Aimed at China, Russia, Biden's Summit for Democracy Must Not Turn into a Moral Class

Asia's Tech News Daily

Aimed at China, Russia, Biden’s Summit for Democracy Must Not Turn into a Moral Class
© Provided by News18 Aimed at China, Russia, Biden’s Summit for Democracy Must Not Turn into a Moral Class

President Biden, as promised, has announced a Summit for Democracy on December 9 and 10 in order to “galvanise commitments and initiatives across three principal themes: defending against authoritarianism, fighting corruption, and promoting respect for human rights”. He is seeking once again to assert US leadership in promoting democracy and human rights worldwide although America’s own credentials on both fronts have been damaged by the exposure of the deficiencies of its own electoral process that were exposed during the last presidential election when the losing incumbent challenged the integrity of the election, called the result illegitimate and allegedly instigated his supporters to occupy and desecrate the Capitol Hill, and so on. Biden himself in his inaugural address acknowledged the depth of the crisis facing America’s democracy because of sharpened political polarisation and racism in society, the severity of the latter erupting subsequently in the Black Lives Matter movement.

Biden believes that he could take this initiative as he had reinvigorated American democracy by vaccinating 70 per cent of its population, passing the American Rescue plan, advancing bipartisan legislation to invest in its infrastructure and competitiveness, rebuilding alliances with America’s democratic partners and allies, rallying the world to stand up against human rights abuses, addressing the climate crisis, and fighting the global pandemic, including by donating hundreds of millions of vaccine doses to countries around the globe.

Many would be sceptical about some of these claims. The US still has not succeeded in controlling the virus in some parts of the country, its vaccine generosity has been late in coming and still leaves large parts of the developing world effectively untouched. Handing over the country to the Taliban that has scant respect for human rights, especially that of women and minorities, has been a failure on the human rights front. The Summit for Democracy is being convened at a time when the US still has not sufficiently removed the taints on the functioning of its democratic institutions and the fissures in its society. What also detracts from the impact of this initiative is the state of democracies in the West in general, the public sentiment about their having become dysfunctional and the sense of alienation this has bred, along with the growth of right-wing nationalism, both in the US and Europe.

US vs Russia and China?

The Summit for Democracy represents an enduring element of US foreign policy, namely, the promotion of democracy worldwide, almost as a crusade. The Cold War was fought as a struggle between democracy and communism. After the Soviet Union’s collapse and that of communism as an ideology, a triumphant US advanced its democracy agenda by regime changes in West Asia, the colour revolutions in Georgia, Ukraine and some Central Asian states and the Arab Spring phenomenon. In Venezuela and some other Latin American states, democracy promotion has been pursued with political and economic means. It is currently being pushed in Belarus.

The political motivation behind this democracy initiative is to forge a front under US leadership against authoritarianism, which essentially means China and Russia. Moscow has been under great pressure on democratic freedoms and human rights over treatment meted out to the political opposition as in the case of Alexei Navalny in particular, the prolongation of President Putin’s grip over power through constitutional amendments, LGTBQ issues and the like. China is under attack for its authoritarian model and violations of human rights of the Uighurs and Tibetans and suppression of freedoms in Hong Kong etc.

The US is now treating both Russia and China as adversaries. That China is presenting its model of political and economic governance as superior to that of western democracies for the developing countries is seen as a challenge. If the Summit for Democracy is intended to isolate China and Russia on democracy and human rights issues at the international level, that objective is hardly likely to be achieved. At the March 2021 meeting in Alaska between Secretary of State Antony Blinken and the Chinese Communist Party’s foreign affairs chief Yang Jiechi, the latter upbraided the former on the state of democracy and human rights in the US itself. At the November 2021 Biden-Xi virtual meeting, the Chinese president lectured the US president on the issue of democracy, reminding him that democracy was not mass produced with a uniform model for everyone, and that dismissing forms of democracy that are different from one’s own was in itself undemocratic.

China is not on the defensive on the issue of democracy or human rights. It has shown its clout both in the Human Rights Council in Geneva and the UNGA Human Rights Committee in New York when it mobilised support from a large number of countries, including several leading Islamic states, on the Uighur issue on which the US-led western countries sought to condemn China.

Nor is Russia defensive. Putin believes that “Russian democracy is the power of the Russian people with their own traditions of national self-government, and not the realisation of standards foisted on us from outside” and that “democracy cannot be exported to some other place. This must be a product of internal domestic development in a society”. In fact, Putin believes that the ideology that has underpinned Western democracies for decades has “outlived its purpose”.

Will This be a Moral Class?

Both Russia and China feel that the Summit for Democracy is a divisive initiative and they have criticised it. The Russian and Chinese ambassadors in the US have published a joint article in the publication The National Interest on November 26 calling the initiative a product of America’s Cold War mentality that is intended to stoke up ideological confrontation and a rift in the world and creating new “dividing lines”. It added that democracy can be realised in multiple ways, and no model can fit all countries. The article claimed that democracy is the fundamental principle of Russia’s political system and that the development of democracy there is closely connected to its culture and traditions.

The two ambassadors further said that democracy is not just about domestic governance; it should also be reflected in international relations, noting that “interfering in other countries’ internal affairs—under the pretext of fighting corruption, promoting democratic values, or protecting human rights… wielding the big stick of sanctions, and even infringing on their sovereignty, unity and territorial integrity go against the UN Charter and other basic norms of international law and are obviously anti-democratic.” They said further that “no country has the right to judge the world’s vast and varied political landscape by a single yardstick, and having other countries copy one’s political system through colour revolution, regime change and even use of force.” There is no need to worry about democracy in Russia and China, the ambassadors said, and called “on countries to stop using “value-based diplomacy” to provoke division and confrontation”.

America’s policies on the spread of democracy and protecting human rights have always been controversial as they are seen as marked by double standards and geopolitical objectives. The list of countries invited to the Summit reflects this criticism. The problem in drawing up such a list is that if one goes by strict selection criteria not many countries would be eligible, but if the criteria is not strict then those left out would feel doubly resentful, especially the leaders of those countries where the domestic opposition may use the exclusion to validate their accusation that the government was suppressing democracy at home. The US has invited 110 countries, with many anomalies. Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Bhutan have been excluded but Pakistan has been invited. Singapore, an ally and pivotal as a partner in ASEAN, has been excluded. The Democratic Republic of the Congo is in. Numerous island states have been invited for geopolitical reasons and not as examples of democracies: Tonga (population 106,000), St Kitts and Nevis (53,732), St Vincent and the Grenadines (110,000), St Lucia (184,000).

The net gain for the US to launch this initiative at this point in time is not too apparent. The US has announced that following a year of consultation, coordination, and action, President Biden will then invite world leaders to gather once more to showcase progress made against their commitments. Fighting corruption has also been included in the summit’s agenda. To seek commitments from participating countries implies that they would recognise their democratic and human rights deficit and promise improvement. Will this be a moral class?

Both the Summits “will bring together heads of state, civil society, philanthropy, and the private sector, serving as an opportunity for world leaders to listen to one another and to their citizens, share successes, drive international collaboration, and speak honestly about the challenges facing democracy so as to collectively strengthen the foundation for democratic renewal”. What will be the criteria for selecting civil society and private sector representatives? Will the US select them on behalf of other countries or it will be an open forum? Will the leaders have to listen to the criticism of elements of the civil society of their own countries in an international forum? These aspects of this initiative are unclear.

The author is Former Foreign Secretary. He was India’s Ambassador to Turkey, Egypt, France and Russia. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Read all the Latest News, Breaking News and Coronavirus News here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Nick Bosa clears concussion protocol will play for 49ers vs. Packers

© Roger Steinman / Associated Press San Francisco 49ers defensive end Nick Bosa (97) against the Dallas Cowboys during the first half of an NFL wild-card playoff football game in ... Read more »

How Putin’s obsession with NATO has led to the brink of war in Ukraine

© Provided by Yahoo! News In response to the rising threat of a Russian military invasion of Ukraine, NATO forces in the region have begun mobilizing. Spain announced Thursday that ... Read more »

Al Michaels isn't thinking retirement with NBC deal ending soon

Al Michaels is a free agent after he calls Super Bowl 2022 for NBC, and he does not have an eye towards retirement. Michaels, 77, appeared on HBO’s “Back On ... Read more »

DC Don 'Wink' Martindale, Ravens part ways

© Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports Don Martindale was the Ravens’ defensive coordinator for the past four seasons. Don Martindale will not lead the Ravens’ defense for a fifth season ... Read more »

Nick Jonas, Priyanka Chopra's astrological compatibility makes them perfect parents

Getty Images Global “It” couple, Nick Jonas, 29, and Priyanka Chopra, 39, have been enchanting the world for years — and now the duo is a trio! With news hitting ... Read more »

GOP Senate Favorite Adam Laxalt Backs Candidate Pushing FBI-Revenge Fantasy

© Provided by The Daily Beast Photo Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily Beast/Getty As attorney general of Nevada, Adam Laxalt was in charge of enforcing the law. But now that ... Read more »

Best Tea Towels

© Credits: Image by kaorinne on iStock A set of tea towels hanging in a kitchen We all need a decent set of tea towels in our lives, both for ... Read more »

Raiders CB Nate Hobbs cited for driving 110 mph 2 weeks after DUI arrest

© Provided by Raiders Wire Yes, Nate Hobbs is in the news for the wrong reasons again. The talented cornerback just completed a standout rookie season and while that’s all ... Read more »

Jurgen Klopp: 'Outstanding' Caoimhin Kelleher will start Carabao Cup final against Chelsea

JURGEN KLOPP HAS described Caoimhin Kelleher as “outstanding” following the Ireland goalkeeper’s latest impressive display for Liverpool. The Liverpool boss has confirmed that he intends to start Kelleher in next ... Read more »

Celebrity Coach Trip's Linda and Lesley crowned 'deserving' winners in final

Celebrity Coach Trip stars Linda Robson and Lesley Joseph have been crowned this year’s winners. After a two-year break from screens, the couple went on to win the iconic E4 ... Read more »

Philly sports talk host John Kincade has bought ‘' domain after Daryl Morey mention

© Provided by Awful Announcing On Thursday, Philadelphia 76ers GM Daryl Morey caused a stir by calling out a Twitter account named “Ballsack Sports” over a “report” on a potential ... Read more »

Megan Cusack still cringes at her nerve-racking first day on set

There’s little surprise that Megan Cusack, who plays new midwife Nancy Corrigan in Call The Midwife, ended up an actress. She comes from the hugely successful Cusack dynasty.  Her grandparents Maureen and ... Read more »

‘Career privilege' – Ryan Tubridy's emotional message to nation on historic night

Ryan Tubridy gave a heartfelt message to the Irish people on tonight’s The Late Late Show as restrictions were lifted. In his opening remarks, Ryan paid tribute to the audience ... Read more »

Premier League predictions: Jones Knows says back Everton to beat Aston Villa

Watch Watford vs Norwich, Southampton vs Manchester City, Crystal Palace vs Liverpool and Chelsea vs Tottenham all live on Sky Sports Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Arsenal will offer Mikel Arteta new two-year deal

Arsenal are set to offer Mikel Arteta a new contract before the end of the season to prevent their manager entering the final 12 months of his deal. Club chiefs ... Read more »

Strictly's Maisie Smith and Tilly Ramsay wow in glam snap as the show's tour begins

STRICTLY'S Maisie Smith and Tilly Ramsay wow in glam snap as the show's tour begins. The BBC One show's live tour kicked off at the Utilita Arena in Birmingham last ... Read more »

Bears complete interviews with Leslie Frazier, Ryan Poles

The Bears’ head coaching and General Manager searches continued on Friday. The team announced that they have completed interviews with Bills defensive coordinator Leslie Frazier for the coaching vacancy. They ... Read more »

Saturn's 'Death Star' moon may have a secret ocean, revealing a new category of worlds that could host alien life

© Provided by Business Insider NASA’s Cassini spacecraft took the most detailed photo to date of Mimas on its closest flyby of the Saturn moon in 2010. NASA/JPL-Caltech/Space Science Institute ... Read more »

March for Life anti-abortion activists ready for the 'tipping point' of a Supreme Court ruling gutting Roe

© Stephanie Keith/Bloomberg/Getty Images Demonstrators hold signs during the annual March For Life on the National Mall in Washington, D.C., U.S., on Friday, Jan. 21, 2022. Attendees of Friday’s March ... Read more »

Donald Trump wants to have his cake and eat it too

There’s a report in Politico today that former President Donald Trump is considering endorsing multiple candidates in a single race — most notably in contested Senate Republican primaries. © Brandon ... Read more »

Report: Rockets interested in John Wall-for-Russell Westbrook trade with Lakers

© Provided by Sporting News The Rockets are open to a trade in which Russell Westbrook could be brought back to the team, according to NBA Insider Marc Stein. Per ... Read more »

‘Perfectionist' Adele halted Vegas shows after managers ‘wanted 60-strong choir' when she asked for ‘low-key' production

'PERFECTIONIST' Adele allegedly cancelled her Las Vegas shows after managers tried to make her perform with a 60-strong choir. The star, who reportedly wanted the production to be low-key, wept ... Read more »

What to spend coins on in Angry Birds Journey

© Provided by GamePur It becomes apparent early on in Angry Birds Journey that coins can be earned by the masses just by finishing a few levels. Better yet, completing ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15, 21 January 2022, Written Update: Tejasswi wins the ticket to finale

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, the second last round of decorating mannequins is between Tejasswi Prakash, Devoleena Bhattacharjee, and Rashami Desai. As the game begins, Karan Kundrra and ... Read more »

How to customize your Quick Chat messages in Pokémon UNITE

© Provided by Dot Esports Pokémon UNITE has added a lot of new features since the game launched. In one of its most recent updates, TiMi Studio has enabled the ... Read more »

Russell Westbrook was more disappointed in Lakers loss than benching

Russell Westbrook saw the bigger picture in his response to being benched in the final minutes of Wednesday’s 111-104 loss to the Pacers. “I was disappointed I didn’t go back ... Read more »

Star Hobson's evil killer ‘splurged £9,000 on diamond-studded Rolex watches for nephews' while in ‘cushy' prison

STAR Hobson’s evil killer has been on a spending spree while behind bars – splurging out £9,000 on diamond studded Rolex watches for her nephews. Savannah Brockhill, 28, is serving ... Read more »

Bitcoin falls 9.3% to $36,955

(Reuters) – Bitcoin dropped 9.28% to $36,955.03 at 22:02 GMT on Friday, losing $3,781.02 from its previous close. © Reuters/Dado Ruvic FILE PHOTO: A representation of virtual currency Bitcoin is ... Read more »

Report: Giants to interview Bills' Brian Daboll, Leslie Frazier on Saturday

© Rich Barnes-USA TODAY Sports Brian Daboll is the Buffalo Bills’ offensive coordinator who has turned the very raw Josh Allen into an NFL superstar. A very creative presence who ... Read more »

Nick Bosa clears concussion protocol, will play vs. Green Bay

© Provided by Niners Wire The 49ers on Friday announced defensive end Nick Bosa cleared concussion protocol. His ‘questionable’ status for Saturday’s divisional playoff game has been lifted and he’ll ... Read more »

49ers vs. Packers: 3 bold predictions, including final score and winner

© Provided by Fansided The Green Bay Packers will take on the San Francisco 49ers with a trip to the NFC Championship Game on the line Saturday night. A pair of NFC ... Read more »

John Harbaugh Announces Ravens Have Parted Ways With DC Don ‘Wink' Martindale

© Provided by The Spun John Harbaugh looks as on the coach of the Ravens. Last year, Don “Wink” Martindale was considered a candidate for a head coaching job. One ... Read more »

Congress's win will be my biggest apology, says Harak, rejoins party

© Provided by The Times of India DEHRADUN: Less than a week after being expelled from BJP, former Uttarakhand forest minister Harak Singh Rawat joined Congress on Friday. This was ... Read more »

ADA Regularisation HC sets aside order year of Punjab govt

© Provided by The Indian Express The Punjab and Haryana High Court while disposing of a bunch of petitions have set aside order of year 2013 of the Punjab Government ... Read more »

Louie Anderson was an 'expert in the craft of comedy'

© Bang Showbiz Louie Anderson has been praised by his showbiz friends Bryan Cranston has hailed Louie Anderson as an “expert in the craft of comedy”. The actor passed away ... Read more »

Five years and a crackdown that ended up in nought

© Provided by The Indian Express On December 25 last year, Punjab transport minister, Amrinder Singh Raja Warring, dashed to a private hotel in Amritsar to confront Delhi Chief Minister ... Read more »

Raiders Reportedly Interviewing Another GM Candidate Today

© Provided by The Spun A wide view of the Las Vegas Raiders home field. Earlier this week, the Las Vegas Raiders fired general manager Mike Mayock. The search has ... Read more »

Brian Laundrie admitted to killing Gabby Petito in ‘suicide note' in notebook & used texts to pretend she was alive

BRIAN Laundrie admitted to killing Gabby Petito in his notebook and used fake texts to mislead the police, the FBI has revealed. The agency issued the statement just one day ... Read more »

UK Weather: Snow to sweep across the country next week as winter chill deepens after -7C Arctic plunge

SNOW will hit parts of the UK next week as winter's chill deepens following a sub-zero Arctic plunge. The mercury plummeted to -7C as far south as Dorset in the ... Read more »

Noel Gallagher's daughter Anais rebels against hellraiser dad – by promoting OAPs' shopping trolleys to youngsters

EX-OASIS hellraiser Noel Gallagher’s daughter ANAIS is rebelling against her dad – by promoting old people’s shopping trolleys to youngsters. The photographer, named after French erotic author Anais Nin — ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic