Americans no longer have faith in the US supreme court. That has justices worried

Asia's Tech News Daily

Our highest court is facing a legitimacy crisis and is in desperate need of reform. And yet, due to the deadlock that seems to be Congress these days, I too often hear the rebuke to US supreme court reform, “None of these reforms will happen, so what is the point of talking about them?”

This defeatist argument fails to recognize a pivotal audience who surely hears the growing public calls for urgent reform – the supreme court itself.

We need only look to the number of justices who have felt the need recently to speak up on behalf of the court, in an attempt to justify its egregious abuse of judicial norms and processes, to know the justices are listening.

Historically, one of the most common features of supreme court justices is their public silence when away from the court. They generally let their decisions speak for themselves. No longer is that tenable as this court’s conservative supermajority insists on using its power to advance a partisan agenda at the expense of our constitutional rights and democratic legitimacy.

Most recently, Justice Samuel Alito gave a speech at the University of Notre Dame that can only be described as an attempted takedown of the press. In his remarks, Justice Alito lambasted the work of journalists and even criticized the press for using the term “shadow docket”, a term coined by a conservative law professor. All Justice Alito succeeded in doing, however, is proving his sensitivity to the public discourse about the court.

It’s not just justices who are attempting to justify the court’s break from judicial norms and disregard for constitutional rights. Senator Chuck Grassley, for instance, has even taken it upon himself to defend the court from what he perceives as bullying. His implication, however, that the court should be beyond reproach is to suggest the public ought to sit idly by while our rights are systematically dismantled for partisan gain.

Justices, and politicians, can proclaim that the court is not political or that the public’s waning approval of the institution is a product of the media, but nobody is forcing the court to deface its own norms and precedents.

Nobody is forcing this conservative supermajority to use the shadow docket to rewrite American jurisprudence. Pregnant people in Texas no longer have a constitutional right to abortion because five justices on the supreme court opted to nullify Roe v Wade by way of the shadow docket.

The court rejected its own decisions in cases decided just nine and five years ago respectively

Nobody is forcing this supermajority to discard the court’s own precedent, even precedent that was written by some of these same justices. Whether you look at the court’s nullification of Roe v Wade in Texas, its reversal on questions of due process for Guantánamo Bay detainees, or the court’s 180-degree turn on juvenile sentencing, this conservative supermajority has made clear that precedent be damned.

By way of example, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in her dissent in the recent Jones v Mississippi case that the majority decision distorted the court’s previous decisions in Miller v Alabama and Montgomery v Louisiana “beyond recognition” in order to “justify” reimposing juvenile life without parole. The court rejected its own decisions in cases decided just nine and five years ago respectively. When precedent is so blatantly ignored, it is difficult to explain the court’s change in direction but for politics.

Nobody is forcing the court to willfully ignore the racially disparate impact of voter suppression laws, pretending that the election of one non-white president means people of color have equal access to the ballot box despite all evidence to the contrary. Our right to self-government, achieved through a meaningful right to vote, is in serious jeopardy because this court continues to turn a blind eye.

Nobody forced Justice Amy Coney Barrett to speak at an event hosted by Senator Mitch McConnell, the very senator responsible for jamming her confirmation through the Senate while a presidential election was under way. At this event, Justice Barrett was proudly introduced by Senator McConnell, and then quickly stated that her goal was to convince the audience that the justices are not just “political hacks”.

Such a claim of ethical clarity just isn’t credible when it is uttered on stage right next to the person most responsible for the partisan gamesmanship that packed the court. What Justice Barrett did succeed in doing with her remarks is to confirm just how closely justices listen to the public narrative about the court – and how sensitive they are to it.

The justices, through their own actions and words, have demonstrated their vulnerability to public pressure in support of court reform. Turns out, justices do not like being told they have no clothes on.

As the court delves into its new term, it should have no doubt that all eyes will be upon it. If they want to escape it, rather than hoping the press will be cowed into submission, the justices of the court might consider fulfilling the mission of the institution they embody, by upholding constitutional rights and respecting judicial norms.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Sir Alex Ferguson picks 'easily the best captain' he managed at Manchester United

Sir Alex Ferguson has picked Bryan Robson over Eric Cantona and Roy Keane as he named “easily the best captain” he managed at Manchester United. The iconic Scotsman was appointed ... Read more »

Soccer-Morata helps Juventus return to winning ways at Salernitana

SALERNO (Reuters) – Alvaro Morata scored four minutes after coming on to seal a much-needed 2-0 win for Juventus away to bottom side Salernitana in Serie A on Tuesday and ... Read more »

And Just Like That... Sex And The City Spin-Off Drops A Revealing Trailer

HBO Max The “Sex and the City” sequel series is nearly here. “And Just Like That …” is slated to premiere on HBO Max on Thursday, December 9. The original ... Read more »

Twitter bans sharing of photos without consent

© Kirill KUDRYAVTSEV Twitter, like other social media networks, has struggled against bullying, misinformation and hate-fuelled content. Twitter launched new rules Tuesday blocking users from sharing private images of other ... Read more »

Wife of drug king 'El Chapo' sentenced to prison

© Provided by dw.com Emma Coronel Aispuro married EL Chapo when she was just 18 years old Emma Coronel Aispuro, wife of the notorious Mexican drug kingpin Joaquin “El Chapo” ... Read more »

Covid cases in South Africa SOAR 92% just days after scientists raised the alarm about Omicron variant as top doctor calls the TEN PERCENT positivity rate ‘scary' – but 87% of those hospitalised are unvaccinated

Leading virologist Tulio de Oliveira urged public to get vaccinated amid the 'scary' surge in infectionsThe Omicron variant has send South Africa from a period of low transmission to a rapid growth of new confirmed casesSouth Africa recorded 4,473 new cases on Tuesday, a 92 per cent increase from the day earlier Read more »

Corrie's Curtis looks totally different in Hollyoaks and Coronation Street crossover role

Coronation Street star Sam Retford looks totally different from his Weatherfield character in his starring role in a short film before the soap. Sam. who plays Curtis Delamere in Corrie, ... Read more »

Holby City star David Ames prepares to film final scenes as Dom Copeland

© BBC Holby City’s David Ames prepares to film final scenes as Dom Copeland, a character he has been playing since 2013. Holby City is drawing to a close and ... Read more »

New Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy Patch Fixes 100+ Bugs

© Image: Rockstar Games CJ and Ryder walk down the cul-de-sac of Grove Street menacingly while brandishing aluminum bats. Today, Rockstar Games released a new patch for Grand Theft Auto: ... Read more »

Ireland demolish Georgia 11-0 in wild World Cup qualifier at Tallaght Stadium

© Provided by Extra.ie Ireland have absolutely demolished Georgia 11-0 in their 2023 World Cup qualifier on a wild and wet night in Tallaght Stadium. Vera Pauw’s side made a ... Read more »

47-year-old among 8 COVID deaths in Singapore, 1,239 new cases

SINGAPORE — The Ministry of Health (MOH) on Tuesday (30 November) confirmed 1,239 new COVID-19 cases in Singapore – bringing the country’s total case count to 264,725 – as well ... Read more »

CRAIG HOPE: Ciaran Clark's brainless foul to send Newcastle down to ten men summed up a club prone to calamity... Eddie Howe received a shock welcome to Tyneside but this draw to Norwich will still lift his spirits

Ten-man Newcastle were denied a big win against Norwich on Tuesday evening The Toon Army have come to expect calamity after Ciaran Clark's early red card Eddie Howe will be uplifted by his support at St James' Park despite the 1-1 draw  Read more »

Ministers offer support to thousands still without power after Storm Arwen

More than 90% of people who lost power due to Storm Arwen have had their supply restored, but 45,000 are still in the dark, the Business Secretary has said. The ... Read more »

Still pressing on! 1940s iron which won't stop steaming named 'oldest working' in Britain

Chris West with the fully working iron, which has been named the oldest working in Britain – SWNS It is often said that older household appliances, safe from the technical ... Read more »

Your Money: ‘Good' and ‘bad' debts: Know the differences

© Provided by The Financial Express These cards often have hefty interest rates and can rapidly become unmanageable. By Supriya Suri Loans play a major role in helping us realise ... Read more »

League of Legends December Prime Gaming capsule now live

© Provided by Dot Esports Kick off December the right way by claiming your Prime Gaming capsule for League of Legends now. As part of Riot Games’ extensive collaboration with ... Read more »

Convicted burglar charged with killing ex who taught self-defense classes, gun safety

Robert J. Tarr is accused of first-degree murder in the shooting death of Leslie J. Reeves. Montgomery County An Illinois man has been charged with killing his ex-girlfriend — a ... Read more »

Book's claim Prince Charles questioned Archie's complexion came from ‘rock-solid' sources, says author

AUTHOR Christopher Andersen has insisted he had “rock solid” sources for his claims that Prince Charles questioned the complexion of Harry and Meghan’s children. He alleges Prince Charles asked Camilla ... Read more »

Queen Elizabeth news – Broadcasters in war to steal Queen's Xmas speech as royals banned from playing Monopoly

CHANNEL 4 has entered the race to air the Queen’s Christmas Day speech. The broadcaster’s application comes in the wake of the Royal Family falling out with the BBC. An insider said: “This ... Read more »

Sir Alex Ferguson's clear choice as "best captain" at Man Utd

Sir Alex Ferguson passed over Eric Cantona and Roy Keane as he named Bryan Robson “easily the best captain” he managed at Manchester United. The iconic Scotsman was appointed United ... Read more »

Glasgow Warriors: Danny Wilson lifts lid on post-Benetton team talk

Danny Wilson is generally an understated character, who prefers to motivate his players with a discreet word in the ear at a quiet moment rather than with a hair-dryer blast ... Read more »

Britain's Davis Cup hopes dashed by Germany in doubles defeat

Great Britain’s Davis Cup team arrived in Innsbruck, Austria filled with ample hope about their prospects after a great year for all their players involved, and during their visit they ... Read more »

Scotland Women thrashed by Spain as World Cup hopes dented

Scotland Women’s hopes of automatic qualification for the 2023 World Cup suffered a dent after they were thrashed 8-0 by Spain in Seville. © It was a chastening night for ... Read more »

US, China in new 'arms race' to develop 'lethal' hypersonic missiles

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The United States and China are engaged in an arms race to develop the most lethal hypersonic weapons, the U.S. Air Force secretary ... Read more »

'Can't stop scoring' - Everton handed ominous Merseyside derby warning ahead of Liverpool showdown

Former Liverpool striker Michael Owen has predicted Liverpool to take all three points back to Anfield with a 2-1 win when they take on rivals Everton in the Merseyside Derby. ... Read more »

Aston Villa U21 player ratings vs Charlton as youngsters crash out of the EFL Trophy

Aston Villa’s under-21s side have sadly crashed out of the Papa John’s Trophy after a 2-1 defeat to Charlton. Mason Burstow peeled away from both Joshua Feeney and Sil Swinkels ... Read more »

New study: Fully vaccinated people with weakened immune systems get COVID-19 more often

It is still very rare for fully vaccinated people to get the coronavirus, but those who have weakened immune systems become infected more often and get more ill, according to ... Read more »

Jan. 6 committee moves to hold former DOJ official in contempt

The House select committee investigating the Jan. 6 Capitol attack plans to move forward Wednesday with criminal contempt proceedings against a former Justice Department official who declined to cooperate with ... Read more »

FDA health panel endorses Merck COVID-19 pill, paving way for U.S. authorization of the first at-home drug for virus

WASHINGTON — FDA health panel endorses Merck COVID-19 pill, paving way for U.S. authorization of the first at-home drug for virus. Read more »

Secret unaired ‘The Office' scene is blowing people's minds

© NBC the-office-steve-carell.jpg Kevin Malone has always been a fan favorite of The Office thanks to his loveable and hilarious personality. And now it seems the unaired finale of the ... Read more »

How to use Hulu Watch Party to virtually watch movies with friends

© Provided by Pocket-lint Hulu Watch Party photo 3 (Pocket-lint) – Hulu offers a Watch Party feature that allows all subscribers to simultaneously watch a show or movie while in ... Read more »

Why Leylah Fernandez Is A Doris Anderson Award Recipient

Too tiny was the verdict of Quebec’s provincial tennis association, when it cut Leylah Annie Fernandez a few years ago from its development program. (The association also took exception to ... Read more »

Dr. Oz Announces He's Running for Senate in Pennsylvania

© ET Dr. Oz is running for Senate. The TV personality and surgeon announced his candidacy for a Pennsylvania Senate seat in an op-ed titled “Why I’m Running to be ... Read more »

How to Know if It's Been Too Long Since You've Pooped

People often wonder how long it’s OK to go without pooping. We checked in with Sameer Islam, MD, a Texas-based gastroenterologist who specializes in the diagnosis and treatment of diseases ... Read more »

'And Just Like That' Trailer: Carrie, Miranda and Charlotte Embark on New Chapters

© HBO Max Carrie Bradshaw and her friends are in a new season of life in the latest trailer for HBO Max’s Sex and the City reboot, And Just Like That. ... Read more »

Ottawa to require test, quarantine from all non-U.S. travellers in wake of Omicron

The federal government will introduce a series of new restrictions at Canada’s borders in response to the Omicron variant, including requiring that all air travellers coming into Canada from outside ... Read more »

Why Dr. Vivian Stamatopoulos Is A Doris Anderson Award Recipient

© Provided by Chatelaine A woman with long hair in black and white wearing a black blazer. (Photo: Erik Putz) Dr. Vivian Stamatopoulos has been thinking about long-term care for ... Read more »

Why Sabrina Craig Is A Doris Anderson Award Recipient

© Provided by Chatelaine (Photo: Courtesy of Sabrina Craig) More than 58 million doses of COVID-19 vaccine were administered in Canada by October. It’s no stretch to say that thousands ... Read more »

PEZA actively pitching Korean investors as economy reopens

© Provided by BusinessWorld THE PHILIPPINE Economic Zone Authority (PEZA) said it is pinning its hopes on expanding the pool of South Korean investors to add momentum to the reopening ... Read more »

The Best Holiday Decor Deals to Shop Now: Home Depot, Macy's, Wayfair and More

© Cavan Images/Getty Images Each product has been independently selected by our editorial team. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic