip-flop footwear in a pre-Budget pictures by photoshopping clown feet over the American-style sandals ... Read more »

Careful on CA convertibility

© Provided by The Financial Express To be sure, we have come a long way since then; today, domestic residents can easily access forex for travel, study and remit $250,000 ... Read more »

19-year-old charged with Raleigh murder indicted in double murder on NCCU campus

A 19-year-old in Wake County jail on murder charges now faces charges in connection with the shooting deaths of two men last month on the North Carolina Central University campus, ... Read more »

3 men injured in shooting on Granby Street Norfolk

Three men were hospitalized after a shooting Tuesday in Norfolk, according to Twitter post from police. Officers responded to a call around 7 p.m. about a shooting in the 2700 ... Read more »

Mike Perry signs multi-fight deal with BKFC

UFC veteran Mike Perry has signed a multi-fight deal with Bare Knuckle Fighting Championship (BKFC), BKFC officials confirmed to MMA Fighting on Tuesday. © Photo by Mike Roach/Zuffa LLC Mike ... Read more »

'End of the story': MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred standing down on Atlanta's tomahawk chop, nickname

HOUSTON — There has been no pressure placed on Atlanta towards changing its nickname or banning the Tomahawk Chop by its fans, MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred said Tuesday, supporting Atlanta’s ... Read more »

Hell Yes, It's the First Trailer for Netflix's Live-Action ‘Cowboy Bebop' (Video)

© Provided by TheWrap Cowboy Bebop So far marketing for Netflix’s live action remake of “Cowboy Bebop” has basically been giant flashing WE GET THIS STUFF WE PROMISE signs for ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic