All-civilian discipline panels are more lenient with LAPD officers, report finds

All-civilian discipline panels are more lenient with LAPD officers, report finds

Los Angeles Police Department officials said Tuesday that they will ask the City Council to reconsider a rule that allows officers accused of serious misconduct to have civilians decide their discipline — after a report found they routinely hand down lenient punishments.

The lighter discipline issued by all-civilian hearing panels undercuts Chief Michel Moore‘s ability to run the LAPD and to hold officers accountable when they are found to have committed major offenses such as lying, according to the report by the LAPD’s inspector general, Mark Smith.

The findings reflect an “imbalance of power” between Moore and the hearing panels that “significantly undermines the ability of the Department to police itself,” the report said.

“A system that allows for the outright and unchallengeable overruling of a Chief’s disciplinary decisions detracts from the Department’s appropriate efforts in furtherance of internal accountability,” the report said.

Under the LAPD’s discipline system, the chief does not have the power to fire an officer. When the chief believes firing is necessary, the officer is entitled to a hearing before a three-person panel, called a board of rights. The hearings are mini-trials in which the officer and department officials present evidence and call witnesses. An officer can also request a board hearing to challenge a suspension or demotion issued by the chief.

Until 2019, the panels consisted of one civilian and two LAPD officers with the rank of captain or higher; but with the passage of Measure C that year, officers could opt to have their cases heard by an all-civilian board.

After the council approved the measure with the backing of the police union and Mayor Eric Garcetti, few officers initially chose a civilian panel. That has changed in the ensuing years; so far in 2022, every officer facing termination has chosen that option, according to LAPD officials.

With more officers opting for hearings in front of all-civilian panels, the share of cases in which boards handed down lighter penalties than Moore had called for increased from 55% in 2019 to 76% in 2021, according to the inspector general’s report. The review looked into 90 board of rights hearings between September 2019 and December 2021.

In cases in which the chief wanted an officer fired, traditional panels agreed with the chief half of the time. Civilian panels overruled the chief more than two-thirds of the time, according to the report.

One reason for the imbalance, the report said, was that department advocates, who serve in a role akin to prosecutor at the hearings, often lack formal legal training, leaving them at a disadvantage against attorneys who represent officers in the increasingly litigious proceedings. The department advocates fare particularly badly in front of all-civilian panels, which tend to demand the two sides submit written arguments and follow other trial-like procedures, the report found.

The department has asked for money in its 2023-2024 budget proposal to hire five attorneys who would focus solely on such disciplinary hearings — one of the handful of recommendations made in the report.

The report, which was presented to the Police Commission during its virtual meeting Tuesday, confirmed an inspector general’s audit released last year that found hearing panels made up entirely of civilians were more likely than panels with law enforcement representatives to overturn harsher discipline.

“The officers are attempting to find their best opportunity for leniency,” Moore said during Tuesday’s hearing. “That is a natural response and one that I would understand.”

Police Commissioner Eileen Decker said she found the review’s conclusions “deeply disturbing.”

“There’s no other place where the odds of getting a lower court’s ruling reversed are as high as this process,” said Decker, a onetime assistant U.S. attorney.

Deputy LAPD Chief Michael Rimkunas said later in the meeting that the department intended to send a letter to the City Council asking it to revisit Measure C, but did not elaborate. Officials also announced an update to the department’s board of rights manual, and their intention to start publishing the names of panelists and their decisions on the Police Commission’s website.

At the time the measure was approved, the union representing rank-and-file officers said that the traditional panels were unfair because the LAPD officials serving on them had an interest in supporting their boss, the chief of police. Critics of the proposal, meanwhile, argued that the civilians chosen for the panels would not adequately represent the public’s interests and would ultimately offer less accountability than traditional panels.

In the report, LAPD officials complained that civilian panelists were unfamiliar with department policies and and didn’t fully appreciate “the ramifications of retaining officers who have committed serious misconduct.”

This, some felt, led to scenarios in which an all-civilian panel would reject the proposed firing of an officer who, for instance, was caught lying on the job, without understanding that an officer with tainted credibility cannot effectively testify in court against people they arrest.

“Sometimes, in cases involving the most egregious types of misconduct, this means that the Chief has no choice but to retain an officer whom the Chief has already determined is no longer fit to perform the essential duties of a peace officer and should be terminated from employment with the Department,” the review found.

The report drew a strong rebuke from the officers’ union, the Los Angeles Police Protective League, which suggested that it was one-sided and sought to give Moore too much power in disciplinary matters.

Speaking during the commission’s public comment period, police union general counsel Robert Rico said that the report was “clearly written to elicit a more punitive approach” and that it omitted important context about legitimate reasons review panels might have for recommending a lesser penalty.

Both civilian and traditional panels seemed to give special weight to the testimony of other officers, the inspector general’s report said.

In one case cited in the report, an LAPD officer was recommended for termination after being arrested for drunk driving in a department vehicle while off duty, among other offenses.

But the panel instead recommended a 65-day suspension without pay and a demotion in rank, the report said, after an LAPD captain testified on the officer’s behalf, telling the board that the officer would continue to be an asset to the department despite their alcoholism.

News Related


The Crown's Dominic West Weighs In On Prince Charles' Breakdancing Skills

Jeff Spicer/Getty Images Replacing previous cast member John O’Connor, Dominic West plays an older version of Prince Charles on the fifth season of “The Crown.” On the Netflix show, the prince ... Read more »

Disney Teases Avatar: The Way Of Water At CCXP With 18 Minutes Of Footage

Disney We’re about two weeks away from “Avatar: The Way of Water,” and it still feels like this movie is never going to arrive. The highly-anticipated follow-up to 2009’s “Avatar” ... Read more »

US passenger killed when big wave hits Antarctic cruise ship

US passenger killed when big wave hits Antarctic cruise ship Authorities say a U.S. woman was killed and four other passengers injured when a massive wave struck the Viking Polaris ... Read more »

Cameron Crowe adores recording ‘Almost Famous’ cast album

Cameron Crowe adores recording ‘Almost Famous’ cast album Cameron Crowe believes the spirit of a place lingers long after the moment has passed Cameron Crowe, left, and Tom Kitt appear ... Read more »

Turkey: Russia, US failed to clear militia from Syria border

Turkey: Russia, US failed to clear militia from Syria border Turkey’s foreign minister says the United States and Russia have failed to meet promises to clear Syria’s border with Turkey ... Read more »

Negotiations begin for a global treaty on plastic pollution

Negotiations begin for a global treaty on plastic pollution On Friday afternoon more than 2,000 experts will wrap up a week of negotiations on plastic pollution at one of the ... Read more »

Rail strike averted: Biden signs bill enforcing agreement

Rail strike averted: Biden signs bill enforcing agreement President Joe Biden has signed a bill to avert a freight rail strike that he said could have plunged the U.S. into ... Read more »

Brittany Mahomes Has 1-Word Reaction To Controversial World Cup Goal

DENVER, CO – OCTOBER 17: (L-R) Gracie Hunt and Brittany Matthews, girlfriend of quarterback Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs check out social media on the field before a ... Read more »

Former Trump White House counsel Pat Cipollone enters US District Courthouse

Former Trump White House counsel Pat Cipollone was seen entering the grand jury area at the US District Courthouse in Washington Friday morning, indicating the Justice Department has compelled him ... Read more »

Tourists at Utah Canyon Capture Video of BASE Jumper Slamming Into Cliff

The video was capture by a family visiting the Kane Creek Canyon in Moab. Read more »

American in Russia who could be part of prisoner swap resumes contact, family says

MOSCOW —  The family of Paul Whelan, an American imprisoned in Russia for espionage, said Friday that he has resumed contact after unexpectedly becoming unreachable in November. Along with WNBA star ... Read more »

As one storm subsides, another will bring much-needed rain to L.A. and snow to Sierra

As one storm subsides across California, another is on its way, bringing much needed rain to Southern California and heavy snow to the Sierra Nevada. Most areas across Los Angeles ... Read more »

Kendrick Bourne joins Mac Jones in his Patriots offensive exasperation

Mac Jones has some company. The Patriots quarterback was not alone in voicing his frustrations as the team struggled to mount an offensive attack against the Bills in a 24-10 ... Read more »

French First Lady Brigitte Macron Shines in White Louis Vuitton Gown & Chrome Pumps at White House State Dinner

Bidens Host A State Visit By President Macron And Mrs. Marcon Of France French first lady Brigitte Macron and her husband, the current President of France Emmanuel Macron, joined first ... Read more »

Trevor Noah: ‘It’s 2022, how can you still be misinformed about Covid?’

Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again later. Trevor Noah This content is not available due to your privacy preferences. Update your settings here to see it. On The Daily ... Read more »

Road maintenance crews will be ‘out in full force’ for potential Lower Mainland Friday snow

Snow is forecast for B.C.’s South Coast Friday and the B.C. Ministry of Transportation said road maintenance crews are ready. “The Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure’s maintenance contractors will be ... Read more »

U.S. rail strike averted after Joe Biden signs bill blocking job action

President Joe Biden signed legislation Friday to block a national U.S. railroad strike that could have devastated the American economy. The U.S. Senate voted 80 to 15 on Thursday to ... Read more »

Saturday ITV Racing Tips: Best bets for Sandown and Aintree

The ITV cameras are at Aintree and Sandown for Saturday's afternoon racing, and the Planet Sport tipsters have a hot selection for each of the eight live races on December 3. Read more »

Public-service ad guru Sherry Matthews aims to flip NYC home for $8.49M

An advertising ace is looking to profit off her condo inside 40 Mercer, a slick condo designed by André Balazs (inset). Arnaud Montagard / FilmMagic Remember the masked Statue of ... Read more »

My 1,000th Outfit Idea Collage & other New Favorites

Y’all I CANNOT believe I am sharing my 1000th Outfit Idea collage! I cannot thank y’all enough for the love and support you have given me over the past 5 ... Read more »

Creative amps up distinctive Pebble Pro desktop speakers

Creative Pebble Pro promise plenty of volume, bass and clarity. Photo: Creative Creative recently unveiled a new addition to its distinctively round and tilted Pebble line of USB desktop speakers ... Read more »

Less than two weeks after Bob Iger’s return, Florida may reverse decision on Disney’s Reedy Creek District

After stripping Disney of the power to essentially create its own government for the Magic Kingdom, Epcot and other Disney theme parks in Orlando in April, lawmakers in Florida are ... Read more »

‘Emancipation’ producer slammed for bringing slavery photo to premiere

Producer Joey McFarland caught reporters off guard when he pulled out a photo of the whipped slave Peter, from 1863, on the red carpet. Will Smith’s slavery drama “Emancipation” held ... Read more »

‘Fashion doesn’t stop at handbags’: Montreal retailer Bentley eyes post-pandemic comeback

A luggage and bag store isn’t exactly top of mind during lockdowns. So Bentley & Co. Ltd. quietly tightened operations and positioned itself for a post-pandemic comeback. The retailer’s predecessor, ... Read more »

Ex-NBA star Jeremy Lin fined by China over quarantine comments

Former NBA star Jeremy Lin, who plays for a Chinese team, was fined 10,000 yuan ($1,918) for criticizing quarantine facilities, according to China’s professional league and a Friday news report. ... Read more »

‘Infowars’ host Alex Jones files for personal bankruptcy in wake of Sandy Hook ‘hoax’ claims

Right-wing conspiracy theorist and “Infowars” host Alex Jones on Friday filed for personal bankruptcy protection in Texas. The Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing comes after Jones and his company, Free Speech ... Read more »

Christian Pulisic Chances ‘Pretty Good' for World Cup Return Vs. Netherlands

Pulisic's pelvic injury will be further evaluated during the USMNT's training session on Friday Read more »

Infowars host Alex Jones files for personal bankruptcy after $1.5B in judgments over Sandy Hook lies

HOUSTON —  Infowars host Alex Jones filed for personal bankruptcy protection in Texas on Friday as he faces nearly $1.5 billion in court judgments over conspiracy theories he spread about the ... Read more »

Why your 2023 tax refund might be smaller than the one you received this year

The Internal Revenue Service is alerting taxpayers about a number of changes hitting in the 2023 tax filing year. Among the most significant: Your tax refund, if you are eligible ... Read more »

Joe Biden signs bill axing rail-worker sick days plea before royals meeting

WASHINGTON — President Biden signed legislation Friday forcing railway unions to accept a labor agreement despite worker objections to a lack of paid sick days — hours before hobnobbing with ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo’s bizarre World Cup continues with South Korea gaffe

Maybe he shouldn’t have played after all. Portugal superstar Cristiano Ronaldo was in the starting lineup for Friday’s group stage finale versus South Korea after some initial confusion about his ... Read more »

Galaxy Digital Wins Celsius Bankruptcy Auction to Acquire Crypto Custodian GK8

GK8, one of the assets put up for auction during Celsius’ bankruptcy proceedings, will play a role in Galaxy Digital’s institutional offering. Read more »

Federal judge orders sanctions for Kari Lake’s legal team in response to voting equipment lawsuit

Kari Lake speaking in Grapevine, Texas in June 2021 After Democratic Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs defeated far-right MAGA Republican Kari Lake in Arizona’s 2022 gubernatorial election, conservative Republican ... Read more »

Young Rock's Bradley Constant Loves How Growing Out His Mustache Transforms Him Into Dwayne Johnson – Exclusive

NBC Playing a teenage version of Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson may seem daunting, but “Young Rock” star Bradley Constant is taking it all in stride. “It’s exciting; it’s surreal,” said ... Read more »

Here's How Law & Order: SVU's Chris Meloni Feels About Working With Mariska Hargitay

Rob Kim/Getty Images They were a TV duo unlike any other — Elliot Stabler and Olivia Benson, the legendary “Law & Order: Special Victims Unit” cops played by Christopher Meloni and ... Read more »

Women Talking Review: A Potent Portrayal Of Protest

United Artists EDITORS’ RATING: 8/10 Pros Excellent ensemble cast Thought-provoking conversations about faith, freedom, and feminism Cons Dialogue-driven narrative can be stagey at times With “She Said” and, now, “Women ... Read more »

Netflix Swings The Cancellation Ax In The Direction Of Deserting Creator Mike Flanagan

Kathy Hutchins/Shutterstock Mike Flanagan certainly took his time and effort on Netflix and built up quite the reputation for creative scares and horror. Known for series like “The Haunting of ... Read more »

11 face death over conservationist's murder in Tanzania

11 face death over conservationist's murder in Tanzania A court in Tanzania has sentenced 11 people to death for the murder of a conservationist there NAIROBI, Kenya — A high ... Read more »

Biden plans to meet Prince William in Boston

Biden plans to meet Prince William in Boston The British royals are stateside for the Earthshot Prize Ceremony. President Joe Biden plans to meet Prince William on Friday during the ... Read more »

Biden seeks seismic shift in primary system, putting South Carolina first: The Note

Biden seeks seismic shift in primary system, putting South Carolina first: The Note The president looks stronger post-midterms and amid more hopeful economic news. The TAKE with Rick Klein The ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network