ALICE Active-Shooter Drills Saved Dozens of Oxford HS Students, Exec Claims

As gunshots rang out inside Michigan’s Oxford High School last week, terrified students scrambled for shelter, barricading classroom doors with desks and chairs should the gunman try to burst inside. Some wielded scissors and calculators as makeshift weapons in case they had to fight back.

One student, 16-year-old star running back Tate Myre, was reportedly shot as he charged toward the gunman in an attempt to stop the mayhem. He died while being rushed to the hospital in the back of a deputy’s squad car.

Sign up here for The 74’s daily newsletter. Donate here to support The 74's independent journalism.

For many, the scene symbolized a harrowing reality: After years of routine drills, the school’s students — members of the “lockdown generation” — seemed to know how they should act under fire. For the ALICE Training Institute, among the country’s most controversial school security groups, scenes from inside the school were validating. Oxford students underwent ALICE’s active-shooter training in October, a fact that Oakland County Sheriff Mike Bouchard said likely saved lives.

The Oxford community “would have seen three to 10 X the number of deaths” without the company’s guidance, JP Guilbault, CEO of Navigate360, which owns ALICE, told The 74. Such casualty claims would have made the Oxford shooting — where four students were killed and six students and one teacher injured — the worst mass school shooting in U.S. history.

“Based on student accounts, it was clear to me the school went well into preparing their kids for something they hoped they would never see,” said Guilbault, who leads the country’s largest for-profit provider of active-shooter drills. “But those kids were prepared.”

Almost all schools in America conduct active shooter drills despite a growing concern in recent years that they’re ineffective and traumatize students who are forced to grapple with their mortality on a regular basis. Dubbed “America’s scariest school shooter drills” by one news outlet, ALICE has repeatedly found itself at the forefront of controversy. In a 2019 ALICE training incident, for example, law enforcement officers who led a mock school shooting shot Indiana teachers with plastic airsoft pellets, leaving welts and bruises on the unsuspecting educators. The episode led school safety experts to denounce the drills.

Now, the high-profile Nov. 30 shooting in Oxford, which resulted in the very rare circumstance of both the 15-year-old suspected gunman and his parents being charged, has reignited a tense debate about how to prepare students for the possibility that they could find themselves under attack. In a letter, Oxford Community Schools Superintendent Tim Throne said the district plans to hire an outside security consultant to review its safety practices.

An “active shooter” is tackled as he attacks a classroom during ALICE (Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter and Evacuate) training at the Harry S. Truman High School in Levittown, Pennsylvania, on Nov. 3, 2015. (Jewel Samad / Getty Images)

ALICE — an acronym for Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter and Evacuate — employs a model that goes far beyond traditional lockdown drills that the company and its proponents say offers a toolbox of options as an attack unfolds and increases students’ odds of survival. Yet critics argue the institute’s training doesn’t just traumatize children, but could put them at greater risk of getting killed.

Traditional lockdowns teach children to bolt classroom doors, turn off the lights, move as far away from windows and doors as possible, stay completely silent and wait for emergency responders to arrive with help. Along with locking doors, “multi-options” approaches like ALICE teach students to barricade the doors with desks, chairs and other environmental objects and to self-evacuate if they feel it’s safe. As a last resort, ALICE teaches students to “counter” — or fight — the gunman.

Teaching kids to fight off a gunman is by far ALICE’s most contentious lesson. But Guilbault, the CEO, said that traditional lockdowns teach students “to just sit in place” and conditions “the natural freeze process” when confronted with a deadly threat. By presenting multiple avenues of response, Guilbault said, ALICE strengthens students’ chances of coming out of such lethal encounters alive. The factors most critical to survival, he said, are “time and distance.”

“Should a door get breached, your job is to figure out how to give yourself time and distance,” including through distraction techniques like throwing books and other classroom supplies, he said. “It’s clear the kids were getting ready, if that door was breached, to throw objects and to give themselves the best chance of surviving.”

People attend a vigil downtown on Dec. 3 to honor those killed and wounded during the recent shooting at Oxford High School in Oxford, Michigan. (Scott Olson/Getty Images)

In one viral video, a classroom of students were shown engaging with someone through a barricaded door who identifies himself as a member of the sheriff’s office. Skeptical of the man who tells them “it’s safe to come out,” students flee the room through a window. Guilbault said the students made the right decision when they refused to open the door because they were unsure who stood on the other side. Yet he said he would have instructed them to remain silent rather than engage in a conversation with the man. The sheriff later said the man was not the gunman, but was most likely a plainclothes police officer.

Though Guilbault declined to comment on reports that Myre, one of the shooting victims, had charged toward the gunman, he advised against the strategy.

“Fighting is a last resort,” he said. “We teach individuals that are not first responders to move away from danger, not towards it.

Drills raise competing philosophies

School safety consultant Kenneth Trump, the president of Cleveland-Based National School Safety and Security Services, is among the institute’s most outspoken critics. K-12 students’ brains haven’t fully developed and many lack the capacity to fight off a gunman, Trump said. Meanwhile, students self-evacuating from the school could increase their odds of getting shot, he said, while inhibiting police officers’ ability to pursue the shooter.

Students are being asked “to make split-second decisions that trained law enforcement and military professionals still struggle with” when confronting an armed gunman, said Trump, who endorses traditional lockdowns during active shootings.

Research on the efficacy of active-shooter drills is limited, but one 2018 report in the peer-reviewed Journal of School Violence used simulations to test ALICE against traditional lockdown drills. Traditional lockdown drills ended when the shooter ran out of ammunition, researchers found, while participants using ALICE techniques were able to thwart the attacker. The study’s results, the authors wrote in an op-ed, “brings into serious question if traditional lockdown should still be considered as the sole response to these types of events.” The sophomore charged in the Oxford shooting had 18 rounds of ammunition still on him when he quickly surrendered to police.

Trump challenged the study’s independence and rigor. One author works for ALICE and the others are certified ALICE instructors. Police officers made up a large share of simulation participants and children weren’t included.

Study co-author Cheryl Lero Jonson, an associate criminal justice professor at Xavier University in Cincinnati, Ohio, denied that any conflicts of interest exist between her being a certified ALICE instructor and her research.

ALICE relies on a train-the-trainer model to put its method in front of millions of kids across the country each year. Through a two-day course, educators and police learn the ins and outs of the approach before passing its lessons on to youth. Guilbault said that multiple Oxford officials are ALICE instructors and the district has been a customer for several years, but declined to comment on who went through the company’s certification process.

“We don’t put smoke in a school to practice for fire or big fans in the school to practice for a tornado. Personally, what I think is happening, it’s rogue instructors.”

—Cheryl Lero Jonson, associate criminal justice professor and certified ALICE instructor

ALICE’s train-the-trainer model allows for a wide degree of variability, Guilbault said. Oftentimes, the drills are conducted by local police, who are accustomed to tactical training, and are conducted to mimic real-world shooting simulations — a tactic Guilbault said “is common in law enforcement, but it’s not applicable for kids or teachers.” Numerous examples suggest such simulations have long been used by ALICE trainers. Guilbault said that ALICE instructors must take students’ age into consideration.

The result, Trump argued, is a training model that resembles the “telephone game” that’s left some districts undergoing full-scale simulations that resemble real-world mass shootings.

“It leaves a lot of room for interpretation to the point where we’ve seen some very extreme cases” including incidents where administrators told kids to keep cans of soup under their desk to throw at any potential gunmen. “Those variations have left people scratching their heads going, ‘What are you thinking?’”

Johnson said that ALICE “adamantly opposes’ full-scale active shooter simulations with weapons and fake blood because it “causes undue trauma” in children.

“We don’t put smoke in a school to practice for fire or big fans in the school to practice for a tornado,” she said while acknowledging that simulations have been central to multiple ALICE-related controversies. “Personally, what I think is happening, it’s rogue instructors.”

“Students” barricade a door of a classroom to block an “active shooter” during ALICE (Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter and Evacuate) training at the Harry S. Truman High School in Levittown, Pennsylvania, on Nov. 3, 2015. (Jewel Samad / Getty Images)

Drills prompt psychological concerns

Some education leaders and school safety experts have challenged the premise of active shooter drills altogether, pointing to a growing concern that active-shooter drills traumatize the kids who are forced to endure them.

Last year, the American Federation of Teachers, the National Education Association and the Everytown for Gun Safety Support Fund called for an end to unannounced active-shooter drills that simulate gun violence. Also in 2020, Everytown researchers analyzed about 28 million social media posts and found the timing of active shooter drills were correlated with an uptick in posts that signaled stress, anxiety and depression among students, parents and teachers.

Jonson, the Xavier University researcher, has pushed back. In a report last year, she found that students are no more fearful of ALICE training than tornado drills. Just 1 in 10 surveyed students reported feeling a negative psychological outcome from ALICE. The 2019 survey was conducted in a single unidentified school district in the Midwest, which used discussion-based instruction rather than simulations.

Forensic psychologist Jillian Peterson, an associate criminal justice professor at Hamline University in St. Paul, Minnesota and co-founder of The Violence Project, said the national conversation about school shootings has focused too much attention on “target hardening” and responding to shootings rather than heading off the tragedies from unfolding in the first place. Peterson promotes a greater emphasis on preventative strategies like improving mental health supports in schools, creating welcoming campus environments and establishing anonymous reporting tools where students can alert the authorities to their peers’ troubling behaviors.

On two occasions just before the Oxford shooting, teachers sounded the alarm about the suspected gunman’s concerning behavior. On the morning of the shooting, the student and his parents met with guidance counselors to discuss his behaviors but he was ultimately allowed to return to class. Several hours later, police say, he walked out of a school bathroom and opened fire. The factors leading up to the shooting will likely be explored in the independent review of the school’s actions

“What was that experience for this perpetrator when he went through this ALICE training a month ago?”

—Jillian Peterson, associate criminal justice professor and co-founder, The Violence Project

Active shooter drills in particular, Peterson said, fail to account for a reality that most school shooters are insiders. Her research has found that 91 percent of school shootings are carried out by current or former students. Along with concerns the drills could lead to heightened anxiety and increase the perception that statistically rare school shootings are commonplace, Peterson said that active shooter drills — including the one recently carried out in Oxford — could teach gunmen how officials will react under siege.

“If it’s an insider going through all of that with everybody else, with all of that information, then that approach just stops making a lot of sense,” Peterson said. “But that also opens up all of these new avenues where you can say, ‘Hey, it’s a kid in this school who is going to do this. How do we make sure, as a school, that none of these kids are going to want to do this?’”

Meanwhile, there’s a growing concern that school shootings are “socially contagious,” in which one mass shooting has a tendency to spark additional violence in the immediate aftermath as vulnerable people considering violence seek fame after reading about shootings and identifying with the gunman. Following the Oxford shooting, schools nationwide were confronted with a wave of “copycat” threats.

Frequent active shooter drills, Peterson worries, could plant a seed by placing so much attention on school shooting preparedness.

“When we’re running students through this over and over and over again, what is that doing in terms of increasing fascination, in terms of having students think through this again and again?” she asked. “What was that experience for this perpetrator when he went through this ALICE training a month ago?”

News Related


Ghost hunters capture ‘smelly 6ft ghost' at one of Britain's most haunted buildings

A CRACK team of ghost hunters say they've run into a six-foot tall spirit – that stinks of BO. The team had been casing the historic and apparently haunted Bolling ... Read more »

New York's leaders: Heed the lament of Det. Jason Rivera's widow

Dominique Luzuriaga, Detective Jason Rivera’s widow ripped DA Bragg’s soft-on-crime policies. The funeral of Det. Jason Rivera was a sad, solemn affair, as hundreds of police officers from near and ... Read more »

Joe Biden to send US troops to Eastern Europe

© Provided by DW US President Joe Biden said Friday he will soon send a small number of US troops to bolster the NATO presence in Eastern Europe amid concerns ... Read more »

Manny Pacquiao: 'Ramdam ko ang nararamdaman ng mamamayang Pilipino'

Leading contenders for the presidency share their views on a number of issues in one-on-one interviews with “Asia’s King of Talk” Boy Abunda. During the presidential interviews, candidates answered the ... Read more »

U.S. Senator Brown says 'no question' Biden's Fed nominees qualified

© Reuters/Elizabeth Frantz FILE PHOTO: Potential 2020 Democratic presidential candidate Brown (D-OH) speaks at a meet and greet on his “Dignity of Work” tour in Concord NEW YORK (Reuters) – ... Read more »

Rutscht ihm hier seine Kandidatur 2024 raus?: Trump ernennt sich auf Golfplatz zum 47. Präsidenten

Donald Trump war der 45. Präsident der USA. Sich selbst nennt er nun auch den 47. Präsidenten des Landes. Das zeigt ein Video auf dem Golfplatz. © Instagram Trump ernennt ... Read more »

Emily Ratajkowski wows in colorful bikini with leopard print coat during snowy photoshoot... as the model sports red tresses

She launched her brand Inamorata in 2017, later expanding to bodywear and lingerie two years later. And on Friday, Emily Ratajkowski posed up a storm in a bikini from her ... Read more »

Death In Paradise fans brought to tears as Florence makes emotional shock exit

TONIGHT'S episode of Death In Paradise left viewers shocked after main character DS Florence Cassell departed the series. Fans were distraught after the intense episode ended with the heroine announcing ... Read more »

IMF urges El Salvador to scale back its Bitcoin push

The Associated PressFILE – “We accept Bitcoin” is announced at a barber shop in Santa Tecla, El Salvador, Sept. 4, 2021. The IMF urged the government of El Salvador on ... Read more »

Eight Russell Group universities STILL won't pull the plug on virtual learning despite ministers' pleas for face-to-face tuition

The eight universities have kept at least a portion online since restrictions liftedOnly six said they could guarantee all teaching would be in-personSome are keeping large lectures remote while holding smaller sessions in person Comes after Education Secretary urged students to consider taking action against universities holding zoom lectures   Read more »

Detached houses are worth over £420,000 on average as prices grow twice as fast as smaller homes - after lockdowns and work from home restrictions left buyers hungry for more space

Detached homes are worth more than £420,000 on average as prices have soared at almost double the rate of smaller properties The average standalone house in the UK has jumped by 16.6 per cent or £60,556 since the start of the pandemic The biggest spike was in Wales, where terrace houses shot up by 25.1 per cent  Read more »

Sue Gray 'is told about Carrie partygate messages': PM's wife 'offered to organise cake for lockdown-breaking party' - and investigator is 'furious' at Met for redacting report that is set to be published next week

Carrie Johnson, 33, is believed to have organised a cake for Boris Johnson's 56th birthday party in June 2020 She allegedly instigated the gathering by asking senior official to get staff together to celebrate the occasionMeanwhile, Sue Gray is said to be furious that the Met Police have asked for a redacted version of her reportPolice confirmed it asked for only 'minimal references' to the No 10 'parties' at centre of the row to be in report Read more »

Devout Catholic Mel Gibson says the church needs to do some 'housecleaning' and 'get back to basics' following series of scandals as he attempts to reframe institution in new faith-based redemption movie 'Father Stu'

Mel Gibson says he believes the Catholic Church should undergo a 'housecleaning' following years of scandals that have destroyed its reputationThe Catholic actor is soon to star in a faith-based redemption movie, Father Stu, which recalls Father Stuart Long, the life of a boxer-turned-priestGibson said his involvement in the movie is part of an effort to reframe the church, as a place for goodGibson is a passionate member of the Catholic Traditionalist movementThe Catholic sect rejects the reforms of the Second Vatican Council in 1964-65 Gibson has also faced opposition in recent years with some accusing him of anti-Semitism and racism, including infamous rant with LAPD officer in 2006 Read more »

Video: How a 90-second speech lit the fuse that helped blow up the EU: Nigel Farage's seismic Brexit triumph makes him one of the most significant politicians of the age, writes MICHAEL CRICK - but snobbery means he has too often been sidelined by history

Read more »

Dylan Alcott and his sexologist girlfriend Chantelle Otten pack on the PDA following a presentation for his retirement at The Australian Open

Dylan Alcott recently retired from professional tennis. And on Thursday, the Paralympic sportsman was showered with congratulatory kisses to celebrate his career milestone.  Dylan, 31, was joined by his sexologist ... Read more »

Leo horoscope today 29 Jan 2022: Income will be good!

Leo horoscope today 29 Jan 2022: Income will be good! What will your day look like in terms of health, romance, finance and fortune? Read everything here. Prediction: Business will ... Read more »

Pendedahan TMJ mengejutkan!

© Provided by Sinar Harian PENDEDAHAN pemilik Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT), Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim mengenai beberapa isu berbangkit membabitkan Persatuan Bola Sepak Malaysia (FAM) dan skuad Harimau Malaya nyata ... Read more »

‘BAM ikut proses sepatutnya'

© Provided by Sinar Harian KEPUTUSAN menarik balik ‘penggantungan’ dua tahun terhadap Lee Zii Jia dan Goh Jin Wei dilaksanakan mengikut proses yang sepatutnya dan bukan disebabkan arahan daripada Perdana ... Read more »

Bad boy footy star Jordan De Goey enters guilty plea over brawl at a New York bar and is forced to undergo anger management therapy

Jordan De Goey pleaded guilty to harassment charge following New York brawlCollingwood star ordered to attend 10 alcohol and anger management sessionsDe Goey had visited The Dream Hotel's PHD Rooftop Lounge in October 2021  Read more »

‘Ozark' co-star Alfonso Herrera on Javi's ‘dark presence'

Alfonso Herrera plays quick-tempered, trigger-happy Javier “Javi” Elizondro in Season 4 of “Ozark.” COURTESY OF NETFLIX Warning: Spoilers ahead for Season 4 of “Ozark.” “Ozark” fans saw Javier “Javi” Elizondro ... Read more »

Over-65s may go without food or heat to cope with energy bill rises, says Age UK

© PA Archive Energy bills Nearly a quarter (24%) of older people believe they will be forced to choose between heating their home and the food they buy if their ... Read more »

Lung abnormalities found in long Covid patients with breathlessness

© PA Wire Lung abnormalities have been found in long Covid patients with breathlessness (David Davies/PA) Researchers have discovered abnormalities in the lungs of long Covid patients who have breathlessness ... Read more »

Limerick criminals ‘doing high-fives' over ‘bonkers' decision to remove CCTV cameras

Criminals in Limerick are doing ‘high-fives and handstands’ as 90% of CCTV cameras in towns and villages have been ordered to switch off due to data protection laws, a councillor ... Read more »

What will next week's Russian manoeuvres off Ireland look like and what's the overall strategy?

RUSSIAN MILITARY EXERCISES some 240km off the south-west coast of Ireland are set to get underway from next Thursday.  The Journal first broke news of the development on Saturday morning last ... Read more »

Winds up to 80mph set to batter northern UK as Storm Malik sweeps in

© PA Archive Blustery Weather Gusts of up to 80mph could batter northern areas of the UK this weekend as Storm Malik sweeps in. Yellow weather warnings are in place ... Read more »

Boris Johnson to visit Ukraine region and hold call with Putin next week

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Vadim Ghirdă/AP Boris Johnson will visit the Ukraine region and hold a crisis talks with Vladimir Putin next week amid fears of a Russian ... Read more »

‘Saingan BN di Johor adalah PH, bukan Bersatu'

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Khaled Nordin berkata keyakinan Umno-BN dalam menghadapi PRN kali ini terbit daripada prestasi ditunjukkan Pakatan Harapan dan Perikatan Nasional sepanjang kedua-dua gabungan itu memerintah ... Read more »

British man, 70, 'dies inside 'happy ending' massage parlour' in Thai 'Sin City' of Pattaya after 'falling asleep and choking' during experience

John Swain died during the experience after falling asleep and chokingHe was receiving a massage at the 'Lovely Massage' shop in Pattaya, ThailandPattaya's officials have been trying to shake the city's image as 'Thai Sin City'  Read more »

Video: Furious bereaved families, ex-cops and MPs accuse 'incompetent' Met chief of a Partygate 'stitch up' as police order Sue Gray to water down report - with a redacted version set to be released next week but the full verdict could take MONTHS 

Read more »

Video: Electric car owners are told to display a warning sign and park close to the charge point so passers-by don't trip over cables in Highway Code update

Read more »

Halle Berry: I always have something to prove

© Bang Showbiz Halle Berry feels she has to prove herself Halle Berry thinks she’s always having to “prove” herself. The Oscar-winning actress is one of the best-known stars in ... Read more »

Stanley Tucci's sense of taste is 'stronger than ever'

© Bang Showbiz Stanley Tucci’s sense of taste is stronger than ever Stanley Tucci’s sense of taste and smell are stronger than ever following his cancer treatment. The 61-year-old actor ... Read more »

Gen Zers going viral for practicing celebacy

People have taken to TikTok to describe the benefits that staying celibate has provided for them. princesshyngle/TikTok; jordanjep Generation Z has declared TikTok a no sex zone. Users on the ... Read more »

Why Adams must build a new psych hospital for the mentally-ill homeless on Rikers

Mayor Eric Adams should utilize space freed up on Rikers Island to create an inpatient psychiatric hospital to treat the city’s mentally ill homeless. Getty Images Two urgent issues facing ... Read more »

Netflix and Mattel developing live-action He-Man ‘Masters of the Universe' movie

“West Side Story” actor Kyle Allen will star as Prince Adam, aka He-Man, in the live-action movie being produced by Netflix and Mattel. WireImage; Courtesy Everett Coll Mattel and Netflix are ... Read more »

Ground squirrels ability to burn almost no energy during hibernation holds the key to the future of long-duration human space travel, scientists claim

Researchers designed an experiment to track urea in hibernating squirrelsThey proved a theory that urea is turned into nitrogen and then muscle tissueThis is used to replace lost muscle tissue from a lack of food during hibernationThe gut microbiome in squirrels is the engine room of this production processAuthors predict one day a pill could allow humans to produce muscle this way  Read more »

The Premier League is on a break, so it's time for the Championship to take centre stage... so get set for big spenders like Bournemouth, Wayne Rooney's basket case at Derby and bags of drama

As the Premier League takes a break, England's second tier takes centre stage Fulham are on course to become first Championship era side to score 100 goalsBlackburn have kicked on, despite losing Adam Armstrong to Southampton  ew expected QPR and Huddersfield to be jostling in the second-tier play-offs Read more »

Stoke City closing in on a loan deal for Josh Maja as Potters manager Michael O'Neill hopes former Sunderland striker can fire his team to promotion

Stoke City eager to add Josh Maja to their squad and bolster attacking optionsPotters are close to finalise loan deal with Bordeaux for 23-year-old forward Former Sunderland striker has missed three months of the season with injuryMaja scored three goals in 15 appearances while on loan at Fulham last season  Read more »

Menopausal staff should be given the same protection against discrimination as victims of racism, say lawyers

Discrimination Law Association (DLA) has called for specific legal protections for women who are experiencing the 'change of life'Menopause should be treated as a 'protected characteristic' under the law, alongside sex, age, race and disability, the organisation saidWould be easier for women to take legal action against employers if they felt they were being discriminated against because they were going through menopause Read more »

9 Things You'll Love To Know About 'All Of Us Are Dead' Actress Cho Yi Hyun

© Provided by Cosmopolitan Philippines It’s no secret that South Korea has no shortage of talented actors of all ages. Apart from the OG actors we all know and love, ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic