Aiia Maasarwe’s killer will not be jailed for life as appeal fails

See all newsletters

A pile of flowers lay in tribute where the body of Isreali student Aiia Maasarwe was found on January 17, 2019. Picture: AAP Image/Stefan PostlesSource:AAP

An attempt to jail a man for life for the brutal unprovoked murder of a woman on her way home in Melbourne has failed.

Codey Herrmann was sentenced in October 2019 to 36 years jail with 30 non-parole by the Supreme Court of Victoria for the rape and murder of Aiia Maasarwe.

Prosecutors had appealed arguing 30 years was not enough, but the Court of Appeal on Friday dismissed the case.

Ms Maasarwe, a Palestinian-Israeli international student, was only 21 when she was randomly attacked by Herrmann while she was FaceTiming her sister, walking in Bundoora on her way home from a comedy show.

Shortly after midnight on January 16, 2019, she was the victim of Herrmann’s unprovoked brutality.

See all newsletters

Codey Herrmann murdered Aiia Maasarwe. Picture: AAP Image/James RossSource:AAP

See all newsletters

Herrmann pictured after he was arrested and charged with the ‘inexplicable’ murder. Picture: Alex CoppelSource:News Corp Australia

He knocked her unconscious, dragged her into the bushes, assaulted her, and set her body on fire in a sickening and senseless act.

A bench of five judges — Chris Maxwell, Stephen Kaye, Richard Niall, Terrance Forrest, and Karin Emerton — said on Friday that Herrmann’s crimes were “deeply shocking” and “seemingly inexplicable”.

Herrmann had never been convicted of a crime before and his actions that day caused “extreme private grief and enormous public distress”, their reasons for judgment said.

But they said the sentencing judge Elizabeth Hollingworth had used great care and skill when making her decision not to sentence him to prison for life.

She had balanced Herrmann’s severe personality disorder and childhood of profound deprivation and trauma against the shocking facts of the crime, they said.

See all newsletters

International student Aiia Maasarwe was killed in Melbourne on January 16, 2019. Picture: InstagramSource:Inside Higher Ed

See all newsletters

Aiia Maasarwe uploaded this picture of herself skydiving to her Instagram account. Her family was left devastated by the senseless killing.Source:Instagram

“The expert evidence of Associate Professor Andrew Carroll, a forensic psychiatrist, established that Codey Herrmann’s severe personality disorder was the direct result of his childhood deprivation, and that there was a clear causal connection between his impaired mental functioning and the offending,” the judgment said.

The Party Games newsletter Get your political briefing from’s political editor Samantha Maiden.

The Party Games newsletter Success! Check your inbox for details. See all newsletters

“In our respectful view, her Honour was fully justified in viewing Codey Herrmann as less morally culpable for this atrocious conduct than a person who had not suffered such deprivation and impairment.”

Director of Public Prosecutions Kerri Judd QC told the court in an appeal hearing in March that Herrmann should be jailed for life to protect the community.

But his lawyer Tim Marsh had said a minimum of 30 years was an appropriate sentence.

He argued it was right that Herrmann’s young age, personality disorder, Aboriginal disadvantage and deprived upbringing were taken into account by sentencing judge Elizabeth Hollingworth.

See all newsletters

The nation was left reeling and in shock after Aiia Maasarwe was raped and murdered while studying in Melbourne in an unprovoked attack.Source:News Corp Australia

“The learned sentencing judge’s remarks and conclusions are unremarkable, uncontentious and balanced,” he said.

“(She) summarises the respondent’s developmental history, acknowledging the respondent’s infancy as one of extreme physical and emotional deprivation.

“She recognised, inferentially, that he ought not to be viewed in the same way as ‘a person who had had the advantage of a stable upbringing and whose values had been shaped by appropriate parenting’.”

Ms Judd had argued a minimum of 30 years for the murder was “manifestly inadequate”, but the Court of Appeal disagreed.

“Violent, unprovoked and sexually motivated offending against women in the public domain has an impact on the community as a whole,” Ms Judd said in March.

“(It) restricts the free movement of people within our society, particularly women.”

“This was a vicious, callous and intentional killing of an unsuspecting young woman.

Hermann could not explain his motive for the rape and murder other than that he “hated the world”, the court was told.

“The killing was perpetrated against a young woman who was a stranger to the respondent and who was simply walking home on a public street,” Ms Judd said.

Hermann, who was only 20 years old when he killed Ms Maasarwe, will be eligible for release in 2049.

News Related


Data modelling shows Sydney lockdown could stretch until September

An epidemiologist has blasted the NSW Premier for dismissing a data model that predicted it could take until September for the current lockdown rules to suppress the state’s coronavirus outbreak. ... Read more »

‘Burnt out' cyber security professionals can make organisations even more vulnerable

Security analysts in Singapore are overwhelmed. Relieving the burden of mundane, repetitive tasks can reduce their workloads. Read more »

Biden names Google critic Kanter as Justice Dept antitrust chief

Big Tech put on notice. Read more »

Some crew taken off virus-affected cargo ship and put in hotel quarantine

A crew member of the BBC California. Picture: Trevor Collens / AFPSource:AFP Three healthy crew members from a coronavirus-infected cargo ship docked in Perth have been moved to hotel quarantine ... Read more »

How to best understand your audience, without cookies

Without being able to track users online, advertisers will gradually lose visibility on learning about consumer behaviour. What can they do? Read more »

Billionaire Jeff Bezos has successful suborbital jaunt

Helps usher in a new era of space tourism. Read more »

Priming Telstra for growth in the Asia enterprise network landscape

Telstra’s advantages lie in its rich legacy in local markets, as well as intimate knowledge and experience with customers, where it can play a role as a trusted advisor. Read more »

Dexus signs on to develop $1.4bn Atlassian office tower

Software maker agrees to 15-year lease. Read more »

The network is key in providing the right AR/VR experience

The success of AR/VR technology depends on whether organisations possess the wherewithal to handle the intensive bandwidth and processing requirements. Can AR/VR be more boon than bane? Read more »

EPA Victoria signs $52m IT services deal with Empired

Transition to take six months. Read more »

Kaseya has working REvil decryption key

Customer data unscrambling operations started. Read more »

Equinix Australia leads group negotiation for access to renewable power

After its progress was criticised in report. Read more »

FSG, Optus to trial 'host neutral' radio network in Queensland

Tests new model to share mobile equipment with many access seekers. Read more »

Linux systemd bug allows denial of service attacks

Old Linux bugs come back to bite users. Read more »

Covid-19 Qld: zero new local cases

Queensland’s latest Covid-19 numbers have been released and zero new cases were recorded. Picture: NCA NewsWire/Tertius PickardSource:News Corp Australia Queensland has recorded zero new locally acquired Covid-19 cases on Saturday. ... Read more »

NBN roundtable returns focus to customer needs - and NBN Co's costs

Areas of scrutiny revealed. Read more »

‘We were pretty shocked': Melbourne man speaks out about contracting Covid-19 at AAMI Park

Zac (left) tested positive to Covid-19 after attending the Wallabies match at AAMI Park. Picture: 9NewsSource:NCA NewsWire A young Melbourne man has opened up about contracting Covid-19 at a “super ... Read more »

Covid-19 Victoria: 12 new local cases recorded

New locally acquired cases have been recorded in Victoria. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Ian CurrieSource:News Corp Australia Victoria has recorded 12 new locally acquired cases of Covid-19 on Saturday. In ... Read more »

The Project: Dr Norman Swan's brutal lockdown prognosis

Carrie Bickmore and Norman Swan on The Project. Picture: Channel 10.Source:Supplied A health expert has told The Project’s Carrie Bickmore that New South Wales “might not get over” its current ... Read more »

Anger at Prime Minister Scott Morrison grows over coronavirus failures

Prime Minister Scott Morrison. Picture: Gary RamageSource:News Corp Australia Backlash against the prime minister has grown overnight with Scott Morrison the topic of conversation from Australian screens to the UK. ... Read more »

Calls for tower apology, Victoria enters seventh day in lockdown

• This coronavirus article is unlocked and free to read in the interest of community health and safety. Click here for full digital access to trusted news from the Herald ... Read more »

Melbourne couple sentenced for owning and exercising power over a slave

Kandasamy and Kumuthini Kannan were jailed on Wednesday. Picture: Andrew Henshaw/NCA NewsWireSource:News Corp Australia Kumuthini Kannan sat rocking in her chair on Wednesday, the same way she had on numerous ... Read more »

Press Council Adjudication

.Source:News Regional Media The Press Council considered whether its Standards of Practice were breached by an article published by the Herald Sun online on 21 January 2021 headed “Mill Park ... Read more »

Live breaking news: Growing fears NSW has lost control of worsening Delta strain covid outbreaks across Sydney

LIVE Last updated July 22, 2021 7:27AM AEST There are growing fears NSW has lost control of the Delta outbreak. There are growing fears New South Wales has lost control ... Read more »

Covid-19 SA: Centrelink office added to huge list of exposure sites as lockdown continues

Centrelink at Modbury has become one of the latest Covid-19 exposure locations, listed by SA Health. Picture: Scott Barbour/Getty ImagesSource:Supplied A busy Centrelink office in Adelaide’s north eastern suburbs is ... Read more »

Katie Hopkins blasts Australia's leaders for ‘imprisoning' people amid lockdowns

Katie Hopkins takes to Instagram Live to criticise harsh lockdowns as she quarantines in Sydney.Source:Supplied Katie Hopkins has blasted Australia’s handling of the pandemic to her large international following, declaring ... Read more »

Farmer Wants A Wife star denies domestic violence allegations

Farmer Sam Messina.Source:Supplied Farmer Wants a Wife star Sam Messina has strongly denied seven alleged domestic violence offences against a former girlfriend. A Current Affair reported the bombshell allegations last ... Read more »

Gold Coast teen creates viral sensation after puffy corn chip attracts $20k bid on eBay

The corn chip now has bids of $20,300.Source:Supplied A Gold Coast teenager has become the centre of a viral sensation after her unique corn chip attracted bids of more than ... Read more »

Woman hits back after cruel letter accuses her of being a bad owner for leaving her dog in the car

An angry note was left by someone who saw Drake in the car on his own. Picture: An angry letter has left a Canberra local rattled after she found ... Read more »

Women separated from their partners during birth, pregnancy complications and miscarriage

A Sydney woman was forced to endure a traumatic procedure without her husband.Source:Supplied A Sydney woman who miscarried twins is among a growing cohort of women who say their treatment ... Read more »

PM pleads with Queenslanders eligible for AstraZeneca to get the ‘totally safe' vaccine now

​The PM insists AstraZeneca is ‘totally safe’, highlighting it has been given the ‘seal of approval’ from the TGA. Picture: Nikki Short / NCA NewsWireSource:News Corp Australia Prime Minister Scott ... Read more »

Sydney professor Dianne Jolley guilty of sending herself fake threatening letters

Former UTS professor Dianne Jolley has been found guilty of sending herself a bizarre series of fake threats. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Jeremy PiperSource:News Corp Australia A high-ranking Sydney academic ... Read more »

‘Man with bloody face' sought after fatal Newcastle shooting

A man was wounded in a daylight shooting in Newcastle on Thursday, officials have said. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Gaye GerardSource:News Corp Australia Newcastle police have asked the public to ... Read more »

Orient Futures in Singapore leverages Snowflake data analytics

Orient Futures Singapore aspires to be a ‘broker of the future’ by become intrinsically data driven. Read more »

ACCC to examine Amazon, eBay, Kogan and other marketplaces

Over rising competition concerns. Read more »

Brad Hazzard flags tough new mask exemption rule in fight against Delta Covid outbreak

Nurses are seen working at the Covid Testing clinic at Fairfield Showground, as essential workers in Sydney are now required to be tested every three days. Picture: NCA Newswire /Gaye ... Read more »

Sacked CEO refused to leave job at ritzy music school: court

The school teaches degrees, certificates and diplomas related to music and speech. Picture: iStockSource:istock A music school in one of Melbourne’s wealthiest suburbs is embroiled in a 17-month court battle ... Read more »

CBA takes 25 percent stake in two NBN retail service providers

Will offer 'discounted NBN and broadband' to customers. Read more »

Gladys Berejiklian's plan to end lockdown as Sydney outbreak explodes

Case numbers continue to soar. Picture: Rachael Tosh-ProvanSource:NCA NewsWire Any “adjustments” to restrictions may be outlined on July 31 when Sydney’s lockdown is due to end, but as case numbers ... Read more »

Embracing risk: Leanne Fry's blended 'security and innovation' journey at AUSTRAC

Exploring the financial intelligence agency's strategy and projects. Read more »